2,376 karma · joined September 20, 2007
Trying out this meet thing:
meet.hn/city/us-Boulder
Socials: - github.com/nswanberg
Interests: Privacy
---
I don't know if this good advice for everyone looking to hire but it seems like filtering for both ability and motivation is a good idea for young, growing companies.
The problem with any discussion here on HN is that, judging by replies, many commenters feel insecure whenever an idea is proposed that they feel could exclude them from a job, even though typically these ideas do not spread, and most people need only one full-time job at a time (writing about interviewing has the same problem. See the first few paragraphs of http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2008/03/get-that-job-at-goog...).
I agree that if every company started this practice in the same way, applying for five jobs at the same time while currently working at one would be difficult. But it seems very unlikely that would happen in practice.
The book also briefly covers the Policy Analysis Market, a program to experiment with using a futures market to help predict terrorist attacks. As this program used real money, and offered the opportunity to make money off of terrorist attacks, some members of Congress were outraged and the program was immediately cancelled (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/3106559.stm). This version discussed in this NPR article seems more publicly palatable. In fact, it looks like the similarity was already reported: http://articles.latimes.com/2012/aug/21/nation/la-na-cia-cro...
By the way, can anyone recommend a more rigorous book than Wisdom of Crowds on this subject?
It's hard to take many interesting ideas out of this implication of bad faith on Chris's part. Wouldn't it be better to talk about the topic of the post?
It's also very nice to see an adjustment on that proposal with some new information. It wouldn't have occurred to me that making a chart look hand-drawn would be effective in implying less precision, but now I have a new idea I can try out for graphics demonstrating rough ideas.
I think Chris's tone can be blunt and read as unaccommodating, which may be distracting from the his points, but I think I prefer it to the overly casual tone many adopt when stating an idea. That tone isn't great for customer service but it's very helpful when trying to understand an idea and whether or not to accept it.
Also, it is important to base comments in fact. He accused people on both sides of innumeracy: "Like most political arguments, the discussion of a Basic Income borders on innumeracy. So I’m going to take the opportunity to launch into a far more interesting mathematical tangent, and illustrate how to use Monte Carlo simulation to understand uncertainty and make business/policy decisions. I promise that this post will be far more interesting to python geeks than to policy wonks. I’m just picking Basic Income as a topic to discuss since it showed up on hacker news yesterday and it’s a topic where I see basically no numbers whatsoever."
My personal single biggest objection, though, is that the review appears to be used as a sort of conversation-ending trump card, usually posted with very little comment, sort of like you might see from a fan of talk radio posting in a newspaper comment section.
https://hn.algolia.com/?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cscs.umich.edu%2F...
https://hn.algolia.com/?q=http%3A%2F%2Fvserver1.cscs.lsa.umi...
It's about as bad as bringing up Wolfram's ego--the consequent discussion never leads to anything interesting. Witness this thread that marktangotango started. I don't believe he was being malicious, but it's clear that rather than start a discussion about cellular automata like he intended it spawned a wasteland thread about attribution.
Why must we talk about TMZ-level bullshit when we could be talking about Turing's paper and the original paper in the post? Why is that discussion losing out to gossip?
One modification they made to Turing's idea was that each cell has the same composition. They found that, to produce the results they expected, they needed to alternate the composition of neighboring cells.
(It would be nice if your post was at the top of the thread, since it's the most relevant and useful so far, but it is not very controversial. Next time consider adding something like "Biology professors hate him! Read this man's 1 weird trick for explaining morphogenesis!")
Anyway, the history of cellular automata is sort of interesting, and the notion of using computation to explain biological markings is also interesting. Thought after skimming Turing's paper it looks like while Turing makes many simplifying assumptions, did some basic computer modeling, and is literally about biological cells, his model is not as abstract as the cellular automata von Neumann, Conway, or Wolfram studied--unlike the others Turing's model uses linear equations to transmit "state" from cell to cell instead of rules. In fact Wolfram's contribution was to remove as many details as possible from cellular automata, enumerate all the possibilities, and observe what happens.
The bummer about referring to that review in other threads or in this case mischaracterizing Wolfram's work is that it distracts from creating more interesting discussions about this stuff. There are currently about 16 comments effectively discussing attribution, and precious few about what sort of model Turing proposed.
Turing seems to be sort of a personal hero to Wolfram, so I'm sure that he'd have some interest in the results in the post.
And for anyone interested in modeling nature with computers more generally, A New Kind of Science is wonderful reading and gives a great conceptual framework on how to go about it. It's sad that the Shalizi review is the first thing people refer to (it's sort of the Huffington Post of reviews).
Neither point addresses Tufte's central problem with PowerPoint, which is that the software, with its templates and bullet-point lists, encourages a certain style of ritualistic presentation, where the presenter's conclusions are the focus, not the backing evidence that leads to those conclusions. This sort of problem preceded PowerPoint (Tufte writes about similar problems with overhead projector presentations with transparencies filled with bullet points at IBM in his essay The Cognitive Style of PowerPoint), but PowerPoint inflamed the problem.
If this was a genuine question and you were expecting some informed answers, consider writing it in a different way. It hasn't attracted very high quality responses.
Anyone reading or writing these sorts of fundamental web programming tutorials should look at Philip Greenspun's books Philip and Alex's Guide to Web Publishing and Software Engineering for Internet Applications, both available free online (The latter is a stripped down version of the former, written for goal-oriented MIT students who don't want anecdotes or pretty pictures). They are around a decade old, so they aren't a good source for copy-paste-ready code, but the ideas in the books have aged quite well (from simple things like using "abstract URLs"--URLs without extensions like .aspx and .php, to focusing on the website's data model and user interaction instead of the programming language).
The most interesting part of these books is that they explored creating web applications for a purpose, not as an end in themselves. They were written for the sort of people who evaluated their past year not on what their manager wrote in some HR form and the raise they got, but on what they were able to accomplish, like creating http://scorecard.goodguide.com/. (What's funny is that in Greenspun's ITConversations interview (around 4:20 http://web.archive.org/web/20130729213414id_/http://itc.conv...), he said that the parts of Phil and Alex's Guide that aged were not the technology, but the rampant idealism in the book that web applications would unleash a new age of enlightenment, like the academics who had believed television would be used to broadcast Harvard lectures around the world).
Here are the chapters on HTML: http://philip.greenspun.com/panda/html http://philip.greenspun.com/seia/html
And the closest to describing HTTP and frameworks: http://philip.greenspun.com/panda/server-programming http://philip.greenspun.com/seia/basics
(It just occurred to me that Philip's interview above is one day short of being 10 years old, and his assessment might be worth revisiting. The internet still contains volumes of crap, but the internet as only grown as a teaching and community building tool, with sites like Meetup and Facebook organizing learners and teachers, Khan Academy and Udacity doing organized classes, and StackOverflow collaboratively solving specific problems).
How much boilerplate text do you need on either side of a token in order to identify it? Put another way, how much can the template emails vary? If the template format changes is there any sort of notification? Did you use the simplest implementation that could work or is this much more complicate than it looks?
Even if we'd been able to play it, though, it's not clear we'd have gotten much more out of it than we'd gotten by reading 1984, Fahrenheit 451, and being at the mercy of the administration of an American public high school.
As for this game, it seemed much more compelling in the intro screen, which resembled some sort of Twitter / Facebook wall and had some cool effects while scrolling. When the actual game started it seemed like a puzzle game combined with a paranoia game, which is great for those who are already convinced by the world the game depicts but not convincing otherwise. It might be a tougher game mechanic to figure out, but it might be more compelling if the UI were Facebook, Gmail, and Twitter clones, and the game was such that the player attempted to sift through volumes of intercepted correspondence and communication metadata, fingering bad guys, political opponents, and hapless citizens, and, with limited resources, decided who to investigate/hassle. The game could have real terrorists that need to be detected, rewarding real detections and penalizing false positives, or have super-cynic Floor 13 mode, where the player used the surveillance system to their own personal gain. Or, turn the system described in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6882378 into a game (I posted then and still believe that the concerns there were, while possible, vague and improbable, but possibly a game could convince me and others otherwise).
As a selfish aside, do any car nerds know how I would begin finding out if a 2004 4Runner has a CAN bus? http://www.auterraweb.com/aboutcan.html sort of implies no, but seems far from definitive.
Then the question is what does one do with all the extra space in this portable world device? Wikipedia information? Languages? Fun times.
Mathematica Cookbook is also a nice reference. The book is much less systematic, but provides code that solves more realistic problems than the Mathematica documentation.
Javascript would be an interesting choice for a toy implementation, especially because there are orders of magnitude more javascript installations than python, and much more effort put towards making javascript fast. And who knows, maybe the toy would turn into something more serious.
As for Stephen's ego, I'm surprised it keeps getting mentioned. He seems like a driven person, but then so are many people whose egos aren't discussed. He comes off as quite a decent person in this Reddit thread http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/tmutz/stephen_wolfram_... and in this interview with Scoble: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mNf8Se_USlE
All of this has only a tenuous connection to the language itself, which is much more interesting to discuss. Sure, it may be the only self-named language (thought it arguably owes its name as much to the brand Wolfram Research as to Stephen, and I'd hoped they'd come up with a more creative name), but if one manages to shepherd a system like Mathematica through 25 years, one earns the right to self-name a language.