HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nhstanley

488 karma · joined August 19, 2014

submissionscomments
nhstanley··on Man saves wife’s sight by 3D printing her brain tumor
> It really is no wonder that the softer sciences have a reproducibility problem.

Even Further, I think it's also indicative of medicine being full of people that have a fatalistic, passive attitude towards their patients and medical care. Medicine and health is really hard, and so many health professionals essentially believe that the only thing they can do is wait until something horrible happens before doing anything. And as the case with this woman, when something bad does happen, they bin it in their per-organized mental filing cabinet and you're fucked if they're wrong. Much like police officers, I think many get so jaded by the job that they can't be bothered to give a shit when they really should. And I really hope technology will save us from this.

nhstanley··on What Is Aging? Most Scientists Still Get It Wrong
> Basically, calorie restriction works, and nothing else does

We don't even know that for sure. There were two big studies in rhesus monkeys which disagreed on that.[1] Evidence from mice, where this idea originated, is dubious at best considering the mice most studies use.

[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/02/science/a-new-salvo-in-deb...

nhstanley··on Schwab password policies and two factor authentication
This has been a problem for years that they refuse to fix. The legacy password thing (Strike one) is bullshit, they could just force everyone to update their passwords when they implement a properly designed system.

I would be even more disheartened if customer complaints and an article in Ars can't get this fixed, but someone "passing it on to a contact" could. It's disgusting that this is how they've handled it. I minimize how much money I keep with them and will be closing the account when I get back to the States.

nhstanley··on Special K, a Hallucinogen, Raises Hopes and Concerns as Treatment for Depression
While it's certainly very true that there are people who just want to ruin everyone else's fun out of spite, this situation is more complicated because there really are problems with uncontrolled administration of drugs, even ones we have studied for other purposes. There a many reasons why people in the article are stressing the need for trials.

Even if we just stick to ketamine, there are many questions. First, is this better than the current standard of care? Is it better in the short term, long term, or both? How much better? Should we discontinue drugs like SSRIs altogether? Are people dying (committing suicide, in this case) because this is a fringe treatment and not the standard of care?

Second, while we clearly already use it as an anesthetic, we don't know what the effects or dangers might be for this kind of use. Is repeated administration (as seems necessary) a health problem? Are side effects like hallucinations just temporary, or is the brain altered in some way permanently? There are drugs that, the longer and more frequently you take them, the more likely you are to have actual permanent problems (some antipsychotics, for example).

Doing any kind of controlled study with humans is inherently difficult, and in some cases impossible (this is why we know so little about nutrition). But not doing controlled studies and carefully assessing the value of a treatment can be just as catastrophic as ignoring something that seems to work. And you can't go with your gut on these things, or we end up with antivaxers and dead people when we should have just done the study(s) the right way from the start.

nhstanley··on Butterfly Player – Open-source music player for Windows
Perhaps they just meant, "Compared to the other ones you're probably using"? Because I know iTunes is legitimately starting to give me problems, despite my Mac only being a few years old. Naturally, Apple is trying to cram a ton of crap into iTunes, when all I want is to be able to play music and make some playlists. I would gladly switch if there was something fast and with as low a barrier to entry.
nhstanley··on The Next Chapter
It looks like we have some trolls in here. Not very good ones.
nhstanley··on Twitter's debt assigned 'junk' status
Yea, I know it's a really tired subject, but twitter really needs a major overhaul from a usability perspective. I think they should keep the 140 characters as a limit for what is shown in peoples feeds, but the character limit should be much higher. This is particularly important when you get into a conversation with many people, and the handles start taking up most of your 140 characters (as Marc Andreessen recently pointed out). It's also really hard to follow conversations, and they get separated somewhat arbitrarily. You might scoff and say that this would basically facebook-ize twitter, but honestly I don't think that's a bad thing. Facebook is moving into twitter's space, so twitter shouldn't be be so slow to act or it will get eaten, IMHO.

Also, I use twitter to keep up to date on some of the industries I'm interested in, and while it's a great tool it's still frustrating sometimes, since there is a flood of info throughout the day. TweetDeck makes it better since I can group things by interest and triage depending on how much time I have. I guess you can do that with the web interface but I have never found it as natural as with Tweetdeck.

nhstanley··on UAB cures diabetes in lab mice, preparing for human trial
It's also important to point out that Type I only makes up about 5% of diabetes cases. Though a cure for either would drastically improve a lot of peoples lives.
nhstanley··on The mystery of the disappearing Silk Road murder charges
> ...non-addictive...

I agree with your general point, but SR was being used for all kinds of things including selling Cocaine and Heroin (and also for not selling drugs but services). Those are very addictive drugs by almost any definition. Fine if you want to argue they are less harmful than, say, alcohol, but they are definitely addictive. Do not allow your point to be weakened by stating something that is clearly incorrect.

nhstanley··on Doctors Tell All, and It’s Bad
It would be interesting to know how many people are injured. It's unfortunate that "killed" is the threshold (in at least part since it is easy cutoff to define), when in reality we should be just as worried about permanent or long-term damage caused by bad decisions as well.
nhstanley··on Microsoft’s Quantum Mechanics
It seems clear that quantum computing would help with QM calculations (which I think you were mainly talking about), but it is less clear to me if it would help with things like MD (and perhaps it wouldn't matter if QM could be sped up enough).

Could quantum computing help with MD or other kinds of simulations (e.g. monte carlo) where we are essentially searching for a minima? I have heard that quantum annealing, which some argue the first QC system are really doing, would work on this. But it's all too confusing. It seems like half of what I read about quantum computing would say "Yes!" to that, and half is saying "you don't understand".

nhstanley··on FBI and Secret Service Files: Aaron Swartz
Yea, unsealed or released would be better words (depending on the situation).
nhstanley··on To Get More Out of Science, Show the Rejected Research
I think that would be a great step. Science would be greatly advanced if there was more focus on whether a good question was asked and whether the experiments were well chosen, than whether the experiments gave positive/negative results.
nhstanley··on TXT Record XSS
Thanks for explaining. I know HN is traditionally programmer/programming focused, but some of us come from other areas and only have limited experience with such topics. It's very common for me to enter a thread about a security vulnerability, for example, and think "wait, how big of a deal is this?"
nhstanley··on After Long Delays, Breakthrough Nanopore Sequencer Finally in Labs
Here is a critique of this system by an expert: http://omicsomics.blogspot.com.es/2014/09/reanalysis-lays-ba...

It's a great achievement and I'm hopeful, but the accuracy needs to go up before it competes with current standard.

nhstanley··on Google's Calico Moves into Reality
In the event that the permalink page isn't loading properly (his blog has been having problems lately), it looks like you can click to the main blog page and read it: http://pipeline.corante.com/
nhstanley··on How Memorizing “$19.05” Can Help You Outsmart the MTA
Wait, how long has it been like this? Haven't lived in NY for a few years but they used to give you a nice round number bonus. This is the crappy kind of thing businesses do that governments should specifically not do nor need to do (trick you with dark patterns, force you to give a no interest loan/gift, etc.). And I should point out it's regressive. That $1.95 matters a lot to some people. Incredibly shitty, IMO.
nhstanley··on Nearly All U.S. Home Depot Stores Hit By Credit Card Theft
An important point to note is that, if banks want/care, they can put other safeguards that solve this problem, too. In Europe it is common for banks to text you a 6 number pin to confirm an online transaction, for example. There is no good reason to not do these things. It's still not perfect, but certainly much better.
nhstanley··on Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
Yup. In a truly free market, murder is totally fine. Kill your competition, literally! There's a reason we don't live in Randian fantasy worlds.
nhstanley··on Why doctors are sick of their profession
> but come on they save lives.

I'm going to say something controversial here, but please bear with me. Your statement sort of encompasses several parts of this problem.

Some doctors are miracle workers (see [1] below), but most doctors are glorified auto mechanics. I don't say that to downplay the amount of intelligence/skill required for the job, but if you think of most doctors as "saving lives", then you obviously haven't spent a lot of time around doctors/clinics/hospitals.

Most doctors rarely save lives, and often when they do it wasn't them that really did the critical life saving steps, they're just the interface the sick person is interacting with. Most doctors deal with a series of inputs (symptoms and circumstances) and output a solution (diagnosis and remedy), which requires very little critical thinking on their part. Sick kids with the flu. Idiots that took too many drugs that need fluids, benzos, cypro, or an ice bath. People at mid-life who made shitty decisions for most of their lives and now need Lipitor/Coumadin/a treadmill/a gravestone.

The truth is most doctors get paid a lot because people erroneously assign to them the ethos of miracle workers, when most of them aren't. In fact, they often can't even do anything for their patients (see above, such kids with the flu, old people who've made shitty decisions their whole lives). The cures really come from researchers and pharma companies that come up with drugs and treatments for these incredibly difficult problems. If doctors deserve their paychecks, it's because they keep alive the illusion society wants. The illusion that when something is wrong, the doc will fix them up good. And indeed that's basically what the article is about. Doctors demand respect and to be paid to keep up the illusion and to deal with the bullshit.

[1] Obvious and important exceptions to this are ER docs and trauma surgeons, who indeed save lives. There are also clinical doctors, who work tirelessly with armies of researchers to try to find new cures for cancers, autoimmune and genetic disorders (among many other things). There are surgeons who come up with new procedures to reduce the invasiveness and trauma of procedures. These are the people that deserve the lion's share of the praise that goes towards doctors, and they should get the lions share of the money as well (some certainly do).

In this whole rant, I'm not trying to lay blame on doctors for the whole mess, because problems come from all sides, as I've hinted. Patients have unrealistic expectations of what doctors can do, the health industry is trying to low-ball doctors (not always without reason) to maximize profits, and many doctors who thought they would be genuinely helping people are realizing in reality that fate is largely decided before they even meet their patient (as a criminal lawyer friend put it, "90% of my client's case is decided before I ever meet him, but he wants me to work miracles!").

This is specifically why I didn't continue into medicine like so many of my friends. If you really want to help people, you don't become a regular doctor. You become a thoracic surgeon, or you do basic research, or you work in pharma, or you start a biotech. That's how you cure people. But no one will praise you for it.

nhstanley··on Keurig competitors crack company's DRM code
Rent seeking. This is one of the things that in my businesses I try to avoid because it is basically should be a last ditch, hail-mary pass. Which is what this DRM probably is for Keurig.

Ideally, you should always focus on being better than your competitors, which is difficult--but not impossible--in commodity products. Good examples are Dropbox or Starbucks. Cloud storage space or coffee are obviously not new or hard to deliver products, but it's how you deliver them that makes all the difference. I think this is a loosing battle for Keurig, and they should focus on providing some additional value (or perceived value, which can be just as good) to their customers. Maybe that's genuinely better tasting coffee, or maybe it's a slight (but acceptable) premium over generics (people like and trust brands).

nhstanley··on How Google Works
For those not old enough to remember, (I believe) this is the Google-Yahoo deal referenced: http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2066171/Yahoo-Partners-...
nhstanley··on Pulling the Curtain on Airport Security [pdf]
Fifty pages filled out means it is now someone else's job to read those pages and implement. His hands are clean.
nhstanley··on Pulling the Curtain on Airport Security [pdf]
Do you know they were stolen from by the TSA, or by baggage handlers? Getting rid of the TSA wouldn't solve the latter problem.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2