HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mwcampbell

11,185 karma · joined February 6, 2013

Note to PR folks: I'm not the InfoQ.com editor named Matt Campbell. Please don't email me about your upcoming press release. If anyone knows a better way to clear up this confusion, please contact me.

I'm a software developer specializing in accessibility for blind and visually impaired people. From mid-2017 to late 2020, I worked for Microsoft on the Windows accessibility team, though my comments were always my own opinion posted on my own initiative.

I'm legally blind myself; I have enough sight to read a desktop computer screen up close with slightly enlarged fonts, but I often use a screen reader when browsing the Web, doing email, and other tasks that don't involve code. (Don't get me wrong; totally blind people can program, but I never got used to doing it that way myself.)

Of course, there's more to me than visual impairment. When it comes to programming, I'm also particularly interested in the challenges of developing cross-platform applications that integrate smoothly with the host platform. Outside of programming, I love music and love to sing. Pre-COVID, I often did karaoke (of course, I memorize the words). And like many nerds, I read science fiction.

Email: mattcampbell@pobox.com

Mastodon: https://toot.cafe/@matt

Blog: http://mwcampbell.us/blog/

Location: Wichita, Kansas, US

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/mwcampbell; my proof: https://keybase.io/mwcampbell/sigs/9sbxkfOoTyW6C8IiDB50bP_ZWa-V73AfbdmvUlfOKe8 ]

submissionscomments
mwcampbell··on Radiant Computer
The thing that always worries me about these clean-slate designs is the fear that they'll ignore accessibility for disabled people, e.g. blind people, and then either the system will remain inaccessible, or accessibility will have to be retrofitted later.
mwcampbell··on Futurelock: A subtle risk in async Rust
In the spirit of "every non-trivial program will expand until ...", I think preemptively choosing async for anything much more complex than a throwaway script might be justified. In this case, the relevant thing isn't performance or expected number of concurrent users/connections, but whether the program is likely to become or include a non-trivial state machine. My primary influence on this topic is this post from @sunshowers: https://sunshowers.io/posts/nextest-and-tokio/
mwcampbell··on OpenAI says over a million people talk to ChatGPT about suicide weekly
> They’re trained to be far too user led. They don’t challenge you enough.

An anecdote here: I recently had a conversation with Claude that could be considered therapy or at least therapy-adjacent. To Anthropic's credit, Claude challenged me to take action (in the right direction), not just wallow in my regrets. Still, it may be true that general-purpose LLMs don't do this consistently enough.

mwcampbell··on Uv is the best thing to happen to the Python ecosystem in a decade
This! I'm tired of the constant calls to be as mediocre as we can get away with, in the name of getting things done faster and cheaper.
mwcampbell··on Typst 0.14
Would it be feasible, with hayro-interpret and krilla, to take an existing PDF and round-trip each of the pages while wrapping the contents in marked content spans and adding tags, to remediate the accessibility of an existing PDF? Round-tripping each of the page content streams through a full-featured PDF interpreter seems cleaner than trying to edit in-place. PDFium can round-trip the content streams and add the marked content spans, but can't do the tagging. What do you think?
mwcampbell··on Software CEO to Catholic panel: AI is more mass stupidity than mass unemployment
Are there places where it reliably saves time, though? Unlike most software tools, LLMs are stochastic, right?
mwcampbell··on Internet Archive's big battle with music publishers ends in settlement
Why do you say that? I'm in agreement with the other responses, and this thread has prompted me to start a recurring donation to the Internet Archive.
mwcampbell··on Orange Pi RV2 $40 RISC-V SBC: Friendly Gateway to IoT and AI Projects
Want to share any links, particularly about building one's own Debian image? I'm especially curious about the bootloader.
mwcampbell··on 30 minutes with a stranger
> Are there even any social networks anymore?

Mastodon?

mwcampbell··on I'm too dumb for Zig's new IO interface
> (outside of very RAM-constrained hardware, at least)

I've spent much of my career working on desktop software, especially on Windows, and especially programs that run continuously in the background. I've become convinced that it's my responsibility to treat my user's machines as RAM-constrained, and, outside of any long-running compute-heavy loops, to value RAM over CPU as long as the program has no noticeable lag. My latest desktop product was Electron-based, and I think it's pretty light as Electron apps go, but I wish I'd had the luxury of writing it all in Rust so it could be as light as possible (at least one background service is in Rust). My next planned desktop project will be in Rust.

A recent anecdote has reinforced my conviction on this. One of my employees has a PC with 16 GB of RAM, and he couldn't run a VMware VM with 4 GB of guest RAM on that machine. My old laptop, also with 16 GB of RAM, had plenty of room for two such VMs. I didn't dig into this with him, but I'm guessing that his machine is infested with crap software, much of which is probably using Electron these days, each program assuming it can use as much RAM as it wants. I want to fight that trend.

mwcampbell··on I'm too dumb for Zig's new IO interface
Can we all please stop complaining about async Rust and just acknowledge that the problem they were solving was both really hard and urgent for the success of the language (particularly given priorities among the most well-resourced tech companies in the late 2010s)? All things considered, I think they did a good job. I certainly wouldn't have done any better. And the feature was well thought through, with years of work before it shipped.
mwcampbell··on Without the futex, it's futile
As the article mentions, Windows introduced a futex-like thing in Windows 8. I know that the original Win32 critical section is based on a kernel-level semaphore. What about the SRW lock introduced in Vista?
mwcampbell··on Launch HN: Cyberdesk (YC S25) – Automate Windows legacy desktop apps
Have you looked at using accessibility APIs, such as UI Automation on Windows, to augment screenshots and simulated mouse clicks?
mwcampbell··on Show HN: Kitten TTS – 25MB CPU-Only, Open-Source TTS Model
Does your Eloquence installation include multiple languages? The one I have is only 1876 KB for US English only. And classic DECtalk is even smaller; I have here a version that's only 638 KB (again, US English only).
mwcampbell··on Our $100M Series B
> (If you are good, remote work with high TC is definitely available.)

But how good do you have to be at things other than the work itself (edit: and how lucky as well) to land one of those jobs with higher compensation? For someone outside of high-cost-of-living tech hubs, Oxide's fixed salary could be life-changing all by itself, even with minimal equity. The fact that they take that deal doesn't necessarily mean that they're mediocre.

mwcampbell··on I'm switching to Python and actually liking it
I think I made a conscious effort in my 30s not to become a crusty old Python dev. But I predict that in another decade or two, I (now in my 40s) will be a crusty old Rust dev.
mwcampbell··on Why are there no good dinosaur films?
So then in this version, when someone escapes the Matrix, they're really just having their consciousness switched to a different simulated world?
mwcampbell··on The Real GenAI Issue
Why do you think the anti-AI side has highly motivated reasoning?
mwcampbell··on Being too ambitious is a clever form of self-sabotage
I wonder if it's actually accurate to attribute authorship to the model. As I understand it, the code is actually derived from all of the text that went into the training set. So, strictly speaking, I guess proper attribution is impossible. More generally, I wonder what you think about the whole plagiarism/stealing issue. Is it something you're at all uneasy about as you use LLMs? Not trying to accuse or argue; I'm curious about different perspectives on this, as it's currently the hang-up preventing me from jumping into LLM-assisted coding.
mwcampbell··on Using Sun Ray thin clients in 2025
For an extended, colorful telling of the experience outlined in that paper, check out Bryan's earliest recorded talk on DTrace, particularly the section starting at the timestamp in this link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TgmA48fILq8&t=35m6s
mwcampbell··on Phoenix.new – Remote AI Runtime for Phoenix
The argument you're responding to is effective enough, based solely on the fact that it has led me to second-guess whether I chose the right line of work, that it would be worth expounding on what you think is wrong with it.
mwcampbell··on Generative AI coding tools and agents do not work for me
I aspire to live up to your description of the best sort of developer. But I think there might also be a danger that that approach can turn into an excuse for spending the week overthinking (possibly while goofing off as well; I've done it), then writing a first cut on Friday, leaving no time for the multiple iterations that are often necessary to get to the best solution. In other words, I think sometimes it's necessary to just start coding sooner than we'd like so we can start iterating toward the right solution. But that "unproductive, burnt out hack" line hits a bit too close to home for me these days, and I'm starting to entertain the possibility that an LLM-based agent might have more energy for doing those multiple iterations than I do.
mwcampbell··on How easy is it for a developer to "sandbox" a program?
Ah, OK. Honestly, it wouldn't surprise me if Electron made it work by weakening the sandboxing. Someone should look into that though before we assume that's the case.
mwcampbell··on How easy is it for a developer to "sandbox" a program?
Why do you say the way Chrome does it requires custom installer logic? Electron is able to use Chromium's sandbox for renderer processes without imposing any installer requirements as far as I know.
mwcampbell··on Avoiding generative models is the rational and responsible thing to do
It should be uncontroversial to say that we understand the failure modes of working with other people much better, because we have millennia of experience with that.
mwcampbell··on Avoiding generative models is the rational and responsible thing to do
So why not wait and find out what those useful and not-so-harmful bits actually are, if there are any?
mwcampbell··on Trusting your own judgement on 'AI' is a risk
You present that title as if it's obviously outlandish, but I think that earlier article does a reasonably good job of backing up that title.
mwcampbell··on I think I'm done thinking about GenAI for now
He explained why he hasn't tried it in the section "The Challenge". Also see footnote 21, which says that what he called his "quirky constraints" in the main text are really bedrock ethical concerns. I respect him a great deal for not compromising on these.

Edit to add: Full disclosure: I've been a fan of his writing and work for a long time anyway, and am a supporter on Patreon.

mwcampbell··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
I disagree with you on this. Artists, writers, and programmers deserve equal protection, and this means that tptacek is right to criticize nerd piracy culture. In other words, we programmers should respect artists and writers too.
mwcampbell··on My AI skeptic friends are all nuts
> there's no escaping it no matter how much you might want to

And if we accept that inevitability, it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. The fact that some people _want_ us to give in is a reason to keep resisting.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →