HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

oh_my_goodness

770 karma · joined October 28, 2021

submissionscomments
oh_my_goodness··on Model Once, Represent Everywhere: UDA (Unified Data Architecture) at Netflix
No, unfortunately the activity is not modeling at all. It's software development. Pretending otherwise will not make our thinking (or data structures) more logically consistent.

I feel the dream. But we went to that place 25 years ago, and we saw that it was stupid.

Tell you what, I'll do a raffle. Leave a comment telling me that I just don't get it. One lucky winner will get my copy of this book https://www.amazon.com/Unified-Modeling-Language-Addison-Wes.... You pay shipping.

oh_my_goodness··on The Blowtorch Theory: A new model for structure formation in the universe
I consider it underhanded to label reasonable disagreement as "anger."
oh_my_goodness··on The copilot delusion
"Well when you have a hammer big enough everything is indeed a nail."

I think this pretty much speaks for itself.

oh_my_goodness··on Prolog's Eternal September (2017)
Yes, that is a big difference. From what I've seen indifference leads to much better outcomes.

:) Agreed, the AI models have great "people skills." Every user is a genius!

oh_my_goodness··on Prolog's Eternal September (2017)
I hear this and I agree. It's obviously a serious problem.

As a side issue. There's also a different, deeper problem. Any Q&A site that's actively hostile to people who ask questions is going to become toxic and intolerable within a few years. I'm pretty sure that's true even if the hostility is reasonable and justified.

As a newsgroup user since 1986: The problem with the original Eternal September was not only a tidal wave of ignorant new users. It was also that a large fraction of the experienced user base were smug lunatics long before September finally arrived.

Sorry for the like "radical candor" here.

oh_my_goodness··on Electromagnetism as a Purely Geometric Theory
"charge density is a field, which propagates at the speed of light."

Uh ...

oh_my_goodness··on Show HN: New world record – verified Goldbach Conjecture up to 4*10^18+7*10^13
Every second is easy. Let's aim for new world records at a 1MHz rate.
oh_my_goodness··on Canadian math prodigy allegedly stole $65M in crypto
Who's using a ledger system for illegal transactions?
oh_my_goodness··on Canadian math prodigy allegedly stole $65M in crypto
Guessed translation: "The point of cryptocurrencies is to reward the people who do cryptocurrency infrastructure."

That's the point for them. It's not the point for anybody else.

oh_my_goodness··on What Is Entropy?
In equilibrium we don't have to make an assumption about the dynamics or the mixing. We just expect to see the most probable state when we measure.

It's interesting to try to show that the time average equals the ensemble average. It's very cool to think about the dynamics. That stuff must be happening. But those extra ideas aren't necessary for applying the equilibrium theory.

oh_my_goodness··on Buffett: America's Growing Trade Deficit Is Selling the Nation Out from Under Us [pdf] (2003)
No fair bringing data. Share your feelings or move on.
oh_my_goodness··on Accessible open textbooks in math-heavy disciplines
Yeah, I remember.
oh_my_goodness··on Accessible open textbooks in math-heavy disciplines
So what's so bad about pdfs?
oh_my_goodness··on Accessible open textbooks in math-heavy disciplines
It does. But why can't LaTex produce png or something? Why does it have to be either pdf or pretty much abandon the idea of typesetting? Or am I misunderstanding?
oh_my_goodness··on Accessible open textbooks in math-heavy disciplines
Uh ... where is it written that LaTeX can only provide pdf output?

Turn that around. Thought experiment. Say we work like pigdogs for 5 years and we completely replace all of Latex except the part that produces pdf. What value have we provided to users at that point?

oh_my_goodness··on Chimpanzees act as 'engineers', choosing materials to make tools
The bombs are real. We really are built on an animal substrate, at least.

On the other hand I think very few 'nonhuman animals' could have the discussion we're having right now. Maybe none of them.

Supposedly the Romans had some horrible bullshit about "half beast, half god." To me even that superstitious nonsense is better than the heuristics we have today for describing what a human is. I agree that we can be worse than animals. It also seems clear that we can be better than animals.

oh_my_goodness··on Chimpanzees act as 'engineers', choosing materials to make tools
'they didn’t even define what engineering is or why it would be significant if the chimpanzees were doing it'

Do you mean literally "I don't understand why it would be significant if animals were doing engineering." ...?

oh_my_goodness··on Chimpanzees act as 'engineers', choosing materials to make tools
If we don't use some metric we're no better than animals.
oh_my_goodness··on Chimpanzees act as 'engineers', choosing materials to make tools
This is prior art. Everybody knows that engineers and chimpanzees share a lot of behavior patterns.
oh_my_goodness··on Alphabet spins out Taara – Internet over lasers
The internet is already over lasers, but I guess this is a free space thing.
oh_my_goodness··on But good sir, what is electricity?
The picture of electrons sitting in states (or the empty states without electrons) is not used for historical reasons. It's used because the next level of explanation requires partial differential equations.
oh_my_goodness··on Gig workers worked more but earned less in 2024, a new study shows
Yeah Uber makes sense if someone else pays for the car, and you're not paying your own rent.
oh_my_goodness··on Why Quantum Cryptanalysis is Bollocks [pdf]
"Reading Gutmann I see a disconnect from reality. Yes a cryptographically relevant quantum computer may never materialize, nor a useful quantum computer at all. [...] But it doesn't matter."

I hear you saying this: Gutmann's factual points may be correct. But he is discussing quantum computing. Quantum computing is so irrelevant to post-quantum cryptography that even mentioning it in that context makes Gutmann seem disconnected from reality.

I don't necessarily disagree. I'm just trying to make sure I understand.

oh_my_goodness··on Why Quantum Cryptanalysis is Bollocks [pdf]
Good question. Yes it is strange, because the information on the slides is mainly numerical. For example the integers "15" and "21" and the years "2002" and "2012" don't pack much of an emotional charge for me. I suspect they wouldn't for most people.
oh_my_goodness··on Why Quantum Cryptanalysis is Bollocks [pdf]
It's strange to see so many negative responses that start with vague emotional language. It's almost as if a lot of critics didn't read the presentation. Or maybe they think the rest of us didn't read it.
oh_my_goodness··on Why Quantum Cryptanalysis is Bollocks [pdf]
Anything specific at all would be helpful.
oh_my_goodness··on Why Quantum Cryptanalysis is Bollocks [pdf]
All this "mooting" is just not happening as described above. Anyone can look at the presentation and see that it's not irrelevant.
oh_my_goodness··on You're not a senior engineer until you've worked on a legacy project (2023)
So, yeah, the minimum bar for "senior engineer" is very low. Can we all just accept that and move on?
oh_my_goodness··on 20k federal workers take "buyout" so far, official says
Yes, I see, the dictionary definition is brand new. It just dropped right out of the sky. Very good point.
oh_my_goodness··on 20k federal workers take "buyout" so far, official says
There is a simple dictionary difference between "legal" and "illegal." Using the actual meaning of a word is kinda the opposite of playing word games.
← PreviousPage 8 of 14Next →