HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mousetummy

8 karma · joined December 31, 2015

submissionscomments
mousetummy··on Luck of the English: A new history shatters myths about an extraordinary nation
Point taken; Blair doesn't self-identify as Scottish but to be fair I've no doubt he would do so if it was to his political advantage, which I think is fair enough - he's in politics.

On the other hand, he was, as you admit, born in Scotland, spent many years of his childhood there, including (I may be wrong) the formative secondary school years (ages 13-18), and I don't think it would be crossing the line if some proud Scot were to claim him as one of their own.

Your second line vaguely defines a 'people' but given the context, I am assuming you suspect me as one of them, so for the record, I am English-born of a largely Scottish origin family, foolishly proud of my Scottish heritage, and do not nurse any grievance - quite the contrary. Indeed, I voted for both recent 'Scottish' prime ministers. I've never noticed a grievance in others claiming Blair as Scottish but will look out for it.

Your last sentence makes a sad but good point.

mousetummy··on Luck of the English: A new history shatters myths about an extraordinary nation
The UK is a very odd country politically. Two of the last three UK prime ministers (Blair and Brown) were Scottish. The third, Cameron is (partly) of Scottish descent, Cameron being a Scottish surname. Scottish people appear to be rather over represented in UK history, politics, and culture given their relative population, for whatever reason.