HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mmmmmbop

1,055 karma · joined May 12, 2015

reach out to me at definitelynotmmmmmbop at gmail dot com
submissionscomments
mmmmmbop··on Even Apple employees hate Siri and are skeptical of its future, new report says
Nah, I'll have to disagree with you there. I don't know about Siri, but I am one of those people using the Google Assistant to set timers and reminders, and for me at least, this is reliable (enough), and definitely faster than by hand.

The obvious use case is setting a timer while cooking, when the phone is at the other end of the room and your hands may be dirty, but I'm using it even in non-cooking settings.

In fact, I just tried it and timed both approaches for setting a reminder. Results:

* Assistant: "Hey Google, set a reminder 10 days from now to file my taxes.": 4.5s to say it (I'm free to focus on other things after this point), 7.5s until reminder is created.

* Manual (pick up & unlock phone, open app drawer, open Calendar app, find the day 10 days from now, click on that day, click create a reminder, type in "file my taxes", save): 17s

mmmmmbop··on Google announces Q1 2023 earnings [pdf]
OpenAI is ahead at the moment, nobody's disputing that. But if anyone is able to challenge OpenAI's supremacy in that space, it's Google.

And if LLMs will indeed be the revolution that some make them out to be, and Google is able to capture 70+% market share within a few years as they were able with mobile OSes, that's not a bad place to be in.

mmmmmbop··on Google announces Q1 2023 earnings [pdf]
Where can I read more about these expectations?
mmmmmbop··on Google announces Q1 2023 earnings [pdf]
Accusing Google of missing out on LLMs is shortsighted, in my opinion. They were the ones who invented the entire LLM infrastructure, and they publicly released their own chat LLM just a few months after OpenAI. It's actually quite impressive to me that a company of this ridiculous size is able to pivot and execute so quickly when needed.

And let's be realistic. Had Google been the first to introduce a publicly accessible chat LLM, all the regulators that were already concerned about Google being too powerful would have intensified their calls for antitrust action against Google.

Also recall that Google was not the first to ship a modern smartphone OS and it took them years to achieve a similar quality to iOS, but now they dominate the worldwide smartphone OS market.

mmmmmbop··on Artist refuses prize after his AI image wins at top photo contest
To me, this just seems like a publicity stunt by the artist. Looking at the other images in the category [0], at least three of them are heavily edited. I see no reason why editing his image with AI-assisted tools should automatically disqualify the artist, unless the contest terms prohibit that, of which I see no mention in the article.

What's left is an artist who sets up the contest organizers by

• happily accepting the selection of his work on his website a month before the event (without a mention of intending to refuse the prize),

• then literally the night the before the event, publishing an "open letter" about refusing the prize on the website,

• and finally, showing up uninvited on stage to make his speech about refusing the prize.

This is a clever way of increasing his name awareness by riding the AI art controversy wave, for sure.

[0] https://archive.is/pH3Jb

mmmmmbop··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
That's a bit simplistic. Fiat currency "works" by being backed by a state, implying that the state will work to protect the fiat currency's value, be that through fiscally responsible governing and/or the use of force to protect its interests. For states which can not guarantee that, the currency tends to rapidly lose its purchase power.

When I mentioned the societal nature of crypto, I meant something different. People who hold crypto have a vested interest in the wider adoption of crypto, and they often tend to become vocal proponents of crypto projects. I don't even claim bad intentions – I believe there is some psychological effect at play here that causes people to hold opinions that serve their interests, and becoming a crypto holder means that from that moment on, the spread of crypto is in one's interests.

Now, my point was, that perhaps I overlooked this sociopsychological aspect of crypto. If enough people in power are personally invested in crypto, and they use their power to advance crypto adoption because it personally benefits them, then at some point it doesn't matter whether there's any intrinsic value in crypto or not – it becomes a self-reinforcing system.

mmmmmbop··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
> Crypto has tons of amazing use cases

Really? Which ones?

mmmmmbop··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
Really appreciate the perspective, thanks!
mmmmmbop··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
Right, and FTX was valued at $32 billion at some point.
mmmmmbop··on Replacing my best friends with an LLM trained on 500k group chat messages
You know, that's not the sentiment I've been experiencing in the industry. There's certainly some uncertainty and risk-taking on the margins, e.g. what exactly constitutes "fair use", how do design user consent flows, and so on. But it's broadly accepted that you can't do anything with personal data without user consent, and I've found companies to be very careful in that regard.

Recently, Meta was fined $400MM for forcing users to consent to targeted advertising [0]. Note how Meta was careful to get consent (even if the way they did it was illegitimate). Sure, $400MM may not be a lot for a company that size, but I genuinely believe that the fines would be an order of magnitude higher if a company intentionally decided to do something with personal data without consent. GDPR fines may reach up to 4% of worldwide revenue, plus likely any proceeds from the illegitimate venture.

[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/04/meta-fined-more-than-400-mil...

mmmmmbop··on Replacing my best friends with an LLM trained on 500k group chat messages
> And as part of their agreement, they can do pretty much whatever they like with those, can't they?

No, they definitely can't. Parts of HN love to hate on GDPR, but laws like that prevent companies from doing the things you proposed.

mmmmmbop··on Replacing my best friends with an LLM trained on 500k group chat messages
Definitely. I think an AI for my friends would be relatively straightforward. It would just never reply.
mmmmmbop··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
There was a time around 2020 I believe, where everyone and their mother was talking about crypto and the blockchain, and how it's going to be this big technological revolution. All kinds of private and public initiatives decided to include "the blockchain" in their projects, NFTs became huge, and there was talk of putting real estate, healthcare, and logistics "onto the blockchain".

It's been three years since then, and still no real-world use case has emerged. I don't dispute that there are completely valid use cases for cryptocurrencies, mainly around avoiding governmental financial restrictions and safeguards, and there are still loads of people using cryptocurrencies for speculation and/or as a "store of value". But the whole ecosystem of distributed apps, smart contracts, DAOs, and so on, still mainly revolves around itself, without wider societal impact.

mmmmmbop··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
Meta can't afford not to invest into generative AI. They are constantly fighting to stay relevant. Just see how TikTok's better recommender algorithm and content creation tools made Instagram play catch-up.

I'm not certain about the direction of Meta, but for now it seems that their most important areas are entertainment (Instagram, Reels) and messaging (WhatsApp, Messenger), not social networking (Facebook), which is dying.

For entertainment and messaging, generative AI is going to be huge. In entertainment, content creation and discovery will be severely advanced by AI. For messaging, at the very least, users will expect AI support in message composition and company-customer communication.

mmmmmbop··on Mass layoffs and absentee bosses create a morale crisis at Meta
The Metaverse was always such a bad direction. At the time, I was really unsure about my intuition -- I figured that if Mark Zuckerberg decided it's worth pivoting his entire company towards that goal, he surely must have some data to back that up. As it stands, my intuition (and everybody else's) turned out to be right.

It's been the same with crypto, for that matter. None of the reasonable people I know ever saw any grand value in crypto. Researching myself, it always just seemed to be a bullshit fractal. At the height of the crypto boom, I was beginning to doubt my conclusions and started to think that perhaps the societal nature of crypto is a force in itself. Like religion, if enough people believe in it, it becomes reality to some extent. But now we see that crypto was indeed bullshit all along.

Contrast that with the generative AI models revolution. It's clear to anyone from day one how useful those models will be, and that they are providing clear value right away. It's no wonder that all the companies are immediately pivoting towards it. Maybe Mark Zuckerberg was just unlucky to decide on a company pivot two years too early -- I'm sure that if he had to decide on a direction to pivot to today, it'd be towards generative AI.

mmmmmbop··on It happened to me today: $80/hr writer replaced with ChatGPT
Not GP, but the bit about the author signing up for Doordash as a driver also made me think the post is fake.

According to the post, the author lost her client on the day of making the post, and within that same day decided to sign up for Doordash before making the Reddit post. Even if she was under severe financial duress, it would be a surprisingly quick decision, but as a writer previously making $80/hr and having the financial resources to take 3 years off work, it just doesn't seem believable.

In the intro, she states that she's using a throwaway to avoid other clients identifying her, so she clearly does have other clients, and she does mention a "normal" rate of $50/hr, in addition to having worked as a "writer for over a decade, [having] worked with top brands as a freelancer, [and having] more than a dozen published articles on well known websites". How is the best use of time for somebody like that to work an unskilled $20/hr gig instead of investing time into building new client relationships?

Even if the author believes that this client firing her implies that her current profession is doomed long-term, it just seems out of character for somebody like that to resort to being a Doordash driver. It just seems like an appeal to the fear of sliding down the social ladder, and as such a manipulative tool (just like the clickbait title) to produce a high-engagement Reddit post.

mmmmmbop··on It happened to me today: $80/hr writer replaced with ChatGPT
The frustrating thing is that companies will likely be getting away with stating falsehoods and/or not following through on what the AI claimed they'll do.

Like how in the old days, if you sent a company a contract offer and they accepted it, they would be bound by it. Today, if you send a request to a company's server that they didn't expect and they confirm the contract, they're still later able to renege since you "hacked them" by removing some client-side constraints.

In the same way, I imagine that companies will claim no responsibility for what their AI says, essentially making the experience much worse for consumers. Today, if a customer service rep states something, the company is mostly bound to it. In the future, they'll just claim it was an "AI bug" or a "query injection attack" so they won't honor it.

mmmmmbop··on Laid-off tech workers choose stability over status
This is interesting, but somehow also a bit creepy.
mmmmmbop··on Defamed by ChatGPT
I'd rather read a 0% accurate newspaper than an 80% accurate newspaper.

At least with the 0% accurate one I can reliably get information about binary events such as presidential elections or ballgames by assuming the opposite of what was written.

mmmmmbop··on Over 40% of the latest YC batch are AI/ML startups
The combination of gradient descent and transformers is a weird choice to ask founders about. One is an almost trivial algorithm, whereas the other is a cutting-edge research result.
mmmmmbop··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
Could you please point out to me the no-go zone(s) in Munich? I lived there for almost a decade and never found one of those.

Or just any area within Munich where it would be unsafe to walk at night, thanks!

mmmmmbop··on Apple passwords deserve an app
There's a feature on the AirPods that allows you to enroll them in your iCloud account enabling Find My.

All you need to do is connect the AirPods to an iCloud-enrolled Apple device, and it will automatically connect to that iCloud account.

Oh, but it's not any iCloud-enrolled device, it must be an iOS device. Connecting them to my MacBook didn't do anything.

I went into the Apple Store to ask for a solution to that problem. They legitimately asked me why I'm buying AirPods if I don't have an iPhone -- they're called Air Pods after all... Anyway, their proposed solution was for me to buy a refurbished iPad for $450 to connect the AirPods to my iCloud.

mmmmmbop··on SVB collapse could mean a $500B venture capital ‘haircut’
Correct, anti-trust law can introduce a lot of rules prohibiting actions that would be fine if it weren't for the monopolistic position of the actor. But as mentioned in the other comment, there's no differentiation there between physical and virtual products.
mmmmmbop··on SVB collapse could mean a $500B venture capital ‘haircut’
Right, but there is zero differentiation there between physical and virtual products. GP implied that there is some sort of protection against price dumping of physical products that doesn't exist for virtual products.
mmmmmbop··on Ghoti
Or Kansas (can-zuhs) vs. Arkansas (ar-kin-saw).
mmmmmbop··on SVB collapse could mean a $500B venture capital ‘haircut’
I agree with the sentiment, but it's not correct that price dumping is illegal for physical products.

Trade treaties and WTO rules cover dumping in international trade for obvious reasons, but to my knowledge, there's no law in the major western jurisdictions covering domestic dumping.

mmmmmbop··on The FTC wants to ban tough-to-cancel subscriptions
I've been in Brazil recently and I was positively surprised with the great consumer protection laws.

One law I really liked was the "right to regret", meaning you can cancel a wide array of contracts within 7 days. For example, when booking a hotel online, no matter the hotel's cancellation policies, you can cancel a reservation within 7 days of making it.

mmmmmbop··on Google to reduce workforce by 12k
Germany, for example.
mmmmmbop··on TensorFlow for Python is dying?
George Hotz is a great hacker and problem solver, but I greatly doubt he has the patience to actually build a product.

This is a fantastic skill set to solo-hack a complicated piece of software and produce a proof-of-concept, but not for building a tool that people actually use. See his track record of never building any successful product after his PS3 & iOS jailbreaks, his latest resignation memo from Comma.ai, and his resignation from Twitter after just 4 weeks.

So I think it's kind of hilarious that you're citing him and his newest tinygrad project in one sentence with the assertion that PyTorch & friends will soon be considered ancient and clunky tools. While I don't necessarily dispute the latter, I'm certain that tinygrad won't be the one replacing them.

mmmmmbop··on Reliability, constant work, and a good cup of coffee
Is the title a reference to the movie 'Stutz'?
← PreviousPage 4 of 9Next →