I wonder how far Redox's microkernel design is from what that comment describes.
11,185 karma · joined February 6, 2013
I'm a software developer specializing in accessibility for blind and visually impaired people. From mid-2017 to late 2020, I worked for Microsoft on the Windows accessibility team, though my comments were always my own opinion posted on my own initiative.
I'm legally blind myself; I have enough sight to read a desktop computer screen up close with slightly enlarged fonts, but I often use a screen reader when browsing the Web, doing email, and other tasks that don't involve code. (Don't get me wrong; totally blind people can program, but I never got used to doing it that way myself.)
Of course, there's more to me than visual impairment. When it comes to programming, I'm also particularly interested in the challenges of developing cross-platform applications that integrate smoothly with the host platform. Outside of programming, I love music and love to sing. Pre-COVID, I often did karaoke (of course, I memorize the words). And like many nerds, I read science fiction.
Email: mattcampbell@pobox.com
Mastodon: https://toot.cafe/@matt
Blog: http://mwcampbell.us/blog/
Location: Wichita, Kansas, US
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/mwcampbell; my proof: https://keybase.io/mwcampbell/sigs/9sbxkfOoTyW6C8IiDB50bP_ZWa-V73AfbdmvUlfOKe8 ]
I wonder how far Redox's microkernel design is from what that comment describes.
For me, the big win of static linking is startup time. Just mmap the executable and go. No need to slow down the startup process with the very branchy process of resolving and loading DLLs.
I use a different retro point of reference than josephg, though it happens to involve the same microprocessor. One of my favorite programs as a child was Diversi-Tune, an early music program for the Apple IIGS. It could play and record MIDI, and also show song lyrics, karaoke-style. The total program size is just under 48 KB, including one file that appears to contain configuration data. Granted, that doesn't count the Apple IIGS ROM or the ProDOS 8 operating system. When you add those, the total comes to just under 200 KB (for a ROM version 01 Apple IIGS).
And Diversi-Tune didn't even use all of the ROM. I know this because one of the areas where Diversi-Tune fell short, even by Apple IIGS standards, was accessibility. The documentation for the Textalker GS screen reader specifically called out that the screen reader didn't work with Diversi-Tune because Diversi-Tune didn't use QuickDraw II for text output. Needless to say, Diversi-Tune didn't support modern internationalization either.
But how much code would it really take to implement a modern Diversi-Tune with accessibility, internationalization, and so on? It must be well short of the ~180 MB (and growing) for an Electron binary. Current work on Rust GUIs suggests that the binary size might fall between 5 and 15 MB, depending on which compiler optimizations one chooses. And that's with an advanced GPU-based renderer that compiles shaders at run time. I'm sure it's possible to do better on that front. Of course, that's on top of the OS, but one could easily imagine a sub-500-MB Linux-based OS as the platform. I don't know about memory usage.
Shouldn't developers be the most self-reliant users possible, especially when working with open-source tools? That is, shouldn't we expect that when a developer has a problem, they dive into the code and figure it out on their own?
And let's not forget that Word 97 felt bloated in its day, however fondly we may look back on it now.
If withoutboats is right [1], then Rust would never have received the industry backing to be as successful as it is now.
[1]: https://without.boats/blog/why-async-rust/ especially the section "Organizational considerations"
I still wish the Python core team had abandoned the Python 3 experiment and gone with Python 2.x for life, warts and all. I learned to work with the warts, including the Unicode ones. I think a lot of us did.
If we want disabled people to not be treated as outsiders, then it seems to me that disabled people need to be integrated into as many aspects of society as possible, including school, so that kids have disabled people as peers from as early an age as is practical. If some of us have to suffer the consequences of bullying or unfair treatment, then hopefully that's a temporary state, and the fact that more people have interacted with us from a young age is a step on the road to equality. Of course, the reason I can say that is that my experiences in mainstream schools were mild, in retrospect.
I don't think working at Oxide would be for me, but I respect the team's values and process.