HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nycticorax

610 karma · joined March 18, 2010

submissionscomments
nycticorax··on The Best Linux Distros of 2016
Could you elaborate on this? I know many people have security concerns about Mint, but I've never found their arguments entirely convincing. the opinion of the Mint devs seems to be that there's a stability vs. security tradeoff, and that Ubuntu chose one point on the spectrum, while Mint chose another. And that for a typical desktop machine sitting behind a router without a lot of ports open (or behind a corporate firewall), the tradeoff Mint chose is a reasonable one. I've seen several attempts to explain why Mint should not be trusted, but they seem (to me) to eventually reduce to arguments that more security is always better, no matter the cost in stability or convenience.
nycticorax··on Scientific Regress
In my experience, academia's brokenness has been greatly exaggerated. All medium-to-large human organizations are broken to some extent. And exactly what are the concrete outlines of these mythical "organizations that do not damage actual science in order perpetuate themselves" that you propose to replace academia with?
nycticorax··on Scientific Regress
Certainly, the reproducibility crisis in social science and cancer biology is important, and deserves attention. But this article mostly strikes me as profoundly overstated. Yes, science is done by humans, and is thus imperfect. Yes, science's approach to truth is nonmonotonic. (I think most working scientists would consider this obvious.) Yes, scientists have various incentives to hype surprising results, cut corners, and even cheat. Yes, a lot of bad science gets published. But clearly science is making progress, since we clearly know more than we did 5, 10, 20, or 50 years ago. Are there things that could be done to improve the way science is conducted? Almost certainly (e.g. preregistering experimental trials, requiring power analysis in published papers), but this article is remarkable quiet about such things. In the end, what is author even really saying? That lay people should trust scientists less than they do? That doesn't seem correct to me. For instance, on climate change, it seems that normal people trust scientists a good deal less than they should, instead placing their trust in talking heads, politicians, and people who are unambiguously paid by oil companies to advocate on their behalf. So: yes, science as practiced in 2016 is imperfect. But what exactly do you propose replacing it with?
nycticorax··on MATE Desktop Environment
I think you are mistaken...
nycticorax··on Handful of Biologists Went Rogue and Published Directly to Internet
How do you know this? One reason they're called "preprints" is that they haven't (necessarily) been peer-reviewed...
nycticorax··on Handful of Biologists Went Rogue and Published Directly to Internet
That's great (seriously), but doesn't that undermine the premise of the original article? I just checked, and American Physiological Society journals still expressly forbid prepublication. So it's still not universal...
nycticorax··on Handful of Biologists Went Rogue and Published Directly to Internet
It's certainly fear, uncertainty, and doubt, but usually when people use the term "FUD' they mean to imply that the fear, uncertainty, and doubt are unfounded. But in this case, all three are justified. The article mentions that Nature and Science are open to papers that have been pre-published. But I believe that many biology journals still have a blanket policy of not considering papers that have been pre-published. If that's the case, the working scientist is highly motivated to not pre-publish, since it shuts the door to later (peer-reviewed) publication. Unless, of course, the scientist is 100% sure they can get it published in Science or Nature. And in practice one is almost never sure of this.

I'm always curious to know how physics, as a field, got over this and related humps. Was it just easier to get everyone on board because it's a smaller community? Were the journals not as savvy to the fact that pre-prints are not really in their interest?

nycticorax··on The Robin Hood of Science
Well, I'm really defending the rule of law, not Elsevier. I fully support the current trend towards open access journals. But open access journals don't involve systematic copyright infringement.
nycticorax··on The Robin Hood of Science
I don't want to defend Elsevier, but this article was just egregiously one-sided. Surely an article like this should examine whether this model is sustainable, or what it would really mean if these for-profit publishers disappeared. (Some of them, for instance, employ full-time editors to sift through papers and pick the best ones. How does this sifting happen in the brave new world of universal free access?)

Also they quote "Robin Hood" thus:

"Elsevier, in contrast, operates by racket: If you do not send money, you will not read any papers."

Ummm, that's how most businesses work. If you want a sandwich, you have to pay for it first... Not all businesses are rackets.

"Robin Hood" continues...

"On my website, any person can read as many papers as they want for free, and sending donations is their free will. Why can Elsevier not work like this, I wonder?"

Ummm, because they're a for-profit company, and their officers have a obligation to try to maximize profit for their share-holders?

Again, I don't want to defend Elsevier, but I think a better article would have acknowledged that there's more than one side to this issue.

nycticorax··on The Villain of CRISPR
I thought this article was interesting because it was that first think I've read that actually lays out a seemingly plausible case for why Doudna et al. deserve primary credit rather than Feng at al. The "Whig History of CRISPR" article was interesting, but it left me wanting to hear more about the biology.
nycticorax··on What is wrong with NULL
But as the writer mentions, optionals are a lot like lists with either zero or one elements, so it seems like many of these issues could be dealt with by simply returning a list, which would have zero elements if (in that example) the key was missing, or one element is the key was present. (And that single element would be nil if that was the value for that key.)
nycticorax··on Firefox nightlies for Linux are now using Gtk+3
I second this. Clearlooks-Phenix is great.
nycticorax··on Cancer reproducibility effort faces backlash
"So you just accept for no reason that tap water is bad somehow, and discard the result you've just gotten?"

What is the "result" that you referring to here? That the tap water in town X kills cultured cells of type Y? Yeah, I guess you could try writing that up and publishing it, but that's a good way to waste a lot of time publishing results that are interesting only to a very small audience. Honestly, if it were me, I'd send an e-mail to people in the same town that might be working with cells of the same or similar type, and then move on.

"but when something happens in science, it needs to be documented"

No, it really doesn't. Stuff doesn't document itself. That takes time, which sometimes is better spent doing other things. Like answering more interesting questions.

"Maybe that particular phenomena that lead to the water influencing your result will give you knowledge about cell metabolism. Who knows?"

That's true, but my point is that it doesn't make you a bad scientist if you shrug your shoulders about why the tap water kills your cells, and get on with your original experiment. For every experiment you do, there's a million others you're not doing, and so it makes sense to focus on the one experiment you're most interested in, not chase after a bunch of side-projects that will (probably) not lead to any kind of an interesting result.

And all of this is very different than a case where you compare control to treatment, find no difference, and therefore just start fiddling with other experimental parameters until you do get a difference between control and treatment. That is, I think you'll agree, a bad way to do science.

"To go back to the computer analogy, it feels like my program is bugged, and to debug it I'm changing variables names (which as far as I know shouldn't matter), and then the code magically works again. Sure, some days, I'll go "Ok, compiler magic, got it", but most days I'd be pretty intrigued, and I'd look into it, because yeah, I might just have found a GCC bug."

I think a better analogy would be if compiler x acts in ways you don't understand, so you switch to gcc, which (most of the time) works as you expect. Are you really required to figure out exactly why compiler x acts as it does? Or would you just get on with using a compiler that works the way you think it should?

"I agree, no one cares, but I did. I don't know what I don't know yet, and I don't want to presume anything. The tap water thing might actually lead us to solid models which would explain why tap water breaks the experiment."

They might, but there are a lot of experiments that have a very very small chance of an interesting outcome, and a near-one chance of a pedestrian outcome. You can do those experiments, and you might get lucky and get the interesting result, but probably you will just get the pedestrian result. And there's nothing wrong (and a lot right) with instead focusing on experiments where (for instance), either outcome would be interesting to people in the field.

"That's why I really think we should start a movement of publishing everything, and trying to deal with simpler models/systems we do understand before going up to models with so many unknowns that the results are basically a dice roll."

I think you're conflating a number of things here. I agree that a reductionist approach to science has bourne a lot of fruit, historically. I agree that studying systems with a lot of unknowns has risks. And it may be that "publish everything" would work better than what we have now. But even if scientists all decide to publish everything they do, they'll still have to make strategic choices about what experiment to do on a given day, and in many cases that will mean not doing a deep dive into questions like "why does the tap water kill my cells, even in control"?

nycticorax··on Science, Now Under Scrutiny Itself
"I don't know about that industry, but generally prices don't depend on the sellers' costs." What you're saying is true only if the revenue at the optimal price is higher than the seller's costs. If the revenue at optimal cost is lower than the seller's costs, then generally the product won't be produced. Therefore if the product is still being produced, the seller's costs put a lower bound on the revenue. If the volume is fixed, this means a lower bound on the price. If the volume is small, this lower bound can be high.
nycticorax··on Science, Now Under Scrutiny Itself
I am aware of that---I've written and reviewed several peer-reviewed papers. Maybe many of the journals are making money hand over fist. But I've become suspicious of arguments of the form "that seems like a high price, therefore they must have huge margins". Sometimes the price is high because the market is small.
nycticorax··on Cancer reproducibility effort faces backlash
People don't investigate things like that, because, frankly, no one cares. Nor should they. If your computer is acting funny, and you find out a spider has made a nest inside it, and it works fine once you clear out the spider nest, would you then decide to determine exactly why that spider nest, in that place, causes the exact problems you observed? No, of course not. Because that's not an interesting question. Computers are complicated machines, and they can break in lots of different ways, most of which are not very interesting in their details.

Similarly, suppose you study cultured cells (which are notoriously finicky), and you want to compare what the cells do in the presence of drug X vs control. But at first, you find that all of your control cells die. And eventually you find out that if you use brand X of bottled water vs tap water, the control cells thrive. Are you seriously proposing that you should then drop all work on drug X, and get to work determining exactly what is up with the tap water in your town? I mean, maybe that would be a fruitful research avenue, if you're worried that the tap water isn't safe for human consumption, or you think that there's something interesting about exactly how the tap water is killing your control cells. But most of the time, investigating the tap water would be an expensive distraction from the question you actually want to answer. And most scientists, I think, would (reasonably) decide to get on with investigating the effects of drug X on their cells, and not worry too much about precisely why the tap water killed the control cells. And I don't think there's anything wrong with that. Life is short, and you have to choose your questions carefully.

nycticorax··on Cancer reproducibility effort faces backlash
"it was trivial to randomize the parameters within their bounds of experimental measurement and create chaotic systems. Did this mean the model wasn't so great? No, it just meant those couldn't be the real-life configuration of those parameters . . . sigh."

Why is this sigh-worthy? Maybe the model is still ok. Maybe some of the parameters are constrained in nature in ways that you/we just don't know about yet. Of course, it could be that the model is bad, but you act as if your results, as stated, demonstrate this. Which they do not, as far as I can see.

nycticorax··on New DNA Results Show Kennewick Man Was Native American
He said "it's a shame" not "they're being stupid". Because these physical anthropologists are probably not part of some grand conspiracy against Native Americans or anyone else. They probably just want to know how humans originally migrated into the Americas. Because, you know, they're scientists, and scientists are curious.
nycticorax··on GitFlow considered harmful
It seems like one of the ironies of git-flow is that it would actually work better if you used it with Mercurial rather than Git, because Mercurial stores what branch you were on when you made a commit. This means that a tool could automatically look at the Mercurial commit tree and figure out which swimlane each commit belongs in, and use this information to draw a commit history tree that wasn't such a mess.

I apologize for the self-promotion, but this answer on Stack Overflow (and the question) talks about this difference between Git and Mercurial, and includes links to articles that explain it better than I could:

http://stackoverflow.com/a/26784550/1013442

nycticorax··on Science, Now Under Scrutiny Itself
I think those journals charge high prices for the same reason that niche software vendors charge high prices. Namely, the product takes a goodly number of highly educated (and thus highly compensated) people to produce, and they don't have that many customers. So if the business is going to work at all, the prices have to be high. Furthermore, they are taking steps to verify the integrity of what they sell. And of course, the more steps they take, the more the journals are going to cost...
nycticorax··on KeePass – questionable security
"I'm fairly certain Dropbox has been broken into more times than LastPass ever will be."

Really? Why is that?

nycticorax··on Microsoft makes its case for Windows 10
If you find yourself using Windows from time to time, you might try Cmder: http://gooseberrycreative.com/cmder/. It's currently my favorite Unix-like shell on Windows. I've used cygwin and Hamilton C Shell in the past, but Cmder offers, among other things, a console emulator (ConEmu, I gather) that is much better than the default Windows console emulator.
nycticorax··on Andy Hertzfeld's take on the Schlender-Tetzeli bio
This statement only makes sense if you feel it is impossible to write a truly definitive biography of anyone.
nycticorax··on Xmonad – A dynamically tiling X11 window manager
How is this news?
nycticorax··on Why are interest rates so low?
What part of the OP do you think reflects an "obsession" with economic growth?
nycticorax··on Academia's 1%
I concluded that in that line, the author was referring to the statistics she had previously discussed. But I have to admit that it's ambiguous.
nycticorax··on Academia's 1%
The author seems to view the hiring statistics she cites as evidence of "bias", but I didn't see any attempt to control for the actual quality of the applicants. I.e. You could read all of this as just more evidence that the "system" works: the good schools tend to be enriched for good graduate students, who then tend to get a lot of the tenure-track jobs.
nycticorax··on Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with a bunch of kids
Perhaps you'd care to elaborate on exactly what the cliches were? Cameron intended to make the early parts with the colonial marines feel like a Vietnam movie, where you worry that the soldiers' lack of discipline and seriousness is going to lead to tears. I'm not sure I'd call that a cliche. Honestly, I think the sound the pulse rifles make is sufficient to earn Aliens a place in cinema history.
nycticorax··on Notes on watching "Aliens" for the first time again, with a bunch of kids
The Abyss and Avatar were both made after Aliens. How can Cameron reusing themes from Aliens in those movies be a criticism of Aliens?
nycticorax··on The vegetables of truth
One idea from the world of science that might benefit articles like this is that of the abstract. It's a one-paragraph summary that helps the reader decide whether they should bother reading the whole article.
← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →