716 karma · joined June 6, 2010
kudos for the raw ambition though.
Godel, Escher, Bach: an Eternal Golden Braid - Douglas Hofstadter
Imagined Communities - Benedict Anderson
Historical Capitalism - Immanuel Wallerstein
Young Man Luther - Erik Erikson
For example, it is discouraging to log in to HN and see that your karma has fallen since your last visit. Using your formula, this would be a very regular occurrence for all but the most active users. Discouraged users are less likely to continue attempting to engage and many would eventually give up their attempts to maintain a decent karma. Then, while your measure may be "more accurate" in some sense, it would easily be less effective for goals that have more to do with engagement & participation than with notional accuracy.
Not trying to poo-poo the spirit of your post though, because as someone without much of a math background, this type of discussion is very enlightening. Just trying to clarify that inaccuracy may very well be a feature, not a bug.
While the idea of decoupling representation from geography is an interesting one and it may seem appealing, in practice I would not be surprised at all to see this result in a rapid deterioration in the quality of representation for areas in which representatives do not live and a corresponding rise in legislative effectiveness for the areas housing the representatives.
Following this line of assumptions a little further, it's easy to understand why Congress is divided into components where representation is based on different geographical scales.
There are plenty of other ways to become involved and have an influence, however small. Not liking the choices is not a good excuse for not participating.
(source:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_third_party_and_i...)
In this day and age, when I join a new network I want it to be easy to find my existing "friends" on said network. SC2 nailed this - I was playing with friends within minutes of my first login. Ping, on the other hand... I saw a couple updates from friends and a lot of more-or-less fluff from Yo-Yo Ma. OH! and the spam. Sweet monkey jesus there was a lot of spam the first week. Not exactly a compelling social experience.
Zynga didn't just make another farm game, they used their familiarity with FB's viral channels to make it the biggest silly little farm game on the platform. Then they turned around and used that audience as a springboard for a number of other games that, while derivative, were simply the strongest distillations of their respective types.
I get it, everyone loves to hate Zynga, but the fact is that they are really good at what they do, and lots of people out there enjoy their games.
In my own experience, it's also the only FB games company that most laypeople (people who neither work in tech/social games nor play Facebook games) recognize.
It's hard to say whether they'll ever achieve the stature or reputation of a Blizzard, but I can't even think of many traditional game companies that enjoy the same type and intensity of customer loyalty that Blizzard does. Maybe Valve? Very few people buy every EA title but the Madden franchise has incredible loyalty... where does something like that fit into a comparison like this?
not saying I'm retiring my gmail account, just that there are plenty of ways that it might make sense for certain cases, despite some folks' knee-jerk inclination to distrust this one particular company.
While I'm sure that a beginner class would still have plenty of value for me, I find that most beginner resources spend a lot of time on stuff that I'm already comfortable with, and it's a pain to dig through to the part where they start covering the topics I'm trying to learn atm. I don't suppose this is a helpful suggestion for your current idea, but what would be most valuable to me is some kind of mentor who could help me figure out what topics/ideas/practices to learn next, where to find the right intermediate-level resources, etc.