HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

mziel

358 karma · joined March 1, 2014

submissionscomments
mziel··on Books Are Getting Longer
And of course the real title is "The big question: are books getting longer?".

Re: article, it's disheartening that good books suffer from this as well. I've recently read "The power of habit" and "Think fast and slow". Both are great, but both would be much better at the half of their size.

For most non-fiction content the magazine article is too short (3-8 pages) and only skims over the issue. It's evident when you read an article on something you're very familiar with. However book is too long (300 pages) and introduces filler and repetitions. I find that Special Reports from The Economist are quite good in size and depth (15-30 pages). My ideal would be around 100 pages, but those reports are still my go-to place if I want to read something.

mziel··on Software Eats Software Development as Andreessen Invests $10M in App Outsourcer
Big chunk of consulting is this busines model, i.e. develop a solution and sell its integration in the vendor architecture.

Is their solution that much different?

mziel··on Software Eats Software Development as Andreessen Invests $10M in App Outsourcer
Lots of tools make coding more accessible to large audience. IDE, higher-level languages, better tooling, libraries/frameworks/modules, stackoverflow.

However this didn't result in less work for the programmers, on the contrary. Same thing may apply here. Just the pressure points will change.

mziel··on Mentat Wiki
Training Paul isn't just a BG byproduct. When he figures it out Thufir Hawat smiles and tells him it was the plan all along. I don't recall Leto or Thufir knowing about BG plans towards Paul.
mziel··on Machine learning works spectacularly well, but mathematicians aren’t sure why
There are. It's all about variance reduction. See the Breiman's paper on Bagging. There's nothing special about random forest though (apart from the fact that a decision tree is a good learner, because of the nonlinearities for example), you can you ensemble learning with any "basic" learner.
mziel··on A Roadmap Towards Machine Intelligence
So basically Siri?
mziel··on Googling stuff can cause us to overestimate our own knowledge
"When wikipedia has a server down, my apparent IQ drops by about 30 points"

https://xkcd.com/903/

mziel··on IA or AI?
> A lot of problems suddenly disappear.

Not to be negative but citation needed.

Also (I guess we'll cross "isolation" of the list): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_giftedness#Social...

mziel··on Ad-blocking: a sign that web publishers don’t care about readers
I would argue that it has exactly the same impact. Your argument is a bit of "If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?" nature.

Unless the advertisers want to publicly (!) admit that they wish they could block TV content from people muting/changing the channel/walking out to make tea during commercials.

mziel··on In China, Your Credit Score Is Affected by Your Political Opinions
I'm not French, but:

http://blog.sextantproperties.com/2012/08/21/the-positives-o...

>However, if you apply for a credit or mortgage in France, all you will have to provide is your last 3-month bank statements and the last 3 month pay slips (or last 3 year tax returns). It is that simple. There is no credit report or score for you to worry about.

mziel··on Evernote cuts 47 employees and shuts down 3 offices
And why wouldn't they switch to MS or Google Drive? The migration costs don't seem overwhelming. Dropbox won't disappear, but it's not a beast you make it out to be.

Case in point: I'm a big fan of Excel and Word, it's a solid piece of software. But I haven't used it in over a year, all my stuff sits with Google Docs/Sheets. Excel won't disappear (extremely popular in finance with VBA) but for most users there's no difference and little switching costs.

mziel··on “On Accident” or “By Accident”?
Are you sure, it's not "It was an accident" ?
mziel··on How language gives your brain a break
Can you provide links? Greatly appreciated!
mziel··on How language gives your brain a break
Something, something, Sapir-Whorf hypothesis :)
mziel··on How language gives your brain a break
> That means language users have a global preference for more locally grouped dependent words, whenever possible.

YMMV, but for German (I'm not a native speaker, although fluent) you can't figure out the meaning of the sentence until the very end.

The authors' even acknowledge this:

>German, which has some notoriously indirect sentence constructions, is far less optimized, according to the analysis.

>And the researchers also discovered that “head-final” languages such as Japanese, Korean, and Turkish, where the head word comes last, show less length minimization than is typical.

German, Japanese, Turkish seem like quite a big chunk of languages (population-wise), so I wonder if initial statements are not too English-specific.

mziel··on Reinventing Performance Management
But there is no cost/downside. At least for you. What I'm arguing is that this "reminder" is not effective.
mziel··on Reinventing Performance Management
Yes, but what does the question actually capture? What's the incentive not to agree with that statement? Or maybe everyone puts "4" instead of 5 to hedge their bets?

Don't want to deride the question without seeing someone from Deloitte expand on that, but the "as if it were own money" seems redundant at best.

mziel··on Reinventing Performance Management
1. Given what I know of this person’s performance, and if it were my money, I would award this person the highest possible compensation increase and bonus.

2. Given what I know of this person’s performance, I would always want him or her on my team.

3. This person is at risk for low performance.

4. This person is ready for promotion today.

Questions 2-4 seem OK, but question 1 is problematic. I've been conducting data analysis on questionnaire data and people can't be expected to imagine "if it were my money". It's not their money, it won't be taken from their paycheck. Basically the stakes are not real. Which in turn will create in upwards bias.

mziel··on How to learn data science
I lived through Statistics, Business Analysis, Decision Analytics, Data Analytics, Data Mining now Data Science. Same thing renamed over and over again.

Regarding post above, it's right. Data scientist is someone better at statistics (classical stats, bayesian, machine learning) than computer scientist, and better at programming (SQL, R/Python for building models) than academic statistician. Plus a teaspoon of visualization (ggplot or d3).

mziel··on R at Microsoft
Most of the things can be transformed through lapply family (and d/plyr equivalents). d/plyr has simple parallel=TRUE. For other problems use mclapply().

That's basically all you need on a day-to-day basis.

mziel··on Ask HN: APL family instead of R for data analysis?
My main criticism is around two things.

One, "clunkiness" of class creation (which I guess is subjective); I don't think it's very readable, but maybe that's bias from other languages.

Second the S3/S4/R4 mess.

mziel··on Ask HN: APL family instead of R for data analysis?
It really depends on what you're doing. If you're a developer tapping into data analysis, sure. But I'm building predictive models for a living and I evaluated quite a few different frameworks and languages.

Sophistic algorithms for missing data, sparse solutions, latent modelling. You can find the many industrial grade algorithms in Python, Spark, Julia, Weka etc. but for stats-heavy data science/machine learning R is unmatched. Sans writing your own implementations based on pseudocode, but this is really not effective use of your time for prototyping.

EDIT: And even for simple stuff, the strength of R packages is easy to prove since they are either directly ported to other languages (ggplot) or heavily influence the implementation (pandas).

mziel··on Ask HN: APL family instead of R for data analysis?
Exactly! There are many good languages for data analysis (Julia is one example) but no other language (not even Python, which is BTW leaps and bounds above all the other alternatives) can match the library support and statistical maturity that R has.

And R is not so bad as a language. It's OO is really bad, but it has functions as first-class members and great support for NAs. Combined with Hadleyverse and pipe operator (magrittr) is makes a very readable code.

mziel··on Java 8: Replace traditional for loops with IntStreams
There are some instances of type inference i Java.

1) Diamond operator for generics 2) Type inference for lambdas

Naturally would be good to get even more of it.

mziel··on Study finds connections between birth month and health
Naturally this comes to mind: https://xkcd.com/882/

Spurious correlation achieved by misusing statistics. Not to mention publication bias.

mziel··on Your data fits in RAM
That's why you never ever grow lists with R. do.call('rbind',...) or even better data.table::rbindlist(). You can't blame R for being slow if you don't know how to write fast R code.
mziel··on Ask HN: When will “Who is Hiring?” be posted? It's past 9am Eastern
Flagged? Not sure what happened.
mziel··on Google Faces Enormous Forces in Fight Over the Future of Android
Objective-C, which is very popular? Give me a platform (apart from iOS and OSX) where Objective-C is popular? Why not the other way around?
mziel··on Markov Chain Monte Carlo Without Jargon
Sometimes I get the idea that people in CS want to "get all this machine learning/data science stuff" without understanding the principles.

Sure, it's trivially easy to build a classifier in R/Scikit (or even code one up from scratch) so it may seem like it's no big deal. Similarily, it's trivially easy to hack up an inefficient SQL query, without knowledge of relational algebra or normal forms. But I would argue that some basic knowledge is essential in applying these things.

mziel··on Timeless Decision Theory [pdf]
Also if you include a mixed (randomized) strategies the postulated Newcomb's problem is idiotic, because the other player is not an oracle. That's why they included a dirty fix that "if the Predictor predicts that the player will choose randomly, then box B will contain nothing".
← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →