HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

minkowskispace

1 karma · joined October 14, 2017

submissionscomments
minkowskispace··on How to stop the decline of public transport in rich countries
> Of course it should be heavily taxed so that cycling, bus and subway infrastructure can be financed.

I like sentences that start with "Of course...". But I tend to think that Stockholm might not be a very representative city of the worst transportation problems.

Stockholm has a population of ~950,000 (or 2.3 million metro) and a city area of 188 km². Contrast that with London with 8.1 million (13.6 million metro) people and 1,572 km². Plus, there are unique geographical characteristics, different population distributions and infrastructures. All these affect commute times and congestion.

I don't think the solution in Stockholm is nearly universal. It might solve the specific problems of that specific city but would fail in many ways if applied blindly in many other places.