HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

montjoy

279 karma · joined November 22, 2019

submissionscomments
montjoy··on AI Is Stifling Tech Adoption
The lack of new training data also makes it bad at projects that are still maturing because it will suggest outdated code - or worse it will mix/match old and new syntax and generate something completely broken.

I worry that the lack of new examples for it to train on will self-reinforce running old syntax that has bad patterns.

If the "AI" could actually store its mistakes and corrections from interactive sessions long-term I think it would greatly alleviate this problem, but that opens up another whole set of problems.

montjoy··on Windshield pitting incidents in Washington reach fever pitch on April 15, 1954 (2003)
> If they? it? wanted to harm us they could/would.

But how do we know they aren’t doing harm in subtle ways? Thus I’m embracing cognitive dissonance. I think the evidence points to something but I refuse to decide it’s real.

montjoy··on Windshield pitting incidents in Washington reach fever pitch on April 15, 1954 (2003)
I’ve come to few conclusions about this recently.

1. Most people will never believe in UFOs until they see one for themselves in an unambiguous way or hear a report from someone in person that they believe is credible. There is too much stigma around this topic.

2. There is a very large amount, probably 1000s records, of credible and consistent evidence out there. However 99% of it is circumstantial and will never be viewed by the public at large.

3. The military, after years of reporting and chasing, can’t be bothered investigating anymore. This seems to be cyclical.

4. A culture/civilization/whatever that has these kind of technologies would have immense power if they wanted it. It’s just too terrifying to believe in, especially if we don’t know what they want.

montjoy··on Bi-elliptic transfer orbit maneuver
I’m pretty sure it’s done whenever there are inclination changes. Mechjeb had an option for it IIRC.
montjoy··on OK, I can partly explain the LLM chess weirdness now
I came to the comments to say this too. If you were prompting it to generate code, you generally get better results when you ask it for a result. You don’t just tell it, “You are a python expert and here is some code”. You give it a direction you want the code to go. I was surprised that there wasn’t something like, “and win”, or, “black wins”, etc.
montjoy··on What is theoretical computer science?
Hi. Comment reader here. Regardless whether you are right or not you’re coming across as obstinate. It might do you well to eat some humble pie.
montjoy··on Astronomers puzzled by little red galaxies that seem impossibly dense
> it was missing other key features seen with black holes, such as X-rays and radio waves. There were also other features, such as a peak in the light’s brightness at certain frequencies, that suggested it came from stars

Amateur speculation:

A dense group of stars tightly circling an early forming supermassive black hole? The stars would be able to (mostly) block the radio and x-rays.

montjoy··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
I have both the Airthings Wave+ and the AirGradient Pro. I like them both. The Wave+ can connect to Home Assistant just fine with Bluetooth so there’s no worry about “owning” the data etc. I didn’t care for the initial software that came with the AirGradient but it was easy enough to flash once I understood how ESPHome worked.
montjoy··on FCC seek comments on NextNav petition for rulemaking on lower 900MHz ISM band
Things in my house that use the lower 900Mhz band already:

- Z-wave network

- Weather Stations

In the past - cordless phones

- baby monitors

Do we have any guarantees that these devices will continue to work?

montjoy··on FCC seek comments on NextNav petition for rulemaking on lower 900MHz ISM band
Great question. I’m wondering the same. According to Wikipedia:

> in Europe it operates at the 868-869 MHz band while in North America the band varies from 908-916 MHz when Z-Wave is operating as a mesh network and 912-920 MHz when Z-Wave is operating with a star topology in Z-Wave LR mode.

So there definitely would be overlap in North America.

montjoy··on Microsoft Chose Profit over Security, Whistleblower Says
I dunno, that’s a pretty cynical take. Isn’t it just as plausible that they became aware of the bribes internally and were trying to curtail them when the scandal broke out? Or maybe the “don’t do bribes” training actually worked enough for someone to whistleblow even if official internal channels failed? Those who are doing wrong often try to stymie others from making positive changes out of fear, greed, etc.

Edit: I just want to add that there are things to be cynical about - I’m not completely naive. If it’s your legal department heading up the training then you can be pretty sure that there was a cause for it.

montjoy··on The Intellectual Obesity Crisis (2022)
Right. The other thing is that the parent claims to be an insider which is great- I love that perspective. However, as outsiders maybe the researchers did the best they could with what data was available to them. After reading the blog article it seems like the main thing the researchers may have had wrong is the margin of error. I don’t have a huge problem with that since science is supposed to get more accurate over time as refinements come in.

Perhaps it would have been better if the blog writer had approached the researchers and said, “Hey I read your paper. I have insider knowledge and I’d like to help you refine your model.”

montjoy··on Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your clients
That was my first thought too. I looked at the Firefly product and it seemed to say they don’t use your personal data. They have other “AI” products through like GenStudio that’s “coming soon” and I don’t see any “ethical ai” section in its description.

I bet this is a “test the waters” EULA and we’ll see them pull it back in the next few days if not hours.

If they do pull it back I wonder if they get to keep all of the content of the people who clicked yes within the time window of the onerous EULA?

montjoy··on The Intellectual Obesity Crisis (2022)
I want to believe you but now I have to trust your claims over what the NYT, etc are publishing. In order to do that I not only need to follow your sources but the original sources that NYT etc define to ensure they are the same. I also have to make my own conclusions about the data to see if I agree with anyone’s analysis. Frankly it’s too much to do when all I want is a few dopamine hits in the middle of the night before I can fall asleep again.
montjoy··on Show HN: HackerNews but for research papers
Looks great!
montjoy··on Show HN: HackerNews but for research papers
I second this. Mobile is how I primarily read news. IMO it should be the first platform you support.
montjoy··on Intel undercut a standards body to give us the PCI connector
I had something like this from a temp job that was liquidating old hardware. They were Northgate PCs and they had two extended 32-bit ISA slots that were giant memory cards. I’m pretty sure the platform was i386.
montjoy··on Unscientific American – Science journalism surrenders to progressive ideology
Since I’m not familiar with City Journal I decided to see who runs it because that headline seemed pretty biased.

From the site’s footer:

> City Journal is a publication of the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (MI), a leading free-market think tank.

Wikipedia on City Journal:

> The magazine is published by the conservative Manhattan Institute for Policy Research[1][11] a national free-market think tank based in New York City.

montjoy··on DOS 4.0 Source Code Released Under MIT License
It’s hard to tell. According to Wikipedia, DOS 4.0 is different than 4.00

> MS-DOS 4.0 (multitasking) and MS-DOS 4.1 – A separate branch of development with additional multitasking features, released between 3.2 and 3.3, and later abandoned. It is unrelated to any later versions, including versions 4.00 and 4.01 listed below

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MS-DOS#4.01

montjoy··on Boeing CEO Calhoun to step down at end of 2024
Of course it’s leadership that makes the call. At any large company sales and marketing have a huge influence on the leadership and therefore the product. The engineering teams that align with those goals will get the best funding and will be listened to the most.
montjoy··on How far are we from intelligent visual deductive reasoning?
IIRC confidence in video is related to predicting what happens next vs what actually happens. If the two seem to correlate to the model it would give it a higher confidence ranking, which would then be used further for self-reinforced learning.
montjoy··on Institutions try to preserve the problem to which they are the solution
I would argue that the main function of the TSA is to ensure the public feels safe flying. As long as the public perceives that the TSA is making it “safe enough” to fly it has value, regardless of its actual effectiveness.
montjoy··on Findaway's new terms of service are unacceptable
Meta wanted more LLM training data from us and we caved. Whoopsie.
montjoy··on "Fake Chinese income" mortgages fuel Toronto real estate bubble: HSBC bank leaks
I think in an ideal world you’re right. Ideally if housing costs were too expensive I would just move somewhere else. However we live in a world where there are borders and immigration policies and violence and relationships and jobs and climates that make moving around hard. Housing is a hard problem because there are limited resources for where people want to/can live. It’s a type of natural monopoly. I’m pretty sure history has abundant examples of what happens when you allow natural monopolies to run unchecked. Personally I’d rather have a mismanaged democratic government in charge of the monopoly than any private entity.
montjoy··on Artist trained rats to take selfies to make a point about social media
I don’t think it matters. While it would have been interesting if the rats got pleasure looking at themselves, ultimately this is an art project about human society that is meant for human consumption. The fact that we read about it means it was somewhat successful. The issue of whether the rats got a dopamine kick from just pressing the button is irrelevant.
montjoy··on Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel
I also remember him saying, (paraphrasing here) “I’m not particularly smart, there are people out there that are much smarter than me. What I am really good at is poking around in the dark with a stick and seeing what happens”
montjoy··on Hans Reiser on ReiserFS deprecation in the Linux kernel
Don’t forget, leaving his cell phone at home on the day of his wife’s murder when he otherwise always carried it with him.
montjoy··on Ask HN: Why do computers/tablets/etc "freeze up" as they get older?
There are a few things going on that I’m aware of. It’s usually related to disk.

- Windows update can take a lot of blame for this. Basically the longer the Windows release has been out, the more windows updates there are. After every boot one of the first things windows does is check for updates. It then scans the local folder where the updates are saved and does some sort of check to make sure everything is good. Processing this folder can take hours on an older machine with a spinning disk.

- The Windows registry, where almost all windows settings and quite often app settings are stored, has terrible performance and can become bloated over the years at as more and more stuff is written to it.

- An SSD can suffer bad write performance if you are dealing with a somewhat full disk and it can’t trim space quick enough to deal with new writes coming in.

- In Linux you’re not supposed to mount with discard any more but instead rely on a cron job that runs in the background once a day. I think various manufacturers are supposed to handle the trim in firmware too but then it’s a black box.

- Filesystems generally perform worse as they fill up. In my experience NTFS seems to have a lower threshold than ext4 or XFS.

- Your disk might be failing. Look at the SMART stats to see if you are hitting unacceptable error thresholds.

- In Linux anything that uses snaps will take forever to start the first time.

montjoy··on Ask HN: Where do you host your own-domain email?
I used to do this, but then I had to move and I moved my domain to Gmail “temporarily” so I could still get email while waiting for my isp at the new location. Short story is that I don’t miss the cognitive overhead and I’m still on Gmail.

How do you manage filtering spam?

montjoy··on Windows 11 Update 23H2 is stealing users' IMAP credentials
It’s encrypted between the starting point (Microsoft) and your ISP. Microsoft is the “client” in this case and just like you can read your email in Outlook or Thunderbird, MS can read all of your email that they pull over from you ISP.
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →