827 karma · joined June 1, 2012
Bill Janeway offers a well-written deconstruction of the "impossibly" part of the author's "impossibly attractive" characterization of SaaS here:
https://wtfeconomy.com/enterprise-software-death-and-transfi...
(from 2016)
"Today we really can preserve ourselves for a much longer time. The means of preservation are reliable and cheap. The haste to live one's mortal life diminishes. The temptation toward perpetual preservation grows. We preserve the living corpse in an optimal state, not so we may do something with it, but for its own good feelings of eternal fitness, confidence, and safety. We hoard our capital to earn interest, and subsist each day on crusts of bread. But no one will inherit our good health after we've gone. The hours of life maintenance vanish with the person."
I'd post a link, but I don't think a public one exists. You can read the whole essay in his "Against Everything" compilation.
With maybe the sole exception of a README (and that's a big MAYBE), I can't think of a more useful artifact to ship with software than a test suite.
At worst, a test suite can be ignored; at best, it's a living record of a system's runtime interaction with the real world.
Can a fleet of fighter planes run on electricity, currently? No.
Has the Army committed to having 100% of their fleet of tanks running on electricity by 2025? No.
Can you run a supply chain to the front lines of a ground war with electricity? Technically yes, but it's only a matter of time until your wire infra gets cut/bombed.
So I completely agree with the OP, assuming a general absence of armed, land-based conflict in the next 20 years.
That said, think about why the US even _has_ a highway system and domestic airlines. There are two main weaknesses of building transportation infrastructure on rail, from a central-planning perspective:
1. You can shut down an entire country's economy by bombing the rail infrastructure (c.f. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman%27s_March_to_the_Sea, viewing the seceded South as a "country" here...), less so with airfields and asphalt highways.
2. There is no consistent demand for continued production of railroad infrastructure, once it is built, which makes mobilizing production in times of great need (e.g. war) slow and difficult.
How this relates to the OP's argument re: electric cars:
1. While battery technology will continue to improve, the main means of transporting electricity is still the power plant + electric lines, which is relatively fragile compared to oil barges/tanks on trucks + highways. You would need to destroy every oil tanker and truck in America to shut down the energy distribution system -- a much harder task than bombing every power plant -- power plants can't move.
2. With gas-powered cars (and planes, though to a lesser extent), you can keep the production running all the time making civilian vehicles. Turning all those Ford F150s and 737s into tanks and bombers is difficult, but it is way easier to do so if you don't have to build the factories FIRST.
As long as we have air wars, we'll also have demand for oil. The logistics of moving an airforce around the world require floating airfields doubling as standalone fueling stations. How efficient would solar need to be for an aircraft carrier + all of its planes to run on solar?
As long as we have wars fought on the open seas... you get the idea. Oil, as a power source, moves quite easily and this cannot be ignored, strategically.
Militaries and governments know this. As long as we have physical borders that need to be defended, we'll have a demand for oil.
I see the same dynamics playing out globally, currently. In the same way that slave-labor plantation model was essentially a hyper-localized implementation of a border control, which had automation of human labor at the root of its demise, I think we will see the modern small-to-midsize governments (e.g. Syria) that exist physically and legally within the boundaries of a nation-state also disappear, as the local capability to provide social and intellectual services (like identity mgmt, communication infrastructure, transportation) is being provided by global entities in an increasingly efficient way. Recall that America had its own migrant "problem" (and arguably still does) in the wake of the legal, socio-economic, and cultural border-control of slavery being loosened over the course of the 20th century. The question that is being answered in Europe/Asia now is whether the economic model of the nation-state that was baked at the end of WWII is inhumane enough to justify its eradication via war. Many of the tasks relegated to those governments can arguably be provided now by international entities in a far more efficient way.
I think that people will be more likely to wear the spectacles for this reason--they can actually pass for a pair of somewhat ostentatious sunglasses to an unknowing observer because of their near-symmetry, vs. Google glass, the mere shape of which screamed "BORG!"
"Have you seen the Freedom Tower? You can see it no matter where you at. They should change the name from the Freedom Tower to the ‘Never Going in There Tower' because I’m never going in there. There is no circumstance that will ever get me in that building. Are you kidding me? Does this building duck? What are they thinking? Who’s the corporate sponsor, Target? Stop it! In the same spot? What kind of arrogant, Floyd Mayweather crap is this?…They better put some mandatory [businesses] in there -- stuff you can't get out of -- like the IRS, family court, DMV…I am never going in the Freedom Tower. Hey, I got robbed on 48th and 8th about 20 years ago. I have not been back to 48th and 8th. I am never going in the Freedom Tower. I don’t care if Scarlett Johansson is butt naked on the 89th floor in a plate of ribs. I'm not going in there."
http://www.truthrevolt.org/news/snl-monologue-chris-rock-jok...
-locally distinguished -distinguished at the town/county level -distinguished at the state level -distinguished at the national level
He told us that we were not competing with each other, but rather that we were competing with "a kid from Glastonbury [CT] who drove to school in a BMW this morning".
The message was clear: if you wanted to get into an ivy, the next four years of school were to be a grand song and dance to get as many state and national level checkmarks as possible.
We were lucky to have heard his message. There were a couple thousand other kids in the school that didn't hear it. How could they know that it worked this way?
This culture, however, does not optimize for original thought.
Regarding the exam structure: (humanities + short answer questions + take-home) = increased likelihood of similar answers, given internet search.
The professor here was lazy, too--these problems could have been avoided with a comprehensive 20-page paper instead of a more-easily-graded short-answer final exam.
Now does it follow that it takes guts to have discipline or vice-versa? I think so, more in the sense that it takes discipline to have guts. Courage (guts) has a shelf life--it needs to be exercised to be maintained.
To contrast, take the typical American CEO: he or she would have taken this money, offshored it, spent another couple of years going to board meetings, and then jumped ship to another gig in some other company's c-suite. You know what I call that person? A COWARD.