HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ohthehugemanate

3,255 karma · joined July 20, 2015

submissionscomments
ohthehugemanate··on State of S3 – Your Laptop is no Laptop anymore – a personal Rant
I've been on the "modern standby" hate train for as long as it's existed. Not because it's such a terrible idea per se. You can debate that if you like. I hate it because it fundamentally changes the behavior behind an existing API (lid close, suspend button, or ACPI S3 trigger, take your pick) without warning, and in most cases, without the ability to get the old behavior back.

Regardless of a valid use case for "modern standby", there is DEFINITELY a use case for "old suspend to RAM" and "old hybrid suspend to RAM", which have de facto been blown away by the change.

I have no problem with adding a new sleep state that makes sense for other users. Go ahead and add S22 for that exotic sleep state manufacturing robots use between shifts. S344 for bluetooth devices waiting for reconnection. Whatever, I don't care. But don't replace an existing PRIMARY UI PATTERN with them.

To be fair this is not on microsoft for inventing S0, or even pushing for it for windows devices. It's on device manufacturers like Dell and Lenovo for dropping S3 from UEFI in favor of it.

ohthehugemanate··on Kepler's 400-year-old sunspot sketches helped solve a modern mystery
I am curious about the methods used by these early astronomers. TFA mentions Chinese astronomers observing sunspots in the third century BCE. How? Did they use a camera obscura, too? It also casually mentions "reconstructions based on tree rings." What? How do tree rings tell us about sunspot activity cycles?
ohthehugemanate··on Open source AI is the path forward
Has anyone taken apart the llama community license and compared it to validated open source licenses? Red Hat is making a big deal about releasing the Granite LLM released under Apache. Is there a real difference between that and what Llama does?

https://www.redhat.com/en/topics/ai/open-source-llm

ohthehugemanate··on A bunch of programming advice I'd give to myself 15 years ago
Which is why it's so important for teams to agree with management on a definition of "done" well in advance, to avoid this kind of argument later. Also why it's important for management to understand that velocity/estimation are Descriptive for long term planning, not Proscriptive and short term.
ohthehugemanate··on Helen Keller on her life before self-consciousness (1908)
The part that really gets ME about that thought, is that those glib psychopaths/sociopaths fill an important role in human society, generally as leaders. I'm sure we can all think of some prominent political figures who are very good at arranging words to get their audience excited, but have a tenuous connection to fact (at best). Actually factual content seems almost irrelevant to their ability to lead, or to their followers' desire to follow.

If that's the function which we can now automate at scale, it's not the jobs the machines will ultimately take; it's the leadership.

ohthehugemanate··on Researchers find high levels of lead, mercury and arsenic in Beethoven's hair
Schumann believed it was a form of syphilis which causes progressive deafness, then a period before death of wonderful clarity, like the whole world is verging on a great revelation of unity and you are the carrier.

This is a real form of syphilis, but AFAIK there's no evidence other than the ode to joy.

ohthehugemanate··on Researchers find high levels of lead, mercury and arsenic in Beethoven's hair
Better than just reading the letter is to listen to the musical change in Beethoven's works.

Beethoven's music is usually divided into 3 periods. The first is really classical sounding, like late Mozart. In fact, Beethoven was a fan of Mozart and some sources say that Mozart appreciated Beethoven's compositions too. Go listen to string quartet no. 1, or symphony no. 1 for a bit. StructureStructured, restrained, even elegant. There's definitely emotionality in there especially compared to peak Classical era like Haydn. Those guys may as well have shit marble, as Mozart put it. Check out the pathetique sonata for something about as emotive as Beethoven got at the time.

Then came the diagnosis of progressive deafness. This letter is the best insight into Beethoven's mind at the time, and "existential depression with suicidal ideation" seems like the right description to me. He stopped composing for several months.

When he returned to composing in 1803, it's a totally different sound. This is the wild, emotional Beethoven we generally think of. Waldstein sonata, symphony 5, string quartet no. 9 are good examples here. It's Rage Against The Machine before electric instruments were invented.

If you're interested in the third period, read on.

The transition to third period is more gradual, around 1815. There isn't a hard biographical line in the sand like the Heiligenstadt testament, but his relationship with his nephew/ward Karl got awful, his love life fell apart, and his deafness took a sharp turn for the worse, all around the same time. His old tricks to keep composing, like sawing off the legs of his piano so he could feel it in the floor (poor downstairs neighbors!) were not effective anymore, and he was reduced to mostly communicating on a chalk tablet.

His music turned inwards, became more introspective. Themes like life and death and afterlife, godliness and debasement, retribution and redemption flood the work. It also gets much more complicated harmonically. He does a lot of contrasts, between the grandiose and the intimate, for example. Symphony 9, particularly the Ode To Joy, is quintessential. Also check out string quartet op.131, the Hammerklavier piano sonata, and the missa solemnis in D.

Now go out and impress your friends at dinner parties with your deep knowledge of Beethoven! Tune in next time for Bach: the original "ba-rock" star.

ohthehugemanate··on Ask HN: What have you built with ESPHome, ESP8266 or similar hardware
I use homeassistant, so the esphome integration makes esp32s priceless.

- integrated my projector via RS232 to esp32

- integrated my projector screen via IR module

- ir receiver lets me use an old tv remote as a universal whole house remote

- motion sensors everywhere so I never have to touch a light switch again

- several wled units for accent lighting, night lights etc

- built a laser maze with esp32s and light detectors for my kid's birthday.

- I've played around with BLE based room detection, but it's not really useful yet (or maybe ever).

I love em!

ohthehugemanate··on Roll-Invert-Unroll: An easier way to replace a duvet cover
Clearly inferior to the "crawl inside the cover" method. Where's the step where I chase my partner around the room making ghostly "woo woo" noises?
ohthehugemanate··on Scientists put Jared Diamond's continental axis hypothesis to the test
yes, that is exactly the topic discussed in the book. To what extent is this narrative, and to what extent determinism, is exactly the discussion _around_ the book. Seems like an area of interest for you which is why I recommended it. Definitely geared towards a popular audience but well-researched, engaging, and thought/discussion provoking .
ohthehugemanate··on Scientists put Jared Diamond's continental axis hypothesis to the test
It has been a very long time since I read GGS, but I can tell you haven't yet... and judging from this comment I bet you would find it fascinating.

To give a top-of-my-foggy-memory answer to your question about industrialization, here are some of the contributing factors as I recall:

- Head-start: agricultural settlements started in Mesopotamia about 10k BCE, and branched out from there. That's the earliest record we have anywhere in the world of a farming culture which allowed specialized classes to emerge (builders, rulers, administrators, inventors, etc etc) and the basis for emerging technology. e.g. in the Americas it looks like this happened 5k years later.

- More wild plant and animal species suitable for domestication. Only a small % of wild plants and animals are suitable and useful for domestication, and they were overwhelmingly concentrated in Europe. Wheat, barley, and beans were farmed earlier and are easier to farm than rice (East Asia) and potatoes/corn (Americas). There are no African or American animals with the capacity for burden and domesticability of european horses, donkeys, and oxen, and we haven't even talked about cattle, pigs, goats, sheep, etc.

- the mix of small arable geographical area and concentrated population centers led to constant war in Europe, which drove a lot of technological innovation, especially in metallurgy. Europe is also particularly rich in iron and coal, which gave another advantage to pre-industrial tech branches (to use a Civilization analogy). In contrast, China was extremely politically stable and had less need for tools of war like hardened steel.

- The relatively limited available land and population also motivated invention in European farming methods, which was not the case in e.g. China, where human labor is in many places still cheaper than technological efficiency. Human labor intensive farming methods from the 6th century are still in use in many parts of China, because that's just more effective than the alternative.

- Constant war improved infrastructure between cities, too (thank you Roman empire). Hundreds of years later this accelerated trade beween population centers, contributing to many features that characterize industrialization as it happened in Europe. Including: a merchant class, production geogrpahically separated from sale, etc.

- Early advantages were determining factors in colonialism and wealth extraction from other continents. i.e. because Europe had better guns, more germs, and better steel (ha), when they arrived in the Americas they wiped out the indigenous populations.

Please don't take this as a unilateral endorsement of the ideas in the book - I'm not qualified! If nothing else the whole question is post-hoc... "why did Europe achieve European-defined success before any other continent achieved European-defined success?" In any case the ideas are interesting and I bet you would enjoy thinking about them, as I did.

ohthehugemanate··on Stable Diffusion 3
It's not an easy fap, but I guess I'm watching people get f*cked either way.
ohthehugemanate··on Mixed Reality gone in Windows 11 Insider Preview Build 26052
It's ok to make short sighted investment decisions based on current market position, especially when one of your biggest bets from the last decade is striking gold in a big way, and you need all hands on deck to reap maximum strategic value during the temporary opportunity window.

In that phase, it makes absolute sense to reduce or cut anything that is not CURRENTLY performing well, in favor of the area that is taking off and needs all the push you can give it. When the gen AI market stabilizes, ideally with Microsoft in a dominant position, it will again be appropriate to diversify bets. That includes pushes for markets where MS can grab 2nd or even 3rd place.

ohthehugemanate··on Mr. Rogers' music was intricate (2020) [video]
Some of his early work as a producer was also for the NBC Opera Theater and Firestone Hour TV shows, which broadcast great performances of classical music and (you guessed it) opera.
ohthehugemanate··on A Canadian payroll dependency chart
You are speaking about different objectives. Quite apart from the basic "(how) does it work logically" which published formulas address, simplicity can be an objective in itself.

For example, Germany has one of the most complex income tax codes in the world, with an average compliance burden of 136 hours[1]. That's a hit to national competitiveness and GDP, and worth addressing in its own right.

[1] https://taxfoundation.org/blog/germany-tax-g7/

ohthehugemanate··on Ask HN: How do I train a custom LLM/ChatGPT on my own documents in Dec 2023?
NGL I think this one has passed the point on the tech maturityc curve where it makes sense to roll your own I played with MS office's copilot builder the other day and it's amazing. Point it at a set of base URLs, uploaded files, public or behind authentication. In literal seconds you have a copilot that can be embedded anywhere, including messengers. I gave it the root of Azure documentation, the root of red hat documentation? And the root of the ansible documentation and it's excellent. It uses MS's open source LLM copilot framework, and you can swap out models for an open source one (instead of GPT) if you like.
ohthehugemanate··on Jarvis: A Voice Virtual Assistant in Python (OpenAI, ElevenLabs, Deepgram)
Actually there are a few LLM wrappers around that use the openai API spec (localai is a good one)... so you could just allow a configurable openai endpoint URI and technically users can swap in any model.
ohthehugemanate··on Roundcube open-source webmail software merges with Nextcloud
Heavyweight? I run it (with all the collab suite features, photo galleries, and ai integrations) on a single RPi4 along with several other applications. But then I only have a handful of users...
ohthehugemanate··on Raspberry Pi 5
I have a Pi3 running pihole/dhcp for my home network, and 4 Pis as part of my home k3s cluster (along with 3 cheapo nucs). Yes it's overkill but I'm in infra and I learn a lot from it.

The cluster runs nextcloud, collabora, plex, longhorn storage, deluge, nzbget, some custom projects I built to sync my bank accounts with my finance software and to sync photos from Signal chats to my nixplay frames, backups for my NAS, Grafana/Prometheus/Loki, netdata, etc.

I also run an entertainment company and we use a Pi Zero to control our onstage LED lights via presentation remote or wifi as a fallback.

I keep thinking of other things to do with them, but this is already enough to maintain in my "spare time".

ohthehugemanate··on Raspberry Pi 5
There's no shortage of projects for this, particularly enby, jellyfin, and kodi spring to mind. The only real challenges are GPU transcoding support, app selection for integration of services like Spotify, amazon prime streaming, and netflix, and app availability on client devices like TVs.

In terms of specs a Pi4 was already beefy enough for this use case, fwiw. But the software stack is hard just because no one seems to target the "set top box“ space quite the same way. There are client/server media platforms to compete with plex, there are single.box media platforms, there are set top boxes to compete with roku, and every possible mix in between.

ohthehugemanate··on ‘All of Sony Systems’ Allegedly Hacked by New Ransomware Group
Not so inflammatory at the time. Those were wild days. Someone else posted his CIO article about "just enough compliance", but IIRC there were talk summaries and interviews around, too.

And for the comedy factor: those hacks were dictionary password attacks against leaked usernames, and a plain text file left laying on an open network share with key credentials. Not exactly oceans' eleven.

ohthehugemanate··on ‘All of Sony Systems’ Allegedly Hacked by New Ransomware Group
Many times. Before the first high profile hacks (that I remember) in 2011, Sony's CTO made a career of giving high profile talks about, essentially, reducing your IT budget by not doing security. Don't do pentests, don't do audits - they only uncover issues for your teams to fix! Certifications are an industry that sells you problems, he said. Ignore and skimp on the whole thing. IIRC there was even a great talk about how to ignore your engineers when they say something is urgent.

He didn't get fired after the first round of hacks, and he wasn't fired after the 2014 round either. I wonder where he is now?

ohthehugemanate··on Car allergic to vanilla ice cream (2000)
I had a single user whose machine would have intermittent disconnections while compiling his codebase. Not every time, but some of the time and every day, at that. This was back in the day when compiling the linux kernel was a 1hr+ task.

The key piece of evidence was when we moved a printer into his office, and it had the same disconnects, at the same times. Every day around midday. Not one disconnection, mind you - starting at about 11 the disconnects would get more and more frequent. From noon to one it was every few minutes. In the afternoon and evening it was just fine. It just so happened that the engineer would work in the morning, and his first compiles if the day were around that time. So, compiles were a red herring.

In the end the problem was the kitchen one floor down from his office, where a microwave was heating up peoples' lunches and causing enough EMI to disrupt (in those days rather brittle) wifi. We bought them a new microwave, and the disconnects stopped.

ohthehugemanate··on Show HN: Sheet Music Management App
I love my Remarkable 2 for sheet music. Just the right size for me, and easy to use the pen to annotate my scores. The scores all have to be PDF, but that seems to be what everyone uses anyway. Plus I'm a classical musician so lots of my music is on imslp as PDFs anyway...
ohthehugemanate··on The Uselessness of Phenylephrine (2022)
Do you have a source for this?

> drug abuse being primarily being a function of the existence or lack of interpersonal involvement and responsibilities that would preclude spending time and money on them

AFAIK there have always been addicts in every culture. Alcohol, various drugs, and strongly self destructive behaviors are not recent additions to the human experience. But I don't know any if the numbers or the research on this root cause you mention.

ohthehugemanate··on Cosmological time dilation in the early Universe
Can I get an ELI5 for how we can use words like "slower" about time? In my mind "slower" and "faster" are comparisons within a timeframe. How can something be slower than something else unless they both exist in the same time?
ohthehugemanate··on Ask HN: What are some self-hosted photo organizing/sharing programs?
Photoprism is great, but Nextcloud's "memories" app is even a step better, especially if you already have a Nextcloud install. Definitely pair with their "recognize" app, which does the AI tagging and face recognition thing for you on any hardware.
ohthehugemanate··on Jira can’t stop people from using it incorrectly
Sad but true. And to make matters worse, those seem to be the same environments where businesspeople make target dates without engineering, and then get angry when the deadlines aren't met.

Put another way, poor management is a human layer problem. No technology (whether process or tool) can solve that for you.

ohthehugemanate··on Jira can’t stop people from using it incorrectly
So many +1s for you.

I want to add that if the team is focusing on the present, it becomes clear that estimation is a passive, descriptive (rather than active, proscriptive) act. No ticket has time pressure on it. The manager predicts the future timeline based on how long similar tasks took in the past, on average. No idea if one task will take 5 or 15 days, but 10 of them will take about 100 days.

Once you understand that, there are many very simple ways for a competent manager to get development velocity out without adding work for the developers... and all management actually wants is average velocity and remaining work in similar units.

If your team tries to keep tickets about the same size, ticket throughput is your velocity. At most the devs can slap gut instinct Easy/Medium/Hard labels on the tickets so they don't have to "right size" everything. Either of those (or a thousand variants), when coupled with the pile of work left to do (in the present understanding) can give a competent manager high precision long term estimates with confidence intervals. No need to make it more complicated (or time consuming!) unless the devs tell you they NEED more.

In my experience, teams that focus on the present, and which are in control of their own process (ie adding or changing only when DEVS feel the need) typically end up evolving their own agile process... which is way more effective than OOTB processes like Scrum, and doesn't feel like a burden (the team drops anything that feels like a burden). Teams who have a process imposed upon them, on the other hand, spend years ranting online about how terrible agile is, and waste a lot of time in unnecessary bullshit.

ohthehugemanate··on GPTBot – OpenAI’s Web Crawler
Interesting. Bing chat cites references... I wonder how different their implementation is?
← PreviousPage 2 of 17Next →