HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

nzp

607 karma · joined October 2, 2013

PGP: 28CC 9078 8358 CE2D 6824 A5BC 2DB2 CD24 5BE7 8F06
submissionscomments
nzp··on [dead]
I think the HURD logo is actually quite good. They should use a different typeface though. And you can't really complain about the MIT Scheme one, that's exactly what it is :) (although it too could benefit from a nicer typeface for the Y combinator equation). GNU Parallel has a great idea but also, I think, needs a better typeface.

But the recutils one... WTF!?

nzp··on [dead]
Heh, they changed it a few years ago. The new one: http://www.list.org/images/logo2010.png
nzp··on Ubuntu desktop moving application menus back into application windows
No, it's actually best handled the way they are about to handle it: let the user choose the alternative themselves.
nzp··on Ubuntu desktop moving application menus back into application windows
Reading the title made my blood pressure start slightly rising as it gives an impression this is not configurable. Fortunately this is not the case. I like the menu bar where it is now, that space is wasted anyway. If Unity didn't have the HUD then the current solution would be problematic with focus follows mouse, but with the HUD it's a non issue.

Doesn't anyone else find it a bit weird how they pretend they invented the top bar menu and are like: "Yeah, we had this really cool and innovative idea, but, um, yeah as it was used in the real world for the past couple of years we gathered some data and we have second thoughts... You know how it is when you're the first and only product with an original feature..." Right... Because it's not like there's a certain other operating system GUI which has had this feature since the '80s.

nzp··on AI
> How would you convince an intelligent being that could not feel pain that it exists at all?

Assuming the being is "reasonable" (in this context it would mean it's willing to accept that there exist concepts that it may not understand or directly experience, and is willing to trust us), we could just point out the chemical and electrical phenomena correlated with pain and say that it's something that causes a certain kind of feeling of discomfort. We would get in trouble if this being also can not feel general discomfort, but you're probably bound to hit a wall in understanding at some point anyway when communicating with an entity whose experiencing capabilities are wildly different from ours.

> The existence of pain falls outside the boundaries of scientific inquiry, I agree. But are you saying that it therefore doesn't exist?

Actually, my point about pain was that it does exist, precisely because it can be examined and explained within a scientific framework. If we couldn't do that, then we could say that for all practical purposes, as far as science is concerned, "pain doesn't exist".

The same is true for consciousness. What's difficult about it is that it's not a thing, there's no hormone for consciousness, there's no brain centre where it's localized, rather it's a process and a product both phylogenic and ontogenic so it's a lot harder to capture it and identify it, to put it "under the microscope". It's not some secret sauce to intelligence, it's a consequence of intelligence. And the most important part of the process is the dynamics of language acquisition (at least when we're speaking of conscious experience in Homo sapiens).

I could go into the details but I'm afraid my posts would explode in length. ATM I don't have time to dig for good online material on this, and I'm under the impression that the theory in time got derailed into developing some practical aspects concerning child cognitive development, verbal learning etc, and away from the hard meaty implications we're discussing here, so I'm reluctant to even attempt to go into that rabbit hole. But they're explicitly there (the books I mentioned discuss the issue at length). Interestingly, about 10 years ago I was doing some work on word-meaning and symbol grounding development and I was both glad and frustrated to see literature on computer modelling in this area full of operationally defined concepts from the theory but people were seemingly unaware that this work has already been treated in depth on the theoretical level because there were no references to it then, I'm not sure if anything has changed, I've since moved on to other things. For example, the Talking Heads model[1][2]. It's not about consciousness per se, and although the authors never reference the socio-cultural theory of cognitive development (a horrible name in this day and age, it tends to evoke associations to post-modern dribble, but nothing could be further from the truth), it can give you a good idea of some aspects of the dynamics explored in the theory because what is happening in the TH model is exactly what the S-C theory describes is happening externally during language acquisition (in broader strokes though).

As for the philosophical zombie problem, I'd like to retract what I said about it being nonsense. Actually, it's very useful in showing why worrying about subjective sensation of consciousness is completely useless in AI and is very much like asking how many angels can dance on a tip of a needle. On a very related note I'd add: people are severely underestimating the significance of the Turing test.

[1] http://staff.science.uva.nl/~gideon/Steels_Tutorial_PART2.pd...

[2] http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=talking+heads+expe...

nzp··on Inside DuckDuckGo, Google's Tiniest, Fiercest Competitor
I don't have an account. You're right, for this particular query there's no MDN in results. I just tried "css box-sizing" (the first thing that popped into my mind) and MDN is the 3rd result. The quick answer thingy shows SO questions. So it can definitely be a hit or miss thing.

I agree with what you write about w3.org, it's almost painful to navigate when you just need a quick reference.

nzp··on Inside DuckDuckGo, Google's Tiniest, Fiercest Competitor
My experience with exactly these and related terms has been almost opposite. Lately I needed to look up info on HTML and CSS a lot and not only am I constantly getting MDN results at the top, I usually get a snippet from the MDN page in the "instant answer" (or whatever it's called) box. Before searching for this stuff on DDG I never even realized how good of a resource MDN is (not that I actually needed much info on web related specs in the past).
nzp··on Time travellers: please don’t kill Adolf Hitler
> but Austria hadn't considered the "chain" of allied countries assisting each other

How could it not consider such a, ahem, small detail?

nzp··on AI
First, the moral argument against inflicting pain on others doesn't depend on existence of pain. The moral dilemma is: is it acceptable to inflict pain on others or not. This is different, and to a large extend independent, from the question if pain exists in experience of others. In other words, if pain exists in others, it doesn't follow that you have to, by mere logical reasoning, make a moral conclusion that inflicting pain is wrong. There is an uncrossable ontological abyss between the empirical what is and the moral what should be.

Second, the case of pain from an empirical side is not at all like what we have in the philosophical zombie "problem". We can empirically observe pain. There are all sorts of physiological and neural manifestations of pain. Of course, now you may say "ah, but how can we know that these empirical manifestations mean the person is experiencing the sensation of pain". Scientifically that dilemma makes little sense, it's simply unproductive, it's scientifically useless. If we were to go by that route, we could inject a similar dilemma into every scientific problem, which inevitably would lead to the problem of solipsism. How can we really, really be certain that anything at all exists? Well, I suppose we can't, but this is a question that science has long ago abandoned because it doesn't get you anywhere, it doesn't yield any useful results.

Do note that unlike the question of pain, the zombie problem is defined so that there is in principle absolutely no way to detect, to measure, if someone is a zombie or not. On the other hand, we can in principle measure and detect events correlated with introspective reports on sensations. If we couldn't do that for some phenomenon it would be wise to consider that the phenomenon doesn't exist for the purpose of empirical scientific examination.

Frankly, I'm surprised that my previous post (where I say the zombie problem is nonsense) got downvoted because this is the foundation of scientific methodology. If you can not, even in principle, measure/detect something then it makes no sense to discuss it. Of course, you can amuse yourself and speculate on it, but that falls outside of boundaries of scientific inquiry and I hope that's what we're discussing here.

nzp··on AI
There's no such data, because the zombie problem is complete nonsense. Well, actually, it is complete nonsense precisely because empirical data can't say anything about it.
nzp··on AI
> Psycology can't answer questions like where does the mind come from or what is experience.

I'm not sure I understand what you mean by this. Of course it can, that's the whole purpose of psychology (and, more fashionably, neuroscience of course). To me that sounds like saying science can't answer these questions. Do note that when I say "psychology" I mean strictly the scientific areas of whatever comes in the bag labelled "psychology". Due to historical accidents the term acquired a lot of BS pseudo-scientific baggage, and it's really a shame those things can detract from a wealth of valuable hard results honest scientific psychology uncovered.

The answer that developmental cognitive psychology, at least the theory I'm referring to, gives is that "the mind" comes from the only place it can come from: neural processes and the way they hook into environmental interactions of the organism (social and physical). The key to understanding what gives rise to "consciousness" is in understanding the role of language acquisition in broader cognitive development. The point where a child utters it's first words is neither the beginning nor the end of this extremely nuanced process. In my first post I took it for granted it's understood that this is not just armchair speculation, it's based on empirical data. As any good scientific theory it's far from complete, maybe in some details is inaccurate but it's certainly infinitely better that an endless philosophical debate (with strong religious, or in the best case idealist, undertones) on what the mind is and where it comes from.

nzp··on AI
> We know a ton about the brain but so little about the mind itself. We still don't have definitive answers to what consciousness is, why it's here, what's useful for, etc. Some people debate whether the mind exists at all. Also, there's still very little understanding of the difference between the conscious and unconscious mind.

One of the really, really bad consequences of the Cold War was the scientific divide between East and West. By that I mean serious lack of scientific data exchange between the blocks. The consequences are still felt and this area (the problem of consciousness) is the one that suffered. The problem of "consciousness" was basically solved, at least at a conceptual level, by Soviet psychology and neuropsychology. Here I refer, of course, to the work of Vygotsky and Luria. What is consciousness? Almost nothing at all by itself. Consciousness as found in humans is a consequence of our cognitive development and the advanced symbolic capabilities of humans. The subjective perception we have of the thing we call consciousness is "simply" (it's not really simple when you get into details) a product of humans acquiring language skills (I'm simplifying).

This is not to say the subject is trivial, it takes volumes to describe what is happening, but the thing we informally call "consciousness" is really nothing at all in and of itself, and the perception we have of it is just a result of the very complicated process of cognitive development. Thin air, like Lisp's cons.

If you want to read on it I can recommend Vygotsky's Language and Thought (actually, it's his only book) and Luria's Language and Consciousness (I'm not sure it was ever translated into English, it's a collection of his lecture notes from a university course he did on the subject) or possibly The Cognitive Development: Its Cultural and Social Foundations.

Why this line of thinking is mostly ignored in the West I have no idea. Why do we still cling to metaphysical (even religious I would say) phantasies about "consciousness" is an interesting topic itself. Is it because it's romantic to think there's something special, transcendent, about our minds? Are we really that sentimental? I have some hypotheses, but it's a different topic.

nzp··on Why I Dropped Out Of YC
˙ƃuıuɐəɯ əɥʇ uɐəlƃ ʎləɹəɯ uɐɔ noʎ ɟı ʇxəʇ əsɹɐd ʎlısɐə oʇ əlqɐ ƃuıəq ʇnoqɐ dɐɹɔ ɐ səʌıƃ oɥʍ ˙əəɹƃɐ ı
nzp··on Why I Dropped Out Of YC
Apostrophes, proper capitalization, punctuation, properly dividing text into paragraphs... all these orthographic conventions are essential to communicating ideas. So if ideas matter, apostrophes matter too. Capitalization even more so, no matter who the person is.
nzp··on Why I Dropped Out Of YC
As a non-native speaker I agree with this. But I've noticed something interesting: before I was aware that mixing up the two was common with native speakers it would never happen in my own writing, but once I realized people do make this mistake I became susceptible to making it too. I still don't, but now I sometimes have to make a conscious effort to differentiate the two. It's amazing where social learning can show it's effects. (And BTW, I think I would just kill myself if I ever mixed up affect and effect, I see that a lot, and for some reason it annoys the hell out of me.)
nzp··on What did Persona get right? Why did Persona fail to gain wide adoption?
Which they can already do with accounts they most likely already have: Facebook, Google, Twitter, LinkedIN any OpenID provider... So the only potential benefit of Persona is the privacy, and if a user doesn't care about that then it's just another account you have to worry about (i.e. the very problem it tries to solve). As it stands, Persona's problem is that it just reinvents the wheel with slightly different spokes when people already have wheels that they consider good enough.
nzp··on Did English ever have a formal version of “you”?
Why do you assume he meant it in a deprecatory (is that a word?) way? By analogy, when one says Lisp has no syntax it's not meant in a derogatory sense, on the contrary.
nzp··on Stallman on GCC, LLVM, and copyleft
We have a free OS + kernel (and mind you, GNU/Linux is not the only viable free software OS) because RMS hacked relentlessly in the 80's on GCC and other C toolchain components. In fact, so relentlessly it destroyed his hands with RSI. No amount of political pushing for copyleft would have made any difference if the code wasn't there. I'd rate GCC as by far the most important enabler of the abundance of free software we have today, and for that I'm deeply grateful to RMS.

I'm fairly certain that no company chose GPL because the management's first concern was joining FSF's struggle against proprietary software. Businesses can't operate that way. Whether a company adopts GPL or not depends on perceived business benefits of adoption. So the question of this or that company adopting GPL or not doesn't have anything to do with moral reasoning behind GPL and is therefore irrelevant to what we're talking about.

Yes, they're changing, in the same way that a factory may change when it adopts new machinery. Companies who adopt copyleft adopt it because of the "open source" philosophy, not because of the "free software" philosophy. This is actually one of Stallman's talking points (open source vs. free software) I'm very sympathetic to.

nzp··on Stallman on GCC, LLVM, and copyleft
"Unwilling to accept" was meant in the sense "doesn't recognize the issues even exist", not "unwilling to let the issues go unsolved".

He's been explicitly not willing to consider issues I'm talking about. In fact, he's quite happy to live in a system which enables and produces conditions which enable the existence of proprietary software. He's never been working to change those issues. In fact, the concept of copyleft, the mechanism it relies on, is firmly rooted in the status quo. You say it yourself, it uses restrictive copyright laws to enforce "openness", but the crucial point is that it's an openness with a severely limited scope. It does absolutely zero to change society in any meaningful, fundamental way. The very act of relying on capitalist state legal system to force people to be "open" serves only to further legitimize that very system which makes possible, even desirable, for things like proprietary software to exist. The GPL isn't even a subversive hack of copyright law--the law was meant to enable authors to put almost any kind of conditions on the use and distribution of their works, as they please. It's the purpose of copyright law all along to enable things like the GPL. The fact that it's highly unusual to release works under such conditions is beside the point. Stallman almost autistically only sees his most immediate grievance, the incidental fact that software can be restrictive to its users, but is completely blind to the actual fundamental social causes of the issue. So no, the GPL is not in any meaningful way successful at actually changing society, the whole concept is fundamentally conformant to existing socio-economic conditions.

nzp··on Stallman on GCC, LLVM, and copyleft
The biggest problem (possibly the only problem, but still a severe one) with Stallman's views on software copyright licensing is that he seems either unaware of, or unwilling to accept, broader social, economic and political issues of our civilization. Software and processes around it, like any other product of human social production, doesn't and can't exist in a social vacuum. It's nice to be focused on a specific social issue, but when your work scales to a certain level it becomes impossible to consider it in isolation. Reading the comments on that article made me glad to see an LLVM developer who chimed in (silvas) understands this perfectly and he articulated it quite well:

We don't do everything in public purely because of internal constraints of the companies that we work for and those won't go away without significant societal changes (i.e., the necessary changes vastly transcend the developers' own attitudes on the issue: we're talking changes at the levels of entire business models).

[...]

> What about iPhone platform support?

I assume you mean that the platform is locked down?

Well, that's their platform. They make the rules for who gets to compile for it. Now, you may say "well, they shouldn't restrict who gets to compile for their platform!" and that's fine, but it's a different issue, one which goes to the core of Apple's business model and the society that enables it and the individuals that make up that society. Even if LLVM/Clang were to magically become GPL'd tomorrow, the platform would still be locked down.

[...]

It's myopic to think that the software is somehow the key factor here: the assault on freedom in this situation is the incentive to keep it proprietary, and that is a much larger issue. There is a similar assault on freedom from the fact that their hardware designs are proprietary as well, and the incentives are similar.

[...]

In my experience, Stallman's view is extremely myopic because the real impediments to free software are larger societal issues[1]. Within the hacker community these issues don't really exist (Eric Raymond's essays cover this well), and so the default is that code is free software (four freedoms), but the other 99.99% of society is still stuck with archaic principles, and any time that a hacker's paycheck comes from "the rest of society", they are subject to a world where these issues exist.

[1] The GPLv3 "anti-Tivo-ization" wording is a perfect example that shows that confining your view just to software is myopic. Why shouldn't we want the entire device and all its chips to be free also? Why shouldn't the company's internal discussions be done in public? The answer to these questions is the same as the answer to "why does non-free software exist?".

nzp··on Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
Well, when you spin it like that... I'm no Steve Jobs apologist, but I think it's important to get the facts straight. NeXT wanted to distribute the frontend as .o files which the user would link with the backend, true. Now, the way you present it makes it seems as though NeXT was hell bent on having a proprietary frontend, but were strongarmed by the GPL to release under the GPL. What actually happened is that Jobs asked RMS if he thought it would be OK to distribute the frontend as .o files, to which Stallman said that it probably would be OK (from a legal standpoint), but then consulted a lawyer who told him that the judge would probably think this is not OK. So RMS then tells Jobs that FSF believes this is not allowed by the GPL. Then NeXT produces GPLed frontend. Notice how smooth all of this went. No attempts of subversion by NeXT or disputing FSF's opinion, they asked, were given a legally worthless negative opinion which they accepted and produced a free frontend. So yes, technically it happened because of the GPL (but only on an assumption that the judge would accept FSF's lawyer reasoning) but based on what actually happened there is no evidence of Jobs wanting to "have his way". If Jobs "hated" "our freedom" and the GPL was the only thing that stood between us and slavery as RMS likes to think, this would unlikely go without any friction whatsoever.

Sources for what happened: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/pragmatic.html http://www.tikirobot.net/wp/2008/11/22/why-gcc-has-a-free-ob...

EDIT: Another source, the first paragraph is telling: https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/gnu.misc.discuss/_pB...

nzp··on Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
The whole point of BSD-style licenses is that there is hardly anything to enforce at all. With such a license you are simply stating that you allow the receiver to do whatever they want with it. This statement is just necessary because by default under the copyright law no rights (with some exceptions such as fair use etc., it depends on jurisdiction) are granted to entities receiving the work.
nzp··on Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
It's really not complicated at all. RMS is simply a social-democrat. He is the shining example of what social-democracy is really in practice. His position is not utopian at all, it's a very limited and specific, socially liberal, demand: it's unjust to have people be unable to do whatever they want with the things they own, not to mention having the things they own controlling them. Proprietary software does tend to limit and control its users, therefore we need to abolish proprietary software. It has nothing to do with hindering capitalism or anything like that.

I can see people in the USA having problems to properly frame his position due to the ideological burden of equating any kind of a demand for sharing and cooperation with communism or socialism, regardless if the demand actually has anything to do with left wing political motivations.

nzp··on Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
My feeling is that they're not more zealous (to be honest, I don't think there's anything wrong with being zealous when you're fighting for a good cause) but rather dilettantes who don't actually understand what FSF is about, or what the various licenses precisely mean. They just find the general aesthetics and rhetoric of FSF and RMS appealing and try to emulate cargo-cult style.
nzp··on Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
> Does RMS go trolling on dev lists for permissively-licensed projects?

Actually, he does. I remember when he went to an OpenBSD list a few years ago[1] and insisted they take out ports for non-free software out of the ports tree.

[1]: Too lazy to find the link.

nzp··on Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
That's exactly relevant! Your premise is that <insert entity> (in this case Apple) objects to releasing things free, and the only thing that made them do it is GPL. GPL is simply not relevant here, no one cared. Apple in turn benefited from Google's improvements of Webkit, etc. People who make decisions in companies, and indeed people in general, are perfectly able to understand the enormous benefits of cooperation. No need for any kind of force or coercion, thank you very much.
nzp··on Richard Stallman - Re: clang vs free software
Your argument, that GPL was KHTML's only advantage, doesn't make any sense because it then follows that Apple chose KHTML because they just love GPL and won't accept anything else despite KHTML's supposed technical inferiority. In other words, you're saying Apple chose KHTML because their only concern was apparently to get to be forced by GPL to release improvements. Because if KHTML was so inferior and forced them to release improvements (let's imply Apple didn't like this), what reason would they possibly have to choose KHTML? "Oh, look, there are these other engines which are better than KHTML but unfortunately their licenses don't force us to release our work, so no, we choose GPL."

In reality KHTML was a much better code base than other options, and Apple didn't really care that much about the license.

Let me tie in this comment with the whole thing about GPL vs. non-copyleft free software drama in general, and why I think GPL has become harmful: what you said I think illustrates a kind of thinking mode that the idea, the practical working principle, behind GPL breeds. The idea is to use force and coercion to make entities do what you want them to do. That road naturally leads to a mindset where every behavior is seen as necessarily motivated by coercion. And that leads one to normalize and accept coercion as an acceptable, even necessary, mode of social relations. I see this mode of thinking a lot with strong advocates of GPL. It's always in terms of someone being forced to do something good, and if they aren't being forced no good shall come out. This is a horrible, horrible way to look at the world. If we take Apple as an example, they open-sourced a lot of stuff they had no legal reason to release, some of those things very non trivial.

I have to point out that I'm writing all of this as someone who respects RMS and FSF's cause a great deal, I even use the term free software rather than open source (in my native language, fortunately, there's no confusion about "free", free as in freedom and free as in bear are not homonyms). However, I do not think GPL and strong copyleft licenses are an acceptable, or even a good way, to accomplish freedom in this domain of life. GPL is maybe a great tool to destroy proprietary software (well, almost, but not quite), but a horrible way to accomplish software freedoms in general.

nzp··on OpenBSD will shut down if we do not have the funding to keep the lights on
Note: OpenXYZ, not OpenSomethingSomething. Anyway, OpenBGPD, OpenOSPFD, OpenNTPD, OpenSMTPD, OpenSSH, OpenIKED. OK, so it's more like OpenABCD and I should probably have written "many" instead of "most". :)
nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
> Why do you say that lxc (and cgroups) are less powerful than FreeBSD jails?

If I was wrong about this it's because I'm not up to date on things that happen in the Linux kernel, it wasn't my intention to bash it or anything like that.

nzp··on CBSD – FreeBSD Jail Management Tools
Yeah, don't get me wrong, I think Docker is great. I remember when I first heard about it thinking "Finally, something approaching jails functionality in Linux." Of course, I know it's a different level of abstraction and all that. My comments were more directed at the underlying Linux infrastructure Docker uses. Granted, I may well be wrong, it's been a long time since I was seriously in Linux land (i.e. not just a mindless day-to-day user), I'm not current with hard technicalities so it's totally possible that I'm being unjust to LXC.

I'm happy to hear about plans for different backends, the jails one would be awesome if it comes to fruition.

← PreviousPage 8 of 12Next →