HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nationcrafting

116 karma · joined November 8, 2013

Gallé Design Studio: http://www.galle.com

Nation by Design: http://www.nationbydesign.com

submissionscomments
nationcrafting··on Chile is introducing free higher education
I live in Peru, next door (give or take a few thousand miles), and completely agree with you w.r.t. Chile being very start-up and generally business-friendly, which does indeed involve government staying out of wealth creators' way, and setting up a couple of programs like Startup Chile. Setting up a new company in Chile can be done in a couple of days now, and much of it online.

Peru is following in Chile's footsteps and has had amazing growth for the last 20 years as a result of a radical reforming of government in the 90s, precisely to kill stifling bureaucracy and red tape. Where there was 50% poverty in the mid-90s, there is now about 20%. Even remote farmers are online via their smartphones, and now know what to grow, when to grow it, how to grow it, where to sell it, etc. Tech and free markets have substantially improved people's lives, to the point that anyone who visited around the year 2000 would just not recognise the place today.

It's clear to me that free markets work, and that Chile and Peru are living proof of it. Sure, it's not first world levels yet, but both countries are certainly getting there at turbo speed. Anyone who doubts this should look at the number of highly qualified migrants going not from Chile and Peru to Spain, but in the other direction: from Spain to Chile and Peru. They see it as a place of opportunity where the old and sclerotic welfare systems of Europe have let them down.

nationcrafting··on How Bitcoin Is Disrupting Argentina’s Economy
Just wondering, since you're argentinian... Since there are so many complications for argentinians wanting to buy dollars, and since the purpose is to store wealth, why don't we hear much about argentinians buy silver or gold coins (say, Krugerrands or Sovereigns) instead?

I'm living in Peru, where there were two hyperinflations in the late 80s and early 90s. The Sol has been very stable ever since, so a lot of people trust their savings in Soles accounts now, but a few people I've met from older generations have their savings in silver coins.

nationcrafting··on Investment Riches Built on Subprime Auto Loans to Poor
Errors in determining the price of money do have fatal consequences.

When interest rates jump from, say, 2% to 4%, in terms of cashflow this means a doubling of expenditure on a regular basis. If your mortgage was X per month, it'll now be 2X per month, which will immediately affect the expenses you have for other goods, such as food, utility bills, etc. If your business loan repayment was Y per month, it'll now mean 2Y per month, meaning you may not be profitable anymore and go out of business.

The mistake you're making is thinking money is a thing that exists separately from real things, a unit of account and medium of exchange.

Money is a product in itself, that enables humans to go forward and back in time (through loans and savings) in order to plan the storage and use of the wealth they've created or are yet to create. Without this function, no wealth is created but the tiniest subsistence-level kind.

So, determining its price makes all the difference between an economy that operates at subsistence-level, or one that actually functions.

nationcrafting··on Open letter to German readers: What you were never told about Greece
You make some good points. I think the solution has to be one that looks at the state as a service provider. Until the issues have been depoliticised, decisions will be made for political reasons rather than good business reasons.

As a service provider, the state has 2 sources of revenue, primarily: private customers i.e. people, and corporate customers i.e. companies. Both those customer groups pay for services in the form of taxes. Now, those customer groups must be, by and large, wealth creators for there to be any wealth that can be taxed or even redistributed (if that is your political inclination).

So, it simply won't do to just reform the state, to spend less, etc. A system has to be put in place rapidly that boosts wealth creation. This includes: minimal bureaucratic lag in the creation of new companies (Chile, for example, enables new company creation within 2 days), very low taxes, easy interaction with regulation bodies, a business-friendly environment, etc.

If the state is too sclerotic to reform, it can be set up through free-trade zones in isolated parts of the country. This was China's route, when they essentially replicated Hong Kong in Shanghai, Shengzen, and all the other FTZs. It allows to you to be ultra-reformist in small experimental areas without putting at risk the power structures that exist in the state at large.

nationcrafting··on Investment Riches Built on Subprime Auto Loans to Poor
I understand your sentiment. Really.

However, let's look at the bigger picture to see if we can spot any unintended consequences of the policy you hint at.

Interest is the price of money. Quite literally, it is the price that a person pays for buying access to a commodity called money now, rather than some time in the future. It is the price that another person is paid for selling access to their commodity called money.

What you're essentially advocating is price intervention in a market. You're essentially advocating that the supplier of this commodity should give their commodity away at a lower price than the natural price arrived at by the market.

The control of prices in just about any commodity is generally a precursor to a complete disappearance of that commodity on the market. Price controls on food are the best way to ensure food will stop being produced, leading to empty supermarket shelves, famines, riots, etc. Soviet Russia had a tight hand on prices during the 20s and 30s, which resulted in mass famines killing millions of people. A similar story is now unfolding itself in Venezuela. Whether you approve of the moral outlook or not isn't the point, it is a mistake to let a moral outlook, any moral outlook, dictate the price of a commodity.

Price isn't just what you pay for something, it is a signal to the market of the relative scarcity of that product, and the necessity for the producers in the market to make more of it. That signal is essential for efficient markets, i.e. for markets to supply what we all demand. Think of the aggregate of all prices in the markets for all commodities as the neural signals that are fired off through your brain to enable it to function. Of course, that information is spread out over millions of market participants, but it is in aggregate much more accurate than any small committee dictating prices could ever model, whether they have the right moral reasons to do so or not.

nationcrafting··on Detroit starts converting shipping containers into homes
>Is there a huge stock of abandonded shipping containers just sitting around?

There is indeed. For quite a few years, imports into the US have been much less than exports from the US, so there are more containers coming to the US with stuff than there are containers leaving with stuff. It's quite expensive to send empty containers back, so they've been piling up and recycled into other things...

nationcrafting··on French blogger fined over review's Google search placing
To anyone who finds this as infuriating as I do: take consolation in the fact that the Streisand effect will probably ensure this restaurant's bad service will now be known by an even greater public.
nationcrafting··on Dear Marc Andreessen
<blockquote>Well, we’re three decades into an era of systemic deregulation and financialization. The result? Global recession, lingering structural unemployment, and an accumulation of capital at the top of the economic pyramid.</blockquote>

To blame systemic deregulation for the recession is to be profoundly unaware of the system in question. One cannot speak of a free market when the very thing at the core of that market - i.e. money, the one thing that everyone buys when they're selling something, and that everyone sells when they're buying something - is in the hands of a monopoly, and a politically motivated one at that: its raison d'etre is not even the quality of the product it provides.

If money were edible, you would see much more clearly just what a centrally managed, soviet style style system this really is, because there'd be queues of starving citizens just as we saw back in the era of soviet resource management.

If anything, it could be argued that without the level of free market we've enjoyed, things would be much, much worse. After all, the one sector where there's been close to zero regulation, the internet, has been the sector that's enjoyed massive growth over the last few decades. Compared to the days when telephony was state managed and nothing worked, we've been progressing in seven league boots, thanks to the free market.

PS: how does one quote on HN?

nationcrafting··on Expatriate Americans Break Up With Uncle Sam to Escape Tax Rules
Read up about it, if you can find the time: the Puerto Rico situation is different than all other foreign countries for US citizens.
nationcrafting··on Soylent: It's Not People. Or Food.
Soylent and food are not mutually exclusive. Soylent replaces feed, not food.

If anything, soylent makes those times when you eat out extra special, since you get to eat out for the sake of flavour rather than to fill up your belly, and you get to spend the money you didn't spend on regular meals.

nationcrafting··on Dear Marc Andreessen
Very well put, Patrick. Funnily enough, I'm living in Peru right now (been coming here for the past 15 years) and make the same argument to anyone who challenges what free markets can do to lift a country out of poverty. Chile's results are even more impressive, given that the country is now in the top-10 freest countries in the world, and the wealthiest per capita in Latin America.
nationcrafting··on Khan Academy: The Illusion of Understanding
Exactly.

I've had this discussion many times w.r.t. global warming, and am amazed so many people, including scientists, just don't get it. The level the seas would rise is not so much dependent on floating ice (north pole) since the displacement is exactly the same, but on ice that was on top of land (e.g. Greenland, Antarctica, etc.).

nationcrafting··on Next Arab American on a stamp could be Steve Jobs
-"We've put your picture on a mail stamp. Now people will see your face everytime they send mail".

-"You mean my face will be pasted in their signature?"

nationcrafting··on Bitcoin Exchanges Under ‘Massive and Concerted Attack’
No. You can usually buy physical at spot + 1 or 2% max. In the UK, coins like Sovereigns or Britannias are capital gains tax free, so you typically pay a bit more for them, like 4 or 5% above spot. But then you won't have the headache of remembering what you bought them for when you sell them (aside from the pleasure of saving CGT-free).
nationcrafting··on How to Name a Baby
Funny, I recently had the opportunity to organise a structured brainstorm to name a friend's baby daughter. I've done this quite a bit over the years for new brands, and figured I could apply similar methods to arrive at a name they felt some connection with and that expressed their values and hopes for their daughter.

It was an interesting exercise, and a very fructiferous one. We ended up with Héloïse, naming her after Héloïse d'Argenteuil ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H%C3%A9lo%C3%AFse_d%27Argenteui... ) whose love letters with Peter Abelard are a medieval classic ( http://www.sacred-texts.com/chr/aah/index.htm ).

nationcrafting··on Tech's Gender and Race Gap Starts in High School
Why does everything have to be evaluated in terms of encouraging one gender to do X or encouraging one race to do Y? Why not just generally encourage humans to be open to learn things they may find interesting or useful?
nationcrafting··on Latvia becomes 18th state to join the eurozone
Plenty of countries have had common currencies throughout history without having a common fiscal policy (I'll assume you made a mistake when you wrote "common monetary policy", since monetary policy is the very thing you give up when you adopt a currency beyond your control). Many great empires, from the Duth republic to the British Empire, were built during periods when their government had no control over their currency.
nationcrafting··on Scientists Petition U.S. Congress for Return to the Moon
No, he hasn't done all those things. That's kind of the point here: this is about going back to the moon i.e. doing things that have already been done. The point now is to do them in such a way that you can generate wealth while doing it. So, when private companies go to the moon, they will do it better, at a fraction of the cost, and generate wealth while doing it.
nationcrafting··on Scientists Petition U.S. Congress for Return to the Moon
That's great. But w.r.t. going to the moon, the ground work has clearly been laid now. They did go there, after all. So, the task is not "getting them to do it again" but "doing it ourselves, better and at lower cost".
nationcrafting··on Scientists Petition U.S. Congress for Return to the Moon
>It's not just the money, but the entire ecosystem to support the industry.

Exactly. You could think of a project on the moon as building a platform, much in the way that the formation of the US was building a platform: creating something that allows other people to generate new wealth on top of it. The benefit to the originator companies of ownership over something like that would be enormous, without them having to do all the work.

nationcrafting··on Scientists Petition U.S. Congress for Return to the Moon
> Okay, so Apple and Microsoft and Google probably could bankroll a modern Apollo program.

You're assuming the entire cost needs to be bankrolled by a single entity or company. No such assumption needs to be made.

> There is no such monetization story for the moon.

North America was less interesting to European monarchies of the 16th and 17th centuries than South America, because they didn't think they'd find any gold there. Never mind the millions of acres of fertile land, or the opportunity to build a platform that would allow millions of people to create new wealth with the right incentives. Confusing the concepts of wealth and money, they turned down the opportunity of acquiring wealth because it didn't look like money. I think you are making a similar mistake. It's not a personal criticism per se: just like it would have been perfectly normal to assume kings and queens were right not to be interested in North America at the time, it's perfectly normal to assume big corporations would be right not to be interested in the moon today.

nationcrafting··on The Other 'F Word': Brewer Responds To Starbucks Over Beer Name
Exactly. And since brands are strengthened by a good story behind them, he'll have this story to tell. Stories of the David vs Goliath variety are always popular with brands that are built on slightly rebellious values.
nationcrafting··on Scientists Petition U.S. Congress for Return to the Moon
Seems a bit 20th century to ask Congress for money to do it, when people like Elon Musk have shown you can do pretty much anything NASA can do privately at a 10th of the cost.
nationcrafting··on I worked on the US drone program. The public should know what really goes on
Scary as current drones are, they are nothing compared to how crazy things are going to get very quickly.

Think of completely power-autonomous drones, the size of a wasp, swarming by the millions in the sky. The swarming feature alone would render most people helpless against an attack, or their sheer presence. To this, add distributed intelligence features, and networked control. The swarm becomes something akin to an intelligent, flying, all-seeing liquid.

Then think of the drop in price that will enable this to become the dominant method of surveillance, policing, and military operations. There will quickly be nothing stopping dictatorships from buying billions of them, making them ubiquitous and all-pervasive. Killing, threatening and controlling billions of people suddenly becomes quite cheap, efficient, easy and cost-effective. Don't like those people demonstrating in your city? Send the swarms.

nationcrafting··on Uber now has to wait 15 minutes before picking you up in France
Exactly. When the system allows you to create wealth, and keep enough of it to make it worth the effort, more people can afford to buy second homes in sunny places.
nationcrafting··on Ask HN: What book changed your life in 2013?
Non-fiction: Antifragile by Nassim Taleb was very good. Reminded me of Hayek's deep insight into chaotic, organic systems (e.g. human interaction systems). Also helped me to find out what direction I should take after my own book (http://www.nationbydesign.com)

Fiction: re-read Milan Kundera's Immortality and The Book of Laughter and Forgetting. Still lifetime favourites after all these years.

nationcrafting··on Uber now has to wait 15 minutes before picking you up in France
France is one of the most frustrating countries a young entrepreneur could ever work in. As soon as you find some way to bypass the rigidity of the system to create something new, to make life easier for people and actually create wealth, the octopus grows another arm to strangle you with. It just sucks the energy right out of you...

The UK may have its problems, but it's a breath of fresh air by comparison. It's no wonder 600,000 French people now live in London (and that's just the ones who registered at the embassy).

nationcrafting··on Telegram secret chat geolocation leak
>and the company actually listens to them.

So far, Telegram have been listening a lot to people pointing out errors, and fixed their errors promptly.

>for free and point it out to them? Forget about it.

It doesn't appear to be for free: aside from their bounty program, Telegram have been rewarding various troubleshooters with pretty decent ex gratia payments in bitcoin. In the article linked to this title, the first comment was from Telegram, asking the author to contact them for a reward.

nationcrafting··on Telegram secret chat geolocation leak
On the other hand, think about the benefits we get from seeing a bug in the software, and then seeing that Telegram have fixed it within the hour. Until a bug is shown and fixed, you don't even know whether it exists or not. So, you have doubt. But once it's exposed, and fixed, your attention is brought to an aspect of the software that you now know is good. The doubt is reduced. Which is a good thing.
nationcrafting··on Telegram secret chat geolocation leak
Your point about bridges and elevators actually illustrates my own point very well. Bridges and elevators may be quite safe today, but they weren't when people first started making them. Some bridges collapsed under various forms of pressure, and better bridges were designed as a result. They all necessarily made the claim to be safe until they were shown not to be.

So, yes, even bridges were built using the iterative process. It's just that the iterative process started long before you were born, and you found the world as it is without seeing the iterations that occurred before.

The same is true for doctors. There used to be all kinds of theories about how to cure the plague, or tuberculosis, or diseases we now know how to cure with a pill. Some of them worked, others didn't. Iteration at work, just over a longer timeline than your own lifetime.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →