1,879 karma · joined November 13, 2010
We build software for training providers: http://www.getadministrate.com/
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/johnjpeebles; my proof: https://keybase.io/johnjpeebles/sigs/081PMOJKYODfmtE3kcLc4TKm6geYcXLF2UcyyEELEn0 ]
But.
What happens in 5 years when Tesla is 10x bigger than it is now, and doesn't do things so perfectly or well at scale? I really wonder if this type of almost-militant napalm style PR will be handled so deftly. What happens when they get it wrong? I think there's sufficient evidence that they already kind of blew it with the journalist they went after previously, and it just seems like no good will come from this culture over time.
So I'm conflicted. I love their products. I'm rooting for the company, but I do hate these kinds of whiny posts. Tesla is better than this, I hope.
I can't count the number of times I'll be talking to some sales rep and they'll describe how they scan the data within whatever application they're demoing and "suggest" items using "big data techniques". In almost all cases they're talking about a few thousand or hundred thousand records, tops.
I've found that when non-hardcore techies talk about Big Data, what they really mean is "they have some data" vs before, when they had zero data.
From the article:
"Consultants urge the data-naive to wise up to the potential of big data. A recent report from the McKinsey Global Institute reckoned that the US healthcare system could save $300bn a year – $1,000 per American – through better integration and analysis of the data produced by everything from clinical trials to health insurance transactions to smart running shoes.
What these consultants mean is that by having just some data compared to the silo'd data that is the norm in US healthcare, they could save a lot, and they're right. My previous company had a large data set (20+ million patients) and we'd find millions of dollars of savings opportunities for every hospital we implemented in, but that's because we had the data, not because we were running some kind of non-causual correlation analysis like the article references. It was just because we could actually run queries on a data set.
-----
Off Topic - how annoying is it that when you copy & paste from the FT, they preface your copy with the following text?
High quality global journalism requires investment. Please share this article with others using the link below, do not cut & paste the article. See our Ts&Cs and Copyright Policy for more detail. Email ftsales.support@ft.com to buy additional rights. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/21a6e7d8-b479-11e3-a09a-00144feabd...
Here's a nice illustration:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Territories_of_Dynasties_i...
Yes, you can make an argument that Tibet and Xinjiang are not part of the mainstream Chinese territories, but I think it's hard to argue that other regions aren't or are recent imperialistic expansions. At what point does it cease to be "imperialistic" and start to become "the way it has been for most of history?" Compare this with almost every other empire: American, Roman, Russian (Soviet), Greek, Persian, etc - all of them expanded in a short time and collapsed (USA maybe not so much, but still lost colonies and concessions in...China! for example) in a short time, and don't today enjoy anywhere near the territory they did after their big imperial outings. Their presence today mirrors their presence before their big imperial thrust.
Today, if you visit most places in China (again, Xinjian and Tibet excluded), you're not going to find really anyone who feels the borders are out of place.
Wheras China's claims to both of those provinces has always been "to get back to the way things were" (for instance, in the Yuan dynasty), there isn't any other territory other than Mongolia for China to really claim based on history. It is unlikely that China would therefore have ambitions beyond it's current borders.
The same can't be said of Russia or the USA.
While it's convenient to portray China as just another modern (western) country with the typical aims of a modern western power, the facts don't really fit this view. For thousands of years China has been content to stay within it's nominal boundaries. Even now, most of the forays China makes that the USA or Russia feels threatened by are economic overtures (hospital ships to africa, supporting less desirable governments, etc) designed to secure raw materials and achieve economic (not imperialistic) objectives.
From Y Combinator's google profile: "Y Combinator is an American seed accelerator, started in March 2005."
From TechStars: "TechStars is a mentorship-driven startup accelerator founded by..."
There's a difference.
Most incubators in my area mainly focus on cheap rent, hotdesking, and basic infrastructure. Nothing like what you're taking issue with.
So the whole thing is confusing.
Even among people who run accelerators, incubators, and other types of programs, there is a lot of debate over where the lines begin, end, etc.
Instead of saying "incubators are bullshit" why not just saying "Doing bullshit is bullshit" since that seems to be the actual point of this post. Don't do unproductive stuff that doesn't actually advance your startup. Great. That advice is just as appropriate for outside of incubator people as those within an incubator.
For example, while reading this article I just kept getting distracted from the actual main point - many incubators just provide low cost office space. Is that bullshit? Many incubators aren't actually accelerators like the author seems to confuse the term with. Is that bullshit?
I remember reading an article from the New Yorker where they talked about making fun of wannabe authors who just sit around and do everything that authors are supposed to do except write. They called this "writering" and it seems like the author is trying to say the same thing about "startuping". Good. But that problem will always exist, regardless of whatever incubator you're in or not in.
So maybe we should focus on the actual problem instead of just blasting a straw man, hoping for clicks?
---------
Full Time Developer We're looking for a full time developer who can start on our support team dealing with bugs and smaller dev projects for the first 6 months, then move on to other things.
--------
Detailed job descriptions can be found on our about page (http://www.getadministrate.com/about), look on the lower right.
We're looking for smart people that get things done, who want to join a small company, have lots of responsibility, and work in a very challenging environment.
We're growing really quickly, have a challenging product that's mission critical for our clients, and we're located in one of the most beautiful cities in the world. We have fantastic offices at Edinburgh's CodeBase (http://www.thisiscodebase.com) with spectacular views of the castle right out of our windows!
You'll need to be eligible to work in the UK - we can't sponsor visas unfortunately. Email me if interested, my name is John: jjp@getadministrate.com
- Why does the circle make it harder to see at a glance? This doesn't seem to be true at all.
- If you can't stop someone, you're not going to be able to read the number on the badge. I don't see any reason why your employee number should be on the front. It definitely doesn't enhance security at all. People faking badges can fake numbers too.
- I'm not sure about your points re: cost or smaller employers, I mean, sure, but I can't imagine that cost would be a huge barrier - more likely changing out equipment would be.
- Badget photo backgrounds probably need to be plain, but as long as it's a photo you can be reasonably recognised from, I'm not sure what it matters. Simply by growing a beard you can become pretty hard to recognise from your badge photo from 5 years ago.
- I agree that the employment classification is probably good to have on the badge, but only because of annoying BigCo obsession about it. In practice, I'm not sure why it would matter much. When I worked at a big company it was just a political tool to remind consultants they were inferior.
http://grist.org/list/scotland-100-percent-clean-energy-2020...
Consider - an acquaintance started a western car dealership which he ran successfully for years, then sold. Flush with lots more RMB than he had invested in USD, he simply created a quality building supply exporting company which sold Chinese building supplies (like marble) in USD to US customers, while purchasing them in country with his RMB. He also built his house with these building supplies. In a year or so, all of his RMB was used up, and that was that.
This was a relatively "small business" owner compared to the kinds of tycoons we're talking about in Russia and China. Replicated this on a larger scale would be trivial, even if there were rules about it.
Already on this article (8 comments posted as I write this) we have a FUD comment saying their post is "smug" and their customers should be worried, and then another talking about how you need to "be careful" about criticising the company because their employees victimised the commenter by "down voting them in groups".
Add to this the backdrop of ridiculous comments by Zendesk founder calling them a ripoff, and just the general FUD espoused by almost everyone whenever an Indian tech company is in the picture, and it's a bit sad.
We don't use Freshdesk, although we're considering moving from Zendesk to them due to some missing features, and I'm not Indian, but I really do think it's interesting how this company is just constantly and vaguely looked down upon by people who should know better.
FD seem to be scrappy, they're growing quickly, their product looks good, they give discounts to startups, and they just happen to be based in India - what's not to like?
Even big time universities are getting into this - witness executive programs offered by many prestigious programs. On the flip side, companies like Treehouse and more exotic options like MOOCs and "learn a language as a service" style instruction are becoming formidable, low risk options.
I think the future will see a reversion to 4 year institutions serving those students who always used to go to college, a reduction in the amenities arms race that others on this thread have pointed out, and an increasingly level playing field (and better perception) of those people who didn't go to college, but do have highly valuable (and demonstrable) skills acquired through for-profit teaching avenues.
Many here will find this distasteful. That's OK. Many who are over 40 find internet dating inherently distasteful too, but that hasn't changed the perception among younger people or stopped its explosion as a real alternative to traditional dating.
Disclosure: I work for an educational technology company who serves a lot of commercial training providers but also many four year institutions.
I also reject this idea that Google's got a lock on every smart person ever. That they don't have any politics or wasted effort. That they're the snowflake they think they are. This kind of thinking is pathetically misguided, and a huge part of their marketing. Google is not perfect. They are staggeringly weak in the face of real competition (witness Facebook vs. G+ and Apple vs. Android).
Your argument is a replay of the prevailing attitude in the mid nineties regarding operating systems (from the same company, surprise!). And then some college student named Torvalds pushed out the most influential operating system ever, and did it for free, with the help of the world.
Nobody and nothing is invincible, and people who say that a situation is unassailable are always, categorically wrong, given enough time.
Also, is PR really the best, only way to do this? Seems like there are all kinds of better (more modern) signals we could use other than links, which were kind of the only game in town 10ish years ago.
Again, I'm not sure what the point here is as US States are not much different from countries in a race to the bottom, other than sooner or later you hit bottom. I mainly just found it amusing as it was a huge deal for Lenoir and now here it is on the front page of HN!
See here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Underground#Trains
Simplicity and familiarity are the bread and butter for most of these customers. They're not marketing to tech people. They're marketing to the flower shop on the corner who has a list of 1,500 people and ads 2 email addresses a week.
So, I think maybe we're in violent agreement here :)?
Lastly - the key thing about MailChimp pricing is that you move up and down on their pricing plans automatically. It's unbelievably low friction. Most of the time when you move up or down, it's because you've just imported new people and have a new email to send. So you don't care. You just get on with it and then forget about it later.
I don't even know why I'm carrying so much water for MailChimp, other than I think people are missing the point of what and who they target.
1. Mailchimp is targeted (and priced for) the small business. Most small businesses aren't going to have lists more than a few thousand, which means most of Mailchimp's customers are going to be paying less than 50ish bucks a month.
2. If you've got thousands and thousands of emails to send, and are paying multiple thousands of dollars to mailchimp each month, you're probably just going to use mandrill and hire a dev to help you out there.
3. For those customers that are spending larger amounrd (500-1000 bucks a month?), they're going to marketing managers at midsize businesses who would never get IT love and can easily justify the purchase against conversions to sales.
4. Lastly, most people who use mailchimp send more than 1 email a month, therefore, most of the commentary surrounding the pricing divided by one send a month isn't really accurate.