HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

omnivore

312 karma · joined March 23, 2008

submissionscomments
omnivore··on Apple killed lala.com
I use Zune Pass too and I've been generally satisfied with it. It's a lot better now than it used to be, almost to the point where I could probably ditch my Rhapsody subscription but Rhapsody proves pretty useful and has been venerable for ages now. I never could get into lala and I'm glad I didn't after this move.
omnivore··on The coming melt-down in higher education (as seen by a marketer)
The real question is, how higher ed will adapt at all. Even still, the game seems to be played the same way it always has. It's a dinosaur industry run by dinosaurs.
omnivore··on Ask HN: forming online-based LLC while not having stable physical location?
You'd be better off getting an LLC and just using a registered agent in a different state, where it's cheaper to do so. Wyoming has no corporate taxes of any kind and its the first state in the nation to create the LLC. You could do it through Legalzoom for less than $200
omnivore··on BlackBerry Billionaire Has the N.H.L. Buzzing
The New York Metro area has 3 teams. All have had varying degrees of success and the Rangers are the dominant team, but New Jersey plays in an arena too close to New York and the Islanders play too far from the city.

The Hamilton-Buffalo connection is overrated. People in Hamilton don't support the Sabres and you see lots of Habs fans there, simply because they hate the Leafs.

Giving them a team would create an instant rivalry and allow fans who have wanted their own team since forever.

It's akin to people saying Devils fans only support the Rangers and Flyers. It's just not true. New Jersey teams don't play close to the majority of the state's population, so fans go where it's easier to get to.

The Newark arena helps that a bit, but there are some problems with that city and people's perceptions, which don't help anyway...plus it's still not close to most of Central Jersey on most game nights.

Hamilton would be successful and it's not going to hurt the Leafs or Sabres, as much as they'd like you to believe.

omnivore··on BlackBerry Billionaire Has the N.H.L. Buzzing
I'm all for moving a team to Kansas City over Hamilton, just given the economics of it, coupled with the whole brand new building in a downtown area thing.
omnivore··on BlackBerry Billionaire Has the N.H.L. Buzzing
The 5 worst drawing teams in the NHL are: NY Islanders, Atlanta (Expansion), Phoenix (move from Winnipeg), Nashville (expansion) and Colorado (move from Quebec City).

http://sports.espn.go.com/nhl/attendance

Denver is a saturated 4-team market and a weak link team. None of these teams made the playoffs this year and each has their own endemic problems, but I'd argue that the Islanders probably need a new building, but that's not going to happen most likely. The others suffer from playing non-traditional markets and Colorado is fickle about anything other than Broncos, though they'll support a team like crazy so long as they're winning.

Florida and Columbus are 6th and 7th worst in attendance and both are expansion teams that have had limited success (Florida made the Cup Finals some years ago..but haven't been good since and Columbus get swept from the playoffs this year)

Contraction shouldn't happen, but...moving some teams around to better markets ought to and I think this Coyotes move will open that door.

omnivore··on BlackBerry Billionaire Has the N.H.L. Buzzing
I think they're going to eventually cave in. The NHL needs any success stories it can cultivate. Copps in Hamilton isn't exactly a modern arena and it would certainly leave Glendale with an empty arena with no major league team in it...and I can understand Bettman not wanting to alienate a market that built a facility for his (poorly thought out) southern strategy, but I think Team Canada will eventually prevail in this one, as to the casual fan, there's little reason to keep teams in places that aren't successful.

I hope it's the domino effect necessary to remove a few other teams in bad markets over the next few years. Couple that with a TV deal that actually makes sense or gives the league more exposure and I think NHL could solidify itself back into somewhat of the mainstream.

It's still more popular than MLS and that's the only fringe threat for 4th major sport status and I doubt that'll change given MLS will never be the home to the best players in the world unless a lot of rich people start buying MLS franchises and decide to turn the league into their version of the EPL.

omnivore··on Nate Silver: Does race affect votes?
The parties flipped. Blacks were heavy Republican voters due to Lincoln until the 1950s when it started to shift. Edward Brooke, the first black US Senator since Reconstruction was a Massachusetts Republican.

Things didn't really shift until the Civil Rights Acts in the 1960s were passed, coupled with Great Society programs of Johnson, that put blacks in the Democratic camp for good and sent Dixiecrats to the GOP.

omnivore··on Nate Silver: Does race affect votes?
I think it's more an issue of voting for one's self-interest, rather than say, voting for a particular race. It's why for instance, GOP Chair Michael Steele didn't win a senate race in Maryland over a white candidate.

It's not so much about voting for race, as much as it's voting for a candidate that is more likely to understand your experience and as a result, will be "thinking of you" as he or she makes decisions.

It explains why so few minorities (Specifically, blacks) have made it to the Senate since Reconstruction.

omnivore··on Nate Silver: Does race affect votes?
Corrupt mayors aren't the only reasons those cities languished. You lose banks, big box retailers at a time when people still shopped at them and have a rise in crime due to all of the jobs being shipped to the suburbs and your cities would go to hell in a handbasket too.

Corrupt mayors didn't help, but let's not act as if this was some sort of problem that was borne solely out of poor management.

omnivore··on How Dumping TV Allowed Me to Quit My Job
Same. I might watch an hour of television combined in a week unless they're something specific I want to see. And that's rare these days.
omnivore··on Ask HN: Cost of 1 Person LLC
Used legalzoom.com and incorporated in Wyoming. It's the best price to do it and best LLC law anywhere.
omnivore··on The Seth Godin Apprentices
The fact that he chose them, is quite telling.
omnivore··on More than 20% of self-made billionaires never completed college
Having gone from working in higher ed to my own startup, I've always been a proponent of people waiting to go to college or doing other things. I just realize that for a lot of folks, it's just not very good advice and they can increase the likelihood of success, if they go to school for one reason or another.
omnivore··on More than 20% of self-made billionaires never completed college
I certainly didn't tell everyone to create startups. But reading here, that's what it seems like it trends towards.

If you're over the age of 27, your example just doesn't count. It's not nearly as easy today to do what you did, than it was a decade ago. The economy has changed dramatically and ancedotal experiences aside, it's hardly a blueprint for mass success.

There is no inverse relationship between "hard work" and "success" in a startup. But that's a fallacy that a lot of folks here seem to believe. If it worked for you, that's great. But it's not some sort of reality for everyone.

omnivore··on More than 20% of self-made billionaires never completed college
And if you fail, go back to college and get the degree.

You say that no one cares. But job postings all over the web pretty much speak the opposite. Google doesn't just want degrees, they want degrees from top schools.

So sure, if someone wants to work for a fly-by-night operation that MIGHT strike it rich, have a blast.

But if they actually want health insurance someday, then it might be handy to get the degree about the way.

People ask if you went to college and if you graduated, after that, no one cares it's true. But without it, you better have a compelling story or have contacts that "won't care."

Ten years ago or more, you could easily get away without having a degree. But graduating NOW and expecting to do that? Yeah right.

And if it were easy to take 4 years and learn to program and "make money doing it" without the slightest clue how to get there, then everyone would do it.

College affords you more than enough free time to "learn to program on the side to make money doing it" while also giving you a backup plan, in case your brilliant plans don't work out.

omnivore··on More than 20% of self-made billionaires never completed college
Aah, more of this madness. The only people who can afford to drop out of college to pursue a startup are those with parents who will subsidize them while they do it, have extensive contacts or those who get very, very lucky.

It's just not practical advice and society doesn't treat folks in the status quo particularly well who do so. You might get far, but inevitably you'll get stuck in a rut somewhere along the way, if you end up out of startupland, because of your lack of an degree or sometimes, an advanced degree or two.

It's not fair, but that's the way the world is. If brilliant folks were more interested in finding ways to bust the higher ed/accreditation monopoly, rather than building the next Facebook or Twitter-killer, perhaps we can solve this problem before our kids become adults.

omnivore··on Virtual Leagues Fold, Forcing Gamers to Find Actual Jobs
I was thinking that too. A bitter copy editor must've enjoyed writing that headline.
omnivore··on Ask HN: Review My Web App - OnMyMission.com - LDS Missionary Profiles
I actually think, in this case, being a niche app is much better..especially given the niche he's selected. He's addressing a real problem with an audience that something like this would be a fantastic boon for. Going beyond that would make it too general and would change the entire way it's marketed and approached.

I think keeping it only for LDS missionaries and MAYBE expanding it at some point beyond that to other youth missionaries abroad would be as far as it ought to go.

Being the "go-to" site for a particular segment is a winning formula here, not trying to be an "everyman" site to an audience that doesn't have a compelling reason to adopt something like this, whereas, the LDS missionary target audience doesn't have an alternative and it's rare that anyone would think to target them, so that helps a lot in this case.

omnivore··on Ask HN: Review My Web App - OnMyMission.com - LDS Missionary Profiles
Really good niche to target, especially for missionaries in places with bad mail service. I think the design fits the target audience well and it should be interesting to see how well it takes off for you.
omnivore··on Ask HN: Deciding between microISV and something bigger
I think starting something small, making money and having success is how you decide whether to grow that project bigger or taking the money and pushing it into something else.

When you don't have the advantage of resources or time to devote to a home run, it seems hitting lots of singles could have a much better effect and while the results are the same, the ways to accomplish your goal are more attainable.

I've found trying to go after "big" projects without building small ones successfully is too much of a gamble. Small successes + networking + revenue generation = the opportunity to seek out something bigger when the time is right.

Otherwise, you're probably wasting your time.

omnivore··on Can Opera Ever Become Popular?
I use it on my blackberry, because it works a lot better than the browser it ships with. But that's it since it first released and I used it some.
omnivore··on College dropout makes $100,000 a year, with a two-day workweek
Great article. He did his homework, targeted his audience and finally sees a payoff. But it took him 10 years of working in a nursery school and babysitting and party hosting at DZ for him to manage to get there. But good on him for recognizing that he had a gift and that he could make a living doing it.
omnivore··on Tell HN: I think I'm quitting my job today
I'm in a similar boat, was mulling over it hard because of the economy and people having problems finding jobs, but the last time I went out on my own, I made it work and I had a lot less going for me back then. So I felt like there was no better time and motivation to deal with the roller coaster of working for yourself is something you have to be mentally prepared for and I am now.

Good luck and don't second-guess yourself, just make sure you've got enough fail safes in place to make a go for it and don't look back.

omnivore··on Ask HN-Y Combinator more prestigious than McKinsey in 10 years?
10-15 years? There will be something better and more cutting edge in the marketplace. These things move too fast to become venerable and established and it seems unlikely that's what the founders intended anyway. But that said, your idea poses an interesting idea about the future of business, credentials and how we view experience versus a piece of paper.
omnivore··on [dead]
It'd be cheaper to get your degree via CLEP, DANTES and GRE Subject tests and get a degree from Excelsior College, Charter Oak State College or Thomas Edison State College, the only three regionally accredited schools that don't have a residency requirement (meaning you can take one class from them and graduate coupled with credits from anywhere else that's regionally accredited)

It's the only reason I finally got a degree after coupling credits from 4 years in the Air Force and 3 years of undergraduate work @ 3 schools. It would've been cheaper had I done it entirely that way and probably less than $7000.

omnivore··on Ask HN: "Y Combinator for people?"
High interest loans would likely get defaulted on, as $100k isn't very much money for someone who has a house, good credit or a co-signer who can help them get more.

It'd be a small sector of people who'd qualify and among those, they'd either be ill equipped to hit a home-run the first time out or other factors would preclude them from succeed the way they'd want to.

I appreciate the sentiment, but I think there are a lot of better ways that you could reach "ordinary people" (aka, folks who don't know what Y Combinator is and would never care) without offering them high interest loans.

The barriers to entry to capital are high and programs that say "forget business plans that no one reads, lemme see what you can create in a short period of time," are the right model, but there are status quo ways to do that and the pitch of "we can create millionaires" isn't going to do much for the ones you're asking to pony up the cash.

omnivore··on Ask HN: work from home or rent an office?
Coffee shops ftw. It's like having a ton of offices, all around town.
omnivore··on Twentysomething: Why it's smart to quit a job after just two weeks of work
The author of this post is the same person who created the site to get hired by Twitter. (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=510591) The timing of this post and the visibility of it, really, really stinks.
omnivore··on Should children have the right to vote?
I've always thought they should lower suffrage to kids who can drive, but...it's not going to happen.
← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →