HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

newbusox

103 karma · joined December 1, 2011

I'm a lawyer and entrepreneur living in NYC, educated in the northeast, grew up in Florida.

john.errico@gmail.com @john_errico

submissionscomments
newbusox··on Workers should not have to die so Apple can build the iPhone 5
I feel like the outrage against Foxconn and Apple (and others) is particularly heightened by the fact that we're talking about an iPhone, as opposed to a piece of industrial machinery, or even, say, a car, the production of which is probably as or more dangerous than the production of iPhones. You’re not going to see an article that says "Workers should not have to die so Toyota can build the Toyota Camry," although that is likely an equally valid claim.

The reality is that the construction of any product, even one as aesthetically sleek as the iPhone (or consumer technology in general), is dangerous and doubtlessly comes with human costs. If we're getting upset at this, why not use this to take issue with the production of other consumer products which, doubtlessly, are made just down the road from the iPhone?

newbusox··on Ask HN: Checklist Platform for Hospitals – a good idea?
You may know this already, but I wonder if Epic Systems (http://www.epic.com/), a big healthcare tech company out of Wisconsin, has something like this as part of their bundled software for hospitals/medical professionals. If not, they may be interested in acquiring something like this.
newbusox··on Why Android isn't gaining on Apple in the Enterprise
I feel like one of the major changes in a Steve Jobs-less Apple is going to be an increased emphasis on the corporate market. This was historically one of the major differences between Apple (focused on end-users) and Microsoft (primarily focused on corporate enterprises--Paul Allen has a lot to say about this in his recent biography). To see Apple succeeding in this market is pretty exciting for them.
newbusox··on DCMA Jailbreaking Exemption Riding Into the Sunset
I know that "public comment" (like whitehouse.gov petitions or wherever) gets a lot of flack, but administrative agencies are legally required to consider your comments on pending rule changes and the like. The Copyright Office is such an entity.

From having friends work on these online implementations of commenting systems in the past, I know that useful, well thought out comments are taken seriously. So, feel free: http://www.copyright.gov/1201/comment-forms/

newbusox··on Show HN: We made a site to crowd fund lobbying.
As others have mentioned, if you don't have an attorney helping you with election law matters, I'd recommend hiring one or consulting with one. You really want to make sure you don't run afoul of election and campaign finance laws (there might be personal liability for you, if you do)--and, if you state that you do comply with these laws, you'll give people that donate a lot more faith that their money will actually be delivered to the correct groups. These laws all exist in a nebulous area which requires some time/effort to sift through.

I'm an attorney and, although I can't give you legal advice, I can try to steer you in the right direction, presuming you're not already in touch with a lawyer.

newbusox··on Petition Asks White House To Submit ACTA To The Senate For Ratification
In addition to the comments before me, it's also because the rules are not as simple as they may seem, and the rules change with practice over time. Unless you believe that the U.S. Constitution and laws are absolutely inflexible (which not even the most strict textualists/orgininalist would, I think, contend), law changes via practice and via interpretation. In the US, it's almost always been the case that the lines between treaties, executive agreements, and something called congressional-executive agreements (consent of Congress, but less than the super-majority requirement of a treaty) are blurry and ambiguous. Given that, you could either presume that whatever the Constitution doesn't explicitly forbid, it permits (in terms of executive power), or the opposite. Most presidents have presumed the former in the realm of executive agreements and treaties, meaning that, because the Constitution doesn't say that can't make these executive agreements, they've felt empowered to do so. This has been affirmed as permissible by the courts, and has happened very frequently, although that's not to say that future scenarios might arise that test the boundary between executive agreements and treaties in a way that hasn't been pushed before.

In summary: U.S. Constitutional law and the common law are very complex. It's not entirely clear that any rules are being broken, even if Obama does not ask for Senate approval. A court of law would be the proper place to resolve this, presuming the case was justiciable, which is another issue. Lawmakers themselves are no more informed than this comment or other commentators, meaning that they themselves can't provide any definitive answers.

newbusox··on RIM should get in bed with Microsoft, Nokia style
I don't have any inside knowledge, but it seems like RIM has some deep structural or managerial issues that are going to hamper any initiative they have in the near-term. Their recent quotes, as reported on in the New York Times and elsewhere today, on the appointment of their CEO, are way beyond corporate spin and into the realm of outright delusion. Markets/investors, developers, consumers appreciate honestly, but that's not at all what we're getting from RIM recently.
newbusox··on Judge: Americans can be forced to decrypt their laptops
Right, well that underlies the exact problem--things change faster that law makers and/or the jurisprudence can accommodate to.
newbusox··on Judge: Americans can be forced to decrypt their laptops
The jurisprudence in this area has to evolve. In a house, for example, the police might be able to search your house because they have a warrant, or they might be able to search your house because of any other exception to the warrant requirement. In all of those cases, police can only search for discrete things--as in, they probably couldn't turn over your bed, unless they thought someone was hiding under it, or the warrant they got suggested that they could. The "plain view" doctrine might indicate that something clearly illegal in plain view could be seized, but this is somewhat narrowly tailored.

If digital jurisprudence evolves the same way, perhaps a warrant (or discovery request) could be obtained to search within a single folder only, but not another, or the like. Perhaps there are cases out there like this already--but possibly a whole body of jurisprudence needs to evolve to deal with these issues.

newbusox··on Sen. Ron Wyden: "You can't come up with sensible Internet policy on the fly"
In my mind, an underlying problem hindering any bill that purports to enforce IP rights on the internet is the judiciary. Almost be definition, laws such as SOPA/PIPA and whatever else will be evaluated by judges, therefore changing (or, rather, more precisely defining) terms within the law. The vagueness and ambiguity within SOPA and PIPA was the big problem. But until our judges (and, frankly, lawyers) understand the ramifications that poorly reasoned decisions could have on the internet as a whole, this problem will continue, likely regardless of how tightly drafted the bill is. We have a separate bar, and mostly separate courts, for many IP law issues, so a focus should be placed on educating judges and lawyers in this realm--or maybe even creating a new court system for these issues specifically.

If our elected officials don't understand these laws, there is little hope that (often) elderly judges will be able to not only understand them, but interpret them in such a way that they effect their narrow purpose.

newbusox··on Redditor Dr. Michael Ham announces his candidacy for US senate (New Mexico)
I think that's a really interesting point and, to some extent, it's an argument that extends back to the idea of representation in a republic in general. You can either think of your representative as functioning as your agent in all matters--that is, someone to parrot your views on everything and, inasmuch as your representative votes differently than you do, that is bad; or you can think your representative as your trustee--that is, someone who you empower with the ability to make decisions on your behalf, but you may not care about, or be aware of, many issues that the representative makes decisions on. If you favor the agentic model, you probably care more about your individual desires and goals being met, whereas in the trustee model, you probably care more about the "greater good" or "national interest" and so on being met, and so care less if your individual preferences are supplanted for the greater good.

If you adopt a trusteeship model, you would argue that your elected representative can (and actually, should) make decisions based on what he or she thinks is best for the world/community as a whole, including decisions about the internet. That person would not be beholden to any "special interests" (as in, whatever people in the constituency might care about like roads or etc.) but would be beholden to whatever he or she thought most important--so, presuming you elected someone with whom you agreed generally, and who implicitly adopted this way of thinking about their role in government, you would probably be "fairly" represented. If you adopt an agentic model, then likely the interests that are most important to the majority of people who elected that official will get priority. Since you may have nothing in common with those people except that you live in the same area, you would probably argue that you’re not being fairly represented, since those people likely do not represent your views.

newbusox··on Apple Isn’t The Only Disruptor: How Amazon Is Killing Publishers
I don't know if publishing companies (or even book sellers, like Borders) have attempted this in the past, but this article (and the article it links to) lays out a pretty fair case for predatory pricing (sometimes referred to as "dumping") which is when a business attempts to root out competitors by selling below cost and then (hypothetically), when its competitors are out of the market, raises the price above competitive levels. This is generally illegal under the Sherman Act (antitrust law) in the United States (and likely in other countries, too), although, unfortunately, it is quite difficult to succeed on these sorts of claims in the US, most notably because, while a company is engaging in predatory pricing, consumers are better off since they are paying less (and a fair number of economists don’t believe that predatory pricing is rational or even possible to work for various reasons).

Still, there are remedies for companies that engage in this behavior--maybe they'll come too late to save small publishers in this case, but they exist.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2