237 karma · joined November 10, 2010
As copyright holders they can later resubmit the game under a different license.
I'm not convinced that there will be much distinction between the infringing works being in the binaries or not. They are in the source tree and that is essentially part of the build process. What's more, the source tree is distributed to all Android manufacturers. Google are shipping the source code.
I'm sure Oracle don't see it that way.
What we should be talking about is how they got into the git tree in the first place.
Two things.
1. When you do Open Source - you ship the source. 2. I don't remember copyright law being concerned with "shipping". I think "distribution" is what counts and if it's in the git tree - that's distribution.
However, there is substance to this and almost certainly violations taking place. The community is all the better to know about.
That is very much of public interest and a prime example of what whistle blowing is for.
I'm not saying it's true but only that I don't see any more evidence that it isn't true than that it is - yet.
I would think the best examples of a conflicts of interest is where particular articles detail unethical behaviour or any content in the public domain that an advertiser would prefer not to be included or made easily accessible.
Obviously, its not to say that it will happen but just that it could. And it is naive at best to think that a separate sales team solves the problems of commercial bias or influence.
Wikipedia is the single largest body of freely available knowledge in the history of mankind. It must remain so and the best way to do that is to continue accepting donations. I see no reason to change.
I consider it somewhat analog to BBC being funded through a license fee rather than commercial advertising - aka Sky (BSkyB, owned by Murdoch).
Check out http://280atlas.com/