HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nordsieck

7,199 karma · joined July 31, 2011

submissionscomments
nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
> The only issue I see is that cellphone battery life is terrible compared to inReach like devices. Not sure I'd want to depend on it for longer than a few hours.

I think it depends on the application you're using it for.

If you're constantly using the gps - yeah, I'd definitely agree with you.

But if you're using it purely for emergency communication, you can just turn off the cell phone, and it should be fine.

It's also possible to pursue a hybrid approach by bringing a battery to change the phone.

nordsieck··on Starlink Direct to Cell
> It will happen over time

I'm optimistic.

I think that, once SpaceX starts launch Starlink satellites with Starship, they'll be able to increase their globally available bandwidth by a factor of 5-10x (although it might take 5 years to roll out). A lot of that bandwidth will be eaten up by existing demand. But hopefully some of it will enable novel services like global cell service through a single provider (even if it's limited to low bandwidth applications like text and voice).

nordsieck··on Weight-loss drug found to shrink heart muscle in mice, human cells
> FFM isn’t entirely muscle, but what other weight would be shed when losing FFM other than muscle?

I'm not an expert, but I have to imagine that most of it is muscle.

After dramatic weight loss, a person will probably lose some bone - particularly in the lower body - due to decreased loading.

I know body builders sometimes eat extremely high protein diets (more than 1 g/lbs of body weight) and lift quite hard to try to hang on to as much muscle mass as possible. And they still lose some when cutting.

nordsieck··on El Capitan: New supercomputer is the fastest
> It's because of the way the weapons are designed, which requires a CNWDI clearance to know, so your curiosity is not likely to be sated.

While that's true, the information that is online is surprisingly detailed.

For example, this series "Nuclear 101: How Nuclear Bombs Work"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zVhQOhxb1Mc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnW7DxsJth0

nordsieck··on Constraints in Go
>> Go is not object-oriented language

> That is most definitely not true.

I think at best, you could say that Go is a multi-paradigm language.

It's possible to write Go in an object oriented style.

It's also possible to write programs with no methods at all (although you'd probably have to call methods from the standard library).

That's in contrast to a language like Java or Ruby where it's actually impossible to avoid creating objects.

nordsieck··on M4 Mac mini's efficiency
I have an m1 as well.

And while I'm broadly satisfied with its performance, I do think that the SSD is probably carrying some of that load. And for a machine that often gets used far longer than a PC, I can't see that being great for longevity.

nordsieck··on Google's TOS doesn't eliminate a user's Fourth Amendment rights, judge rules [pdf]
> “Mens rea” is a key component of most crimes. Some crimes can only be committed if the perpetrator knows they are doing something wrong. For example, fraud or libel.

We're talking about orthogonal issues.

Mens rea applies to whether the person performs the act on purpose. Not whether they were aware that the act was illegal.

Let's use fraud as an example since you brought it up.

If I bought an item from someone and used counterfeit money on purpose, that would be fraud. Even if I truly believed that doing so was legal. But it wouldn't be fraud if I didn't know that the money was counterfeit.

nordsieck··on Google’s TOS doesn’t eliminate a user’s Fourth Amendment rights, judge rules [pdf]
> the good faith exception to the exclusionary rule supports denial of Maher’s suppression motion because, at the time authorities opened his uploaded file, they had a good faith basis to believe that no warrant was required

This "good faith exception" is so absurd I struggle to believe that it's real.

Ordinary citizens are expected to understand and scrupulously abide by all of the law, but it's enough for law enforcement to believe that what they're doing is legal even if it isn't?

What that is is a punch line from a Chapelle bit[1], not a reasonable part of the justice system.

---

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WlmScgbdws

nordsieck··on Gross Apple Marketing
> What does the Ubuntu ad say to the user? How does it capture someone’s attention?

Exactly. Contrary to the article, it doesn't tell a story at all. It's just some slick-ish graphics with a few words overlayed on top. They're nice words. But they didn't really embrace "show, don't tell".

nordsieck··on H5N1 virus isolated from infected dairy worker is 100% lethal in ferrets
From the article:

> Ferrets are a common model for studying how influenza viruses that primarily affect birds are able to adapt to mammals, a topic that Kawaoka and his colleagues at UW–Madison’s Influenza Research Institute investigate since such a jump could trigger an influenza pandemic.

nordsieck··on New Mac Mini with M4
> You'll be able to sell your M4 mac mini in 5 years for $150 for an instant-cash offer from backmarket or any other reseller

If you want to put in a bit of elbow grease, you can get a much better deal. M1 Mac Minis in my area are regularly selling for $350+ on FB Marketplace right now.

nordsieck··on New Mac Mini with M4
I have lots of USB-A devices, so I get what you're saying. But converters are pretty cheap and seem reliable.

And Apple has a long history of making this change ahead of the rest of the market. It's been years since they've move to all USB-C in their laptops, so IMO, it was only a matter of time.

And yeah - upgrades are awful price wise. From what I can tell, it's basically only worth it to buy base models unless the machine is making you money. Hopefully they upgrade the Mac Studio to M4 down the line.

nordsieck··on New Mac Mini with M4
There are a number of companies that specialize in making hubs/NVMe enclosures that match the aesthetics of the Mac Mini and sit directly underneath it.

For example: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08S47KBMC/

nordsieck··on New Mac Mini with M4
Honestly, I wish they'd go with an external USB-C power brick.

The only reason they might not is that they want to keep everything across the entire line, and the highest end Mac Studio probably needs more power than USB can offer.

nordsieck··on New Mac Mini with M4
> No mention of the SSD size

The base model is 256 gb. You can see it here:

https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/mac-mini

nordsieck··on New Mac Mini with M4
The new model is looking really good.

* Kept HDMI

* New, much smaller form factor

* Front facing USB-C

* Base model has 16 gb of ram

nordsieck··on Crossing the USA by Train
Exactly.

Most of the times I've driven across the US, I was either moving, or transporting a vehicle.

nordsieck··on Crossing the USA by Train
> Amtrak is more comfortable in every way.

I can easily believe that trains are more spacious and the seating is more insulated from odors.

But my experience riding trains is that they sway/shake obnoxiously while going around curves. Where as busses like Megabus are a very smooth ride the entire way.

> room to walk around and stretch your legs

My experience with busses is that there are somewhat frequent stops where people are encouraged to walk and use the bathroom. Which isn't a complete fix, but it does serve to substantially mitigate those problems.

nordsieck··on Plastic chemical phthalate causes DNA breakage, chromosome defects, study finds
> But if you had to put one of them inside your body, it's quite possible the gamma ray emitter would be the safer option, simply because more of its energy would escape harmlessly.

That's definitely the case with Polonium-210. Even though it emits alpha particles, it's very dangerous to ingest.

nordsieck··on Ozempic linked to lower Alzheimer's risk in people with Type 2 diabetes
> With the constant stream of positive news around GLP-1s, and ever-growing list of things they treat, we may all wind up on some dose with only the dose varying depending on what illness they're targeting.

So far, I haven't seen much evidence that GLP-1s have a positive effect on people who aren't overweight. And while I'll be the first to admit that the proportion of people who could benefit from these drugs is quite large, it's pretty far from everyone.

nordsieck··on World-First Starlink Service on Boeing 777 Launched by Qatar Airways
> I'm confused by that move - why make it free when they could easily charge their captive audience for it?

My understanding is that it's actually a condition of using Starlink for commercial aviation. Every other airline that's announcing a partnership with Starlink is also providing it for free to customers.

IMO, it's a way for Starlink to put pressure on other satellite internet providers. The utilization of free wifi will be way higher than paid wifi. And the other networks - be it OneWeb, Viasat, Hughesnet, etc. don't have as much available bandwidth.

nordsieck··on Math is still catching up to the genius of Ramanujan
> It's weird to say that about English when good communication is essential for success in any engineering field

Some of what's taught in English classes is about clear communication, and some of it isn't.

I think learning the 5 paragraph essay structure was very useful. But that's maybe 3 months worth of learning. The rest was English major stuff. Which is fine, but please don't pretend that it has a lot to do with "good communication".

> Even if all English does is force you to read more, it's probably a win in this regard.

It's not enough to say people had to read for English classes. You have to compare it to the counterfactual. In that regard, I don't think it stood up well.

1. I was already reading a lot. I just read different things.

2. I came to hate pretty much everything I read in class. It's only decades later that I've been able to appreciate some of the classics that we read.

On this point, I think English class was a net harm, at least for me. Of course, everyone has different circumstances; I'm sure there are people for whom a similar program as what I went through would have been a benefit.

nordsieck··on Math is still catching up to the genius of Ramanujan
IMO, you're thinking about this backwards.

It's good that public school exposes children to many subjects - hopefully most of them. So that they can discover if they click with one of them. The real danger is that someone never gets exposed to a subject at all. College is the place to specialize in a subject.

nordsieck··on Can SpaceX land a rocket with 1/2 cm accuracy?
This is more or less easy to see depending on the video you watch. Here's a good one that demonstrates it very clearly.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ExV6PHRM8eI

nordsieck··on Intelsat 33e breaks up in geostationary orbit
> Who is going to pay the day SpaceX has a "whoops" ?

Ironically, SpaceX is probably one of the least bad companies in that regard.

1. They launch satellites to a very low LEO orbit. The satellites use their onboard thrusters to get to their final orbits. This means that satellites that malfunction early in their life (the first lip of the bathtub[1]) deorbit in a matter of months. And they're so low, they don't affect anyone else.

2. And even Starlink satellites that do fail are at such a low orbital height that they'll spontaneously deorbit in 5-10 years.

---

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bathtub_curve

nordsieck··on Intelsat 33e breaks up in geostationary orbit
Looks like WGS-10 is the closest.

From Wikipedia, it looks like it's a USSF satellite launched in 2019 with a service life of 14 years. It provides wideband communications to DoD customers.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USA-291

nordsieck··on Intelsat 33e breaks up in geostationary orbit
> Not to mention debris can be in GEO for a long, long time.

On human timescales, it's basically forever. Hopefully we'll develop the tech to clean up debris in space, but it's extra challenging to do it in geostationary orbit since it's so far away from Earth, both in terms of actual distance, and delta-V.

> People worry about LEO constellations causing Kessler syndrome, but the reality is that LEO debris deorbits in the order of months/years.

It's a little more complicated than that. The time to spontaneously deorbit is based on orbital height. Starlink can deorbit on its own in 5-10 years because it's orbiting so low. But any OneWeb satellites that malfunction[1] will take 1000+ years to deorbit because they're up at 1000+ km.

---

1. Like this one

https://spacenews.com/oneweb-mulls-debris-removal-service-fo...

nordsieck··on Intelsat 33e breaks up in geostationary orbit
It is particularly bad for a satellite in geostationary orbit to break up or fail. Satellites are packed as tightly as possible into that orbit due to its economic importance (it's very useful for a satellite, particularly communications satellites, to always be over the same part of the Earth), so there is a higher than normal likelihood that this could be seriously disruptive.
nordsieck··on Traveling with Apple Vision Pro
> My brother in god, you can travel from any point of the Earth to any other point on the Earth in less than a week. At what point are modern people going to “deal with it”?

Clearly people do "deal with it" since lots of people fly all the time. But that doesn't mean that the experience can't be improved.

nordsieck··on Traveling with Apple Vision Pro
> Do planes have access to Starlink now?

There's a number of airlines that have signed contracts, like United. I think it'll take a while for everything to be completely rolled out.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →