HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nknighthb

4,726 karma · joined April 5, 2013

submissionscomments
nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
5 seconds is beyond the tolerance point for most consumers. 3 seconds is getting into annoyance territory. You're mostly OK below 2.

Your argument is now circular. 90% of the US is fine because they have at least 4mbps, which is fine because 90% of the US has it. That doesn't work. In fact, I can turn it right around on you, as Wheeler recently did -- "When 80 percent of Americans can access 25-3, that's a standard.".

You have cinemaphiles exactly backwards. They are more tolerant of delays and long downloads than ordinary consumers, because they understand and expect that they will have to put up with such for maximum quality. Ordinary consumers want something that works like a TV channel or a website.

Raising the threshold for internet service to be classified as an advanced telecommunication capability is not a "federal rescue", it's the FCC doing what it's mandated by 47 USC § 1302[0] to do -- report on the availability of advanced communications capability, defined as "high-speed, switched, broadband telecommunications capability that enables users to originate and receive high-quality voice, data, graphics, and video telecommunications using any technology.".

You should also read the actual report[1], where they discuss exactly why the new level was chosen. Hint: They recognize households consist of more than one person.

[0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/47/1302

[1] http://transition.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2015...

nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
You are fortunate to live somewhere with high-quality DSL, and not have anyone else using your connection. These things do not hold true for the majority of people. I expect you're also tolerating much longer startup times than most consumers tolerate.

Vudu is not providing meaningful HD. The way you get 2.25mbps "HD" is by providing a 720p or 1080p stream of very low quality. 2.25mbps is not capable of providing even close to HD quality without going to h.265, which is not currently practical.

Your premise was that 4mbps was "plenty" for HD. To now speak of SD is simply admitting that you are wrong, and 4mbps is not meaningfully broadband.

I also have T-Mobile LTE. It's almost useless without putting the phone in the window, has massive latency spikes, and can't maintain high speeds for long without dropping out completely. It is of no practical use in replacing the connection I do actual work on.

nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
Under the hood, consumer fixed wireless is usually just wifi gear, but running on licensed frequencies and attached to big outdoor antennas.

If you're very, very lucky, the hardware might have been manufactured to run optimally on those frequencies, or it might just be a WAP in a different box running tweaked software.

This has the generally-crappy results you would expect.

Business gear is substantially more robust and expensive.

nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
I've personally had three fixed wireless installations over the past decade. Two residential, one business. I've researched the option in numerous additional cases for both business and residential service.

Both business and consumer services are typically more expensive by 10-100% and have installation (particularly LOS) requirements many -- if not most, in topographically unfavorable areas -- cannot meet. While the business services are usually OK once installed, consumer services are particularly unstable and the equipment prone to early death.

Notably, the wireless ISPs I'm familiar with ended up either shut down or moving to a different line of primary business as soon as any sort of viable wired service made it into town.

While far better than relying on mobile data if you don't have other options, it's still definitely not a substitute, even for DSL.

nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
> 4Mbps is already plenty for HD movies and video teleconferencing

The last six years of my life have been consumed by work on video streaming services. While in a lab environment you would be correct, I can tell you that in the real world you are off by a factor of about 4, and will be off by a factor of about 8 for 4k video.

> Most places in the US had zero 4Mbps options 20 years ago, and now they have 5+.

I have no idea where you got that idea, unless you think wireless is a substitute for cable or DSL. It's not.

nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
By making it public infrastructure.

Remember, if not for an accident of history (cable and telephone services running over completely different kinds of wires), it wouldn't be a duopoly, it would be an outright natural monopoly -- a prime candidate for treatment as a public utility.

nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
They would be better served long-term by overall growth in internet traffic. But large corporations beholden to the stock market don't want to have to explain to Wall Street that earnings are going to tank next quarter after some of their most lucrative customers went elsewhere in retaliation for their political stance.
nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
"Broadcast" and "hook up a server" are in no way similar under the relevant laws and regulations.

Radio broadcast is licensed because of the general problem of limited spectrum. The Internet's point-to-point nature has no such problem.

Meanwhile, the FCC already regulates all electrical devices -- including servers, your PC, and even light bulbs -- to prevent interference.

So, bad news, your fear came true -- in 1934.

nknighthb··on FCC Passes Strict Net Neutrality Regulations on 3-2 Vote
Congressional testimony is not the same thing as transparency. In my experience, it's just the opposite.
nknighthb··on Docker Image Insecurity
So you're a bitter ex-employee who comes to HN only to anonymously sling mud? That sounds about right.
nknighthb··on Docker Image Insecurity
Linux is not a counterexample. The only reason it looks different is that the primary gatekeeper and a few key developers are paid jointly and circuitously by the sponsoring companies.
nknighthb··on Docker Image Insecurity
> you remind me of the CEO of Linode

Hmm... You've just increased my respect for Solomon.

> He is equally infallible and ignores criticism.

As a long-time Linode customer, I know this to be absolutely false.

Was it your intent to so thoroughly discredit yourself?

nknighthb··on Apple EFI Firmware Security Vulnerabilities
> the same as saying employees who pick up abandoned USB thumbdrives on parking lots and plug them into work computers are guilty

This has been true for as long as USB has existed. The broader version -- "don't attach untrusted hardware" -- has been true for as long as there have been computers.

There is a reason secure installations do not allow employees to bring in arbitrary electronics.

nknighthb··on “I am not authorizing you to release a Ruby port of Metaphone 3”
What's rude is granting a license and then trying to take it back after people have relied on it.
nknighthb··on Multiple vulnerabilities released in NTP
I really have no interest in this. You're being incredibly defensive and looking for reasons to argue with someone you don't fundamentally disagree with about trivial crap. For someone who professes to be so busy, that's very strange.
nknighthb··on Multiple vulnerabilities released in NTP
You're defending a lot of stuff I didn't attack. Almost everything you're doing sounds good to me, and I have no idea why you would think otherwise.

The only point I made was that 100,000 lines is not staggering for all of the functionality ntpd encompasses, which goes way beyond just "query and steer".

I didn't say a typical NTP client should be 100,000 lines. 10,000 lines sounds far, far too large to me, in fact, for the 80-90% case.

nknighthb··on Multiple vulnerabilities released in NTP
I don't think I am, and you haven't given me any reason to believe I am.

Why don't you list some of those "extras" and "nice to haves"? Some of them are probably absolutely critical to my services. All of them are probably critical to somebody's.

I don't think you're understanding that I'm not in any way disputing that we need something orders of magnitude smaller for the most common case of a simple desktop or server keeping an approximately accurate clock.

If your response to me talks about just steering a clock, you are not responding to me.

nknighthb··on Multiple vulnerabilities released in NTP
100,000 lines of C is certainly unnecessary for the most common usage of ntpd, but it is far from staggering considering ntpd's full scope as a portable client, server, and peer-to-peer node attempting high precision synchronization on heterogeneous hardware across the globe.

It doesn't just "query a remote server and steer your clock", and "steer your clock" is a lot more complicated than it sounds when you're trying to achieve such precision.

nknighthb··on An experimental, automatically generated set of AWS clients in Go
Really? Code generation tools shouldn't mention the language they generate code for?

(Put another way, you might want to take a moment to understand what the tool is before you use it as an excuse to complain about Go.)

nknighthb··on Hacker News metrics (first rough approach)
Yeah, not interested in engaging with someone like you.
nknighthb··on Hacker News metrics (first rough approach)
> There's nothing wrong in making it clear that the code itself does not target social issues.

I agree, and I suppose if you choose to read my comment completely free of the context of the rest of the thread, my attitude might not make sense. But when you realize he had also said to 'somehow' that he "thought that was the main point of the article?", it's obvious he was missing the forest for the trees.

nknighthb··on Hacker News metrics (first rough approach)
I seriously have no idea what you're talking about. If you'd like to point out something specific you think I've misunderstood, I'm listening. If you just want to engage in content-free sarcasm, I'm uninterested.
nknighthb··on Tim Cook Speaks Up
If my opinions and actions don't stand the test of time, and I'm still alive when they don't, I'll repudiate them.

Eich had his chance. He declined and ran away instead.

nknighthb··on Tim Cook Speaks Up
People keep claiming Mozilla employees weren't hostile to him, and wanted him to stay. You can't have it both ways. Which is it?
nknighthb··on Hacker News metrics (first rough approach)
... Wow.

Does it help if we change the word "algorithm" to "system"?

Stories entering the HN system on certain subjects are more likely to be penalized by that system. Humans are an integral part of HN. HN would neither function nor exist without them. You cannot simply ignore them and pronounce the system unbiased.

Does that make more sense to you?

This is really surprising to me. I usually disagree with you on, well, everything, but you have not previously seemed like someone who suffers from this particular technologist disease of utterly missing the big picture because someone used a word that you define narrowly in a broader way.

nknighthb··on Hacker News metrics (first rough approach)
You said:

"The Hacker News ranking algorithm does not penalize stories that address social issues."

And then explained the observed effects as being from flags and vote ring detection.

People flag stories that address social issues, thus, the ranking algorithm is penalizing stories that address social issues. That (the collective) you did not specifically intend this makes a nice case study in unintended consequences and/or the collision of technology and humanity, but doesn't change the point being made.

nknighthb··on Hacker News metrics (first rough approach)
This is insanely disingenuous. User flags and the voting ring detector are part of HN's ranking algorithm, whether they're labeled as such in the code or not.
nknighthb··on The new archive.org
While I, sadly, am not at all surprised to hear that yet another group of developers treats security and user experience flippantly. I'm rather starting to regret defending you and lending resources to the twitpic grab.
nknighthb··on Redis latency spikes and the 99th percentile
Actually duplicating the memory contents would be slower still, I'm sure. What seems to be going on here is simply a consequence of paravirtualization needing to implement certain functions in software that would otherwise be taken care of in hardware when using HVM or bare metal.
nknighthb··on Redis latency spikes and the 99th percentile
It's important to remember two things: First, in a more general way, fork() is kind of slow just by virtue of being a system call and involving several steps, so applications try to avoid making lots of calls to fork (e.g. webservers long ago stopped doing the naïve fork-for-every-request model).

Redis uses fork in a way nobody else seems to. Applications using tens of gigabytes of RAM -- databases, media editing, etc. -- just don't usually fork except during a startup process.

Redis uses fork for persistence. It's clever, and it works great in general, but it's weird! Unique, even. It seems much more likely to hit a fork() weakness in a noticeable way than almost any other application out there.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →