HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nostrebored

2,711 karma · joined March 20, 2015

Opinions discussed here are my own.
submissionscomments
nostrebored··on Was my $48K GPU server worth it?
$6500 AUD can get you a good chunk of B200 time on any of the GPU neoclouds :)
nostrebored··on Waymo updates 3,800 robotaxis after they 'drive into standing water'
Right, but humans are terrible at the happy path. I’d take 20% safer on the happy path over 40% less safe in unforeseen circumstances. The failure mode being “stopped car” is also not that bad.
nostrebored··on AI is making me dumb
Hypothetical future callers, "for extensibility" abstractions, single-use helpers, ceremonial try/except blocks, and options dicts with one key all get culled.

—

But this is never the problem. Claude WILL NOT abstract and WILL NOT use your abstractions. It finds them all “ceremonial” and the idea that you could add something that might seem indirect that actually dramatically reduces the problem space is almost impossible to convey.

You can watch this in action for any API whose design you’re familiar with in a domain you understand well. If you attempt to design the same API with Claude, your will invariably get a mess of flat, insane types and no reuse. I’m talking an array of tuples of maps of set to map type insanity.

What has been helping is a mandatory pass of “Claudisms”, but even then it can only find the problem and never the solution.

It is so frustrating.

nostrebored··on I returned to AWS and was reminded why I left
GCP has similar offerings to Lightsail, Fargate, EC2, Lambda, or other compute substrates. Nobody is forcing you to use more than “basic” offerings. AWS core services are often architected that way!
nostrebored··on I returned to AWS and was reminded why I left
Egress costs have substantially reduced (thankfully)
nostrebored··on I returned to AWS and was reminded why I left
How many real applications actually want this behavior? AWS is not built around hobbyist needs. It’s built around being a platform to run most shapes of production use cases.
nostrebored··on A recent experience with ChatGPT 5.5 Pro
Noted, doesn’t seem like I’m able to edit anymore though
nostrebored··on A recent experience with ChatGPT 5.5 Pro
No, the anthropic releases have felt marginally negative
nostrebored··on A recent experience with ChatGPT 5.5 Pro
2024-2025 was filled with huge improvements. 2025-2026 has not been, outside of open source.

The idea that we’re at the point where it’s superseded our ability to tell just makes no sense. I’ll be happy if we can get to a point where I don’t have to tell Claude not to tail every bash command or make a job that writes throughout instead of once at the end. I’ll be happy if “continue this interaction naturally, you are taking over from an independent subagent” works.

But I’m not holding my breath. It’s still really cool that any of this stuff is possible.

nostrebored··on A recent experience with ChatGPT 5.5 Pro
Hmm, I don’t know, maybe the fact that 4.6, 4.7, 5.3, 5.4, 5.5, 3.0, 3.1 are all marginal improvements?
nostrebored··on OpenAI’s o1 correctly diagnosed 67% of ER patients vs. 50-55% by triage doctors
I don’t know if you’ve just never had bad healthcare, but this story does not seem unbelievable to me.

I’ve had doctors try to convince me not to pursue medical care, that problems of people close to me were not real and purely psychological, and I’ve personally required emergency surgery due to inaction. In every case there were obvious signs and symptoms.

Doctors are not good at their jobs. In the US, we’ve done a particularly stupid combination of forcing them to incur legal liability and intermediating everything with insurance, both of which impact the care people actually receive.

nostrebored··on AI uses less water than the public thinks
wouldn't it be great if we hadn't actively sabotaged grid capacity and development at every turn
nostrebored··on DeepSeek v4
I think most hardcore people I know are still sticking with 4.5 for coding workflows
nostrebored··on San Diego rents declined following surge in supply
This is an obviously farcical belief.

If everywhere built more housing do you think the price of housing would go up? Where are these people bringing up housing prices coming from?

nostrebored··on San Diego rents declined following surge in supply
This is empirically not supported. Relaxing zoning rules works extremely well.

Look at Japan, look at any metropolitan U.S. city that has actually leaned into it. Europe has had mixed use zones for effectively centuries and is not the dystopia that NIMBYs proclaim will appear in the absence of zoning.

It is unpopular because we subsidize the lives and assets of people who “have things” through zoning policy that they make.

nostrebored··on The quiet disappearance of the free-range childhood
It is in SF. My son’s school would not let him walk 3 minutes to an aftercare program. They were actually willing to break federal law to stop him from walking a single block away.

I also let him play at the park on his own occasionally. I will get calls from well meaning but extremely overprotective friends to let me know that “they can’t watch him anymore.” He is ten! The library, connected to the park, has a phone which he can use to reach us.

People called my parents hover parents, but at ten I could have played at the neighborhood park by myself.

nostrebored··on I still prefer MCP over skills
This is obviously not what it is. If I give you APIGW would you be able to implement an MCP server with full functionality without a large amount of middleware?
nostrebored··on I still prefer MCP over skills
But if you have customer facing APIs then all of these problems were already solved in an enterprise context. You can force an oauth flow from skills if you want.

I don’t think that CLIs are the path forward either, but you certainly don’t have to teach a model how to use them. We’ve made internal CLIs that adhere to no best practices and expose limited docs. Models since 4o have used them with no issue.

The amount of terminal bench data is just much higher and more predictable in rl environments. Getting a non thinking model to use an MCP server, even hosted products, is an exercise in frustration compared to exposing a cli.

A lot of our work is over voice, and I’ve found zero MCPs that I haven’t immediately wanted to wrap in a tool. I’ve actually had zero MCPs perform at all (most recently last week with a dwh MCP and opus 4.6, where even the easiest queries did not work at all).

nostrebored··on I still prefer MCP over skills
Skills can bundle scripts. Skills can express how to use curl. Skills can integrate with your fips keys if you want them to.
nostrebored··on I still prefer MCP over skills
> Also, MCP is better for restricted environments because you know exactly what it can or cannot do.

The continuous exploits of MCP despite limited adoption really makes this seem wrong.

nostrebored··on I still prefer MCP over skills
What about remote MCPs lend themselves to security? For instance, do you think that it is more secure than a traditional endpoint?
nostrebored··on I still prefer MCP over skills
Why are they not calling APIs directly with strictly defined inputs and outputs like every other internal application?

The story for MCP just makes no sense, especially in an enterprise.

nostrebored··on EFF is leaving X
This is entirely framing.

To most people “I want to deport minorities” would imply nothing about citizenship status.

Someone with the opposite opinion would frame it as “open borders”, which is an extremist viewpoint globally and also not what people on the left in the US are advocating for.

Media coverage in the US is partisan. This is not an insightful viewpoint or nearly as incendiary as you’re making it out to be.

nostrebored··on US and Iran agree to provisional ceasefire
Iran has been funding and arming groups which threaten maritime security for a while now. They also have been obviously attempting a nuclear weapons program while saying if they achieve their aim that they will do crazy shit.

I guess the games you think are stupid depend immensely on your priors.

nostrebored··on OpenAI's fall from grace as investors race to Anthropic
Because it isn’t honest, it is investor hype that these frontier labs need people to believe despite obviously hitting the sublinear part of the improvement curve.

“It’s so dangerous, we’ve reached AGI, we just have to release models that are obviously incapable of abstraction for your safety”

nostrebored··on Simple self-distillation improves code generation
Could we not get the same with EAFT? Maybe that’s what it’s doing but definitely not the first to think “let’s lock in high probability solutions”

In nemotron the high perplexity solutions are selected for RL, in VLM training a few people are looking at the entropy distributions of the training set, etc

nostrebored··on The FAA’s flight restriction for drones is an attempt to criminalize filming ICE
These are completely orthogonal. That’s cool if you want to appeal to an in group, but I think you’ll find that a huge portion of the country thinks that we should have rules around immigration. So do most other countries.

You should probably argue your actual position instead of “your guy bad my guy good”. This comment is more Reddit than HN.

nostrebored··on The FAA’s flight restriction for drones is an attempt to criminalize filming ICE
I don’t think this has ever actually been a critique. It solves societal problems in a way that many people don’t like while introducing others.
nostrebored··on Google releases Gemma 4 open models
Training for tasks still works petty well, but “vision” is a super broad domain and most seem optimized for OCR and screen processing (which have verifiable outputs and relatively straightforward data generation)
nostrebored··on The Anti-Intellectualism of Silicon Valley Elites
A weird claim when science is littered with a history of poor, insane explanations for phenomena.

People play back the “Greatest Hits” without really going into the historical misses. The reality is that the quality and predictive power of science is covariate with culture.

There are a lot of good reasons to think that academic culture right now has a groupthink problem, mostly because the group is so much larger. Alternative theories typically have to wait for an incumbent group of thinkers to die. But if the gradient of thought is more continuous then do bad ideas become more sticky?

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →