HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

musgravepeter

866 karma · joined May 8, 2013

submissionscomments
musgravepeter··on Ask HN: Good software for interactive exploration of quantum/particle physics?
If you want to tinker with gravity, you can try ThreeBody (Lite or Full) on iOS/Android.

Disclaimer - I'm the developer.

musgravepeter··on The only way to solve the three body problem
Flagged by my Google alert on "three body".

WAY more triple homicides than physics articles, but every once in awhile something good like this shows up!

musgravepeter··on The Sad Story of Heisenberg's Doctoral Oral Exam (1998)
I'm assuming it's the exam team member that wants to torpedo a student to show how smart s/he is by asking something tricky or tangential.

I was lucky. My supervisor asked for recommendations for who to ask from the Math department and I replied "a push-over". He thought for a second then said "Ok, I know who to ask."

musgravepeter··on Ask HN: (Devoted time):(revenue) ratio for side project
I have been developing odd-ball physics apps (ThreeBody, Geodesic Asteroids most recently).

I'd say I put in about 10 hrs/week => 520/yr.

Last year my revenues were up 400% (to $88) with expenses of about $400 (apple developer fee, web host, test device, couple of books) - so a loss of about $300.

Time/revenue = 88/520 = $0.17/hr

musgravepeter··on Google Cardboard Plastic
When will the Unity game engine support this?
musgravepeter··on This should never happen
My favourite was some Telecom code that returned "Not Kansas", as in "We've not in Kansas anymore".
musgravepeter··on Show HN: I released my first Android game: “Black Hole Escape”
Thanks for the snippet.

Working code is a good thing. I tend to rat-hole on the physics stuff, since I have a background in it.

musgravepeter··on Show HN: I released my first Android game: “Black Hole Escape”
As a fellow physics geek mobile dev (eg. ThreeBody, Geodesic Asteroids) I gotta ask: how are you modelling the gravitational force?
musgravepeter··on Ten lessons I wish I had learned before teaching differential equations (1997) [pdf]
I thought the comment on exterior differential forms was interesting. I always wanted to delve into those and better understand what a dx all by itself was when separated from dy/dx by simple manipulation. Loved his comment "We justify this sudden introduction of differentials by saying that this is 'just another way or rewriting the differential equation,' or some equally atrocious lie."

I am now lusting after http://www.amazon.ca/Exterior-Analysis-Using-Applications-Di... but it's a bit pricy for a indulgence purchase!

musgravepeter··on Flyby anomaly
The mass of the "test particle" Cassini will cancel out of orbit equation but will matter for drag, radiation pressure etc. If it's outside the error bars they gave for mass, then this is conceivable.

OTOH this is a pretty conservative bunch.

It may "just" be something in the details (much like the Pioneer anomoly: http://www.planetary.org/blogs/bruce-betts/3459.html?referre... which was solved after 20 years of digging and LOTS of speculative ideas that did not work out).

musgravepeter··on Purifying Physics: The quest to explain why the “quantum” exists
Thanks for the link. That is a pretty long paper!
musgravepeter··on Ask HN: Books you read in 2015?
"Leaving Orbit - Notes from the last days of American spaceflight" - pleasantly sentimental view of the wind down of the shuttle program.

"The Dark Forest" 2nd installment in Three Body Problem series. Quite clever.

"This Changes Everything" - triggered by a quote from the doc on the radio about trying not to think about climate change and whether it's possible to be bored by the end of the world. Lots of good info (including a visit to a climate deniers conference), bit long winded.

"The Princeton Companion to Applied Mathematics". If I read only 10% still worth it. Lots of things to dip into.

"The Astronomer and the Witch" Kepler fights to save his mother from persecution.

musgravepeter··on How to Become a Good Theoretical Physicist
The most important part of this is to do the problems!

After a PhD in theoretical physics then 20 years as a s/w developer I decided to get some of my chops back. You can read and nod about stuff but until you face a blank sheet of paper you don't know if you really understood.

+1 for Penrose's "Road to Reality"

Also a huge fan of Eric Poisson's lectures (basically free textbooks) http://www.physics.uoguelph.ca/poisson/research/notes.html

Short description of getting my chops back: http://nbodyphysics.com/blog/2015/02/28/learn-physics-with-t...

musgravepeter··on Infinite Force? Forty-year-old Fortran to the rescue
Thanks! There is also a discussion in The Million Body Problem (Heggie & Hut). Looking forward to poking around in this.
musgravepeter··on Infinite Force? Forty-year-old Fortran to the rescue
There is a vast literature on some simplifications: Circular Restricted Three Body (two bodies in a fixed orbit, third subject to their field) and even two fixed points (Euler Problem). Even here there are complex orbits.

Maybe an app unto itself!

musgravepeter··on Infinite Force? Forty-year-old Fortran to the rescue
nbody here.

Note the Android Lite version 2.0 somehow ended up in Occulus mode in the final APK. A fix is uploading to Google play now!

I have no idea how to even turn that on in Unity - so it's a bit of a puzzle!

musgravepeter··on The Triumph of Stupidity (1933)
I found this worthwhile.
musgravepeter··on Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
A great book on good physics which did not pan out is http://www.amazon.com/Higher-Speculations-Theories-Revolutio...

Vortex theory was very cool, but not how the world worked.

musgravepeter··on Earth Might Have Hairy Dark Matter
The arxiv pre-print is http://arxiv.org/pdf/1507.07009.pdf
musgravepeter··on Not Your Father’s FORTRAN
Yeah - I hear you. Converting 1000 lines was a BIG drag.

I did experiment with native and f2c versions - but when targeting for mobile it meant a bunch of Android and iOS packaging that was kinda irritating.

The specific code I targeted (3 body evolution using KS regularization, the triple code at http://www.ast.cam.ac.uk/~sverre/web/pages/nbody.htm) was modest and not CPU intensive.

I'd love to do the same for NBODY6 and that would have to be native.

Look for an update to my ThreeBody app with this code (and a cool gallery of new 3B solutions) sometime late in the year.

musgravepeter··on Not Your Father’s FORTRAN
I first learned FORTRAN in high school, where we used optical sense cards to create code. The teacher took them each night to the board office and brought back our output for the next class. If you had ten days for an assignment, you had ten chances to compile/run. The next year the school got a Commodore PET and I had a chance to use that.

I still code - and have just finished converting some FORTRAN astrophysics simulation code from 1974 into C# for a Unity project.

musgravepeter··on Bitbucket is down
Thanks for the heads up!
musgravepeter··on New Quantum Cats game launches to build better understanding of quantum concepts
Also Mike L (BB founder) funded the Institute that did this work
musgravepeter··on Fox Yeah
This came up in the car ride back from work with my spouse. I argued that there must be some other interpretation since I couldn't believe that they'd throw this out there - maybe some part of recent culture I was not aware of.

Wrong.

Guess I'm not the one in tune with the Zeitgeist.

musgravepeter··on Beware Simple Stories
At some level TED etc. are just providing what the market (us) wants.

Given a choice between thinking hard and an easy answer we tend to prefer the later until it no longer meets our needs or becomes clearly wrong.

musgravepeter··on The tensor renaissance in data science
I agree it's unfortunate.

I think this is really a flimsy use of a technical term which does have a precise meaning in the context of mathematical physics to make the idea of multi-dimensional array seem "deeper" than it really is.

There are enough hard problems in data science - I don't think it needs to burdened with terms like this.

musgravepeter··on The tensor renaissance in data science
A 1D list of numbers is not necessarily a "vector" in the Differential Geometry sense. The definition of a vector or tensor is based on how it transforms as the co-ordinate system transforms. See e.g. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Covariance_and_contravariance_o...

One weird consequence of this is that if A and B are vectors, the cross product (AxB) is NOT a vector in the tensorial sense. [Aside: Cross products are really weird since they are defined in the familiar way 3 and 7 dimensions only! (see http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/185991/is-the-vector...]

musgravepeter··on Geodesic Asteroids: Classic arcade game gets correct physics
I agree with your point about embedding.

The game solves the geodesic equation using the instrinsic geometry of the torus in 2D space without reference to any embedding. It is in this sense that one might call the physics "correct"

The motion is then mapped into either a 2D or 3D representation and I agree this has a strong effect on how things look.

I'll need to think about the four space example.

What is the metric for a mathematically abstract flat torus?

musgravepeter··on Geodesic Asteroids: Classic arcade game gets correct physics
Very hypnotizing! I assume you have a heuristic for geodesic motion? I doubt I could write down the metrics for some of those surfaces in a Lundum Dare timeframe.
musgravepeter··on Geodesic Asteroids: Classic arcade game gets correct physics
Thanks! You can get a free version for iOS, Android and Blackberry... (Same as paid version, just no bonus ships)
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →