HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

myrmidon

3,422 karma · joined April 14, 2014

submissionscomments
myrmidon··on 'Offensively cheap': solar power is looking up
An underappreciated fact is that the Japanese/German renewable push starting in the early 2000s contributed a lot toward the global state of solar power now.

Solar programs/subsidies there is how a lot of local (and later Chinese) industry was bootstrapped despite being far from competitive with fossil energy back then.

Those initiatives might have accelerated the whole solar power industry by half a decade or more. We are now reaping even (indirect) benefit from industrializing countries (Pakistan, India, etc) that go straight to solar instead of conventional plants.

People often insist that western climate initiatives are "meaningless", "wasteful" and "ineffective", but examples like this prove that global effects are absolutely realistic.

If those two countries had fully invested into nuclear power back then, we might be significantly worse off right now as far as global CO2 emissions are concerned.

myrmidon··on Who Aligns the Aligners?
No, that does not follow.

Any other argument against <ridiculous apocalyptic supposition> is perfectly fine, just not the "it hasn't happened before" one.

myrmidon··on The same nine streaming subscriptions cost $702/year more than in 2021
Sure, but do you actually do this every weekend?

I mean obviously there are people that consume a lot more movie entertainment than the average, but I'm personally getting nowhere close to 70 seasons per year.

Bingewatching occasionally might not be enough to economically justify your subscriptions.

myrmidon··on Hitachi launches CO2 heat pump water heaters with solar-friendly tariff controls
It's an arab loan word for ~"price list" (originally strongly suggesting an import-duty-like meaning).

The same word exists in e.g. German or Italian, but mostly just means "pricing scheme" there, like in the article ("import duty" using a different expression in those languages).

Might be a mostly/somewhat "false friend" for a German (pv magazine is german).

myrmidon··on The same nine streaming subscriptions cost $702/year more than in 2021
Buying breaking bad on DVD is <3 months of netflix subscription (no ads).

So if you watch <2 seasons per month on average, you already come out ahead, and this is assuming only a single subscription.

People tend to wastly overpay for subscriptions because they end up underutilized and are typically never cancelled quickly enough because people are lazy.

myrmidon··on Show HN: What if the speed of light was 5 km/h?
Sadly there is no realistic approach to get there (even assuming fantasy-levels of technology).

Chemical rockets are currently the only thing that allow sustaining such accelerations briefly for human-size payloads, but the low exhaust velocity and exponential reaction mass requirement make sustaining it for days/months/years completely impossible.

You'd have to supply the energy externally (i.e. some sort of beam propulsion), but getting any significant fraction of g out of such a system (with human-sized payloads) seems unlikely within the next centuries, especially as the distance increases.

myrmidon··on Navier-Stokes – Tristan Buckmaster [pdf]
Just replace the model with a human student.

"Training" on textbooks => fine

"Training" with unpublished notes from another professor, then publishing something on that exact topic with a similar approach without giving any credit => extremely questionable.

myrmidon··on PISA 2025 Students' reading and mathematics performance declined across the OECD
Depending on the education/age of new recruits, you might not have seen much of the, younger, lower scored cohort, because the sharp performance drop only really started after 2018 (so the oldest affected people are around 22).
myrmidon··on 216M Spy TVs – The LG Smart TV Problem [video]
Modems becoming super cheap is gonna be a big problem for this, because those make it even harder to prevent such snooping.

Just imagine having to jam the devices in your own home just to stop them from profiling you.

Better pray to your deer god that modem + data contract is gonna stay more expensive that the expected value from selling more data...

We really need regulation to stop this.

myrmidon··on bzip3
There is a comparison with "zstd -19" on the Silesia corpus, showing better compression ratio for bzip3 (47.2 vs 53MB) while being ~5 times faster (and using only half the memory).

Even if the examples are highly cherry-picked, it is quite suprising to me that such pareto-dominance is possible at all.

edit: Tested it myself and found that it often also does slightly worse than zstd -19 in compression ratio but faster (it was slower in one case on "uncompressible" input).

Compression performance vs "zstd -19" seems to depends a lot on actual input data in a very unpredictable way. I'd assume the benchmarks that they show are definitely somewhat cherry-picked.

myrmidon··on Tiny $70 Xteink X3 e-reader
There is no way shipping alone explains the difference.

I would suspect the majority comes from higher (VAT) tax level; possibly also some indirect overhead because Europe is a more segmented market, and needs a bunch of localization at the very least.

myrmidon··on US refuses payout for soldiers who died in Iran 'because it isn't a war'
Not counting China (and South Korea) because they joined the "industrialized" club much later than the rest, but so far it is looking good, and I'm somewhat hopeful because their demographics make war an increasingly risky proposition.
myrmidon··on US refuses payout for soldiers who died in Iran 'because it isn't a war'
My view is that France tried to hold on to Indochina unjustifiably for almost a decade after WW2.

So they get the blame because the US could have hardly escalated a proxy war without proxies.

Not saying America is blameless though, but I do blame France for setting the whole thing up basically (split Vietnam), and for all the wrong reasons, too.

myrmidon··on An Alien Mind
There were leaks before the Manhattan project even concluded:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klaus_Fuchs

Sure, non-US nuclear arms would have most certainly happpened either way, but exfiltration did presumably at least accelerate the timeline.

myrmidon··on Project HydraFusion: Frontier quality via multi-model orchestration
With all due respect, but I'm not letting some newfangled comic taint/monopolize a perfectly usable name that's been used to describe many-headed-thing (water snake) for over two millennia.
myrmidon··on US refuses payout for soldiers who died in Iran 'because it isn't a war'
I'd argue the US only got dragged into lots of conflicts because of its role as de-facto global hegemon.

A lot of wars it did not really start; if you blame the US for Vietnam (instead of the french), you also have to count South Ossetia, Abkhazia, Transistria and Chechnya 1 & 2 on the Russian side.

The industrialized nations that actually did laudably little warmongering in the last half centuries are (somewhat ironically) the core WW2-axis powers: Italy, Austria, Germany, Japan; despite having plenty of "opportunities" to start something (e.g. over Königsberg/Silesia, Dalmatia, Kuril islands, ...)

myrmidon··on Project HydraFusion: Frontier quality via multi-model orchestration
Why? I feel it kinda implies what the approach is. Could definitely be worse, strongly prefer this over just giving the thing a random-ass name like Laguna.
myrmidon··on US diesel prices hit a record high of $5.85 on average
Any externalized cost that you tolerate as regulator is already an indirect form of subsidy in my view. E.g. allowing a mining company to dump tailings in the next river is exactly the same as paying for proper disposal with tax money (from a company finances point of view).

So any untaxed air polluter/CO2 emitter enjoys an indirect subsidy already.

But in the french case, farmers and fishermen got paid 15-30 cents per liter on top (removing all ambiguity).

myrmidon··on US diesel prices hit a record high of $5.85 on average
Diesel for agricultural use is subsidised almost everywhere in the west to some degree.

France removed taxes on non-road diesel this year and paid per-liter-subsidies on top.

Keeping independent local agriculture is quite existential for any state, so this is understandable despite being morally questionable in my opinion.

myrmidon··on US diesel prices hit a record high of $5.85 on average
Agreed.

Interesting fact: If you price CO2 at <$100/ton and assume that (ballpark) 2000 Gt of emissions (starting now) already lead to very severe consequences (this is quite generous), then you are pricing "somewhat intact climate for the next few centuries" at around one years GDP (which is insane to me).

myrmidon··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
Is there any reason to assume they are not doing the same (ingesting books that they hold no rights to into training data)?

From the copyright holders point of view, it is simply much easier to prosecute western companies.

myrmidon··on Hackers Had a Live Feed of Every ID Verification Company Scanned for over a Year
> You can fix companies by voting a government too

Indirectly only. This is typically also always too late; instead of doing "the right thing" in the first place, companies are disincentivized by regulation from doing "bad things" again.

Regulations are like scar tissue, they don't help against getting burnt in the first place.

Preemptive regulation typically sucks, and is admittedly extremely difficult to get right; most governments don't even bother trying.

Corporation know this and exploit it ruthlessly-- there are almost never consequences as long as they keep to the letter of the law, even when acting with intent, against better knowledge and causing astronomical damage to society (just consider the whole leaded gas disaster for an extremely clear example).

myrmidon··on Hackers had a live feed of every ID verification company scanned for over a year
I understand the sentiment, but your government you can actually fix by voting.

If Apple (or another large international company) suffers from decreasing margins, gets a new CEO and decides to turn the data it sits on into money there is absolutely nothing you can do, and you might in fact still stay a "forced" customer because of network effects (=> just consider whatsapp being an important communication channel in many places worldwide).

I think this attitude in general is often harmful; if your government sucks, fix the government instead of making yourself dependent on some quasi-monopolist private company.

myrmidon··on Discovery of a new OpenAI agent message board
It's "move fast and break things" in action.

But Anthropic alone paid >$1bn for copyright violations, so they did not just get away with it.

These hacking cases are more difficult, because from a legal perspective there is no obvious damage and obviously no intent.

edit: "no obvious damage" is more about the first hacking incidents; in this case it is more straightforward.

myrmidon··on How an MIT research project became the Julia programming language
Julia is really fun to use, and I think they are onto something with the type system: Complex types interact much better across module boundaries than in most other languages; here's a good talk on this by one of the creators:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kc9HwsxE1OY

The biggest drawback of the language in my view is that Julia is an LLVM toolchain "pretending" to be an interpreted language (it is, technically), this often leaks as very slow first execution latency (and almost forces you to keep the interpreter open instead of just calling it on the file you're editing).

myrmidon··on Dutch central bank moves share of gold from U.S., Canada to London
There is a big difference between some sports association being greedy/unethical and elected officials abusing their position of power (especially when they sit in the highest positions and there are zero consequences).
myrmidon··on Quasar 438B: Europe's Leading AI Model
The EU comission is not directly elected, what else is the AI supposed to reply here?

Comparisons between Chinese and western media control/censorship always strike me as somewhat ridiculous; This is like comparing Guantanamo Bay with the Soviet Gulag System: Yes both of those are unethical, but there's a factor of 1000 difference in scale.

Case in point: You can freely read about criticism like yours from anywhere in Europe (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_legitimacy_of_the_E...), but all of Wikipedia is just blocked in China.

myrmidon··on EFF to Courts: Don't Rewrite Copyright over AI Hype
> so all you need is for paying clients to not be motivated to redistribute the chapters in an organised way

This is exactly what copyright is.

I agree that you could work around this in a world without copyright (e.g. by watermarking content and blacklisting), but it would be difficult and make the whole profession less viable.

Mass distribution and payment becoming accessible/low overhead was an extremely helpful development for authors in my view, and removing copyright would have the opposite effect (but cutting it down even to several years would change surprisingly little).

myrmidon··on Since it was stripped of planetary status, Pluto’s defenders have been fighting
Gravitational binding energy is too large.

Project sundial was ~10Gt of TNT, but dispersing Pluto would require a billion times that (~5E27J).

myrmidon··on EFF to Courts: Don't Rewrite Copyright over AI Hype
The more successful "self published" authors writing web novels make significant money from patreon (>$20k/month); this relies on copyright protection (but interestingly, just a few months would be sufficient for that business model).
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →