HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nknighthb

4,726 karma · joined April 5, 2013

submissionscomments
nknighthb··on Amazon Home Services
> For starters. "To your door" urban drone delivery would be nearly impossible as most urban dwellers live in condos, apartments

Many such structures in densely-populated areas have large, flat, mostly-empty roofs. (Hell, some of the apartment buildings in my little urban area of ~40k people have flat roofs, as do most of the local dorms.)

nknighthb··on Amazon Home Services
So, anyone not targeting every nation on earth must not use GTLDs?
nknighthb··on A court case so secret, US Govt says it can't go on
No, I don't want the government to get involved. I hold the (probably far more radical position than you) that government is not entitled to secrets at all, and that all government employees should be live-streaming their activities to the public Internet at all times while on duty.

I was presenting an alternative on the assumption the government would anyway.

nknighthb··on Amazon Home Services
Last week, Amazon's VP of global public policy testified before the Senate Commerce Committee[0] about the FAA's delays in approving testing in the US that they've already begun in other countries. An FAA administrator testified in the same hearing. This comes more than a year after Amazon's initial announcement on December 1, 2013.[1]

This is the same VP, by the way, that testified before the same committee in January on net neutrality.[2]

Are you suggesting he's lying to Congress?

Last year, Amazon hired for their Prime Air team, among other high-profile individuals, a former NASA astronaut, a Keyhole co-founder, and a mess of aerospace vets and MIT grads.[3]

Argue all you want about its viability, but this is not "a press release" or "april fool's joke".

[0] http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/mar/24/amazon-con...

[1] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/amazon-unveils-futuristic-plan-d...

[2] http://recode.net/2015/01/21/congress-still-bickering-over-n...

[3] http://techcrunch.com/2014/08/20/despite-faa-setbacks-amazon...

nknighthb··on A court case so secret, US Govt says it can't go on
> So the government can somehow hack into the NYTimes editing process and put a retraction of some earlier claim into the newspaper, all without the NYTimes staff cooperating?

Can you come up with a concrete example of how such a court order might come about in a case that the government is intervening in in this manner?

> Similarly, if A is constantly harassing B, B should just shut up and take the money the government pays him in compensation, along with the harassment that isn't being stopped?

See above.

> Are you sure that is the outcome you are advocating for?

It's difficult to know, since these seem to have no relationship to any hypothetical case I can come up with.

nknighthb··on Amazon Home Services
Amazon.com is their US site. If you're there, you've effectively walked into a store in Seattle. If you want a store not tailored to the US market, you'll need to visit one of the sites they've made for other countries (where this is probably not available yet).
nknighthb··on A court case so secret, US Govt says it can't go on
The government can either take the action itself if it makes sense, or compensate B for its costs.
nknighthb··on Amazon Home Services
> Remember the "drone delivery"? (It makes no sense on the face of it, and will never happen. But it was a big press release.)

You mean the drone delivery they're actively testing in the UK? The drone delivery they're fighting with the FAA about? The drone delivery they just testified before Congress about?

They're spending an awful lot of time, money, and political capital on something that makes no sense, will never happen, and was just a press release.

nknighthb··on A standard for building APIs in JSON
Five years ago, much of my team's time was being consumed fighting with the WSDL and SOAP specs, and their various subtly incompatible or outright broken implementations on our target platforms.

A switch to JSON-RPC 2.0 meant everyone now understood the entirety of the specifications our APIs relied on, and if we couldn't find a good implementation for our target, we could either fix one, or write one ourselves in just a few hours.

The productivity gain was effectively infinite.

I look at the JSON API specification in all its architecture astronaut glory, and weep.

nknighthb··on Super Mario 64 HD
> What is a game if not an expression of an idea?

A set of rules. Such rules are potentially eligible for patent protection. They are not eligible for copyright protection.

> On one hand you can say that games are not protected. Tetris however is. And has successfully been defended us such in court.

I suggest you read the actual text of the Mino decision, which rests heavily on visual elements, not gameplay. I also suggest you not put too much stock in the decision of a single district court judge. District court decisions are not binding precedent. Especially ones obviously written by a judge who either doesn't understand what the functional elements of a game are, or was looking for an excuse to find for Tetris.

> The layout and configuration of levels is not an idea.

Those would be assets.

nknighthb··on Super Mario 64 HD
http://www.copyright.gov/fls/fl108.html

This is long settled in US law. Things like art and text are copyrightable. The game itself is not.

nknighthb··on The Shut-In Economy
Median garbage collector income in the US is close to median personal income, and they don't even get out of the truck on most stops anymore. They're also widely unionized with substantial benefits.

I haven't bothered having anyone cut my hair in years, but yeah, people working at SuperCuts make crap, in much the same way and for the same reason that people working at McDonalds make crap.

nknighthb··on The I-JSON Message Format
POSIX specifies that there are 86400 seconds in a day. POSIX is not making claims about reality, it is specifying its own reality. That's what standards do.

ECMA-262 isn't really relevant at all, since it's not the (or even an) authority on JSON. JSON was simply derived from it -- in an incompatible way at that. It's doubly irrelevant since you were talking about Unix, so that's what I was addressing.

By the way, your phrasing is odd/confusing. You're talking about "epochs" in a strange way. In Unix/POSIX land, there is one epoch, "The time zero hours, zero minutes, zero seconds, on January 1, 1970 Coordinated Universal Time (UTC).". Unix timestamps are derived from the epoch, they do not define it.

nknighthb··on Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit
> If you change your mind and want to learn anything else, my door is always open.

I can't imagine what could lead you to think I'd be interested in "learning" from someone who clearly doesn't even understand what my claims/opinions are, but insists they're "ignorant" and "trolling".

What you've accomplished here is not to teach, but to harden my existing biases.

nknighthb··on Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit
> You did though. You claimed the terms were meaningless.

Just to be sure I didn't comment in my sleep, I went back and looked, and I see the word "meaningless" nowhere in my comments.

> But if you study, you find out they they have very specific meanings.

Some people have defined them in very specific ways. The description in the originally linked article is actually one of the ones I hate the least. That doesn't make it good, and doesn't make the terms useful.

> Calling C pointers "references" is just the tip of the misunderstanding iceberg.

What, precisely, will it take to convince you that I understand your position and simply disagree with it?

> But if you prefer to wander around in ignorance

Please stop being insulting.

nknighthb··on The I-JSON Message Format
They're really not competing at this point. 7159 is the one spec to rule them all. ECMA-404 (which was kind of silly to start with[0]) isn't really relevant to most developers anymore.

ECMA-262 even explicitly uses 7159's predecessor (4627) with two exceptions[1], one of which is the top-level compatibility headache 7159 fixed, and the other just requires the API to disregard the "MAY" in section 4.

[0] https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/201x/2014/03/05/RFC7159-J...

[1] http://www.ecma-international.org/ecma-262/5.1/#sec-15.12

nknighthb··on Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit
> If you google "pass-by-value" vs "pass-by-reference" and understand what they mean, in a language-agnostic way, and you understand what Java is doing when you pass parameters, then you too will come to the same conclusion and I have, and the people who wrote the wikipedia article, and everyone else.

What conclusion would that be, exactly?

> your claim that pass-by-reference is meaningless

I didn't make that claim.

> and is also what Java does

I didn't make that claim, either. Nor would I ever. Stop putting words in my mouth.

nknighthb··on Stripe Connect v2
There's a pricing link at the top of the page right where it belongs...
nknighthb··on Stripe Connect v2
I'm on a late-2013 rMBP running Yosemite. The page looks nice and animates smoothly in both Chrome and Safari. There may be some deeper problem on your system.
nknighthb··on Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit
> sometimes you have to read and comprehend

If you don't understand how you're being insulting here, I can't help you.

> The JLS does define exactly what happens when parameters are passed...

Yes, it's very nice in that respect.

> And that happens to match the definition of pass-by-value/call-by-value exactly (even Java is listed as an example language for pass-by-value)

It happens to match the definition of "call-by-value" used by whoever wrote that blurb on Wikipedia you seem to love so much. The irony here, of course, is that people who like to use these terms don't even agree on how they're spelled...

None of this makes the terms useful.

nknighthb··on The I-JSON Message Format
POSIX specifies the Epoch to be UTC and has since at least 2001. People may have other opinions on how it should be specified, but if you're going to follow POSIX as it exists, you're not left with a choice in the matter.

http://pubs.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/009695399/basedefs/xbd_...

nknighthb··on Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit
> Most people agree on the meaning (read the JSL - it says Java is pass-by-value.

I assume you mean the JLS, in which case it -- very wisely -- does not use the term "pass-by-value" (or any similar term I've seen) to label its semantics. It simply describes its semantics.

> Read Wikipedia too. Or really any other real reference that isn't some confused people in a forum.)

So is it "most people" or a reference that, if anything, supports my point (JLS), an un-encyclopedia, and unspecified "real references" that aren't from people you enjoy insulting?

> That's what the article does.

That's one thing the article does, yes. Why is it you think you need to point that out?

> People in these forums who still don't get it need something more. That's what I'm giving them.

I agree you are giving people in this forum "something more". I suspect we disagree as to what that "something" is.

nknighthb··on Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit
> Reference is a long-established term, and using it to refer to C pointers is typically considered incorrect.

I am not confused, I disagree.

> In addition, pass-by-reference and pass-by-value are very useful terms for anyone interested in accurately speaking about and understanding what will happen when they run the program they write.

The terms would be useful if people agreed on their meaning (they do not) and if languages actually followed one way or the other consistently (they do not). That is the very reason this thread exists.

If you wish to accurately speak about what will happen, then speak about it. Describe what actually happens, instead of spending your time arguing about which round hole the square peg fits in better.

> There are people who consider accuracy and understanding to be pedantry.

In practice, pass-by-value and pass-by-reference provide neither accuracy nor understanding. Stop using them, and these arguments instantly vanish.

> More often than not, in my experience, they are a larger source of bugs than those who strive to truly understand how their tools work.

That I strive to truly understand how my tools work is the very reason I reject these terms as worthless.

nknighthb··on Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit
I'm not confused at all, thank you. I'm of the long-standing and well-informed opinion that "pass-by-reference" and "pass-by-value" are worthless terms that need to die, and that this entire conversation is an exercise in useless academic pedantry.
nknighthb··on Java is Pass-by-Value, Dammit
A pointer in C is a reference (see ISO 9899:1999 § 6.2.5) under siege by nasal demons (see § 6.3.2.3). The implementation isn't really required to do many of the things people assume it is.

(It's ironic, by the way, that in seeking to be more pedantic, you reference stacks. Stacks are not part of C.)

nknighthb··on A demo that Magic Leap was going to show at TED
OK, that's right. I'm still not convinced anyone can say that this must be faked. None of this is impossible with current tech, just not likely in a wearable/battery-powered device.

Edit: Actually, no, I don't think it's right. Modern chroma keying could probably handle this.

nknighthb··on A demo that Magic Leap was going to show at TED
The gun is a physical object.
nknighthb··on A demo that Magic Leap was going to show at TED
I must have missed the perfect hand tracking. Could you share where it was? All I saw was rather exaggerated movements to make things work.
nknighthb··on A demo that Magic Leap was going to show at TED
I'm not clear what's so surprising to you. AR has been progressing rapidly. This looks like the next iteration. It's not some giant leap from what we've seen before, or even what's in millions of consumers' hands right now.
nknighthb··on Where's the Generic Insulin?
Your resumé says you live in a state that expanded medicaid. Eligibility is now entirely income-based, NOT asset-based. If your current income is below the cutoff, you qualify for medicaid, period, end of story.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →