HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mxxc

76 karma · joined January 29, 2021

submissionscomments
mxxc··on David Dushman, last surviving Auschwitz liberator, dies aged 98
there are a few rhetorical tricks here. what am i denying exactly? the genocide? yes i am. it's not a genocide. there isn't a planned extermination of uyghurs going on. there have been planned exterminations of armenians from anatolia and jews from europe.

on the other hand: am i denying the existence of fishy "re-education camps" targeting one ethnic group and one only, where they are brought in under very opaque circumstances? no, i am not denying that.

if you want a very long read with some context behind some of those claims, here's one: https://www.qiaocollective.com/en/education/xinjiang

there are a bunch of things there, a full timeline of the "conflict", a couple of articles debunking both poor google maps journalism and a few poorly-made BBC & vice docs on the matter.

there's also the fact that some of the "punishments" against the uyghurs are forcing children to go to school, to mandarin-speaking public ones even, which is the same policy most countries in the world adopt (a recent request in france to partially allow schooling in catalan in the region of perpignan has been rejected). there are some claims that state-funded xinjiang schools are even bilingual but i haven't dug enough on it.

i won't comment on the wuhan issue because i don't really know enough about it, but as someone who is born in an island with plenty of US bases i laugh at everyone claiming china is "flexing their muscles" with their navy.

to be clear: nobody approaching any of those bases gets allowed in, just like in the "xinjiang camps". does this excuse china? no, it doesn't, but we should probably be fair in our judgment.

mxxc··on David Dushman, last surviving Auschwitz liberator, dies aged 98
this is the same question that china asks when confronted with the uyghur problem. they believe they are fighting terrorism and extremism and those camps are (part of) the solution. we can disagree with them – and if the extreme claims about those camps are correct, then i do disagree with them.

on the EU issue: there isn't one single solution since all the cases are different. a few come to mind. i would not pay blood money to morocco and libya to "keep them at bay" because the EU can't just champion human rights at home and then fund concentration camp-like establishments outside of its borders – we are not funding the ones in xinjiang, we are funding the ones in the libyan litoral. a way more efficient refugee processing scheme with the participation of everyone else would be ethically better. much as i disliked him, matteo renzi put it very well for the eastern european extremists: no refugees, no money. on an EU level i'd also crack down on pushbacks (such as the ones happening in spain and in greece), where the carrot should be a better refugee distribution.

let's not forget that europe's exploitation caused this problem, it's also on us to help people and figure out a solution.

mxxc··on David Dushman, last surviving Auschwitz liberator, dies aged 98
they're not ignoring it, plenty of countries have been recognising it. the issue is that much of the available information isn't exactly reliable, a lot of the research comes from one single person (an ultra-christian extremist), and plenty of the people who have been detained are leaving from the front door, unlike the armenians in 1895-1925 and the jews in 1943-1945. mosques are still open and there are plenty of videos of 2021 eid al fitr in xinjiang.

not saying "there is nothing going on there" and "those incarcerations are complete lies" but the whole thing is fishy, especially considering that there are political motives behind screaming bloody murder – for comparison, there is literally zero western pressure on israel on the occupation issue, and the EU is blatantly ignoring the insane conditions migrants are subjected to on the other side of the EU barriers.

mxxc··on Cities with the Best Work-Life Balance 2021
the best cities in the world by work life balance are always the ones where you can happily spend your non-working time freezing to death :)
mxxc··on The PGP Problem: A Critique (2020)
i think once most PGP implementations rely on public key servers + key signing a "global web of trust" is a first principle, while the "small web of trust" really isn't
mxxc··on The PGP Problem: A Critique (2020)
doesn't that apply to PGP too? you could still have a key logger or malicious kernel modules or whatever.
mxxc··on The PGP Problem: A Critique (2020)
i don't think the web of trust as a "first principle" is necessarily a good thing. it made sense a while ago perhaps, but nowadays it's just overkill. there are several use cases where either you want to keep a closed loop on everything (e.g. you intend keys to circulate only within your company), or very very different cases where there is value in keys that are valid only for the sake of a chat: it doesn't need to be anything illegal, but if two parties negotiate a message exchange and there is trust in the fact that the very first key exchange is secure, you only need the subsequent messages to match the first key pair. after that, the keys can safely be destroyed, not added to your respective keyrings and signed on the public internet.
mxxc··on The PGP Problem: A Critique (2020)
i think the main problem with PGP has to do with its general usability, and often wrappers, GUIs etc. are mere workarounds to its UX flaws. like the article says, it's not much more than a swiss army knife and for many of the uses that most people mention here there are often better tools – end-to-end secure messaging, file encryption and so on.

i think pgp is a reasonable tool in absolute zero-trust circumstances, where one has to send and receive messages and files through channels that are at constant risk of tapping or phishing. even there, i'd say it's "very annoying to use" but it's probably better than death, or jail.

mxxc··on The Goodreads “Classics”: A Computational Study
the literal meaning of that sentence is "i am a roman citizen", i.e. today's transposition would be "i am a norwegian national". nothing to do with the colour of his skin or latinx or whatever.

edit: worth noting that this is cicero speaking about legal status and citizenship within the empire, not caesar talking about foreign tribes calling them names, which is precisely what anyone calling garcia marquez (a latin american author) latinx (north american terminology) is doing.

mxxc··on The Goodreads “Classics”: A Computational Study
it's several people's perspective. labelling authors and personalities according to 2021 america's standard of race is a bit ephemeral, as it assumes that a. everybody agrees with america's definitions b. those definitions are here to stay. assuming that rashid al-din, al-idrisi and khalil gibran have anything to do with each other despite coming from three extremely different places and three very different historical periods is a bit obtuse and doesn't do them any justice.

it's fine that america labels people by skin colour for their own political purposes – although i'd be interested in seeing what the difference between the average italian and the average lebanese is, in the classification – but if we're doing any sort of analysis of humanities, it seems a bit amateurish.

mxxc··on The Goodreads “Classics”: A Computational Study
i agree with all of the above. i learned that alexandre dumas had caribbean ancestry in this article. would have been more interesting to add more details, like the fact that his "caribbean ancestry" was due to a nobleman marrying a slave, which definitely gives an indication of the class dynamics of the time and could be an interesting fact in itself.

i would go one step further and, exaggerating, claim that putting alexandre dumas and chinua achebe in the same bucket is, in fact, racist.

mxxc··on The Goodreads “Classics”: A Computational Study
in most recorded history people have been writing things the way they wanted to, which is why we encounter a lot of different spellings of the same names, and in several languages occasionally we'd get this or that corruption. it could be that i don't have a lot of education and you are patronising me for that, or it could be that i am highly educated and i can't be bothered to use the shift key. could be many things ;)
mxxc··on The Goodreads “Classics”: A Computational Study
tomato tomato. "identifying as" is also a modern mostly anglo-saxon concept. the world is much more complex than individual egos.
mxxc··on The Goodreads “Classics”: A Computational Study
i find it interesting that these days many articles emphasise (lack of) diversity within a given topic and then introduce some biases themselves that will inevitably skew their results, e.g. in this case focusing the bulk of the work on english reviews in order to do text mining, instead of maybe spending some more time figuring out whether the rankings, most read, ratings, etc. apply to everyone else.

also, i hope garcia marquez is rolling in his grave at the thought of being referred to as "latinx".

mxxc··on The Asses of Parnassus
the parnasses?
mxxc··on Just because you can work from home doesn’t mean you’ll be allowed to
the funny thing is that many jobs that aren't particularly real-life-interaction-demanding were never considered as potentially remote and still have people getting infected in their offices.

at least for those that were open to the possibility - eg many tech jobs - the taboo has been broken and ultimately i think companies that offer permanent flexibility will have an edge.

mxxc··on Employee accused of skipping work for 15 years
not sure if you're italian but to add insult to injury italians themselves complain about EU fund usage in the south :)

it is true however that between arrest and initial prosecution the justice system in italy is very trigger happy (whether people stay in jail is a different story) and it makes a good story for the press. there are examples elsewhere where law enforcement is a lot more magnanimous. not defending this case at all but in general this might partially explain why italy is more on the spotlight than other places.

mxxc··on Fitted Filtration Efficiency of Double Masking During the COVID-19 Pandemic
no not really. the study says that one of the two groups was instructed to wear masks. it's the people outside that were only recommended to do so. half of them reported always wearing them and only a small minority reported never doing so. the results of the test are in line with the sad reality in most european countries that have mandatory mask wearing since last summer.

nobody is questioning lab tests.

to be clear: the effectiveness of mask-wearing policies on a broad population can not be done in a lab, although it would be interesting to test "not wearing masks" in a country that does have that policy; this unfortunately can't be done either because it's currently against the law - where applicable.

mxxc··on Fitted Filtration Efficiency of Double Masking During the COVID-19 Pandemic
no idea where you live but since masks have been enforced everywhere here (including: the beach, hiking trails, walking alone at night), with the police actually checking people, we've had 3 subsequent waves of covid. i'm only talking about exteriors because i haven't seen a single person not wearing a mask inside – no mask in a shop? you don't get allowed in.

expecting more than this and discussing the result of a study that can't really be done in a lab is debating philosophy, but of course critics can go on downvoting.

mxxc··on Fitted Filtration Efficiency of Double Masking During the COVID-19 Pandemic
> They studied the efficacy of "wear a mask" recommendations. Not mask wearing itself.

as far as policy is concerned, these two are equivalent

mxxc··on Chariots of steel: Barcelona's hidden army of scrap recyclers
i've heard that before ;)
mxxc··on Chariots of steel: Barcelona's hidden army of scrap recyclers
>Funny timing, as it seems the local government is starting to crack down on dumpster divers in the name of "collecting recycling data": https://www.ccma.cat/324/barcelona-estrenara-contenidors-int...

ironic if this stuff will show up while paper metro tickets still reign supreme

mxxc··on Plotnine: Grammar of Graphics for Python (2019)
what's with the matplotlib hate on this post? it's an extremely mature piece of technology, but maturity itself isn't the only reason why libraries like ggplot and altair aren't the default choice for python plots. as per many topics, most plots are just quick drawings and plt.scatter(x, y) is not just quicker, but, by far, much more intuitive to me than anything involving the word "geom" (ggplot2) or "encode" (altair).

some here say "i haven't gone back to mpl". oh i have. every single time i tried any of these alternatives.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2