HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mr_tristan

1,282 karma · joined October 3, 2015

Greybeard engineer
submissionscomments
mr_tristan··on Ian Lance Taylor's Response to “Go Is Google's Language”
It _might_ be an institutional risk for people, who are evaluating tooling, to just decide that they don't see other major companies getting involved, see a bunch of gripes about the module system switcheroo, and decide "nah".

You really get a sense of "this is Google's approach" with the go toolchain, because it's pretty unique. One of the first documents, "How to Write Go Code", sets up a workspace that doesn't clearly integrate in with any other toolchain I'm aware of.

So, just by reading about the ecosystem, it's not clear who is really investing in it, and, you have a single, unique approach to tooling apparently dominating.

I just wonder if these arguments would be mitigated if Go ever got the investment in "developer relations" that other Google projects get, with some better onboarding documentation.

mr_tristan··on Ian Lance Taylor's Response to “Go Is Google's Language”
It's just interesting because Android seems to be much more "externally focused", as opposed to Go, which seems much more of "here's an internal tool you can use".

Kotlin and the community version of IntelliJ came along _way after_ the Android toolchain was already available, and Google basically shifted gears and adopted it. Android Studio switched from Eclipse to IntelliJ, and Kotlin is now a default language.

I just don't see that kind of change ever happening with Go. There's no "other voice". It feels like it's "Google with a few enthusiasts".

mr_tristan··on Ian Lance Taylor's Response to “Go Is Google's Language”
I kind of read the original argument that Go is dominated by a "Google point of view", and there really isn't a significant alternative view that's as coherent. And that may be a risk.

It's not obvious to figure out how Go "plays with others". And it's unclear if that's much of a risk or not. As an outsider, you read of the funky module system duality and you wonder... "What if I don't want to 'work like Google'? Will this work in the future?" It's actually not that clear.

It's weird, because I don't get this sense, for example, with Kotlin projects in Android. You can write Kotlin in Android Studio. Or, in IntelliJ for backend code with Spring. And the tooling seems to be oriented in the same way. For most devs I've met, you can just swap Kotlin for Java, and everything else just works the same, and they don't get lost. You never have this sense of "well... _Google_ does it _this_ way..." when it comes to the tooling.

mr_tristan··on Grocery Outlet S-1
Grocery Outlet will on occasion have significant deals on things like gluten-free ingredients, things that might not exist at Safeway, but do at Whole Foods (at significantly higher prices). This is an interesting wrinkle: a lot of budget stores just completely avoid products that might appeal to the "luxury" WF customer. But, I've seen trust start to develop with a broad demographic. People using social media to tell each other when GO has some of these expensive products.

I've not seen this broad of a demographic reach with other budget stores. GO seems to be purely about "buying cheap, sell at a margin", no matter what it is.

mr_tristan··on Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B
Right, this feels like they inflated their TAM a whole lot.

They are a "luxury option" already today, so ... I'm not sure what they're replacing. If they truly are gonna take on public transportation, I'm not sure how they could stop governments from shutting them out.

mr_tristan··on Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B
I'm only starting to hear that Uber intends to replace public transportation:

> Our Personal Mobility TAM consists of 11.9 trillion miles per year, representing an estimated $5.7 trillion market opportunity in 175 countries. We include all passenger vehicle miles and all public transportation miles in all countries globally in our TAM, including those we have yet to enter, except for the 20 countries that we address through our ownership positions in our minority-owned affiliates, over which we have no operational control other than approval rights with respect to certain material corporate actions. We estimate that these 20 countries represent an additional estimated market opportunity of approximately $0.5 trillion.

See "Our Market Opportunity" section in the S1 (https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1543151/000119312519...)

This seems quite ... optimistic to me. I'm not sure how many public transportation companies actually operate at a significant profit, such that they can undercut. It also seems risky, in that they might generate a huge backlash if they try to do the whole "we're just gonna loss lead until we're dominant, then jack up the price" strategy.

I'm guessing there is section of the population that says "screw it, I'll rent a car" where public transportation is quite slow, but replacing public transportation for poorer people is just going to be losing money. Given that Uber is already losing money, I'm just wondering how you'd develop a model where this TAM makes sense.

mr_tristan··on U.S. adults are spending big on video games, playing mostly on smartphones
It seems like Apple and Google have a lot of opportunity here. My sense is that the subscription model would fit the "immersive" gamer far better.

If they can get, say, 5% of the existing US market to pay $10/month, that's still around 1 billion USD annually.

My guess is that they can probably get a lot more than that.

mr_tristan··on Flutter desktop shells
It's _very_ early, though, as well.

There's not much of an ecosystem for multiplatform yet for desktop projects at all. For macOS you have a way of "making a framework you can use" and that's about it.

There is a lot of promise, though, in the mobile space: https://touchlab.co/touchlab-square-kotlin-multiplatform-col...

My sense is that as the mobile multiplatform space gets ironed out, the desktop space will benefit.

Though generally speaking, Kotlin/Native has a _much_ lower level of "institutional" risk, since the Kotlin approach doesn't subvert the control Apple or Microsoft have over their platforms. Flutter, on the other hand, seems to abstract it away.

mr_tristan··on Ask HN: I lost my ability to focus for hours on coding. How to regain?
I would add that _almost anything_ that requires focus for a period of time can actually help you out. This book talks about the benefits of learning to memorize a deck of cards - just you and a deck of cards in the morning (no phone, no computer), can help "repair" your ability to focus.
mr_tristan··on Why we’re switching to calendar versioning
This feels like the "product version" has taken over again.

I promote semver internally primarily for wiring together build automation. But I also try to make it clear that there can be a _completely different_ "product version" that can mean whatever the hell we want it to be. Calendar versions are great product versions.

Many people, frequently product managers, are very uncomfortable with this distinction.

So many places use the product version as "the version", which then becomes the main justification for monolithic version control, even for distributed applications or multiple product lines. So now, you re-build and/or re-deploy everything, even things that had no changes, purely to stay in sync with "the version".

There are usually good _technical_ reasons for monolithic version control, but doing it just to slap a product version on everything usually ends up with an alarming amount of waste.

mr_tristan··on Please Don't Say Just Hello In Chat (2013)
After reading _Deep Work_ by Cal Newport, I realize that this "hi" message is just yet another way we are distracted in the modern workplace. (I heartily recommend that book.)

What I've adopted is a structured "offline" timeframe, where I answer _no_ communication over the period of about 1-2 hours. When I come "online", I take the time to really answer questions very completely.

I've noticed a few things:

1. This has reduced stress a _lot_ 2. Nobody cares I don't answer immediately 3. People do appreciate that when I do answer them, I've taken the time to really research the response

(Now, "offline" isn't really offline, it's more "no distractions or notifications".)

The funny thing I've noticed, is that the people that just want you to be online when they say "Hi" are often very distracted people themselves.

mr_tristan··on Spotify Saved the Music Industry (But Not Necessarily Musicians)
It sure seems like the a lot of suggestions on Spotify try to find "similarities" based on things you've listened to recently. Makes sense that the similarities are very likely pulled from recent popular additions ... from curators.

My sense is that is probably as good as it tends to get, unless you want to get incredibly creepy and start bringing outside personal information, e.g., associating that the 40-something living in Chicago may have an affinity towards Wilco. Personally, I'd rather deal with "meh" suggestions then have my music service track detailed demographic models of me.

mr_tristan··on Spotify Saved the Music Industry (But Not Necessarily Musicians)
Right, I'm not saying Spotify isn't trying out algorithms at all, but their algorithmic stuff doesn't seem much different from Apple Music, Google Play, etc. A lot of the "algorithmic" stuff enters into "lame" territory fast, where you see the issues like artist fixation, or "variations on a theme" where you get like 5 remixes or live cuts of the same song.

The main benefit of Spotify is that I can just bypass the algorithms, and go straight to people. And that's really where the "long tail" effect seems to thrive.

mr_tristan··on Spotify Saved the Music Industry (But Not Necessarily Musicians)
It's interesting, I've gone back to Spotify from Apple Music primarily because I can easily find more interesting playlists from curators.

I don't think Spotify has any kind of special algorithmic sauce, they just make it easy for people create and share playlists.

It amazes me how most of the other streaming services try to turn everything into an algorithm, via "special radio" stations, etc. And yet, the best way to provide a long tail for music still seems to be basic web 2.0 - let the people make the content for you.

mr_tristan··on There Are No Dream Homes
It's an interesting question, but I'm not sure this is the constant trend.

I just looked up home ownership rates by age group: https://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/charts/fig07.pdf

The only group that doesn't seem to have declined in the last 15 years is 65 and over.

This is where I think the large size of the US and the tons of domestic migration won't really make inheriting a home as common as you would find in most of the world.

Anecdotally, I know nobody that I went to high school with that is remotely close to our home town - we all left. This is roughly 50 people, and I'm sure that all of them, like me, would not think twice about selling any property inherited from parents.

mr_tristan··on There Are No Dream Homes
Ah, I may have incorrectly stated this - it's 30M or so boomer _homeowners_, which are less than 10% of the current US population.

Still, less than 10% of the US population owns 40% of the homes.

mr_tristan··on There Are No Dream Homes
I’m thought this article was going to be about McMansions losing value over time, but just seemed like an opinion piece with a couple of anecdotes about elderly people having problems selling very expensive estates.

Here’s an article about McMansion depreciation: https://www.fa-mag.com/news/mcmansions-define-ugly-in-a-new-...

What’s interesting is that the valuations mentioned for McMansions are... like an order of magnitude cheaper then the multimillion dollar estates mentioned in this piece.

So... I looked for the WSJ article this was really a response to: https://www.wsj.com/articles/a-growing-problem-in-real-estat...

What is actually concerning was this statement:

> Boomers currently own 32 million homes and account for two out of five homeowners in the country.

So... given that boomers are less than 10% of the population but are 40% of the homeowners, I suspect there will be a strong downward pressure long term, since, well, all these boomers are probably in their home before “the home”.

mr_tristan··on Maybe You Don't Need Kubernetes
I took a look at it, and if you were starting from scratch, I'd give it a serious look. The main reason I didn't push for it were mostly internal politics - we'd have to setup an on-premise installation of the Habitat Builder. And we have rather (ridiculous) requirements that would have made that a massive hurdle.

Habitat is very new, so I'd expect to spend some time nailing down exactly what you want for your stuff. But, it's very easy to use.

mr_tristan··on Show HN: Songcraft – Online Songwriting Platform and Guitar Tab Builder
I'd be curious to hear about the experience with customers in 6-12 months. It seems like if you can tap into the "hobbyist" market, and keep them interested, it could be a solid business.

I'm reminded by the Fender presentation at re:Invent this year (https://aws.amazon.com/solutions/case-studies/fender/). Fender noticed that 45% of Fender players are new to the instrument, and most spend more on lessons then the guitar itself, but 90% quit after a year. The 10% that stick with it will go on to purchase 8-10 guitars, typically from their brand. So their whole strategy with apps and services is just to chisel away at that 90% number.

mr_tristan··on AT&T Is Dragging HBO's Streaming Strategy Out of the Dark Ages
I noticed something similar. HBO seems to have a "premium" brand mostly because it led the pack with their content before streaming, but that was a while ago. Given that I'm 41 years old, I remember the early shows that set HBO apart. But I'm not sure this holds for the 20 year olds and younger right now.

It sure seems like HBO executives think they're a cut above, though: https://static1.businessinsider.com/att-ceo-compares-hbo-to-...

I'm just not sure they can justify their "premium" status with their price point. GoT's final season is nearly here, and after that, I'd be curious if cancellations start to happen.

mr_tristan··on Why is the wedding industry so hard to disrupt?
Lemme clarify that "pays well" meant "pays well in comparison to their other gigs". Which is still pretty bad, in comparison to doing pretty much anything else. Just a sad fact that almost all musicians make absolutely nothing.

Given that music is already the #2 cost for weddings, I'm not sure how you "disrupt that" other than not hiring musicians.

mr_tristan··on Why is the wedding industry so hard to disrupt?
"AirBnB for event space" sites already exist, like https://www.peerspace.com. All of them just generalize for "event" planning. But most of the spaces are for smaller events, because that's what's unused.

Once you get to 100+ attendees, options drop dramatically. When I did a cursory search for "average us wedding size", I got a number of 120.

So, I'm just not sure where this source of "good enough" venues are going to come from, that aren't already in use.

mr_tristan··on Why is the wedding industry so hard to disrupt?
Considering that the biggest expense of a wedding is the venue, then services (band, photographer), I could see the direct correlation to real estate.

I'm not sure you could get the venue owners to drop rates, because it sure doesn't seem like many have much of a demand shortage. Wedding venues seem to be booked way far out in advance, and don't seem to have any issues with vacancies. And I'm sure they are well aware of each others' rates.

Anecdotally, I also see large disincentives to lower costs for the other major services. Musicians who play weddings do so because the gig pays well, not because playing crappy covers is what they really want to do. Pretty sure the same goes for photographers - if the wedding business wasn't so lucrative, they'd probably just go do something else with their lives. They're all professional, but I'm not sure many would identify as a "wedding singer", just "musician" or "photographer". But, I'd guess they too are very aware of each other's rates, which gives them no reason to work for less money.

Not sure what there's to "disrupt" here other than culture. And if there's one true rule I've learned: Culture eats strategy for breakfast.

mr_tristan··on Famous Laws of Software Development (2017)
Yeah, I get frustrated that few people actually post the full quote, because, with the context, it means something completely different to young ears.

The full quote makes me think: "You should identify the critical paths of your system early." The shortened quote makes me think: "Deal with performance later."

Pretty big difference in meaning.

mr_tristan··on I Hit $115k/Month with a Status Quo Improvement
This is where things get really complicated. The output data of these tests are typically for a specialist to interpret, I'm not aware of "consumer" tests that break down things like "here's here you flipped over to your side" and "this is when you woke up". Specialists can interpret this, and can read past how you might adjust results yourself.

What gets covered by insurance and what doesn't is specific to your situation (what state/country you live in, etc). I just requested it with my primary care physician, who set up the consultation with a sleep center. Because my case isn't considered "problematic", it really helped to have a specialist request the CPAP, because otherwise, I'm pretty sure insurance wouldn't foot the bill. (I might add this is insane, because I'm sure I've added years to my life with the improved sleep. That's healthcare in the US for you.)

My impression is that the kind of tests is up to the sleep specialist to kind of figure out. The take home thing is much cheaper so I think they'll probably go that route first. I do note that they deal with a wide array of problems, like narcolepsy, sleep walking, night terrors, etc., and that's where I think you'll end up in a monitored hotel room.

mr_tristan··on I Hit $115k/Month with a Status Quo Improvement
CPAP is a machine that forces continuous air through your nose via a mask. When you have sleep apnea, you're actually not breathing, thus, wake up during the night. The CPAP machine keeps the air moving, thus, you don't wake up.

I have _mild_ sleep apnea (you go through tests for diagnosis). With a CPAP machine, I've been able to add a solid hour per night of sleep, from about 6.5 hours to 7 .5-8, with it being continuous. Ergo, I don't make the "midnight trip to pee" with it on. With it off, I snore loudly, and wake up at least 1-2 times during the night.

It's possible that Ajay here actually has worse apnea, and the "9-10" hours from before was actually spent waking up, then trying to get back to sleep. Thus, the "6 hours" is just purely continuous sleep, instead of hours of tossing and turning.

Sleep apnea tests are comfortable take home tests. You basically just wear a couple of sensors for a night. If you're not prone to apnea, don't bother with a CPAP. It's not cheap, and some people can't get used to putting the mask on.

mr_tristan··on Oregon Bottle Deposit System Hits 90 Percent Redemption Rate
At least in Portland, the window smashers are very like homeless addicts. Many stories abound of people having their window smashed in, coins looted out of the glove box, but things like $400 pair of sunglasses just left to hang out on the dashboard. One of the most frequent posts on Nextdoor here are cars getting looted in front of their houses. (We have lots of homeless scrounging for change.)
mr_tristan··on Preparing for Prison (2016)
Hard to say, but there is a strong reason poor people would plea out even if they were innocent: they can get in and out with a minor plea, since their processing can take a long time (weeks or months). Ergo, if you're financially solvent, that fact may be taken into account, since you'll be harder to prosecute - you'll have your own lawyer, etc.

One major problem with plea bargains in the US is that we don't know, because plea agreements themselves are sealed. Also, there is very inconsistent oversight of these plea arrangements.

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/05/plea-ba...

mr_tristan··on Monorepos and the Fallacy of Scale
I come back to this tooling issue again and again. It really, really depends on the platform, too.

Some platforms, like C++, require a lot of tooling work. So it's kind of a natural thing to just add on to it. And in fact can speed up the build a bunch when you start tracking change of intermediate objects.

For almost every web service kind of app I've been involved with, build tooling is typically very standard, and supports semantic version locking out of the box (e.g., bundler, Maven/Gradle, etc). Dealing with multiple repos is just easy to manage in a very controlled way.

The places I've been at that use monorepos were C++ shops from long ago. Their tooling grew out of that approach.

mr_tristan··on Asciidoctor – A fast, open-source text processor and publishing toolchain
Eh, I'd say they're pretty different goals and use cases in reality. Pandoc is great for translation into other formats, where the other format then is applied final styling using downstream tools.

AsciiDoctor is for the Asciidoc format, but, generally includes some nice tooling for commonly used output formats.

Yes, you can use pandoc to convert asciidoc to something else, but in general, I've noticed that asciidoctor has great support for HTML themes:

https://asciidoctor.org/docs/produce-custom-themes-using-asc...

https://github.com/darshandsoni/asciidoctor-skins

The PDF styling directly out of the asciidoctor tool, on the other hand, isn't as advanced. So going from asciidoc to DocBook can make sense here, and I think is probably still done to do things like create truly professional looking PDFs.

What to use? Depends on your toolchain. I almost never need anything but HTML and PDF.

I've found that people, used to Markdown, can jump into Asciidoc and use `asciidoctor` easily.

← PreviousPage 7 of 10Next →