1,423 karma · joined August 28, 2019
Currently “on sabbatical” learning more about operating systems and native code.
a) are almost universally honest about the empirical difficulties in their field,
b) are reasonably exploring the possible theoretical options to hopefully create testable predictions for a future experiment/telescope (science is hard)
c) have made major advances in mathematics, with important (and testable) applications outside of string theory
I feel like you’re projecting the attitude of one sometimes unscrupulous scientist (Brian Greene) onto the entire field. Although laypeople’s fascination with string theory has died down it is still a vital and vibrant field.
This article is simply not aimed at you, it is directed towards experts. So your complaint is a bit like complaining that “C# In Depth” doesn’t sufficiently explain basic syntax.
Once again: eBay’s policy is not to ban harmful ideas generally or anything that might be morally icky. They have a specific policy against racist items, in any form. That includes the blatant racism in some of Dr. Suess’s books. The policy is reasonable and not that complicated. If you want to buy something racist, there are other websites.
eBay is not trying to police everything, they just don’t want racist stuff on their website. That is their perogative as a business and is hardly a meaningful threat to free speech even considering eBay’s market share.
Part of the reason this preposterous “debate” keeps raging is that people keep inappropriately elevating the issues to abstractions, since the specifics of the case are really not controversial:
- Just as YouTube and Twitch do not allow pornography, eBay does not allow racism. That does not mean that porn and racism are banned under the 1st Amendment. Likewise there’s plenty of stuff on YouTube that’s more immoral than any legal pornography, but YouTube never claimed to ban everything bad. They just don’t want to be associated with porn. Likewise, eBay doesn’t want to be associated with racism.
- Some of Dr. Seuss’s children’s books have bigoted depictions of nonwhites, including cartoons black people that resemble “darky iconography,” which anyone in good faith would agree are deeply racist.
- Since eBay doesn’t allow racist items (and had good reason to be concerned about racists rushing to buy discontinued Dr. Seuss books), it banned the items from its store.
Nobody seriously thinks that YouTube is censoring the porn industry. It is true is that the “buy racist crap to own the libs” industry is much smaller than porn and probably can’t easily survive without eBay’s help. I fail to see how that’s eBay’s problem.
If instead of layers of warm/cold air there were giant glass lenses hovering over the ocean, the mirage wouldn’t be mysterious.
> there’s a mildly offensive picture of a Chinese person.
a) Fuck off with “mildly offensive,” it’s flagrantly racist and doesn’t belong in a children’s book or on eBay’s marketplace (in accordance with eBay’a policy)
b) I see you didn’t mention the cartoon of the Africans in the exact same book, which is straight out of the Klan and makes your argument much weaker.
Incidentally this isn’t true:
> Books advocating for segregation.
Or, rather, if such books are available it is against eBay’s policy and they should be reported. eBay has a specific policy against items that glorify racism or endorse racist stereotypes: https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/prohibited-restricted-ite...
It does not have a policy against everything morally icky, but it’s quite clear about racism. Mulberry Street and If I Ran The Zoo are both racist and against eBay’s policy.
While there is a grey area around general German WW2 artifacts, including those associated with the Nazi government, eBay explicitly disallows Nazi propaganda. It has a blanket ban on any item with a swastika that was made after 1933.
While some are going around to “point out” Mein Kampf can be bought on eBay, eBay only allows critically-annotated copies designed for scholars.
From one of the listed items:
> This item has been listed previously. eBay removed it with this reminder of the guidelines:
> "You listed the book Mein Kampf, but it is not a critically annotated edition. eBay only allows critically annotated versions of Mein Kampf to be listed on the site. While we appreciate that you chose to utilize our site, we must ask that you please not relist in this case."
> This is their policy and this edition is compliant with that policy.
From one of the listed items:
> This item has been listed previously. eBay removed it with this reminder of the guidelines:
> "You listed the book Mein Kampf, but it is not a critically annotated edition. eBay only allows critically annotated versions of Mein Kampf to be listed on the site. While we appreciate that you chose to utilize our site, we must ask that you please not relist in this case."
> This is their policy and this edition is compliant with that policy.
> (and even if used correctly complicate audits).
With correctness-sensitive and security-sensitive C programs like Git, it is not enough to simply assume flawless diligence and care on the part of the developers (especially since the unsafe functions are very convenient and can easily slip in to production code during testing or prototyping).
So “banned.h” is really an automated auditing tool: at a quick glance, Git users can verify that large families of C bugs are much less likely throughout the Git codebase (and many standard strlen/etc bugs are obviously impossible).
Software projects shouldn’t loudly advertise that they are written by people with the political sophistication of a college student who smokes too much weed.
> It is a market of poor souls forced to compulsively consume digital content in order to forget the misery of their everyday life, commute, or just any other brief free moment they have that they are not using to produce goods or services for the ruling class. These individuals need to keep focusing on their video games (because not doing so will fill them with tremendous existential angst)
- cute comments and snarky method names buried in source code, and
- a long, vituperative, divisive rant in the actual documentation
It’s not just about “having fun” - there’s nothing “fun” at all in the rant, it’s just unprofessional and irritating.
That’s not what happened. Do you have a source? Because reliable sources make it clear that the publisher has been working on this internally for months[2], after years of criticism from educators.[2]
Your stance is “some people might think vicious racism is bad but nobody is allowed to criticize it, especially not teachers who work with young children.” Obviously that is transparently indefensible so you have to resort to flagrant lies about a Twitter cancellation mob plotting to take away all of Dr. Seuss. It’s pathetic, and I’m tired of pretending you people are discussing this with even a modicum of good faith.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/02/books/dr-seuss-mulberry-s... [2] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/reckoning-dr-seuss-racis...
This is too reductive an understanding. A far bigger issue is that many many actors, technicians, directors, and so on probably don’t want to work with someone like Carano - particularly nonwhite and non-cis people, but also outspoken progressives like Mark Hamill. She isn’t merely very conservative, but a racist nutjob. She’s bad for business even if she doesn’t immediately impact viewership.
This is by the way an issue of “cancel culture” that is too often ignored: it’s not just a moral judgment about an individual, it’s a judgment that they can’t be trusted to treat nonwhites/LGBT/etc with decency. Or, in the case of Dr. Seuss, it’s a judgment by the estate that Seuss’s legacy is tarnished by the outdated racist imagery he used and that some works shouldn’t be continually reprinted.
Seriously this is just incoherent. Dr. Seuss himself amended some of his past work while he was still alive because he was embarrassed by his earlier racism. His estate is certainly allowed to make similar decisions. It is not censorship.
- While the GameStop thing should be investigated and the lack of transparency criticized, Robinhood’s stated reason for halting the trades is plausible and corroborated by other people. I suspect their shadiness was because their internal finances are worse than they are letting on. The idea that they were acting as the foot soldiers of hedge funds (who were hardly overexposed to GME anyway) is preposterous.
- Robinhood absolutely deserves to get in legal trouble (like “send the CEO to prison”) for its horrendously predatory “appification” of retail investment[1]. I had a poor opinion of Robinhood and I was still shocked by how horrible their behavior was[2]:
> In 2019, Robinhood rolled out a new cash management feature with an early access waitlist and utilized gamification to reward customers who interacted daily with the application by improving their position on the waitlist. Customers who did not interact daily watched their position on the waitlist precipitously decline, while those who succumbed to the effects of Robinhood's gamification soared up and up the waitlist.
> In an effort to encourage trading, Robinhood provides lists of securities on its application, including lists of the most-traded securities on Robinhood's platform and the most popular securities traded by Robinhood customers. This is no different than a broker-dealer agent handing a list of securities to a customer, pretending to be surprised when the customer purchases securities from that list, and then proclaiming that he made no recommendations to that customer.
> Robinhood advertisements use young actors and illustrate Robinhood's attempt to lure young, inexperienced investors into using its platform...[f]or example, one such advertisement contains a clip of a young adult saying "I'm a broke college student and investments might help my future tremendously."
Sincerely rotten folks at that company.
[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/16/robinhood-reportedly-facing-...
[2] https://www.sec.state.ma.us/sct/current/sctrobinhood/MSD-Rob...
And his broader point is one that C evangelists should take seriously - the fact that C can be compiled on all sorts of esoteric architecture does not mean that every open-source C program is supported on those architectures. There is a serious risk with using a crypto library on instruction sets the author isn’t supporting, and the responsibility is on the package distributor or consumer (depending), not the maintainer.
> [I]n many ways, XML and XSLT are better than an ad-hoc YAML based scripting language. XSLT is a documented and standardized thing, not just some ad-hoc format for specifying execution.
Standardization and reliable documentation really is an important risk mitigation compared to a “widespread” convention in YAML that might disappear (and even become confusing to new developers) if some new YAML-based API becomes more popular. In many cases this stability will not be worth the annoyances of XML, but it’s not a trivial concern.
Even Karlicoss would agree that this stuff is pretty small potatoes compared to the vast complexities of human life (99.999% of which don’t exist the internet, even in messy archival form).
The problem as I see it are the two other things:
- telling employees to vote by March 1st in a specific mailbox, even though the deadline is March 29th, is blatant intimidation (since management is clearly surveilling the mailbox and will know if you don’t comply). If that’s not illegal it really needs to be.
- “Protect what you have” is a very suspicious and threatening message that suggests retaliation if workers unionize (especially given the last page in the mailer). I would say this is paranoid if we weren’t talking about Amazon - they lost all presumptions of decency with the traffic light shenanigan.
Nobody is saying HR is infallible. But a mistake like “HR had a silly policy around hiring” is not as bad for an organization as “the director of engineering got drunk, harassed an intern, and threatened to fire her if she complained.”