4,866 karma · joined October 7, 2008
Web frameworks do their best to provide useful, general abstractions for writing web applications. Sometimes you need different behavior on a lower level to which the framework provides no interface. In other words, your particular application breaks the general mold in some way. It doesn't necessarily make sense to change the framework for each of these application-specific needs. Writing those portions yourself and not contributing them to the project seems like a sensible way to go.
If the framework is really trying to work for the entire universe of web applications, it will quickly become too bloated to be useful for getting simple, common apps off the ground. As a framework maintainer, you have to strike a balance between the set of applications that your framework can accommodate and the usability of the framework.
That said, the author's tone does seem to suggest that Django is doing a poor job as a web framework because it doesn't fit his needs. That's an unfair criticism. Django fits a lot of people's needs. It's not supposed to be all things to all people.
I think a lot of us have come to the same conclusion as this author: the abstractions frameworks provide are often too high level. Very quickly the needs of your project cannot be served by their generalizations. Especially in a language like Python, it's often easier just to roll your own systems.
However, starting off with a framework is a great way to get off the ground quickly. If you were to write everything from scratch from the beginning, you might burn out before you even produce anything usable.
Personally, I think CherryPy is the way to go. You're probably not going to need to rewrite HTTP [1], so that's an abstraction layer with which I'm comfortable. Everything else will need to be easily customizable for your project.
[1] Unless the threaded model doesn't work for you, like it doesn't for our chat backend.
Having written a lot of Python it is now frustrating to write C++, mostly because of the verbosity. Instead of thinking about the problem I'm trying to solve, I'm thinking about how to deal with the language or necessary data structures. Python just gets out of your way and lets you solve the problem at hand quickly and concisely.
I don't think more thought goes into a line of Python code, and if it does, it's productive thought. It's not the "what's the 6th argument to this function?" or "is the type of the 3rd argument to this function really just a typedef for a float?" type of my-language-requires-me-to-jump-through-hoops thought.
To me, all that verbosity means more time thinking about the code and less time thinking about the problem.
Sometimes the borrower would claim that they could not pay. In that case, the collector was instructed to just sit down and wait for them to pay. The shame of having the collector sitting in their village was overwhelming, and payments were usually made within the hour.
A lot of people try to get away with bad stuff because nobody they know is watching. I'm glad that there are no Anonymous Cowards on HN. It's always interesting to see how differently people behave when their peers' focus is turned on them.
We'd all be more successful if we could capitalize on our good moods and not let our bad moods drag us down for long.
Maybe someone should set up a cron job to submit that talk to HN every 3 months.
For example: yell at the hardware manufacturer instead of the software developer; yell at the app developers; if you need that functionality, go buy a 3rd party app; it's slow because of OS implementation details; it doesn't work as you'd expect it because of implementation details; Google's own apps work relatively well.
Users don't care about why something is slow or broken (from their perspective). They shouldn't have to care. They don't want to go find an app in the Market for basic functionality, and they don't want to write a Perl script, either. Apple gets this. I hope Google and their partners will some day.
Users don't want answers to these questions. The list of questions you replied to was a rhetorical way of saying this: the iPhone user experience is far superior.
For some reason I don't think this is exactly what Gruber had in mind when he said, "The goal should be to make a phone that is better than the iPhone. Better."
We run our own instance of Trac and svn on a slicehost slice, which is relatively painless to maintain. Using github or bitbucket would be another good option there.
For a distributed team, I do have to make a shameless plug for my own startup: http://shoptalkapp.com. Communication is key, and IM just doesn't cut it, we've found. We're always looking for feedback from fellow HNers, so let me know if you try it out.
Hopefully we'll have our bot API ready for public consumption soon. I'll let you know. We've taken most of our UI cues from irssi, so I bet our interface, although it's a web interface, is pretty similar to yours.
Let me know what you think if you try it out. It's all over standard HTTP ports, so hopefully your IT department won't notice. :)
Sounds like we should consider increasing the priority of the desktop client. Thanks for all the great feedback.
I'd be interested to hear what you use the desktop client for. We have been thinking of creating one simply for DM alerts, but do you find it useful beyond that? It's a shame that browsers can't do notifications.
Also, could you elaborate on why chat rooms make more sense for larger companies than for a startup? The real-time conversation aspect has just be so useful for us, especially since we're a distributed team.
I like that he mentions integrating with other systems. Some of the biggest productivity gains we've seen have come from chat bots, which interject useful information into the conversation. They can also respond to commands from users to do useful actions. Our API still needs some polish, but we'll be releasing it to the public soon. Internally, we have chat bots that notify us about svn commits, Google alerts, changes to any Trac ticket or wiki page, etc. I can't wait to see what all the hackers here do with it. :)
Communication tools like this really change the game, especially for distributed teams.
We're in open public beta right now. Check out http://shoptalkapp.com and let us know what you think. We always value the opinion of HN readers.
I think that Braude feeds his ego by assuring himself that his ability to program a computer must prove that he's smarter than everyone else. Now that programming has become easier and anyone can do it (which is not even close to the reality of the situation), he feels less special. It's so ironic when technologists resent technological advances for this reason.
That all programmers don't need to know about "virtual methods, pointers, references, garbage collection, finalizers, pass-by-reference vs. pass-by-value, virtual C++ destructors, or the differences between C# structs and classes" is a very good thing. Lots of that stuff is ugly and overcomplicated and poorly designed and error-prone. The reason that large classes of programmers needn't pay any attention to any of it is that the state of the art has advanced and newer, better designed technologies are at our disposal now. As technologists, how can we do anything but celebrate that?
Maybe this is just meant as a proof of concept. In that case, it's great. But if it's meant to be a useful way to find restaurants and get reviews, I think there are much better interfaces for that. Including existing apps.
Pop artists generally pay big name producers for 2 to 3 tracks per album, which they plan on releasing as singles. The rest of the tracks are more or less filler so they can justify charging $15 for a long play album.
With digital distribution becoming more popular and consumers buying more singles instead of full albums, I thought pop artists would be the first to stop releasing full-length albums. I guess this is just another example of the music industry being unable or unwilling to adapt to the changing landscape.
I really do hope, though, as you mentioned, that real musicians continue to put in the creativity and hard work it takes to produce full albums. The result is just far better than a collection of singles.
Of all the incredibly smart and successful technologists in the US, I find it very hard to understand why this guy was chosen.
1) Much smaller user base
2) The Litmus ad on the right side of every page
EDIT: The rest of me sees healthy competition and an interesting take on freemium marketing for their money-making app. :)
4) Use Mailplane (http://mailplaneapp.com/). Disclaimer: Mailplane is not free and I'm not affiliated with it at all.
It's easy enough for me to call a mechanic or two to find out how much they would charge to replace my transmission, but how do I know that my car actually needs a new transmission? My primary fear when going to the mechanic is that they'll claim that my car's problems are much more serious than they actually are, so they can charge me for the more expensive repair.
They can easily get away with this, because I'm not knowledgeable enough on the subject to second guess them. Oddly enough, the situation isn't much different with doctors and dentists. Every time my dentist decides to drill into my teeth, I can't help but wonder if they just see it as an opportunity to make a large sum of money.
If anything, the situation is worse in the medical industry. They almost never give price quotes up front. What's up with that? And there's basically no way of knowing how much your insurance will cover. Generally I just do what the doctor/dentist says and save my pennies while I wait for a huge, seemingly arbitrary bill to arrive in the mail. This system is obviously broken.
Now, one of you HN readers looking to start a company: go fix it! :)
We could definitely use this for ShopTalk (http://shoptalkapp.com). Keep up the good work.
Here's one small visual bug you can fix: you suffer from the Safari PNG gamma problem (http://hsivonen.iki.fi/png-gamma/). In short, a PNG of a certain RGB color will not match up with that same RGB CSS color in Safari. The easiest solution is to use a 1px by 1px image for your background instead of specifying it as a color in CSS.
Good luck!
EDIT: I should mention that CherryPy is at its heart. We love CherryPy. And our chat backend uses a secret sauce Python async framework that might or might not be open sourced very soon...
Think back to the Windows and IE antitrust legal battles. iTunes is similar to the Windows monopoly. It's the biggest platform for buying music online. According to antitrust laws, it is illegal for Apple to leverage that monopoly against competitors.
That said, Apple made a big investment into the whole iTunes infrastructure and has put a ton of work into negotiating with record labels to get all that music in the store. They did all that for basically no direct reward; they make almost no money off iTunes. They did it to support their iPod business. It seems a little unfair for other MP3 player manufacturers to expect all the benefits of using that infrastructure without the investment. The $1-$5 per device that the article suggests is not nearly enough. Apple makes hundreds of dollars off each device they sell which use the iTunes music store.