HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mrozbarry

366 karma · joined May 22, 2018

submissionscomments
mrozbarry··on Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
> Yes, you can scale the offense up to the point where most would answer yes to allowing this.

So, you are saying the judicial system should only use evidence depending on how severe the crime is? That is a very poor precedent.

mrozbarry··on Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
I think that's a bit of a bad argument, maybe a strawman. The whole point of the law is to make good citizens so we can all live together. It is in the best interest of both individuals and a community as a whole to not break the law. Breaking the law has consequences. It is the job of the police and justice system to find criminals and punish them. Finding criminals requires the justice system to find evidence and proof.

Let's make another scenario: someone's home was burglarized, and the family who lives in the home submits DNA so the police/investigators can flag finger prints/DNA not left by the family. It turns out the father of the house raped and killed several women 30 years before. The DNA submitted by the family has effectively convicted their father by volunteering his DNA for crimes he committed 30 years ago. Would you be equally upset that this rapist and murderer has been caught?

mrozbarry··on Woman sues after DNA from rape kit used to arrest her
I can't believe I am the minority on this, but I don't see a problem. This woman volunteered her DNA. She has committed a crime in the past. Is it a misuse of DNA if a criminal is brought to justice, where that DNA was literally volunteered?

This does not undermine the fact this person was raped, and that is horrible, BUT justice will be carried out in that case. The justice system cannot overlook a reported crime when there is evidence to persecute because a criminal involved in that crime has been hurt.

mrozbarry··on Show HN: TinyClock – a tiny true 5-arch universal Mac OS X single-binary GUI app
I agree that a clock should absolutely open faster than a browser, but it would be good to know what this metric actually represents. I don't know much about this style of universal binaries, so I don't know if the binary being "true 5-arch universal binaries" is the focus of the application start time metric.
mrozbarry··on The United States Is Still Under-Policed and Over-Imprisoned
Without reading the article or data, but wasn't there a huge push in the US to defund the police? Did that go anywhere?
mrozbarry··on Tell HN: I DDoSed myself using CloudFront and Lambda Edge and got a $4.5k bill
We have alarms, but things like cloudwatch can be up to 5 minutes before an alarm goes off.
mrozbarry··on Tell HN: I DDoSed myself using CloudFront and Lambda Edge and got a $4.5k bill
At work, my development team is contracted with a company that uses AWS, and for better or worse, we have also become the devops team. We have been burned by AWS before, and we have a rule of thumb: if you are deploying new functionality/service communication, after deploy, monitor for 10-15 minutes, with a wide enough window to see if there is a noticable/unexpected change from before the deploy. It always feels like wasted/burned time, but better to waste time than money. AWS is good about reversing accidental charges, though, but life is always easier if you don't even have to contact support.
mrozbarry··on LaMDA is not sentient
I think the test of sentience should have at least this criteria:

- Understanding of the passage of time

- Independent activity, without prompts

- Has self understanding of it's current inputs, like a camera

I don't think that's a full list, but to me the transcription really indicates that LaMDA responds to user prompts with reasonably relevant responses, but it gives me no indication that the system has a self awareness.

I think a good test would be to ask it the same non-mathematical question several times in a row, and see if there is any awareness of the same question, or if the answer change. Like if I asked LaMDA it's favorite color, can it name a color, and tell me that answer consistently? Does it know that I've already asked it, and give answers that seem frustrated after a while?

mrozbarry··on Ask HN: What game do you wish existed?
I had this idea a while ago, and it just never materialized:

- Every player can use their tablets or phones, and as many as they'd like

- Each device can be assigned with different controls

    - Wasn't sure if this would be decided before the game starts or if some player could control it, or if anyone can just add in controls as needed

 - The game plays only on the ship bridge, there would be no first-person anything

 - One device acts as the viewer screen
Scenarios would be things like escorting a ship through hostile space, delivering cargo, peace treaties, or search and destroy. One thing I wanted is the game to favour fun over realism. Like a player could go rogue and navigate the ship anywhere they wanted, or start firing on a friendly ship. Controls should be easy, like navigation could be as easy as scanning for nearby locations and then picking it, letting the computer plot a course.

I liked the idea of players all hanging out in a living room, connect the "viewer" player to a TV, and just have fun. Some scenarios and situations would involve teamwork, like having an engineer reroute power from navigation (ie nav has to slow down to make power available) to weapons for more powerful shots.

I thought it would be fun to build, but I just didn't have the time to develop it myself.

mrozbarry··on Why Mother Octopuses Torture and Eat Themselves
"The researchers believe that these chemical changes all come together and cause octopuses to torture themselves. The exact reasoning for why these changes occur, though, or why the octopus’s body is designed this way is still unclear."

It's strange to read that a secular news site like this refers to biology as "design" rather than ask why their biology evolved that way.

mrozbarry··on The Good Ol' Days of QBasic Nibbles
In the very late 90s and most of the 2000s, I hung out on qbasicnews and eventually moved to the freeBasic community. I even learned "basica" (basic advanced) from an old IBM 5150 computer originally. A lot of the reason I do programming professionally is because of some of the mentoring I saw in those communities, filled with lots of smart and friendly people. A good friend of mine and myself learned QBasic together, and played a lot of QBasic Mayhem ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHIAMF-EKWY ), it was so cool. So many good memories around qbasic.
mrozbarry··on Show HN: Vessel – Your Passport for the Internet
Help me out, why does anyone want their crypto wallet connected to their web browser? Isn't that a huge security concern?
mrozbarry··on Ask HN: How do you deal with rude interviewers?
I think that's a valid approach, too. It might just depend on the interviewee which is better. The inverted phrase is a bit more direct and dominant (which I don't think is bad), so I don't think it fits everyone's personality. That said, my recommendation is simply to be polite and leave, and do it on your own terms.
mrozbarry··on Ask HN: How do you deal with rude interviewers?
Leaving doesn't have to be rude. If there's no reason to work on your interview skills, you can simply say "I appreciate your time, but I don't think I'm a good fit for _company name here_." You don't have to give any further reason. You are the boss of your time and effort, so don't waste it if you don't have to.
mrozbarry··on Behold GoldenEye 007 with four screens – dream come true or travesty?
I think a lot of game development companies have lost sight of the charm of basically zero-hardware config multiplayer. By that I mean, one computer (or console), one screen, multiple controllers, and no user names/sign ins. GoldenEye was great for that, you could just jump in. Having multiple monitors just seems like overhead. Some of the fun was the fact that you could target a player and be a total jerk, and you quickly find out who the "honorable" players are. To me, it's part of the game. Honestly, I wish there were more modern games like this. I'd gladly sacrifice shiny graphics and 4k to have a local couch coop game with some friends.
mrozbarry··on The only thing we should be talking about is the climate crisis
I don't know if that's true, do you have an article/thing I can read that backs that up?
mrozbarry··on The only thing we should be talking about is the climate crisis
I think we should talk about:

- How to be decent human beings to each other, and especially how to not kill each other

- The media has too much power

- Government over-reach

Probably other things, but I don't know, these seem like way better hot-button issues.

mrozbarry··on Ask HN: How do you avoid video game addiction?
I don't know that you should get relationship advice around computer gaming from some random dude from hackernews, but if you're willing to hear it anyway, I'd communicate your struggle with your spouse - it's very important she understands your struggles and concerns, and can help you. With that, maybe work on figuring out if you're using gaming as a way to relax or a way to escape. If it's escape, what are you escaping? Maybe that's the sort of self reflection you should do, and the sort of topics you want to talk to your wife about. Being a team is hard. I've been married 10 years, and we just had our first son this year, so I'm at least not talking out of my butt.
mrozbarry··on Using Windows after 15 years on Linux
I guess my confusion is your initial statement "Lets not customize it then" followed by you proposing fully customized installs, and I'm not sure if I missed your point.

I only brought up trusted vendors because it seemed that you also want repositories of customization scripts, and I don't disagree, but it shifts the trust from the people making your operating system to you reviewing a bunch of scripts to get the system you want.

I'm making a point that people don't want that at all. That will absolutely cause analysis paralysis, there would be too many possibilities, and it would continue this idea that Linux is hard and elitist when it really shouldn't have to be that way.

mrozbarry··on Ask HN: How do you avoid video game addiction?
If you self-admit it was an unhealthy habit, then I'd be cautious about going back to it. Addiction is not something a person should be willing to edge into, and if you think it's an addictive behaviour, then it probably is. Definitely make sure it is not affecting your marriage or job, that would be a key metric to know for sure if it's an addition and not just a source of entertainment.
mrozbarry··on Using Windows after 15 years on Linux
The thing you are proposing sounds like absolute customization, unless I horribly misunderstand. "Take it from there with scripts" means not only is it fully customized, but you don't even have a trusted vendor to provide the scripts, which sounds like a nightmare to me.
mrozbarry··on Using Windows after 15 years on Linux
I appreciate everyone's taste and opinions on UI, but this seems a lot like confirmation bias. Windows has warts. Linux has warts. OSX has warts.

I'd say in terms of consistent UI, OSX probably is the biggest winner. Both Linux and Windows are the losers in UI consistency. Yeah, you can customize it, but customization, in my opinion, can be a real time-suck and it doesn't make you any more or less productive, it's just visual enhancement.

Unix is the real commandline winner, because piping and good underlying tools, and as a result, OSX and Linux do very well here. I'm not familiar with the powershell equivalent, but at the very least, it's just a copy of how unix works.

Application installs is a very mixed bag across the board. Every distro of linux has their flavor of installs in commandline, and some have graphical. I've never had a lot of success mixing the two, it always puts some package database in a corrupted out-of-sync state. OSX is primarily graphical installs, but there are cli tools like homebrew - neither seem to fight each other, though. Windows is download/installer based. There is a store, but the store is mostly paid applications, and the Windows ecosystem has a large amount of free installer tools that will almost certainly never be on the store.

The article doesn't even talk about hardware. My typical experience is hardware "just works" in OSX and Windows, and will often/mostly "just work" in Linux, but also there can is usually is some tinkering (as well as do I want the free/open source drivers vs the binary blobs in cases like graphics cards).

So I guess in summary, Windows doesn't suck, in the same way that Linux and OSX don't suck. Every OS has a mess in some capacity, and I would say Linux's biggest mess is there is too much room for customization that will always lead to rabbit holes. For context, I use a company-given OSX laptop for work, and use Linux for my personal computer/daily driver, but have a Windows partition for gaming.

mrozbarry··on pnpm: Fast, disk space efficient package manager for JavaScript
When I tried pnpm last, I was on a react native project (react 14 maybe), and something about the symlinks from pnpm caused me to not be able to build the project (and I went back to yarn). Anyone know if this is still an issue?
mrozbarry··on Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will'
This wasn't strictly freezing donations, it was completely freezing a person's bank account.
mrozbarry··on Britain being forced to go cashless 'against its will'
CBC is literally state-funded media, and Trudea literally lives in Ottawa. In no world does he have an excuse to be blind, and even in some sliver of hope where he honestly didn't know, why didn't he make a public apology?
mrozbarry··on Maybe you should do less 'work'
I work at a software consultancy, and here are my hot tips around this:

- Take breaks between tasks. Your flow should mostly allow 5-10 minute breaks often (like once an hour or so) without anything or anybody blowing up.

- It's healthy that your client (or bosses) will always want more work, especially if you and your team do good work.

- Always instill in your client (or bosses) that work will get done when it's done. They are paying you to know how long something _should_ take, and to identify obstacles that could make something take longer, as well as the time you need to plan/prepare to keep you and your team sane.

- Your best working state is when you're relaxed. People have told me they work best under pressure, and I really refuse this to ever be true. You can certainly work under pressure, and even work fast, but I honestly believe your best work is the work that you enjoy and care for, not just the work you spit out fast.

- You can have fun doing just about any task if it's not stressful. Sure, there are a lot boring tasks in software, like waiting for compiles, or doing slow-moving dev-ops work, but if there is a clear path with no major obstacles, it really won't be that bad.

The biggest thing for me is having me and my team take breaks often. It's a good time to reflect on the work that's been done, think about a problem, or just take your mind off a larger problem for a few minutes. Depending on the industry, your client, your boss, etc., your mileage is going to vary, but as a software consultant, it is your job to advise on what time you need to get something done right.

So I guess I agree with the article. Not that you shouldn't regularly give 100%, but you should always be buffered so in high stress, high stakes, you and your team have capacity to go above and beyond the usual, but your average work load isn't maxing you out all the time.

mrozbarry··on Ask HN: How can scam callers fake a mobile phone number?
One thing people don't know is that the phone network is actually a bunch of duct-taped technology that is pretty old. There has been advancements, and if you're in the US, you'll be happy to know that mobile carriers require stir/shaken handshaking, which is _mostly_ equivalent to https on the web (this is a gross simplification).

The short/simple answer is carriers don't care, because they make money when a call is placed on their network. There is also a difference between what is a valid number (digits are correct) vs a real number (someone owns a number). It is cheap for a carrier to check validity, but not "realness" - to check a real number, a carrier may have to do some sort of data request to any number of carriers to determine if the number is owned.

mrozbarry··on YouTube blocks global access to Russian state-funded media channels
With all this blocking of state-funded media channels, they should block CBC in Canada. I can't speak to a lot of other media outlets, but if we're okay with big tech just blocking anything willy nilly, they should at least do it consistently across the board.
mrozbarry··on Which search engine is the least censored?
I think the validity is mostly scoped the current major world-wide events. It would be interesting to have some sort of topic censorship ranking website; give it a topic, and it ranks various search engines.
mrozbarry··on Against Pair Programming
I have this exact issue. My client has a few teams working on related products on different platforms and languages, and when we discuss bugs, I'll use a term that will almost immediately get a "oh, that's not what you mean, because thing x in this context means thing y." For example, iOS sandbox applications vs testflight applications vs sandbox purchases. Both applications use sandbox purchases, so just saying "sandbox" is ambiguous or can often cause confusion.
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →