HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

noblethrasher

2,892 karma · joined March 14, 2007

https://github.com/noblethrasher

http://stackoverflow.com/users/3927/rodrick-chapman

rodrick@rodlogic.com

submissionscomments
noblethrasher··on The Unparalleled Genius of John von Neumann
Citing Kathy Sierra’s book, Badass (pp 91–92)

> Evidence has been mounting for decades that for most non-sport domains and for most people,“natural talent” is not an absolute requirement for reaching high levels of expertise.

> Other than the sports that depend on specific physical prerequisites, few domains have hard genetic limits for expertise.There is a way in which natural ability might contribute to high expertise in non-athletic domains, but it’s not domain-specific “natural” gifts... it’s a natural ability for focused practice.

…

> Even at the very top levels in most non-sport domains, there’s little evidence that “natural talent” is a hard requirement. But where it might exist, it’s most likely to show up at the beginning of the curve and the very very very top.

noblethrasher··on Differentiable Programming Manifesto
He also gave nice presentation on AD: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ne99laPUxN4 (surprised that you didn't already mention it, considering the venue ;-))
noblethrasher··on Ask HN: Self taught programmer, now wanting to learn more about CS theory
I get what you mean, but it’s worth remembering that TLA+ is a language that is designed foremost for thinking about CS stuff, and at the end of the day, it’s “just” an improved notation for mathematics (particularly the kind of math that’s relevant for describing systems). In fact, Lamport didn’t even believe it was possible for TLA+ to practically run on a computer when he invented it (someone else did TLC).

So, here are a few reasons that recommend learning TLA+:

* If you already know how to program, you can learn it pretty quickly; almost certainly in less than a month. Just use TLC as a highly responsive yet infinitely patient teaching assistant.

* Once you learn TLA+, you’ll not only find it easier to think about systems and algorithms, but you’ll also have more opportunities to practice since you just need pencil and paper. I find myself doodling in TLA+. I'll even go so far as to say that TLA+ has a Tetris Effect[1].

* This is probably true of most esoteric technologies, but since TLA+ is pretty obscure, the community is still in that sweet spot that is the intersection of smart and friendly. Lamport answers questions in the mailing list.

* Just my opinion, but TLA+ (or something very much like it) is part of the future of CS pedagogy.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetris_effect

noblethrasher··on Announcing .NET Jupyter Notebooks
Actually, C# had a REPL even before Roslyn: The Mono project shipped one about 4 years prior.
noblethrasher··on I tried to adjust the time on my alarm clock
I've complained about this before [1], but I once bought a $70 (USD) Microsoft Arc Mouse that required you to both register an MS account and download an app just to be able to turn off the obnoxious synthetic clicking sound that was enabled by default.

I made a second trip to the store that day just to return the the thing.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11390494

noblethrasher··on The Machine Stops (1909) [pdf]
Jaron Lanier often recommends the story in his talks on the dangers of social media.
noblethrasher··on IT Runs on Java 8
.NET Value types do inherit from System.Object.

See: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/api/system.valuetype...

noblethrasher··on Joe the office mate
E.g. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/event/lampsonfest/
noblethrasher··on Joe Armstrong has died
Not at all hard to believe that he was sincere. He seemed to be pretty starstruck when he was interviewing Alan Kay on stage just three years ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhOHn9TClXY.
noblethrasher··on Interface Dispatch (2018)
C# prefers `@class`
noblethrasher··on Languages I want to write
I'd argue that it's not a syntax error simply because the whole point of Scratch is to make programming accessible an audience (small children) for whom the kinesthetic and iconic mentalities are dominant. Syntax belongs to the symbolic mentality, which they haven't developed yet.

Even in the case of other visual programming languages that are targeted towards adult professionals, the point of such tools is to suppress the symbolic mentality because the iconic and kinesthetic might be better for getting the job done.

noblethrasher··on Filing Your Taxes Is an Expensive Time Sink. That’s Not an Accident
Rent lets you live in a house; taxes let you live in a civilization.
noblethrasher··on Why Wolfram Tech Isn’t Open Source
> or possibly Google, but they wouldn't ratify MS's platforms by investing resources in maintaining a fork.

While they're not maintaining a fork, it's worth noting that the head of the ECMA C# standards committee is, in fact, a prominent Google employee.

noblethrasher··on Alternative Periodic Tables
Information Design: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_design.
noblethrasher··on Morgan Freeman Converts His 124-Acre Ranch into a Giant Bee Sanctuary
In a healthy economic structure, most of the power would be in the middle class (i.e. the distribution of economic power is a bell curve). If we had that instead of the current power law distribution, then tax incentives would work simply because they would directly reflect with will of the people: The fat part of the curve -- representing the average -- would be able to out-vote and out-spend everyone else.

Trying to control the behavior of giants that are smarter and stronger is probably hopeless, so our focus should be on getting the economy back to normal (pardon the pun).

noblethrasher··on Object-Oriented FizzBuzz
I did a Smalltalk-style OO FizzBuzz in C# a while back: https://gist.github.com/noblethrasher/539f71d60b4768ca514aeb...
noblethrasher··on Erlang OTP 21.3
Yes, I knew that you were referring to the lambda calculus y-c.

I've edited my original comment to make the pun more apparent.

noblethrasher··on Erlang OTP 21.3
> I hated that in order to do a loop in a lambda, you had to implement a y-combinator, but they fixed that.

Heh, I see what you did there.

noblethrasher··on Elizabeth Warren Proposes Breaking Up Tech Giants Like Amazon
Conversely, if you didn't build the Internet, you don't get to break it.
noblethrasher··on Kurt Gödel's Letter to John von Neumann (1956) [pdf]
I'm pretty sure 'theaeolist meant that, since von Neumann died young (53 actually), that he never had the chance to even reach an "advanced age" where you might expect the fear of death to have lessened.
noblethrasher··on Kurt Gödel's Letter to John von Neumann (1956) [pdf]
> It is well documented that, after Von Neumann learned of his terminal pancreatic cancer...

Bone cancer, actually.

noblethrasher··on 80 Characters per Line Is a Standard Worth Sticking to Even Today
C# offers a way to mitigate that, somewhat.

I often have something like this among the top level `using` statements.

    using FooMemo = System.Collections.Immutable.ImmutableSortedDictionary<string, Foo>;
noblethrasher··on C# 8: Switch expressions
Well, to be clear, I was being tongue-in-cheek when calling it "envy".

I just mean that C# looks messy from the point-of-view of an ML-wannabe, but pretty elegant as an aspiring Lisp. And I say this as someone that is fluent in F# and prefers functional programming in the style of ML rather than that of Lisp.

noblethrasher··on C# 8: Switch expressions
For some time, I've thought that the direction of C#'s evolution makes a lot of sense if you look at as the designers' effort to cope with Haskell envy (pattern matching, type inference (which is really just class inference), and monad comprehensions).

But, it makes almost complete sense if you instead look at it as coping with Lisp envy. I'm still amazed that they managed to sneak in function literals and FEXPRs (Linq), a metaobject system (dynamic + DLR), a limited form of call/cc (aysnc/await), first-class metaprogramming (Roslyn -- albeit more in the style of Smalltalk rather than Lisp), and a REPL.

noblethrasher··on Java’s Forgotten Forebear (2009)
Gosling created PostScript? That's… news to me.

(NeWS was an implementation/extension of PostScript, but PS was invented by an entirely different group of people).

noblethrasher··on You can't impress developers. So don't try
More context: https://zedshaw.com/2018/03/25/the-billionaires-vs-brandonm/
noblethrasher··on Tesla Faces Criminal Probe Over Whether It Misstated Production Figures
> and there is also a limit to the number of shareholders before you are required to go public.

You're never forced to go public, but you will be required to disclose financial data to the public if you have more than 1,999 individual shareholders and assets with a value that is greater than or equal to 10 million dollars.

noblethrasher··on Naming and Synchronization in a Decentralized Computer System (1979) [pdf]
Dave Reed (author of the linked paper) also gave a fantastic presentation on the End-to-End Arguments a few years ago: https://www.usenix.org/conference/usenixsecurity10/end-end-a....
noblethrasher··on WebAssembly’s post-MVP future
At one time people thought that you couldn't possibly have a high performance runtime that supported both object-oriented and functional patterns vis-à-vis garbage collection, yet the CLR managed to pull it off with some clever use of ML (pun intended)[1].

[1] https://youtu.be/ZTbyKsw7uIU?t=684

noblethrasher··on Paul Buchheit on Joining Google, How to Become a Great Engineer, and Happiness
Dan Ingalls

Ivan Sutherland

L. Peter Deutsch

← PreviousPage 2 of 32Next →