HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

olalonde

27,826 karma · joined December 17, 2009

Philosophical zombie
submissionscomments
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
Courts have already set a precedent on this (it's fair use) and even if these decisions were overturned, the liability would fall on the LLM creators for the initial training, not on their users. The outputs would keep being treated individually on their own merits.
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
Anthropic and co basically have the opposite policy (for paid users): if you get sued for copyright infringement, they will indemnify you. That means they're confident it's not an issue.

By the way, do you have a source on Midjourney spitting out copyrighted stuff all the time? Does it happen at random or when users intentionally steer the prompt in that direction? I suspect it's the latter but I admit I'm not really familiar with this tool.

olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
Yes, that's what I meant. It's harder to use the copyright excuse for those use cases.
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
That's just not an issue in practice. All major AI labs match generated code against their training data to prevent outputting verbatim copies. They're so confident they won't output copyrighted code that they offer copyright indemnification to paid users.
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
I think they meant it as "indistinguishable from a human contribution".
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
No, it's far-fetched to believe GCC would get sued for incorporating LLM-generated code.
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
At the same time, they would be somewhat forced to concede those use cases if they wanted to stick to the copyright story. Maybe you're right but I remain skeptical.
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
Not sure I understand. If some company or open source project is violating your copyright, you sue them for copyright infringement, no?
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
Can't speak for others but I'm just tired of hearing far-fetched copyright concerns that mask the real motivation (ideological opposition to LLMs).
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
> just that it can be done and that the copyright owner could come along and cause legal problems later. It's absolutely possible to have a fly-by contributor who purposefully asks for code that reproduces X/Y/Z without a maintainer knowing about it.

If a contributor doesn't care about submitting copyrighted code, they can do it without an LLM as well.

olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
It's enough to tell you that, if it does happen, it must be quite rare and not a widespread systemic issue. It's also worth noting that Anthropic and co are so confident that it's a non-issue that they offer full copyright indemnification to their commercial users.
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
Again, it would require an extremely unlikely set of circumstances.

1) All of GCC would have to be LLM generated. If some parts are not, it's sufficient to prevent the re-licensing.

2) That someone would have to prove that all the GCC code was in fact LLM generated. Good luck doing that.

3) A court would have to decide that all the LLM-generated code does in fact fall under public domain, because it involved insufficient human input.

olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
This doesn't really happen by accident, especially where it's significant enough to constitute copyright infringement. And to my knowledge, there hasn't been a single lawsuit over this in the entire history of LLM-assisted coding.
olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
He's correct though. You would need 3 extremely low probability events to all occur simultaneously for the concern to actually manifest.

1) Courts reverse their previous decisions and declare LLM generated code as belonging to LLM labs.

2) LLM labs decide to assert their copyright and sue open source projects.

3) They are able to prove that the code was generated by an LLM and not just any LLM but their LLM.

olalonde··on GCC steering committee announces AI policy
You can use an LLM and demonstrably understand the code it produces.
olalonde··on AI's top startups are barely publishing their research
It seems you are confusing source-available and open source. One of the criteria of open source is free redistribution. If your license forbids sharing the source then it's not open source.

In practice, if you use an actual open source license in a B2B setting, it's best to assume that your software will become available to the general public (e.g. it just takes one person to publish it on GitHub).

olalonde··on Superlogical
> LLMs have destroyed problem solving, creative thinking in general.

People probably had just as many uncreative ideas before, but lacked the ability to execute on them. Remember the "idea guys" constantly looking for tech cofounders to build their "brilliant" visions? Now, LLMs have given them the ability to execute.

olalonde··on AI's top startups are barely publishing their research
Hence why most companies don't publish research and most software is proprietary. Publishing and open source only make sense in certain situations.
olalonde··on A walk through of the DeltaNet family of linear attention variants
Mathematicians probably spend less time writing than programmers.
olalonde··on A walk through of the DeltaNet family of linear attention variants
I never understood people who preferred traditional math notation (e.g. single letter symbols, weird characters like ∣q⟩ instead of writing down an explicit type, etc.). I guess the main advantage is terseness? To me, the mathematical expressions would be so much easier to understand if they were just written in pseudo code or an actual programming language like Python.
olalonde··on Our position on open-weights models
Stupid question but why should we care about Amodei's geopolitical insights more than anyone else's? I don't think knowing how LLMs work makes you particularly qualified to comment on this.
olalonde··on US Government targets Cop City protester over phone operating system
Oh ok, I misunderstood! Ledger wallet has a similar feature where you can assign a decoy wallet to a pin code.
olalonde··on US Government targets Cop City protester over phone operating system
This feels like a rhetorical question but I'm not entirely sure. What do you mean?
olalonde··on US Government targets Cop City protester over phone operating system
Deceiving a kidnapper into thinking you complied with their order to unlock your phone would be a legitimate use.
olalonde··on Understanding the AI Economy
No money is generally accepted. USD would come closest but it's still far from true (probably fewer than 10% of merchants globally).
olalonde··on Understanding the AI Economy
No, I didn't mean anything beyond what I wrote.
olalonde··on Google’s ATLAS is a look at how people are using AI
These AI threads seem to attract the same kind of repetitive, low-effort dismissals that crypto threads used to.
olalonde··on Why I am not going to buy a computer
I don't think that's true. I think most people are naturally against this idea emotionally. Why would humans not want to be special? I know I wish it wasn't true.
olalonde··on Why I am not going to buy a computer
Probably not the author's point but to me, the takeaway is that these people are driven by emotion and can't be won over with rational arguments. They have an emotional attachment to their old ways, a fear of being obsoleted, a wish that there is something truly special and mysterious about humans, etc.
olalonde··on Why I am not going to buy a computer
The top AI labs still employ thousands of software engineers. If it was dead, they'd be among the first to stop employing them. If by "software engineering is dead" you mean that using AI coding tools is now part of the job description, I think that's largely correct.
← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →