942 karma · joined March 20, 2017
I'm a bit confused about why so many applications have bothered to create custom protocol handlers. I can see the benefit for something like Spotify, you click a link in your browser and it takes you to the song you want in the Spotify application. But is the NordVPN application really so complex that they can't just say, "hey, open Nord and click this"? Just seems like an unnecessary UX decision. Unless there's something I'm not seeing?
If it's a hidden service you're connecting to, it's fine, there's no way for a malicious exit node to alter what's sent to you. If it's a normal website (i.e: not .onion) that you're getting the address from, then the exit node could perform SSL stripping [0], an attack in which a website which would normally be served over HTTPS is served to you via HTTP, and so the malicious exit node could alter the content. In this case, the attacker could change any cryptocurrency addresses present in the website to convince you to send currency to the wrong address. It would be visible in your browser that the website is being served over HTTP, not HTTPS.
It should be noted, this scenario is getting rarer with the introduction of HSTS [1], especially in conjunction with HSTS preloading, which prevents your browser from accessing the website over plain HTTP. Tools like HTTPS Everywhere [2] can help ensure that you never access websites over plain HTTP also.
Also, this isn't a vulnerability in Tor per se, the exact same is possible without Tor, it's just that when you connect to a website via Tor, you're deliberately introducing extra hops between you and your destination, which wouldn't normally be there.
So, things that would need to come together for this attack to work: First, you're not connecting to a hidden service. Second, the website you're connecting to doesn't use HSTS, or you've not connected to them before & they're not in the preload list. Third, you aren't using a tool like HTTPS everywhere and you don't notice the website is coming to you over HTTP. Fourth, you don't verify that the address you've been given is correct independent of the website before sending a payment. This seems to me to be a fairly rare set of circumstances on the modern internet.
0: https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/41988/how-does-...
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_Strict_Transport_Security
I think this quote reveals a lot more than the person you know necessarily intended.
> Recently, I decided that I'd like to interview a cosmonaut who has never been interviewed by the west before.
I would have loved to listen to this conversation, but unfortunately, I come from a working-class background in the UK, and as such, I don't know anyone who would have a Clubhouse invite to give me. I'm not trying to make any assumptions about your background here, and I'm sure there are many people on Clubhouse who come from un-privileged backfrounds, but perhaps the intimacy of the environment comes from being surrounded by people who come from a similar place (i.e: Ivy League colleges, Silicon Valley companies) due to the exclusivity Clubhouse has imposed.
I think you've misunderstood egypturnash's comment here. They're saying that if the $15 dollar minimum wage proposed in 2010 had been adjusted for inflation since then, it would now be equivalent to $18.22. If you check an inflation calculator, $15 in 2010 is equivalent in purchasing power to $18.22 in 2021. The argument is not that the actual minimum wage of 2010 would now be equivalent to $18.22 today.
If I said Trump (or some other political figure, I’m just following from your example) was a fascist, rather than a Nazi, then undoubtedly that would also be viewed as an insult by many. But it’s a position that I could try to defend by looking at the characteristics of fascist groups, and showing how they could also apply to Trump. Trump would undoubtedly never self-identify as a fascist, but if he fit all the conditions to be a fascist, then it seems naïve to say “Trump is a fascist” could not be a statement of fact just because he disagreed with the label.
The article you've linked does not specifically advocate deplatforming as I read it.
It begins by questioning when platforms should make the decision to deplatform, and who should have the power to do so:
> When should platforms make these decisions? Is that decision-making power theirs alone?
It implies that deplatforming is ineffectual, as there's no single voice which could be silenced to prevent hate:
> [...] the rampant use of the internet to foment violence and hate, and reinforce white supremacy is about more than any one personality
And it suggests solutions, which you have included in your post, which do not involve deplatforming, they involve transparency. It says, "Changing these dangerous dynamics requires more than just the temporary silencing or permanent removal", which I suppose you could read as advocating deplatforming as well as their proposals if you approach the article with the intent to find that view, but given the context of the rest of the article suggesting that deplatforming doesn't work, it seems more like the author is suggesting that deplatforming be replaced.
It's a pretty wishy-washy article overall, and I think its suggestions are a bit hollow without more specific steps to take, but it appears to go to great lengths to not specifically endorse deplatforming. Reading what they have said as a call for such action, rather than advocating alternative solutions to the issues faced by social media comes off as disingenuous IMO.
Edit: Looking further into this, Darknetlive is apparently already serving phishing links according to a signed statement from its operators. I would imagine quite a few people will be caught out by this.
Just in terms of avoiding confusion, you might want to reach out to mixin.one to try to replace that document with one that clarifies that the design outlined there was not used? Or publicise the actual design a bit better? (I couldn't find a link to this repo on the MobileCoin website, which is why I searched for the whitepaper elsewhere in the first place).
I should perhaps have been clearer when I referred to generic VPN clients, I was talking about the original WireGuard implementation by Jason Donenfeld, not just some random software, which I would hope you agree is a (sufficiently) secure implementation when used by technically proficient users? I do appreciate that there are reasons for having a specific client for your service, and it is absolutely necessary for those who are new to VPN apps, but I would hope you appreciate the reasons for providing implementation-agnostic WireGuard/OpenVPN config files, since your own service does so?
Regardless, thanks again for the work you're doing in this sector, and best of luck for the future.
I want to give Mozilla my money for this, but it's really annoying how unfriendly its implementation is.
1: https://www.mozilla.org/en-GB/products/vpn/#faq-compatibilit...
With something like SDL2, I would have to interface with each operating system's accessibility API directly, in such a way that's not easily portable, unless I bring in a separate library. Even something like GTK has this problem on platforms other than Linux. With Electron, I know that my program will be accessible wherever Chromium's rendering of HTML is accessible, which is a lot more places than anything I'm going to be able to bodge together.
That's impressive corruption. My mother works in one of the local secondary schools, and they absolutely do not get know when inspections will occur, I guess that really depends on the school.
I will say though, some of the content of this article appears outdated, and the author doesn't seem to have checked to see if their memory lines up with the reality of how things work today.
For example, about Ofsted inspections:
> Now, you may imagine that these inspections would be unannounced, so as to best get a real image of how a school works. Not the case. They’re scheduled well in advance.
This is absolutely not the case today. Schools have a general idea of when an inspection will be (i.e: what season of the year) based on when their last inspection was, but they're only told that an inspection will happen on the morning of the inspection [0]. Schools don't really have a window of opportunity to game the inspection in the way the author describes.
> Another way the stats were gamed was by not recording bad behavior
This whole section seems a little naive. Teachers in lower sets have an incredibly tough job, and have to try to support those students who genuinely want to learn, but are struggling, while also managing the behaviour of disruptive children. Sometimes, it is the better option to just allow some disruptive behaviour slide (e.g: swearing) rather than interrupting the whole lesson just to deal with one kid. A lot of the time, if behaviour doesn't provoke any response, it won't escalate. As the author says, if a student is actually aggressive towards other students, then obviously action is taken, but I'm not sure they quite appreciate how difficult it is to try to teach a struggling class.
wrt cheating, it definitely happens. I'm not personally aware of any examples quite as extreme as what the author described, but I know my Spanish teacher turned a blind eye while I let my friends copy my work, for example, and I'm sure in the lower sets behaviour such as this was more widespread. I will say though, the exams the author is talking about here are GCSEs. They don't determine your ability to get into university, they're only used by 6th-forms (equivalent of US high school) to determine what subjects you can study. While they absolutely affect parents' perception of schools, they are not quite as serious as if students were receiving A-levels based on cheating. Also, students choose GCSE subjects. If someone only speaks 20 words of French, it's unlikely they would choose to study French.
0: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...