HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

orangedog

360 karma · joined June 25, 2026

submissionscomments
orangedog··on QGIS: No AI contributions permitted
I guess there's a way to use them productively. I only use them rarely which means I use them when I know they'll speed me up and the tasks take a few minutes. I literally could not do the tasks in less than an hour or two, the same with UIs that get generated here, it's just impossible to be faster than the models.

> How could you possibly be confident of that?

I just don't see any indication that we're anywhere close to that. It would take a rather big shift in governance.

orangedog··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
Well, yeah, when you are asked why people talk about these models on HN and your answers are: myopia, funded support, taking things personally, and pedantry and then you double down on it suggesting that another reason is these people aren't capable of evaluating what they are seeing, then you are only painting those people with a negative brush.

Do yo believe there are positive reasons people are adopting these models? Because there is nothing in your responses that suggest you do. I, as somebody who rarely uses these models but understands why people might, don't see any attempt at being unbiased.

orangedog··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
[flagged]
orangedog··on GLM-Legal
That same stuff can all still happen tot he lawyer who uses these tools. If he makes an egregious enough mistake, he's liable.
orangedog··on QGIS: No AI contributions permitted
> I guess let's just ignore the evidence, then.

There isn't any evidence. It's pretty much all anecdotal. I can only speak from my experience.

> People only say this about things that they want. Ignoring the consequences of one's actions is not a neutral position. Societies are perfectly capable of banning things (yeah, you can probably sneak a local model through a hypothetical law, but it would end the industrial scale problems).

We're not going to ban these models, though. Which means we have to figure out how best to live with them.

orangedog··on QGIS: No AI contributions permitted
It's just from my personal experience when I rarely use Claude, I can get it to produce things in minutes that would take me hours. They're not shitty, I can review what's been generated and it's better than I would have done. Similarly with the UIs we build here, they would take days or weeks and we can put them together in a few hours.

I can't speak to you other issues but these are here to stay and I think the only realistic way forward is to learn how to use them.

orangedog··on QGIS: No AI contributions permitted
I've encountered plenty of it on HN and elsewhere, I just don't share your view of the space.
orangedog··on QGIS: No AI contributions permitted
Thanks but I'm not going to watch it.

> people are simultaneously much more easily impressed and often lack the skill to properly evaluate the output they're getting

Yes, this is the exact sentiment expressed. That the praise you see is because of these people with low-horsepower who aren't capable of evaluating their own experiences.

orangedog··on QGIS: No AI contributions permitted
I just think this speaks more to people observing different things and taking that as ground truth. I notice the people who are critical of these tools because like the above post and yours, they are relentlessly critical without ceding basic things like people are excited about these tools because they are useful. I have 0 doubts some people are seeing 5x productivity boosts because of the stuff that is regularly posted on HN - stuff that used to take months taking days.

I'm not a booster, I barely use these tools but what I notice is the two apparent "sides" that people have shifted into and really I don't think that' necessary because these are just tools that have adnvantages and disadvantages.

orangedog··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI contributions
You're again reverting to the only reason people like these is because they're stupid.

People are writing entire apps in days. You're just jaded if that isn't impressive to you.

orangedog··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
I don't observe the same things on HN that you do. I see a variety of sentiment - positive, negative, low-effort and high-effort.
orangedog··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI contributions
The only "binary thinking" I'm using is not assuming that the reasons that people support these tools are all negative (myopic and arrogant, false sentiment, defensiveness, and pedantism).

You didn't even try to suggest that a lot of people are using these tools for positive reasons. Who is being myopic and arrogant? Who is engaging in binary thinking?

Consider that some people simplye find that these tools work for them.

orangedog··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
Then you aren't going to get to why people are using these tools because a lot of intelligent people are using them.
orangedog··on QGIS bans AI assisted contributions
I'm not selling anything.
orangedog··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
I didn't say that dumb people don't exist, I think positing that the reason people like these tools is because actually they're stupid isn't very compelling.
orangedog··on QGIS bans AI assisted contributions
But the majority of positive sentiment probably isn't turfed. HN is not that important, it's a small forum. Is some money being spent to boost the image of the industry. Probably. But if you read most comment sections, they are organic users which are posting positive things.
orangedog··on QGIS enacts moratorium on AI assisted contributions
> 1. The people on HN tend to think they're very clever, but they're often not as clever as they think they are. That has a lot of wide-ranging implications, from classic "engineer's disease" thinking to stuff a lot dumber.

I don't think suggesting that people are stupid is a very good argument. I think part of the reason people are for it is post like yours which are rude and not in good faith.

I'd imagine why as many people are for it on HN is for many people, it just works. Now imagine this snark about not being as clever as you think you are just because you enjoy using a tool. What's that going to do? Cause you to dig your feet in because you're being told the real reason you like these tools is because you're not very clever or you take things as a personal criticism. Yes, being told you think you are clever but you aren't really is personal.

I don't think you're posting in good faith. I certainly don't think you're going to get the real reasons people support this stuff when you act like they're stupid or suggest a lot of this is being turfed. People are using these tools because they work.

Your post says more about you than it does supporters.

orangedog··on No Man Is an Island
Isn't the fact that "anybody" can sit down and write a clone of Illustrator without years of work incredibly liberating?

If the tradeoff is giving up attribution, then is that worth giving this power to other people? This has and will made things that were previously impossible possible.

I think theft is a pretty strong term since what's been "stolen" is now freely available to everyone. People will have to find newer forms of motivation.

None of this work was previously found or accessible by people unless it found the right venues. For example, many people have written languages, only a few have gotten lucky enough to get on HN and get people even paying attention to them. In this new world, it's really not any different. If you find the right venues, people will know what you've created, if you don't as before, nobody will care or know.

orangedog··on Show HN: Quake ported to safe Rust, playable in browser
They said they worked on it over about 4 months. I'm assuming that takes a pretty decent amount of prompting and therefore effort and learning.
orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
What would proof look like for you?

I suspect you don't hold other news stories to the same standards We have a claim from a company and the media is reporting on it.

orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
What proof would be acceptable? That could just as easily be made up.

"Proof" isn't the baseline for reporting on things.

orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
WP is not the NYT.
orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
This isn't an extraordinary claim. Iran is at war, they have a propaganda arm, it would be shocking if they weren't doing this.

What exactly would meet your standard of proof?

Once again, they quote an editor of one of the outlets that ran these stories. The entire article falls apart if the fake journalist is actually a real journalist; this makes it very easy to confirm.

orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
> The campaign placed about 100 fake articles across at least 20 news outlets, the company said.

The entire article is couched in terms like this, showing it's what the company is claiming. How exactly would you push back against internal data a company is using?

Once again, should they just not report on it?

orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
What about the editor that ran one of the articles agreeing that he didn't vet it

You still aren't providing any evidence to suggest why the article is invalid.

orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
You first need to show that this article is lying or incorrect. Otherwise I can just bring up that same article for every single media artifle ever posted and suggest that because the media was wrong once I can't trust any media.
orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
It's because the first comment is basically whataboutism. It's no even just complaining about Israel, it says that essentially WP reporting on it is somehow invalid.
orangedog··on Iranian campaign planted fake articles in real U.S. publications using ChatGPT
Should they just not report on it?
orangedog··on Show HN: Quake ported to safe Rust, playable in browser
Devs have been wasting time and money on projects for decades. Somebody does something novel and complete and now we want to shit on it?

Why comment if all you have is negativity.

orangedog··on Show HN: Quake ported to safe Rust, playable in browser
Is the point of somebody's project to make you feel something inside? Up your curiosity.

It's amazing it is even possible.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →