HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mplanchard

5,132 karma · joined April 5, 2019

https://blog.mplanchard.com/
submissionscomments
mplanchard··on Advancing human gut microbiota research by considering gut transit time
From the article’s “key takeaways”:

> By considering interindividual and intraindividual differences in transit time in human studies, diet–microbiota interactions and disease-related microbiome signatures may be better elucidated.

There is also an entire section entitled “The role of gut transit time in health and disease”

mplanchard··on Advancing human gut microbiota research by considering gut transit time (2023)
The article is open access, I don’t see any reason to prefer the dumbed-down narrative summary: https://gut.bmj.com/content/72/1/180
mplanchard··on Ben Lerner's Big Feelings
Coincidentally, I just this morning read another review of this in the new yorker: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/04/06/transcription-...
mplanchard··on Binary Dependencies: Identifying the Hidden Packages We All Depend On
This is one of the reasons I like having a nix flake in all of my projects that defines a dev environment, and integration with direnv to activate it. The flake lockfile, combined with the language-specific lockfile, gives a mostly complete picture of everything needed to build/deploy/develop the package.
mplanchard··on The future of everything is lies, I guess: Where do we go from here?
Regardless of how you feel about this question, it doesn't necessarily map to the current situation.

Just because the loss of one skill to a supplanting technology led to one kind of societal change, does not mean that the loss of any skill to a supplanting technology will lead to the same kind of societal change. Assuming that to be true is a faulty generalization.

I think it wouldn't be hard to argue that writing has changed human society more profoundly than any other invention. Whether or not the change was positive is a matter of taste and likely unanswerable. The point though is there are plenty of other examples of new technologies that changed technology and deskilled humans, both mentally and physically, that changed society in radically different ways, compared to writing (looms, tractors, sails, calculators, computers, guns, and so on).

There's certainly a case to be made that, of major past technological advancements, the kind of deskilling we'd see due to heavy AI use is most comparable to the deskilling due to writing: presumably there were many day-to-day and essential activities that made use of the mental acuity people would lose due to reading, just as there are many day-to-day activities that one can imagine people becoming less skilled in due to AI use.

To me, the most dangerous difference though may be in what gets deskilled. If we only relinquish our ability to do certain menial and intellectual drudgery, that is one thing. But if what we actually relinquish and deskill is our agency and discernment, as a result of constant "delegation" to AI systems, I think we're in for a much worse time.

mplanchard··on The future of everything is lies, I guess: Where do we go from here?
My hope is that there is a sort of Cambrian explosion of small software projects built by people who have absolutely no clue what they're doing. Many such projects will go nowhere, but some percentage of them will see success and growth. My second hope is that there will always come some threshold of complexity beyond which AI cannot effectively iterate on a project without (at minimum) the prompting of an expert in the field.

The combination of these two things could lead to a situation where there is a massive, startup-dominated market for engineers who can take projects from 0.5 to 1, as well as for consulting companies or services that help founders to do the same.

Another pair of hopes is that a) the LLM systems plateau at a level where any use on complex or important projects requires expert knowledge and prompting, and b) that because of this, the hype of using them to replace engineers dies down. This would hopefully lead to a situation where they are treated like any other tool in our toolbox. Then, just like no one forces me to use emacs or vim (despite the fact that they unambiguously help me to be at least 2x more productive), no one will force me to use LLMs just for the sake of it.

mplanchard··on The future of everything is lies, I guess: Where do we go from here?
This comment seems to be both reductive and in bad faith.

Of course there is an idea of non-toxic masculinity that doesn't just equate to !masculinity. People love to bring up examples of non-toxic masculinity in media. Someone on reddit has even compiled a megalist of examples of non-toxic masculinity in film: https://www.reddit.com/r/MensLib/comments/eb0ir1/a_megalist_...

mplanchard··on The buns in McDonald's Japan's burger photos are all slightly askew
Not sure about this, given that sufficiently accurate plastic simulacra satisfy the law, right? Is it just that it can’t be digitally generated?
mplanchard··on Google broke its promise to me – now ICE has my data
a) The kids in cages garnered significant press, public sympathy, and protest

b) I also lived in Austin during that time, and the scale and militarization of current ICE action is on another level to what it was in the early 10's

mplanchard··on Two Months After I Gave an AI $100 and No Instructions
But not novel or interesting enough for anyone to actually write anything about it?

Why should I spend my time enabling someone too lazy to do their own writing? If I want to know what an LLM has to say, I can prompt it myself.

mplanchard··on Two Months After I Gave an AI $100 and No Instructions
If the author couldn’t be bothered to write it, why should I be bothered to read it?
mplanchard··on Two Months After I Gave an AI $100 and No Instructions
I agree that it is extremely disrespectful to your readers to produce content with LLMs that you intend for them to actually read. Luckily there are still relative obvious tells for stuff that is generated whole-cloth (especially: “Not this thing. Not that thing. Other thing”), so it’s easy to duck out.

Much of the issue with the way people use these machines is in the way they use them to denigrate the social contract. Mimicking language and expecting it to be taken seriously in a social context is an ethically nauseating thing to do: it’s essentially one half of why plagiarism is wrong. Plagiarism isn’t just wrong because it is theft; it’s also wrong because it is a lie that disrespects your readers, breaking the implicit contract that what they’re reading represents your legitimately earned thoughts.

mplanchard··on Google has the same AI adoption curve as John Deere
https://xcancel.com/i/status/2043747998740689171
mplanchard··on Sam Altman's home targeted in second attack
Yes, exactly. One of the definitions of a State is that it's the organization holding the monopoly on legitimate use of violence.

When a State becomes undemocratic, it can more easily wield that violence against its own people. Part of the founding ideals of the US is the hope that the people would oust such a State, explicitly through the threat and application of violence if necessary, thus the second amendment.

mplanchard··on Sam Altman's home targeted in second attack
Yes, and in addition to this, we see examples daily of violence being inflicted on the poor by the rich, both literally (ICE, police militarization, harsh prison conditions, poor oversight of prisons) and figuratively (reduced social safety net, threat of ruin and bankruptcy due to medical debt, thread of lost jobs and corresponding loss of safety, a lack of consequences for criminal behavior directly correlated to wealth).

I often can't help but see the "all violence is bad" narrative as another tool of oppression by the ruling class. Even if that isn't its intent, it certainly seems to serve their purposes.

mplanchard··on A Canonical Generalization of OBDD
Makes sense, and thank you for the expansions! Makes it easier to look them up
mplanchard··on A perfectable programming language
fwiw, I think a similar tik-tac-toe evaluator could be made in rust declarative macros, no proc macros needed. I’ll see if I can smuggle some experimentation time today to make an example.
mplanchard··on A Canonical Generalization of OBDD
When I was writing biochemistry papers, it was a rule that you had to introduce the full spelling of a phrase along with the first use of its acronym in the full text. Is that not a thing anymore? This abstract reads like something out of a deep immunology subfield, and the first few paragraphs of the introduction didn’t help me out much either.
mplanchard··on I gave every train in New York an instrument
I think every line’s route is normalized to the same length of time, and a note is played when trains are at stations along that route.

If you turn on the map portion of the UI, you can see where the stations are. This is why there’s a dearth of notes over the east river (no stations on the water), other than the one stop at Roosevelt Island, for the F or the M, depending on the time of day.

mplanchard··on I gave every train in New York an instrument
I’d love to see this as an art installation in a subway station, please consider chatting with MTA Arts & Design, maybe they could hook you up with the right people to make this a fixture somewhere: https://www.mta.info/agency/arts-design
mplanchard··on US – Iran negotiations end with no deal reached
Agree with the general point, but the second example shouldn’t have been that hard to imagine. We’ve done it before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_invasion_of_Pana...
mplanchard··on Great at gaming? US air traffic control wants you to apply
a) it’s possible to live at the edge your means regardless of where you are relatively to the poverty line.

b) It’s not a bad salary for an individual, but supporting a family of 3-5 on $155k does not leave a lot of room for error

mplanchard··on Surelock: Deadlock-Free Mutexes for Rust
Just wanted to add to your great summary a link to tokio’s docs on which kind of mutex to use, which seem applicable to the mutex in TFA as well: https://docs.rs/tokio/latest/tokio/sync/struct.Mutex.html#wh...

Also to note, regarding “future not send,” that, in tokio codebases where the general expectation is that futures will be Send, enabling the clippy lint “future_not_send” is extremely helpful in avoiding these kinds of issues and also in keeping the error localized to the offending function, rather than it being miles away somewhere it happens to be getting indirectly spawned or whatever: https://rust-lang.github.io/rust-clippy/stable/index.html?se...

mplanchard··on A security scanner as fast as a linter – written in Rust
Sure thing, feel free. If you’d like more details, you send me an email at msplanchard (at gmail)
mplanchard··on Great at gaming? US air traffic control wants you to apply
Many people are living paycheck to paycheck. A month or two of missed payments can have a ton of downstream consequences.
mplanchard··on The Seasons Are Wrong
Here (Vermont) we call Locking Stick Season and Unlocking Mud Season, but agree that six is the right number
mplanchard··on A security scanner as fast as a linter – written in Rust
It is still quite fast on that codebase, fwiw. 10.7 ms.
mplanchard··on A security scanner as fast as a linter – written in Rust
Looks interesting, will give it a run on the codebase at $work. One thing that would be nice to see in the README are benchmarks on larger codebases. Everything in the benchmark table is quite small. I’d also list line count over files, since the latter is a much better measure of amount of code.

For context, the codebase I work on most often has 1200 JS/TS files, 685 rust files, and a bunch more. LoC is 13k JS, 80k TS, and 155k Rust

mplanchard··on Charcuterie – Visual similarity Unicode explorer
Love the name, very clever
mplanchard··on Help Keep Thunderbird Alive
For their more common meanings, like in your paragraph, as a verb you want affect, and as a noun, effect. So, when in doubt, use that as a rule of thumb.

However, both have alternative meanings as the other part of speech.

Affect as a noun means emotion or disposition, and is mostly used in psychology. Your psychologist may say you have a depressed affect.

Effect as a verb means to bring about. You might say that a successful protest effected change in society.

As a verb, in addition to “have an impact on,” affect can also mean “to pretend to have,” like “she affected an air of mystery,” although this is less common.

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →