HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mjolk

1,426 karma · joined April 25, 2011

HN is not a startup community. Good luck!
submissionscomments
mjolk··on As Leaks Multiply, Fears of a ‘Deep State’ in America
> That view would be a lot more legitimate, IMO, if we had a functional government trying to carry on normal business for the benefit of the people... An analogy that should ring a bell with many HN regulars would be the new technical manager with zero technical background who was hired because he's the CEO's nephew, who happens to be borderline mentally challenged but makes up for it with defiant corruption, extreme nepotism and flamboyant temper tantrums.

A lot of hyperbole gets thrown around, but do you legitimately believe the US government is no longer "functional" and run by "borderline mentally challenged" people?

You don't have personally like the newcomers to the top levels of the US government, but you're deluded if you think they're not capable people (or good at playing a game) acting within a system that's been built for hundreds of years.

mjolk··on The Bull Case for Snapchat
Facebook asks for a lot of information from users and grew its way into government contracts and safer high $value arrangements due to how much data they store. Even if you're not "on" Facebook, people you know will establish a presence for you in Facebook's data.

Twitter accounts are cheap and the platform only has value as long as advertisements can run unchallenged by a large number of users.

mjolk··on SNES preservation project on hold due to missing $10,000 package
Traditional full time employment is a much safer bet for savings.
mjolk··on SNES preservation project on hold due to missing $10,000 package
If your startup isn't a labor of love or you're not driven by a strong dislike of an alternative career path, then almost every startup would die the second the founder(s) do the math of income opportunity cost of trying vs stable employment.
mjolk··on SNES preservation project on hold due to missing $10,000 package
> Is any labour of love worth your potential future?

Kind of a funny question on a site for people doing startups.

mjolk··on Steam needs to stop asking its customers to fix its problems
Core complaints of article (please add any that I missed):

1. Steam receives dozens of releases a day and it's difficult for developers/publishers to make their title stand-out without performing marketing.

2. Author perceives that Steam's display algorithm results in display of outliers (very good/bad).

3. Very low quality titles are released/being sold by Steam.

4. Reviews are a very poor metric as reviewers can be shills or rate content poorly out of pettiness or malice.

5. Author thinks that staff-curated titles are the solution.

My responses:

RockPaperShotgun is a game review site. Reviewing games is how they manage to make ad revenue (well, besides click-bait articles). If the defense is that more content comes out than RockPaperShotgun can review, then RockPaperShotgun should hire more people. If that's cost prohibitive, and there's market demand for it, then why are they asking Steam to do it?

1. Welcome to selling anything.

2. I don't know if this is true; I'm not rejecting this claim, but I'd love to see the data.

3. Quantifying "good enough to sell" is a risky game. I'm okay with spending $5 (most of a beer at a bar) on something kind of buggy if it's amusing for 30 minutes. For someone else, that amount may be double or $0 on principle.

4. If this subproblem gets solved without background checks on reviewers, you have a serious business that Amazon/Yelp/etc would love to buy from you.

5. Beyond catching content that simply _does not do what it says on the box_, this is all personal taste.

And as an aside, there's a "curious" market that exists in low-quality games that have DLC/content that ends up on the Steam Community Market (Steam gets a % of each transaction), so the "how did a broken game end up on Steam?" question has more depth than a casual observer would guess.

mjolk··on CPython: GitHub migration scheduled for Friday
As a Python user, I have mixed feelings about this change.

I think this move to corporate hosting is acknowledgment of usability and ease of use at the expense of political purity -- for a project as important and major as Python, this further solidifies GitHub's positioning as the place where open source coding "happens" (consider what a move to GitLab would have done for the legitimacy of their platform), a position that they've very successfully used to up-sell "free" into paid accounts.

Python preceded and will outlive GitHub, but this now implicitly means Python is amplifying and promoting the various political positions[0] of GitHub by driving more traffic and money to their platform, which is run by a company that currently employs at least two people to be politically active who have publicly made questionable/racist statements[1]. If you personally agree with GitHub's politics, great, but some do not or would prefer their work to have more apolitical side-effects.

That said, as someone that "source dives" on the semi-official CPython mirror on GitHub, then verifies on hg.python.org, this makes my life easier, and I'm only a casually interested party of the CPython source. I do wonder about the increase in (people) management overhead the ease-of-use will bring in filing "issues" with the project though, as the prior mechanism acted as a filter for non-technical people and those unable to follow instructions.

[0] https://action.github.com/ ; https://github.com/blog/2039-adopting-the-open-code-of-condu... (in contrast with PSF's https://www.python.org/psf/codeofconduct/ );

[1] "some of the biggest barriers to progress are white women" - GitHub's VP of "Social Impact" ; "don't think we'll succeed teaching white, male middle managers empathy and compassion anytime soon ... so let's limit their scope of damage" - GitHub's Technical Director for "Social Impact"

mjolk··on FBI Is Building a Watchlist That Gives Companies Real Time Updates on Employees
I'm not sure why you replied to my reply, but the moral "should" isn't really relevant when the database-to-protest-a-database suggestion is a non-starter due to more egregious flaws.
mjolk··on Trump Is Right: Silicon Valley Using H-1B Visas to Pay Low Wages to Immigrants
Please explain.
mjolk··on FBI Is Building a Watchlist That Gives Companies Real Time Updates on Employees
If you're trying to accuse me of something, I'd prefer you have the decency to do it directly and unequivocally.
mjolk··on FBI Is Building a Watchlist That Gives Companies Real Time Updates on Employees
Please re-read the parent comment:

> it should start with a list of companies that publicly state that their employees are allowed to protest, even if the company disagrees with them.

The part that is objectionable is the expectation that my company would need to register on a list stating that I respect the rights of my employees. Doing things within your legal rights is the _default_; I reject the act of playing into someone's political "are you with us?" game.

mjolk··on FBI Is Building a Watchlist That Gives Companies Real Time Updates on Employees
You're suggesting a left-wing form of McCarthyism. I don't care if my employees/reports protest as long as they do their job and don't attempt political intimidation, but I am not willing to put my company on a list to satisfy a virtue-signaling busybody.
mjolk··on FBI Is Building a Watchlist That Gives Companies Real Time Updates on Employees
How would you verify that an employee was fired for peaceful protest or that self-reporter even worked for the company? Would you demand that a company admit this was the reason or would you trust the person that created the entry for the employer? How would an employer get itself off this list? How would you avoid libel? How would you verify the identity of the person making the entry and that person is even in the "RAP BACK" database? How would you prevent verified self-reporters from being discriminated against for future employment?
mjolk··on FBI Is Building a Watchlist That Gives Companies Real Time Updates on Employees
Your solution for a problematic database is to create a problematic database?
mjolk··on New data show that joining the 1% remains unsettlingly hereditary
> Yes, that is a problem. However, the capacity limits you mention don't disappear when we just say, "Open University of California to the whole planet". The only real solution is to build up more top-quality universities in Missouri and Alabama.

That's unrealistic, otherwise there would be a top-quality university in Missouri and Alabama. Our existence is one of constraints.

> Once you've committed to making Missouri and Alabama more productive, the process helps itself along, so it's actually nowhere near miraculous.

Education is the immediate antithesis of productivity -- we're on hacker news and you know that pair programming is either a code-quality, knowledge-sharing, or bug-avoidance issue, and specifically never a means for immediate gains nor all three. You can't throw cash at university and get smarter students -- I went to a top 50 school where the top administration is compensated better than the top 10.

> Actually, the last place I worked, everyone earned the same salary. We functioned pretty well.

What about now? Do you ask junior QA if you can give them the earning difference? If you oppose this notion based on separation of duty, do you think union politics would be better at making this differentiation?

> Because you can't enjoy things when you're dead, and we've seen in history that inheritance leads to aristocracy, social instability, and mass destruction.

You avoided the issue of removing inheritance being untenable. If I die, my nephew gets all of my wealth and I hope it brings him happiness and fulfillment. If you try to legislate that, I will simply route around you.

What mass destruction? What social instability? My partner comes from a communist nation and his/her (not interested in disclosing sexual details) experiences add color to the reality that political dispensation of resources is a terrible machinery.

Socialism/communism does not result in a more "equal" society. If hard numbers don't do it for you, find the nearest Chinese/Russian emigrant area and buy an older person a drink and ask if it's alright to pick his/her brain.

> Is it in your interest to defect in a one-shot prisoner's dilemma? Was it in the interest of Marie Antoinette to say, "Let them eat cake"? Your long-term rational interest can differ from short-term selfishness.

I have no obligation to your kids, will always pick my own kids over yours, and it's not a prisoner's dilemma -- if you try to tax me to the extent that I'm providing luxury for others, that changes the moral algebra for resources that I very well could shield from taxation.

mjolk··on New data show that joining the 1% remains unsettlingly hereditary
There's no private-message interface for hackernews (so I'm unable to communicate this out-of-bound), but I wanted to tell you that even though we recently disagreed in a different thread, I appreciate your perspective.
mjolk··on YouTube removes hundreds of the best climate science videos from the Internet
Their videos are just clips of others' content, this isn't original work or a leader on the topic: https://www.youtube.com/user/ClimateProgressWorld/videos

This reeks of breaking a ToS and then trying to masquerade their political site as something more noble to rationalize creating a narrative of victimhood for marketing/attention.

The group/person behind climatestate.com is either deluded or trying to sell an aggrandizing message by claiming that they're the subject of a "concerted attack on climate science originating from the current U.S. Administration". There might be an attack, but no way was this on anyone's radar.

mjolk··on YouTube removes hundreds of the best climate science videos from the Internet
Youtube is owned by Google. Google is not at all pro-republican party, so this is not a Trump-related thing.
mjolk··on New data show that joining the 1% remains unsettlingly hereditary
> If we mean what we say about equal opportunity, then we're essentially talking about cutting the probabilistic link between one's background and one's distribution over outcomes.

The intrinsic problem with this approach is that it "drags others down", reducing the purpose of working harder or unfairly affects those more naturally capable.

> * Admitting students to university based on merely adequate grades and their citizenship in the community

Assuming you mean "citizenship in the community" to be "I live in state X, that means I have a better chance of access to X State University", over a generation, this would just mean that for higher achieving state X, students from state Y would be locked out of better opportunities based on geographic residency.

A real life example would be higher admittance for Californians to California State schools, which reduces the opportunities for a kid from Missouri or Alabama (because of realistic capacity constraints). The kid that went to University of Missouri is now at a significant disadvantage (based on education) and is not able to compete against her peers for jobs in regions with better long-term opportunities, even if she had a lot of potential. University of Missouri then has to accommodate the lackluster abilities of its enrolling body (as it ostensibly does with a 77% acceptance rate), which leads to dropping STEM requirements, which means an even less capable constituency.

> rather than based on a "meritocratic" competition that actually just conditions outcomes on starting-points.

Related to the last point, this would seek to normalize the achievement by "boosting up" those that haven't demonstrated aptitude, while limiting the opportunity of those that would benefit from a more rigorous program.

> * Supporting trade unions and other institutions that regularize wages/salaries/incomes.

For non-specialized labor, maybe. If the idea is that the base salary would need to increase, that would just increase the costs of goods "across the board", which doesn't do much except broaden the divide between the full-time employed and the unemployed.

Would you be willing to give up a percentage of your salary to someone else in your department that earns less, even if he/she doesn't work as hard or isn't as skilled? If yes, why aren't you doing that now?

> * Taxing inheritance heavily.

Why are others more entitled to the results of my labor after I'm dead versus when I'm alive? It's not my job to posthumously give advantage to the kids of strangers against my own in a competitive world. Also, if you try to implement this, you'll end up getting the government involved in interpersonal gifting (as the logical workaround would be to give the maximum tax deductible gift per year or sell assets to family at well below their value, if not just creating new avenues to tax avoidance).

> * Enforcing anti-trust law.

Agreed.

> We're looking to defy that natural process, cut a natural link, and thus regularize certain statistical structures.

This suggestion makes my brain feel fuzzy. If the thought is that it's a natural process for the above-average to create advantages for themselves and their own, isn't this asking for more laws to compel them to act against their own interests?

mjolk··on New data show that joining the 1% remains unsettlingly hereditary
Is your assertion that we should seek to normalize outcomes in order to address differences in opportunity?
mjolk··on New data show that joining the 1% remains unsettlingly hereditary
> So there's a lie being told to the rest of us that life is supposed to be reasonably fair and that we're supposed to work toward keeping it that way.

Whoever told you that did you a massive disservice. You're not entitled to what others have; you get what you create.

> Why the hell do I need to be put up against your performance enhanced kid when it comes to success? Just have me toil in your lands where I compete against all the other serfs instead. If you're going to start people off in life ahead of me at least give me the courtesy of degrees of separation. Pretending at equality while everyone is rigging the game is trying to have your cake and eat it too.

Drop the histrionics; at least in the US and Canada, the game isn't that rigged, especially in fields where merit and effort matters (and within tech, I've noticed PR, marketing, other non STEM to be where the 'connected' get promoted). I grew up relatively poor and my kids will grow up significantly better off because you can earn your way into better opportunities (and I say this not being particularly smart).

mjolk··on Google's diversity numbers haven't budged, and it just lost its diversity chief
Not saying that I disagree that the standards aren't being lowered, but that conclusion doesn't necessarily logically follow. Where you only have one side of the data for your anecdotal experience, it's also possible that you didn't do well enough in the interview for the well-meaning-but-super-racist bias of lowered expectations to bridge the gap.

Anyway, good luck with the interview process and I hope you land something great.

mjolk··on Google's diversity numbers haven't budged, and it just lost its diversity chief
I'm sorry if this is just really dry satire, but that's absurd.

> "Hire California Latino workers or we will tax your ass out of existence!!!"

Speaking as someone that's been involved with a lot of hiring decisions, it ultimately comes down to who is in the pipeline when you're hiring for positions that require expertise.

If you think companies should be forced to hire based on race, openly stating that people will be judged differently based on physical attributes, I welcome you to create a business and try this for yourself.

mjolk··on Google's diversity numbers haven't budged, and it just lost its diversity chief
> I'd love to once see a scientific approach rather than the political one

You're asking a lot from soft science, especially where said effects would be really hard to measure.

mjolk··on Snap commits $2B over 5 years for Google Cloud infrastructure
> First, if you don't notice some random/unexpected EC2 instance failures, you don't have a big EC2 deployment. ...Not seeing any unique value proposition here for "the cloud".

Because when something fails, you don't have to care about the "why" as long as you can replace it. I see about 4 instances needing a maintenance per month per 1000. That's reasonable enough to not demand someone be full-time focused on making sure that only the good lights blink on the hardware.

> The point is that even when you're using EC2, you still have to set all of that up. Contrary to popular belief, EC2 is not a panacea that can magically make your software reliable and redundant.

You're making a strawman by suggesting people think it's a panacea. The advantage is that a lot of the work, maintenance, and feature improvements for 'infrastructure as code' is handled for you. Cloud hosting means writing the software layer and being done, no managing the infrastructure services, facilities, hardware, business relationships involved with rack/stack.

> It's just a nice interface that makes it easy to rent servers from Amazon.

To be fair, it's a _very_ nice interface.

> I know EC2 et al are popular because people like buzzwords, but that doesn't make it good business (or does it? Investors love cloud because it keep capex low, and because investors are buzzword-driven like everyone else; saying "cloud" will make them like you more and want to give you more money).

If you think cloud hosting is popular because of op-ex or buzzwords, I think you're out of touch. EC2 and Google Cloud are popular because they let you focus on getting shit done, even when you have variadic workloads that are uptime dependent.

> For companies that are still in the garage (literally in the garage), shelling out $20/mo for a couple of cheap VPSes from something like DigitalOcean is going to be just fine. But once you get bigger than that, there's no way to avoid paying attention to this stuff, even if paying Amazon tons of money creates a false psychological connection that makes you think they're doing the work for you.

They _are_ doing a lot of work for you. You say $20 is the point that it makes more sense to self-host. I'll be charitable and round that up to $100, but even at that price, there is _no way_ you'll be able to get something as fault tolerant or low-cost as a cloud hosted solution. Do you really think that for $100 a month you can self-host geo-close servers with redundancy to the point that you don't have to think about it? Keep in mind that "two is one and one is none" when planning your hardware purchase.

> Vastly overallocating here.

No, that's conservative for a major US city (e.g. where Snap would be doing the hiring). Have you tried to pull a handful of really good system hackers out of thin air recently? Even if you can get them, they're not cheap, and you'd need a sizable team to pull off the highly-redundant world-wide install that Snap needs for its growth projections. It starts off expensive to hire good tech and gets more spendy the longer you're fishing.

And that's even ignoring the costs on productivity (for that and other employees) when an employee isn't happy or decides it's time to leave -- staffing also takes money and attention to maintain.

> And the added benefit of being a trendy tech company is that after your company creates some extremely specialized solution, you can open-source it and watch with an uncomfortable mix of amusement and horror as 90%+ of other companies's tech departments contort themselves into pathetic, desperate architecture pretzels so that they can become cool by abandoning a stable, proven, mature stack for your company's experimental, sputtering, duct-taped abomination that requires a PhD to even get to compile.

You seem like you're speaking from personal experience. Having a working infrastructure that isn't a barrier to growth isn't trendy or sexy, it's a base competency for any internet-reliant business model.

> Sure, but they don't have to set massive gobs of money on fire for no reason along the way. But then, I guess they wouldn't be part of the Silicon Valley family if they didn't.

This isn't setting "massive gobs of money on fire for no reason", this is going with a high-performance datacenter that someone else maintains. They clearly have something very big in mind and I doubt they made a multi-$bb commitment without asking themselves "are we lighting this money on fire?"

mjolk··on Snap commits $2B over 5 years for Google Cloud infrastructure
> And when EC2 falls over, like it tends to do a few times a year?

Multi-AZ, multi-region complete failures are very, very rare. How often do you get a failure in your data center per year (that you notice)?

> You're going to be writing a lot of the same fallover code if you're running on someone else's hardware, so why rent?

The answer is in the question -- when rented things fall down and go boom™, your code runs and someone gets a text message with the receipt.

When a handful of the "wrong" disks decide to revert to air-blocking bricks or your upstream network provider has an outage, you're lucky if it's something you can fix by heading to the data center. I promise that AWS or Google is better at running a DC, and unless you're trying to enter the hosting business, I wouldn't advise spending the time and money to meet their uptime and features.

I've only managed data storage in the scale of many petabytes (and this was a handful of years ago) and honestly, I think it required at least 20 hours a week of babysitting by various staff. At Snap's scale and traffic patterns (viral content, lots of writes, so on), I imagine this is a very non-trivial spend on scaling, staffing, tech implementation.

At 2bb over 5 years, maybe Snap would benefit from rolling their own -- hiring 50 great hackers at a mildly conservative 250k/head (say 200k average + benefits + taxes + employee support costs (HR, payroll, recruiting, legal, etc)), eating a year or two of transition costs off their cloud hosting providers, then probably saving a bit of money even after hardware, bandwidth, facility, insurance costs. Hell, maybe they'd even open source some software and recruiting would get easier after conference talks of how they did it. Or maybe they get bought by Google or Facebook in a year. Snap's in the business of selling ads and getting more eyes on those ads. Whatever enables growth and doesn't serve as a distraction or speedbump is a "fine" decision.

mjolk··on Snap Inc. S-1
That interpretation would only make sense if TF or Go could only run on Google's "cloud".
mjolk··on Snap commits $2B over 5 years for Google Cloud infrastructure
Where cloud-hosting costs are recurring, it's something that won't amortize.
mjolk··on Snap commits $2B over 5 years for Google Cloud infrastructure
What are the terms? I'd take that action if we're talking in their current form/focus.
mjolk··on Snap commits $2B over 5 years for Google Cloud infrastructure
> Script your stuff out in Ansible or something similar, run it on your own hardware, and use GCloud/EC2 as secondary data centers for failover/backup/support/emergency bursts/whatever. You can have the flexibility without paying through the nose.

Except then you have to run your own networking and when shit fails (as disks, links, and switches are want to do), it's now "your problem". Hybrid clouds and not being a tenant is nice, but not without time and monetary costs -- by the time you have geographically distinct failover, you've also spent a non-trivial amount of opportunity costs making phone calls, flying around, and writing lines of code and config for things customers don't even know exist.

← PreviousPage 2 of 21Next →