2,004 karma · joined July 16, 2009
[1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/sopa-twitt...
I normally would not feel the need to correct a typo, but in an instance like this it is different as most people on hn do not automatically know what was intended.
It would require post-processing anyways (rip out templates, wikilinks, reflists, whatever) but it would be easier to isolate what is actually in the page.
Good counter-examples are Autodesk's products (their DRM/dongles stand up for 6+ months) or the PS3 that took years for people to be able to play pirated games.
Also, Jimbo has very little to do with the running of the English Wikipedia. He stepped down as a leader of it because of how often his actions were sharply criticized by the community that he was out of touch with. Just because you co-founded something 10 years ago does not make you an expert on it.
I was saying that a) firesheep does not have anything to do with passwords (which he implies it does) and b) it would be prevented with ssl anyways. I don't even know why he brought it up.
I don't have a lot of confidence that this is secure or useful, but it sounds like it is already useless because it fails over to normal DNS and the attacker this is targeted at can just as easily block the traffic and force you to downgrade.
It assumes everyone that has user accounts wants people's 'Internet Identity', by which they apparently mean an email address. instead of something local. An account system that does not revolve or include an email address is entirely a foreign concept to them.
Lots of random rambling about the evils of passwords.
Completely irrelevant aside about spam.
Back on topic and talking about OAuth as the first solution. We're not even going to mention OpenID even though we link to their site when talking about implementing OAuth later.
AccountChooser.com as a service. Apparently, A/B testing is an important consideration when designing an identity system.
I gave up reading around that point. If you want to promote some new sort of identification system make an RFC or at least write in the style of one.
I actually upvoted your other post on the story as it was too grey for my taste (making an honest attempt at on-topic discussion), but downvoted the comment I'm reply to as it is strictly noise.
Chalk it up to another thing that could be improved but won't because news.arc is designed more for elegance and showing off arc.
Wikipedia says it is basically a flea market except people selling out of their car's trunks.