HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

opticfluorine

214 karma · joined May 13, 2018

Senior Manager of Software Engineering. Outside of work I'm interested in open source games and related projects. Currently developing Sovereign Engine, a retro-style 2.5D ORPG engine: https://sovereignengine.com. Email is my username at Gmail.
submissionscomments
opticfluorine··on Faked Crystallography
Yes, with a powerful enough source you can resolve protons, that's true. They didn't make such a claim - they listed a run-of-the-mill instrument in their methods section that would not have been capable of this.
opticfluorine··on Faked Crystallography
Sure. But in this case there was no claim of a sufficiently strong X-ray source for this, so it fell flat on its face.
opticfluorine··on Faked Crystallography
Typically not on their own - it's very easy to calculate an optimized structure that is incorrect, so you typically want some sort of justification for your structure. Typically you would be calculating one of these geometries along the way to calculating other interesting properties to either compare with experiment or make new predictions (or both). The "gold standard" is... comparison with a crystal structure from X-ray diffraction.

In my field (small inorganic molecules used as catalysts), I typically calculated the structure along the way to calculating the molecular orbitals for describing the electronic structure (important for understanding many properties of the catalyst and its reactivity) and predicting the infrared and visible spectra (useful for comparison with experiment and for explaining the electronic and magnetic properties of the molecule). It's the whole picture that's valuable, not just the structure - and the more experimental properties you include, the harder it is to fake the whole thing.

opticfluorine··on Faked Crystallography
That's unfortunately all too common of a story. And with the way peer review works - where the leaders of any niche topic are the ones who will be asked to peer review articles in the same area - the system makes it very easy for an established professor to shoot down dissenting voices.

Now, sure, if you can prove that there was deliberate misconduct on the part of the PI, then you can go through channels and hopefully get an investigation opened. There was an article on HN recently (linked in another comment here) where this happened/is happening with Alzheimer's research. But it's often not so clear cut, as you've pointed out - you leave enough room for ambiguity, then "apologize" and retract the paper. There's no (significant) negative consequences for the retraction if you're already an established leader of your field (and you can still use your influence over the peer review process to shape the field to continue favoring your research). Meanwhile, the accuser is all but guaranteed to be blacklisted from their field for the same reasons - and if they don't have tenure yet, then game over, hope you had a backup career in mind.

The current incentives in academic research are broken. Sometimes I wonder if the tenure system is partly to blame - does it go too far in creating these protected positions of power that can be abused? Then again, tenure exists for a very good reason - to protect dissenting voices by being pushed out by these same forces. It seems more and more however that tenure is no longer sufficient to protect against this (or maybe it never was), and we need broader reform of the peer review system in order to foster healthy and open discussion in the research community.

opticfluorine··on Faked Crystallography
Same here - I went into science thinking that it would be all about trying new ideas and pushing the boundaries of what we know. And while in a certain sense that is still present, it takes a back seat to the perverse incentives you describe.

This was one of (and unfortunately not the only) reason I decided to leave academia after my Ph.D., leaving my field entirely and going into software engineering rather than taking a postdoc position. Academia isn't for everyone, and neither is industry... but wow, I sure am happier where I am now.

opticfluorine··on Faked Crystallography
These aren't protein crystal structures, they are metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), so AlphaFold probably wouldn't work well on these ones.

It would be really interesting to see an equivalent model trained to predict these structures. The physical chemistry of transition metal complexes, especially when multiple metals are in close proximity to each other and connected by shared ligands, is much more complicated than proteins. The reason is because of multireference effects - essentially the quantum entanglement of multiple possible electron configurations. These are exceedingly difficult calculations to perform - common approximations are O(n^8) or worse and require highly specialized knowledge to apply correctly - so an ML model that can efficiently make predictions in this space would be a major transformative breakthrough.

opticfluorine··on Faked Crystallography
While pursuing my Ph.D. in chemistry, I was asked to peer review an inorganic chemistry publication in which the author attempted to fake crystallography data. In this case the telltale sign was that they left the hydrogen atoms in the structure - X-ray diffraction is unable to resolve the hydrogens, you need a more sophisticated technique like neutron diffraction for that.

What it turned out they had done is optimize a predicted structure of their molecule using density functional theory (DFT), then draw it like a crystal structure would be displayed (a 3D plot with error ellipsoids at each atom, with probable bonds shown) and tried to pass it off as a true crystal structure. My advisor missed this when he reviewed it first - if you're reading quickly, you just see a crystal structure and accept it for what it is. So I wonder how many like this slip through the cracks every year. Apparently a lot, if the CCDC identified ca. 1000 of them.

opticfluorine··on Coding Stories: Me vs. the VNC Guy
I was reprimanded for using PuTTY to log into a remote server for a course I was taking through the local community college in high school. The head IT person said that the white text on black background looked too much like "hacking" and that it wasn't allowed. I switched to black text on a white background, and everything was good again.
opticfluorine··on Entropic Gravity
It's not that the dark matter distribution is isotropic (it's not, as you note). Think of it like this: locally for a given object in the universe, we can work out the amount of dark matter necessary to describe one of its anomalous properties under the DM model. That same amount will work to explain the other anomalous properties locally for that object. You can do this at any point in the observable universe, including the unusual cases like the DM-deficient galaxies, and the model still holds up. MOND and related theories struggle in this regard, which is why DM is viewed as a more likely explanation (whatever the underlying nature of DM might be).
opticfluorine··on Banned C standard library functions in Git source code
The issue is that strncpy doesn't guarantee that the destination string is null-terminated after a copy, particularly in the case where n is shorter than the original string, so you could run into overflows if you then ran strlen() or similar against it.

Here's a good explanation from Raymond Chen: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/?p=36773

opticfluorine··on Banned C standard library functions in Git source code
Yes, and interestingly, because even when used correctly they "complicate audits". This is an interesting use of preprocessor macros, I'm strongly debating introducing something like this at work.
opticfluorine··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
It's a native frontend, using SDL2 for windowing/audio/input/etc and Direct3D 11 (via SharpDX) for rendering. Backend targets .NET Core and is meant to run in a container on Linux.
opticfluorine··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
I think you might be right about the popularity. Major commercial MMOs are deriving revenue from either subscriptions or microtransactions, with the latter becoming much more common (and requiring a far larger userbase to maintain profitability). The trend toward "bland but flashy 3D" has been around for a long time now, so it makes sense in my mind.

About ~ 15 years ago there were quite a few 2D MMO engines freely available, mostly written in VB6. The two big ones were ORE (a very basic FOSS project that didn't support much beyond logging in and walking around) and the Mirage family of engines (closed source, but was licensed and forked quite a few times, most notably into the Playerworlds engine). The various Mirage engines, especially Playerworlds, really lowered the barrier to creating MMOs, and consequently there were quite a few indie "MMOs" with userbases of ~ 50 - 100 regular players.

I know of at least one other FOSS engine project out there (Lunar Engine, which is much further along than my own) besides mine. My hope is that if a few easy-to-use engines are made available and promoted well, another community will form around these 2D indie MMOs. So we'll see what happens.

opticfluorine··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
This really resonates with me. My big motivator has always been the challenge of all the different technical details. Persistence was certainly a fun one, though I stuck with a RDBMS instead of going the NoSQL route.

It's why I'm making an open source engine instead of focusing on making a single game - I can work on whatever tech problem I find interesting at the moment, and eventually (I hope) others who are more interested in the creative side will be able to build off of the engine and create their own games. My first run-in with MMOs was back in the day when there were lots of random MMO engines written in Visual Basic 6, and the indie MMO community back in those days was amazing.

opticfluorine··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
Embedded development is fascinating. I work in embedded professionally and what I've always enjoyed about it is working closely with the hardware engineers (this for a project where the hardware is designed and built in-house). It's a different perspective and I've learned a lot from working with them.
opticfluorine··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
What a cool thing to be working on! What scale does your pilot installation produce at?
opticfluorine··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
Thanks! It's very fulfilling. Part of me always feels like I should be working on something else that I could eventually monetize. But this has been my passion project for a long time, and I've learned so much - both now and back when I was just starting out - that I think it's worth it personally.
opticfluorine··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
I've been telling myself that I'll finish one day too, and now on my eighth attempt, I think I can pull it off. Learning to manage long-term projects has definitely helped me with that.
opticfluorine··on Ask HN: What are you working on?
In my free time I've been working on a 2D MMORPG engine in C#. I'm working on the networking code right now, working toward being able to connect and move around the game world. I'm enjoying the network code, but I'm really looking forward to getting back to shader code and implementing dynamic lighting at some point down the road.

Wanting to build an MMORPG was the main thing that got me interested in software development over a decade ago, so it's been nice to be able to work on this hobby project again.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2