HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mlinsey

5,217 karma · joined April 18, 2008

www.twitter.com/mlinsey

Engineering @ Homejoy (YC S10)

hnchat.com:8pJMixG6jypNc7WE7714

submissionscomments
mlinsey··on There is no Jake Frink
OK, so this is the second time in a week I'm going to have to post this PG quote: "Your comment is a classic instance of people on a forum rushing to judgment based on incomplete information. It's isomorphic to the sort of thing one sees on reddit, except that it's about startups rather than the federal government or international bankers."

Edit: it looks like Jiggity (aka Jong-Moon Kim, Warp Prism's creator) has gone and posted a lot more details here: http://www.reddit.com/r/starcraft/comments/im6r4/there_is_no...

If he's come forward and put all the details on the record, I feel comfortable putting a lot more details here, along with my own commentary on the whole mess.

Jiggity was indeed a co-founder of Teevox, which was in last summer's YC batch. He and Andrew were one always one of the most energetic, technically impressive, and just fun-to-be-around founders in the batch. Seriously, one of the bright spots of weekly dinners was always the corner of the orange room where the Teevox demo was set up each week, greeting passerby with equal parts cheeriness from the founders and magic from the slick Hulu demo.

Which is why it was so heartbreaking when Teevox was one of the first startups in YC S10 to die. It was a sober reminder to everyone that coming up with a clever product just isn't always enough, and we're all in a low-success-rate business.

In any case, Teevox is gone. Dead. Kaput. No longer there. Corporate entity unraveled. It happens to startups. People who spend time here should know that, even though the reddit posters cluelessly assume that Teevox lives on with a team of coders and a "slick marketing team".

Andrew went back to school but Jiggity decided to keep on plugging away at some side projects. One of them turned into Warp Prism. I think that this is fucking awesome. In fact, it's pretty much the classic startup feel-good turnaround story: smart hacker down on his luck, has a startup shut down and fail, keeps on hacking away and eventually stumbles upon something people love to use. He keeps on iterating on the product, out0executing a similar competitor all by himself. (one of the posters in the linked thread said s/he was always suspicious that WarpPrism could ever have been built by one person!) Awesome! This is the classic inspirational never-give-up narrative in action.

Except in this case, some moron hiding behind an anonymous pseudonym does a simple whois search, discovers that the domain is registered to the same guy who happend to found a startup the year before and - gasp - concludes that s/he's unearthed the scandal of a century! WarpPrism can't be the work of a lone hacker, it must have a whole "slick marketing team" behind it! Angry reddit mob, enter stage left!

I do not know why Jiggity chose the name "Jake Frink". (In retrospect, isn't that um, sort of obviously a pseudonym?) I do know that Jiggity has previously used various aliases in everyday conversation, and rarely his real name. But the reality is, aside from that one name, every other detail of the original story is true.

Why was everyone so quick to rush to judgement? Is it a reflexive distrust of anything that might be backed by a company? Is it a predisposition to believe in a made-up but apparently widely perceived trend that, in the words of another poster, "the newer YC bunch are playing dirty to win"?

In any case, this time it makes me upset. It's one thing if people mis-read a boilerplate line in the Dropbox ToS and decide to get angry over that; Dropbox is doing well and will be fine, internet mob or not. But this is different. This is not a large successful company, it's just a friend who has bravely marched straight through the hell that every startup founder has nightmares about. but the one that is never far from my mind when it's racing late at night - the idea that all your hard work will eventually evaporate.

I went through that period once when my first startup died four years ago, and it put me into a rather severe months-long depression. Thankfully my current startup is doing quite well, but the memory of what happened before and the gnawing fear it could happen again is never far from my consciousness late at night when my mind is racing and I have trouble falling asleep. I think pretty much every founder feels the same way all the way until (at least) the liquidity event. It's a special kind of overbearing stress that only other founders can truly understand.

Jiggity pushed right through that, and created a kickass product people loved using. The three months after my first startup died I spent mostly half-heartedly applying for jobs and walking around the streets of Palo Alto in sort of a daze; Jiggity spent that time single-handedly creating the best way to watch StarCraft 2 games in the world. And when those users find out, that gasp, the creator of the product they love so much was using a pseudonym - this is how they react.

I advise everyone who reads Hacker News and is thinking of one day starting a company to think of Jiggity's story as inspirational, and the reaction to it as a warning. In the end though, despite the fact that I was moved to post this long rant, I know he'll get through it just fine. He's thrived after going through much worse.

mlinsey··on Ex-Wave, Ex-Plus engineer on Google Plus
We'll see. I agree that Facebook Groups is much less powerful than Circles and much less fundamental to the core Facebook experience than Circles is with G+.

On the other hand, Facebook Groups takes less effort to use - each person does not need to sort their friends, a small number of curators can organize the group. More importantly, it is clearer to the user just what is going on. I have been trying to talk to as many non-techie non-early-adopters as possible about Circles, and many get it and love it, but several don't really understand it.

In particular, the asymmetry of circles is overlooked by a lot of people, even by some casual users who think they understand how Circles works. On Facebook, there is one authoritative list of who is in the group, and posts to the group stay in that group. On Google+, your circles are not my circles. I may have you in a "close friends" circle, you may have me in a big "co-workers" circle, or you might have all your friends in one circle. When I am browsing my "close friends" feed and see a post by you, I may guess wrong about the social context that you are sharing that message in, and make an inappropriate comment, not realizing who else received the message. (The way to determine on G+ who received a post is by noting and clicking on the gray "Public" or "Limited" in the upper right of the post) Maybe I am underestimating people, or maybe comments are just much less big a deal than posts, but I think this lack of clear social context for individual messages within Circles is going to lead to some serious privacy/sharing accidents.

If I had to make a prediction, I'd think that the ease-of-use and clarity of FB Groups will trump the power and flexibility of Circles. I could be wrong, so it'll be interesting to see what ordinary users prefer.

mlinsey··on Google on today’s massive Google+ spam influx: “We ran out of disk space”
since a lot of people keep gmail open ... Not as common to keep one's facebook page open.

Do you have data on this? I'd think it would be close, if not the opposite.

Edit for clarification:

In my social circles, what you said is probably true, but I know many others use FB messages more than email (any email, not just gmail). Facebook has more pageviews total, and Facebook has probably around 3X as many active users (I couldn't find numbers at the same point in time, Gmail was at around 200 million last November as per the WSJ, Facebook was at 500 million last July and 750 million last week)

Don't get me wrong, I agree with you that G+ notifications in Gmail (and on Google Search!) is hugely powerful, and will mean G+ engagement among its users will stay quite high. But when you talk about "unseating" Facebook, you have to first come to grips with just how entrenched it is, compared to social networks that rose and fell before it. It is so entrenched that Gmail integration alone will not be enough - Facebook is substantially bigger than Gmail.

mlinsey··on ITerm2 1.0 Released
I think only a few things in iTerm2 are really unpolished. That said, when a tool becomes part of how you do work for 14+ hours a day, feature-set and efficiency can matter more than simplicity and intuitiveness. After all, that's why we're using a command line in the first place! Terminal itself doesn't really "feel like it belongs on the Mac".

I wouldn't want to spend all that time in a terminal without native screen splitting, just to pick one example of a cool iTerm 2 feature.

mlinsey··on What's yours stays yours. - Dropbox Terms Update
You die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain.

Facebook, Google, Microsoft...all were everybody's favorite scrappy insurgents at one point.

Once perception shifts the other way, it's hard to turn things around because everyone starts assuming the worst. This incident is a perfect example: the old ToS were standard boilerplate that appears in a bunch of other places, and had most other companies done it, it would have been seen as a non-issue. However, since Dropbox has been receiving other negative press lately (some centering around real issues, some centering around similarly trivial nonsense), that changes how every new story about them is perceived.

mlinsey··on MySpace, Skype announce partnership (2007)
I used Facebook video chat this morning, and it required a download that you then had to run in order to proceed.
mlinsey··on A Conversation With Julian Assange, Slavoj Zizek & Amy Goodman (Live)
Žižek is a brilliant writer, and Perceval doesn't really understand Žižek at all if he thinks he's a "postmodernist", but I have to agree that it's easy to waste a lot of your life and mental energy studying Žižek and not get very much out of it.

I say that only as someone who spent a lot of time reading many of his books, and discussing his work only in a rather informal, amateurish context, so perhaps I am pretty unqualified.

But my warning to HN readers about Žižek is that while his columns and short commentary can be very clever, his real theoretical work all starts with a foundation built on top of Marxism and Lacanian Psychoanalysis. Granted, Žižek reinterprets both of those disciplines in clever, Hegelian ways that might make them unrecognizable at first glance to the modern reader, but if you're of the opinion that those two disciplines have little to offer intellectually (and I suspect most HN readers are in this boat), you'll ultimately look at the time you spent puzzling out Žižek and want those hours of your life back.

mlinsey··on Zynga Files to Raise $1 Billion via IPO
Lots and lots of people here read TechCrunch. It's still essentially the paper of record for the startup scene. Consequently, when major interesting news breaks, several different people see it on TechCrunch first and all submit the article at about the same time. The duplicate submissions count as upvotes, and just 5-10 of these immediately after an article breaks is enough to get a submission near the top for a short period of time, during which it's the first link on the story people coming to the HN frontpage see, so it gains momentum.

Honestly, I don't think TC is as bad as you characterize it, especially when it comes to breaking news (as opposed to high-level commentary). They've done a good job at breaking several big stories in the past year, even though I disagree with a lot of the more opinion-type pieces.

mlinsey··on Google in preliminary talks to buy Hulu
This could very well be true, but there are a couple different things that could happen as well. Google has had a lot of experience in the past several years monetizing YouTube much more effectively, so it's possible they could do a better job than Hulu does now at generating revenues.

Alternatively (and I think perhaps most likely), Google simply sees mainstream TV being available on the Internet as of tremendous strategic importance. They might be willing to take significant losses in operating it for that reason. They might even be willing to pay the extra fees to bake it into Google TV, which would immediately make that product far more compelling.

mlinsey··on Why founding a 3-person startup with 0 revenue is better than working for GS
The reaction in all the other replies to your comment astounds me. I am reminded of a comment from PG earlier today, which he made in a thread on a totally different topic: "Your comment is a classic instance of people on a forum rushing to judgment based on incomplete information. It's isomorphic to the sort of thing one sees on reddit, except that it's about startups rather than the federal government or international bankers."

In this case, Antonio made an argument a year ago about why starting a startup was better than continuing to work for a Wall Street bank. He made no claim that continuing to run a year-old startup was better than working for a large tech company. That of course depends on many other factors about the startup, about the large tech company, and about whatever offers were made. Nobody on this thread knows any of those details, but that apparently doesn't stop anyone from rushing to judgement.

mlinsey··on Earbits (YC W11) Snags $605K From Charles River Ventures And Others
As with other ads, the difference between ads that hurt the UX and ads that help it is relevancy. I certainly wouldn't mind hearing sponsored songs that Earbits can algorithmically determine I am likely to like based on my tastes and use of the service. A well-targeted system would also make it more viable for small artists, who could target small niches of customers that had a higher probability of converting to sales of merchandise, concert tickets, etc. This is what happened with AdWords. One might have expected AdWords to be a mechanism for large content sites with money to spend advertising to get a lot more traffic, but as it turned out AdWords was a boon for niche but profitable businesses.
mlinsey··on Peak Facebook
Doubtful. The last time I was privy to accurate data on the top search terms at a major search engine was almost five years ago, but at that time the most searched-for terms were all names of popular websites. Lots of people use search boxes as URL bars. With Facebook the most popular site in the world, it doesn't surprise me that it would be the top search query.
mlinsey··on Husky Starcraft: From Burgerville to 500K YouTube Subscribers in 2 Years
staunch's estimates were using CPM, not CPC, so click throughs are irrelevant (CPM - cost per 1,000 impressions displayed).

That said, $2-3 CPM sounds high to me. But I don't know anything about the YouTube ad market.

mlinsey··on What Safari’s Reading List means for Instapaper
Thanks to Safari's reading list, I'll likely stop using the Instapaper bookmarklet on my iPad. But the most common use case I have for Intapaper is when I see an article on my laptop in Chrome and want to read it later on my Kindle 3. So I expect I'll be using Instapaper for a while longer.

This is a generalizable pattern for survival for all the other apps Apple "killed" today - you can still compete for any users that don't live 100% in the Apple ecosystem.

mlinsey··on Video of StartX Demo Day (formerly SSE Labs)
Opening remarks start at 7:50

Presentations start at 20:10 with the Summer Companies (ie, the companies who are about to be in the just-starting batch)

Presentations for the companies in the batch that just ended start at 37:40.

mlinsey··on Airbnb Has Arrived: Raising Mega-Round at a $1 Billion+ Valuation
This is pretty mild as "calling outs" go. I would summarize your first two points as "there is tremendous demand for this concept".

Your first point is that this basic concept has been so successful that governments have felt the need to regulate it to combat its adverse effects, which is a risk Airbnb is pretty well aware of. In fact, all of the adverse effects you list are true of hotels as well, except for "shorting cities on their hotel taxes". If municipalities eventually decide to force Airbnb to charge hotel taxes, that would diminish their appeal but probably not destroy the business. Hugely successful companies like Amazon are facing similar problems.

Your second point is essentially that the idea of providing an online marketplace to remove inefficiencies of brokerages is not a new one, and therefore Airbnb should not be "overly" congratulated. But we're not congratulating Airbnb for the novelty of the idea, but for building a business which is apparently worth a billion dollars. Many hugely successful startups have ideas which might be obvious.

As for your third point, there might be something legitimate there. I don't know anything about VRBO vs. AirBNB in terms of traction and customer satisfaction, but it appears from one of your other replies that your only evidence is anecdotal. My personal anecdotal evidence is that everyone I know has been very happy with using AirBNB.

mlinsey··on Windows 7 Network Awareness: How Windows knows it has an Internet connection
" If the response is never received, or if there is a redirect, then a DNS request for dns.msftncsi.com is made. If DNS resolves properly but the page is inaccessible, then it is assumed that there is a working internet connection, but an in-browser authentication page is blocking access to the file. This results in the pop-up balloon above. If DNS resolution fails or returns the wrong address, then it is assumed that the internet connection is completely unsuccessful, and the “no internet access” error is shown."

Would this mean that DNS poisoning msftncsi.com would prevent Win7 machines from accessing the internet? Or would this merely cause the 'no internet access' error to be displayed despite your connection working anyway?

mlinsey··on Google to Announce Chrome Laptops for Students - $20/Month
Microsoft's own online office site (docs.com) is underrated. Ironically enough it might become the killer app on Chrome OS.
mlinsey··on What percentage of people are alive today?
Of course Earth must have some finite carrying capacity, but that's only terrifying if you assume that "The Crunch" is the only way to bring population growth to a halt.

Population growth is already zero or negative in most developed countries if you remove the effects of immigration. If this becomes a consistent rule for all countries once they become fully developed, the real question is not whether we can sustain infinite population growth, but whether we have the resources to support a developed lifestyle for the entire world. Given current technologies and energy sources, the answer is almost certainly "no", but this is a much more tractable problem.

mlinsey··on Greplin: 1.5 Billion Documents Indexed, Six Engineers
It's a big deal because:

(a) It's a proxy for traction. Greplin indexes data that can't be crawled; users have to authorize it to index their data. So aside from how hard of an engineering feat it is, the fact that they've indexed this much data probably means that they have a sizable number of users.

(b) While you're right that the technical challenge of indexing that many documents is easier now than in 2001 thanks to things like AWS (and numerous open source projects), to do it with a team of six is still impressive.

mlinsey··on Why I, Jeff Bezos, Keep Spending Billions On Amazon R&D
I was hired with no college degree, when Microsoft and Google would not even consider me on that basis.

Also, for Amazon and other companies, there is a world of difference going through their public-facing recruiting process and getting to know someone on an interesting team through your network, and getting hired through them.

mlinsey··on Nintendo confirms launching new console in 2012, playable at E3
Their lead in casual gaming isn't so massive if you consider that their competitors in the "casual gaming" space include not just Xbox and PlayStation but also iOS, Android, and Facebook games.

That's just in the American market, too. In equally important Japanese market, you have to throw Gree and DeNA in there too.

mlinsey··on That dev's salary is higher than mine
The comeback is identical.
mlinsey··on TI buys National Semiconductor for $6.5B
Your post seems to be implying that Facebook hasn't found a business model, and that a day of reckoning will come "the second they start charging". However, Facebook is already charging for advertisements, that's how they earned about $355 million in profits in the first 3/4 of 2010: http://nymag.com/daily/intel/2011/01/goldmans_leaked_details...

In contrast, National Semiconductor earned about $220 million in profits for approximately the same period: http://www.google.com/finance?client=ob&q=NYSE:NSM (not exactly the same months, because their Q1 goes from Dec-Feb, but still a useful point of comparison)

One can make the case that Facebook is overvalued, perhaps even grossly overvalued, but to say that it should be valued at less than National Semiconductor is a big stretch, even if you are very conservative and use only current bottom-line financials. In my experience, those who make such statements are not basing their opinion on fundamentals of the companies, but on an opinion that companies like National Semiconductor do "real" engineering as opposed to "frivolous" social networking sites like Facebook. It's discouraging to see such attitudes, but they are not new: both early internet companies (including ones that survived the bubble and turned out to be sound companies) as well as early PC-era companies were also derided as toys or fads.

mlinsey··on Spend the Summer at Lightspeed
What's with the editorializing in the title? In any case, taking no equity in companies is not necessarily a good way to compete with YC; in fact it makes the two programs complimentary by making it easy to do both programs, as Indinero did.
mlinsey··on How to Ace Calculus: The Art of Doing Well in Technical Courses
This is why I did terribly in quantum mechanics; I was never able to generate a whiff of insight about anything that was going on. The thing is, I'm not sure the top students really did either.
mlinsey··on Meet Y Combinator's Latest Class
I attended the alumni preview of demo day along with a bunch of other founders from my batch (Summer 2010). We were told after our demo day that we were universally acclaimed as the best YC batch ever. All of us were completely blown away and humbled by the quality of the startups in this current batch; we were outdone and then some. Congrats to all the W11 founders, now go conquer the world.
mlinsey··on Meet Y Combinator's Latest Class
FYI: I can't speak for other batches, but the spreadsheet here has a few companies from the S10 batch that were missing from citizenkeys' list.
mlinsey··on You shouldn't apply to YCombinator if...
Definitely not clueless. Stateless. Big difference.
mlinsey··on The thousands of startups today that are pitching...
There have always been startups whose first products seemed like quick hacks (including some that went on to be extremely successful). There have always been startups that seemed more derivative than inspired. (And a few of these turned out to be revolutionary, because even if 98% of the idea was a ripoff, the last 2% was based on a deep understanding of the product being 'copied' that nobody, especially pundits, understood the significance of)

The only difference the author can point to is that more people are doing startups, more startups are getting funded, and there is more of a supporting infrastructure to help startups (incubators, hackathons, blogs, etc). Certainly starting a startup has become more socially acceptable. While this may make the act of entrepreneurship less "rebellious", this is not necessarily the kind of rebellion that makes for disruptive startups. Whether I get nods of approval or worried looks when I tell my non-startup friends I quit my big company job to start a startup has little bearing on how disruptive my idea is.

The article sounds more like a hipster's complaint than anything else ("I was into startups before they were cool!")

← PreviousPage 8 of 22Next →