There's no putting the genie back into the bottle.
906 karma · joined January 16, 2018
There's no putting the genie back into the bottle.
That's an irrelevant theory. There are very few fabs capable of making adequate asics.
>if this ever happens there is no recourse as the supply of coins to stake is finite.
It's much easier to fork rather than fight state-affiliated miners.
This is a really bigoted comment that generalizes a whole state. If it would be racist for any random country, eg. 'Mexico' or 'Nigeria', why is it ok for an American state?
(no, I'm not from Alabama).
Energy use is so large mining at any non-negligible scale anonymously is impossible. Any serious miner will have to open a company, move to a special facility and get a special energy connection. Mining only makes financial sense in few countries with cheapest energy. Last but not least, due to the difficulty mechanism mining for anyone but enormous miners requires pooling with others.
Pools are public entities that are yet another possible layer of control by regulation. Adding all that and the conclusion is that PoW has zero resistance to regulations. China could take over bitcoin, but they decided to throw away mining instead, only making it possible for America to do so in turn.
All it takes is indirect or direct control over >50% of hashrate to censor anything. It's not possible to create a fork without censoring miners, because any minority fork can be trivially attacked in an adversary situation. If any PoW network even becomes important for American government to try to censor it there's no defense.
To stake in ethereum, you need to buy eth, which can be trivially bought anonymously from anyone that owns eth, most likely fully online without any physical contact. A more permissionless system isn't possible. There's no physical trail, both from ordering asics and from energy use. All that's needed is an internet connection. Staking can be easily fully anonymous and can happen anywhere in the world. That's why PoS is the only way to have a decentralized network.
It's always possible to fork with any arbitrary subset of validators, whether for censorship reasons or other disagreements.
PoW is objectively worse than PoS in literally everything but as a method to distribute coins. Mining is a way to sell coins for energy and hardware cost, which is an advantage at the cost of being worse in everything else, but only in the early period.
so they pump eth price to infinity to get majority of stake? While in theory it could work, it would cost at least hundreds of billions of dollars. Compared to maybe $1B-$2B to take over PoW from nothing. Two orders of magnitude difference.
As nobody needs a blockchain with censorship everyone else would move to a fork without the governmental stake. A very foolish plan.
In practice, us government would pass a regulation that forces miners to register and to censor sanctioned addresses. Once they realize that miners they control own majority of hashrate, they can add a requirement to ignore chains with sanctioned addresses (from others miners).
There's no defense against this, because unlike PoS, you can't really move anywhere else. China has its own ban. Energy prices in europe are insane. Russia is sanctioned and just getting chips in is almost certainly a crime.
Under PoS as long as there's any subset of non-censoring validators a fork away from censorship is possible. Unlike mining, staking is extremely mobile globally.
It's impossible to mine anonymously with any non-negligible hashrate due to power differences and required specialized hardware - all trivial to track.
Taking over PoS is much harder because there's no way for governments to print tokens. It's easy to stake anonymously. A closed stable state in which only non-censoring validators control the network is always possible to achieve.
Banning discord in general is of course less damaging, but the reasoning is similarly incorrect. It's an enormous platform for chats about virtually everything.
A general ban on discord is going to socially harm any kid in the west.
Ten years later: why is my kid such a loner?
Discord is the main persistent group chat service in the west (telegram seems popular in the third world except for China). It's used for virtually everything. Socially it's almost equivalent to cutting your kids from any online chat.
Honestly, I would consider a total ban a mild form of child abuse.
If DRM ever gets good enough to block piracy (imagine displays themselves using ml to recognize what are you watching and if you are allowed to) streaming will become worse than cable ever was.
how would that be different from tornado? There's no legal difference between a contract with a balance and an internal utxo tree, and a blockchain with a total balance and an internal utxo tree.
Kidding aside, I think this is actually good. Humans need ephemerality. We are never getting the full version of it back, but with photorealistic ai video and image creation some freedom returns. I think without it a society in which everyone has a camera all the time would mean absolute ossification of social norms. Right now it's very, very new - I mean multiple generations living with the current, or better (eg. recording eye implants) technology.
The future is going to be much more extreme. I expect euthanasia to become the leading cause of death by far. Imagine being 70, slightly disabled and alone today, with mental capacity severely diminished. It's too late for any realistic chance of antiaging. There's no rational reason to continue living at that point. Suicide seems unthinkable now - but if it was culturally accepted millions of old people would do so each year. Rich people may as well choose suicide by cryogenics - that one definitely should be an option.
Irresponsible people losing money on ponzis is sometimes sad - but also definitely deserved.
Maybe you live in a stable and developed country. Nice. Those people don't and it's extremely hard for them to open a banking account elsewhere. What they can do is save in usdt or usdc on ethereum. It's empirically much, much safer than holding dollars in a Lebanese bank.
Ethereum is switching to PoS at the last minute, PoW miners are very easily forced to enforce sanctions because they can't hide due to enormous physical and legal presence. Home stakers can easily hide and break the law.
Average person is dumber each year because high iq is negatively correlated with fertility. On top of that populations are collapsing due to below replacement tfr. There's a real danger that technical civilization collapses later this century. The problem is that all easily accessible fossil fuel sources are already used up, so restarting much later from eg. a late xix century level is borderline impossible - civilization will run out of wood fast and progress stops due to an energy deficit. Advanced semiconductor manufacturing beyond proof of concept requires scale unattainable by such a civilization.
In short, the falling intelligence trend coupled with running out of easily accessible energy means that most likely, either humanity escapes biological-planetary constraints this century, or becomes stuck in a low-tech hairless ape local maxima until the inevitable extinction. A very good candidate for the Great Filter.
Fossil fuels only exist in the first place because for millions of years no organism on Earth was capable of digesting lignin. As trees died they just became buried, eventually transforming into coal and oil. That process stopped the moment fungi evolved the ability to digest lignin. This means that there's not going to be another chance even in millions of years, whether for human descendants or some other intelligent species (racoons seem like a good candidate). Easily accessible fossil fuel energy is a one time event per planet.
There's less than 100 years to escape the trap and it requires sci-fi level tech, either advanced genetic modification of humans or superhuman level ai.
>In fact, if we follow this logic, less smart people should be unhappier, since they are in an even worse position to do something
Worrying about something requires realizing it's a problem first.
Many people eventually give up thinking about things too much and give up to various forms of hedonism, but that's not real happiness. When it happens after 40s it's called a 'mid life crisis', I don't think it has a name when it happens earlier, but fundamentally it's the same thing.
Real happiness would require advanced transhumanism or even more (ie. uploading) - without it, we are all trapped only being able to imagine perfection.
https://github.com/MetaMask/metamask-extension/commits/devel...
>But because everyone knows that is a natural consequence of POS, it is exactly why no reasonable person would be on board with a transition to it.
You described mining - public companies operating big industrial warehouses with miners. PoS is the opposite - it needs next to zero physical resources. No reasonable person can support PoW unless they support totalitarianism. There's no way to make PoW resistant to government interference.
No, it shows the exact opposite - that mixers are legal and the government has to utilize a completely arbitrary executive power to ban particular mixers.
What's important is to keep that potential open, of course.