HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

monkeywork

1,051 karma · joined July 5, 2015

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/monkeywork; my proof: https://keybase.io/monkeywork/sigs/ttwbwbc0hvERD7_z90G53Q6NNJ3JErE_O0zkiid2C4M ]
submissionscomments
monkeywork··on ‘You Are Done’: The letter sent to King by the F.B.I (2014)
You make it sound like this would pass into law and within 48 hours everyone would need to go get an ID.

You'd pass this into law and then have it take effect 2-4 years out, and if you can't go and secure yourself an ID after 2-4 years of notice you aren't a functional adult.

monkeywork··on ‘You Are Done’: The letter sent to King by the F.B.I (2014)
Do you pay taxes? Have you ever applied for a loan/bank account/rent/mortgage/etc? Have you ever enrolled a child in school? Have you ever applied for a job? Have you ever had to fill out paperwork after the loss of a loved one? etc etc etc etc

These are all tasks that a functional adult in the world needs to do regardless of background / race / creed / etc.

It's not bad faith to say hey as a functional adult you should go get a fucking ID.

What is the % of people that honestly do not have one? Pass a law and give people 4 years to go get one.

Like why must you insist on treating people like hopeless children?

monkeywork··on ‘You Are Done’: The letter sent to King by the F.B.I (2014)
Does the American left feel the same way about firearms? I've heard for years that there should be registration and licensing on them (which I actually agree with).
monkeywork··on ‘You Are Done’: The letter sent to King by the F.B.I (2014)
I'm asking something that specifically targets black Americans as a group - the VRA doesn't target them (at least as my understanding goes) but rather as you said is allowing gerrymandering which more divides down political lines than racial ones unless you are suggesting that every person of a racial group thinks and votes the same.

I guess to put it more directly if we took a hypothetical black male named Steven and a hypothetical white female named Sally who have the same job, live in the same neighborhood, etc - what rights has been rolled back on Steven that were not on Sally.

monkeywork··on ‘You Are Done’: The letter sent to King by the F.B.I (2014)
Honest question as I'm not American and may be missing context but what Civil Rights are black Americans having rolled back on them?
monkeywork··on Improper redaction reveals Google Data Center water and electricity usage
>other is actively being used for malicious crimes against humanity.

Yawn... every time people make claims like this the less and less I care to hear their concerns.

monkeywork··on Improper redaction reveals Google Data Center water and electricity usage
if you think farmers are "absolute brain dead" you haven't spent any time with them.
monkeywork··on Does Reddit have an astroturfing problem? What the data suggests
A few things I miss:

Smaller communities. You generally knew what kind of community you were participating in. Focused discussion. A forum was usually about a specific subject, rather than one account participating in dozens of completely unrelated communities.

Your identity was more compartmentalized. What you said on a linux forum didn't necessarily follow you into a motorcycle community.

Moderation had different incentives. If you ran a forum, you needed people to actually want to come back. Moderation that became too heavy-handed could kill the community you were trying to maintain.

Reddit essentially turned the forum model into one enormous site with thousands of sections, sounds great but broke more than it fixed.

Your Reddit account becomes a single identity spanning everything you do. Someone can look through your activity in completely unrelated subreddits, form an opinion about you based on that, and potentially use something you said somewhere else against you... no matter what the culture/norms/rules were of the other community.

A traditional forum depended on its community surviving. On Reddit, a subreddit can become extremely valuable simply because it occupies a desirable name and has accumulated a large user base. The underlying platform is doing most of the work of bringing people there. The moderator can be "all powerful" and heavy handed because they know rarely do competing subreddits actually work out.

monkeywork··on Parley: Federated, decentralised chat that speaks plain IRC
>Unfortunately XMPP is an absolutely terrible protocol

Can you provide more details here? I've never seen an issue with the protocol at all, more issues with feature difference between servers depending on what they have decided to implement or not.

monkeywork··on PipePipe: NewPipe hard fork implementing SponsorBlock
Are you not describing perfect as the enemy of good?

A product doesn't need to serve EVERY human on earths needs, just enough of them that it can become large enough that established legacy solutions need to adapt.

I get why you might think this wouldn't be a fit for YOU but rather than argue against it from a niche viewpoint instead maybe look at how if it did exist it could be good for many.

monkeywork··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
or the phrase lesser of two evils...

Candidate A - will do X, Y, Z all in ways I think are the best Candidate B - will do A, B, C which I prefer less than X, Y, Z but in the grand scheme likely impact my day to day life little. Candidate A - also supports (or is supported by) people / movements that actively make my life harder and piss me off.

That's not cutting off my nose that's deciding I can live with a less optimal solution to some problems to avoid something that pisses me off massively from growing more powerful

monkeywork··on Does Georgism work? Five years later
I don't know how you can say it's a straw-man argument when you qualify the the statement as "typically" increases the value of the land... that indicates you KNOW at least occasionally it doesn't increase and instead decreases, and if it's a real possibility (even if the % is low - 10-15%) then it's not a straw-man argument to be concerned about it, it becomes something that should be risk weighted and explained to mitigate the concern.
monkeywork··on EU chief opens door for Canada to become 'associate member'
No - it means that Charles III is an independent monarch for two separate nations.

The monarchy is 99% ceremonial in Canada but it's important to note that the Canadian Crown isn't the UK Crown... Canada is not a dependent of the UK in anyway, simply the person that wears the Crowns is the same person.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monarchy_of_Canada

>the Crown has had both a shared and a separate character: the sovereign's role as monarch of Canada has been distinct from their position as monarch of any other realm,[n 4][16][65][66][67] including the United Kingdom.[n 6][69][70][71][72] Only Canadian federal ministers of the Crown may advise the sovereign on any and all matters of the Canadian state,[n 7][70][73][74][75][76][77] of which the sovereign, when not in Canada, is kept abreast by weekly communications with the federal viceroy.[78] The monarchy thus ceased to be an exclusively British institution and, in Canada, became a Canadian,[40][79][80][81] or "domesticated",[82] establishment, though it is still often denoted as "British" in both legal and common language,[40] for reasons historical, political, and of convenience.

monkeywork··on EVE Online moves to Python 3
if you like the idea of dwarf fortress check out songs of syx. it really scratches that itch for me and is infinitely more accessible
monkeywork··on Nostr is an inclusive communication commons
can you expand on the gaming ecosystem around it?
monkeywork··on Nostr is an inclusive communication commons
From what I've gathered it's pro-censorship however since the user is entirely mobile and can change relays at will without friction that the power still remains with the user... the relay doesn't have much power in anything they can't keep their users from finding you, and they can't keep you from publishing elsewhere they can only choose to not accept your posts.

When I setup my account I list 3-4 relays that will host my content, if any one relay decides they dislike me and bans me no big deal everyone who follows me already knows to check 3-4 different servers for me and will find my content on the others, and I can update that list at any point in time just as quickly as I'm banned... so unless you can get every relay (which ideally are all individual groups with likely different rules / regulations) I publish to to ban me at the same time there is no real way to "censor" someone in the way we are used to currently.

monkeywork··on Nostr is an inclusive communication commons
Funny timing on this - I just came across my backed up keys recently and signed back into it. Poking around over the last 24 hours has left me underwhelmed in terms of actual interesting content (I'm not a cryptobro) nor overly innovative things built on top of the protocol.

Those who are finding it useful - can you give me some direction on things I may have missed? It feels less useful than blsky which feels less useful mastodon which feels less useful than X...

monkeywork··on I'll be stepping back from leading product for X
X has been great lately for me, especially compared to any of the big alternatives. Things like having auto translation, community notes, a followers tab that actually works, and account location are all fantastic.

My experience with X is you get back exactly what you seek out and put into the platform. If you are engaging with toxic political nonsense, engaging with clickbait negativity, or try to farm engagement with hot takes that's the posts you get back. If instead you simply follow PEOPLE you find interesting, ignore the noise, block the really bad, within a week your feed is cleaned up and fun to go through.

Honestly those who are still crying about X and Elon are coming off like clingy ex-lovers who can't accept that the other side isn't thinking about them anymore. Move on if you don't like Elon or X, it's fine, be happy elsewhere... we don't need to listen to the belly aching.

monkeywork··on AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog
>Public shaming and rejection are probably the best way to teach people

For me it's a reverse filter, the people I see doing the shaming, those the loudest most seemingly unhinged anti-AI folks - they get blocked / ignored and looked at as if they were the equiv of PETA activists.

monkeywork··on AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog
For most people your blog is really for you, and if anyone is reading it on the regular than bonus points... but the vast majority of the planet who runs a blog the traffic is very low.

So do with it as you wish, if you enjoy playing with AI and having it assist you with any part of it it's your corner of the net do with it as you absolutely wish and everyone else can kick rocks.

monkeywork··on The End of an Era
no, you don't have 1M counter examples. I'd also wager the vast majority of examples that you do have are on older models of LLMs that have been vastly surpassed in capabilities in the last 6 months.

You are essentially talking out a hole on the bottom half of your body.

monkeywork··on The End of an Era
Before you would ever get to a point where someone claiming your work was AI would be able to get access to your computer, editor, family/friends, etc there would need to be a bar that needs to be cleared for a judge to allow that discovery to take place.

What I'm asking is what is that bar?

Copyright is going to be assumed by default - in order to break that assumption there needs to be some process... however for all the people who are "concerned" about the copyright status of works that have touched AI I've never seen anyone make a feasable argument on how it would ever practically take place.

monkeywork··on The End of an Era
How does one PROVE AI or human writing to determine copyright?

Who is challenging a lack of copyright on a work?

You publish a story, I take it and republish it / remix it / whatever, you invoke copyright protections and try to have mine taken down - how do I prove your work was AI and thus has no copyright, and how do you prove (or do you even have to) that it's human?

Who has the burden of proof - the person claiming AI created it, and thus it has no copyright, or the person who claims they wrote it and it does have copyright?

monkeywork··on The End of an Era
Again - did you even read the article you are commenting on? The author gives an example of a novel that had a huge advance offered on it and then pulled because of AI concerns... in order to get to the point of having the offer a bunch of competent writers, editors etc didn't notice.
monkeywork··on The End of an Era
Why would there need to be a stigma for getting paid based on a tool they used?

Do other authors have a stigma for using a word processor instead of a typewriter?

Artist have a stigma for using photoshop instead of canvas?

monkeywork··on The lost joy of music piracy
>(I’ve got a song still stuck in my head from a Canadian indie band that made its way onto my iPod via via and I’ve done all the searching in the world for the lyrics I remember and have never found the band. I love this that I’ve never found them!)

what were the lyrics you recall?

monkeywork··on Telegram's t.me domain has been suspended
someone enforcing a min character policy on them?
monkeywork··on Chatto is now open source
your comment sounds like your the type to say you won't buy a house in North America cause its stolen land...
monkeywork··on Your ePub Is fine
You're completely (and I think intentionally) missing that flash enabled people to easily create those things... and that creativity and ease of use still hasn't been replicated (your example of Unity - doesn't come close to the ease)

People loved flash for what flash was good for (creative toys) they disliked flash when certain sites started making it the core of the navigation etc.

When people are nostalgic for flash it's for finding random toys from other people who weren't "IT people".

monkeywork··on Write for One Person
Is there a link to the "shuffle seven times" talk?
Page 1 of 16Next →