HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ordinaryperson

2,156 karma · joined December 13, 2016

submissionscomments
ordinaryperson··on What No One Is Reporting About Caster Semenya: She Has XY Chromosomes
How would this work? Some Olympic distances are:

-Sprints (100m, 200m, 400m),

-Middle distance (800m, 1500m)

-Long distance (3000m Steeplechase, 5000m, 10,000m)

-Hurdles (110/100m, 400m)

-Relays (4x100m, 4x400m)

Men would dominate every distance, you'd have no women competing.

More cynically I'd point out that all high-level athletics are really television shows and the audience (deservedly) wants women's sports.

To me the solution is a new intersex category.

ordinaryperson··on I Can’t Answer Standardized Test Questions About My Own Poems (2017)
Yes, and she generalizes about all testing organizations. To repeat hear exact line in full context:

> Dose of reality: test makers are for-profit organizations. My poems are a whole lot cheaper than Mary Oliver’s or Jane Kenyon’s, so there’s that.

She does not say, "Texas state test makers..." -- she just says "test makers." She singles out STAAR in the rest of the article but that graph explicitly says "test makers."

ordinaryperson··on I Can’t Answer Standardized Test Questions About My Own Poems (2017)
> Dose of reality: test makers are for-profit organizations

The College Board, the maker of the SAT and Advanced Placement (AP) exams, is a not-for-profit organization. While the test in question the author refers to is the Texas state assessment tests (STAAR), it is factually incorrect to say test makers are for-profit organizations.

ordinaryperson··on The End of Being a Duke Professor and What It Means for the Future of Higher Ed
Interesting. Corporate America has been a similar experience for me but it's obviously you're much less emotionally and personally invested in each corporate opportunity. Thanks for sharing.
ordinaryperson··on The End of Being a Duke Professor and What It Means for the Future of Higher Ed
Great feedback. Can you tell us more about your decision to leave? Besides the family stuff, what kind of "administrative nightmares" were you dealing with?
ordinaryperson··on The End of Being a Duke Professor and What It Means for the Future of Higher Ed
Yep. I'm not disputing the injustice (at least, as his essay lays it out -- some comments on the article tell a different story of him being difficult to work with).

But contracts not being renewed -- happens all the time in the "real" world. My point is just: good people don't get their contracts renewed all the time, often for silly or dumb reasons, and it's not some cosmic injustice because most people find another job.

The fact that finding one of these jobs is so difficult should not change the basic risk/reward stature of at-will employment.

ordinaryperson··on The End of Being a Duke Professor and What It Means for the Future of Higher Ed
While I agree and sympathize with Professor Charney's on one level, on another the real problem (IMHO) is the lack of legit opportunities in Higher Ed.

In the corporate world people are fired or let go for silly reasons or non-reasons all the time: that's at-will employment. But for people in most fields they just find another job and move on; the problem here is there aren't many opportunities to teach at a prestigious university, at least not at anything resembling a living wage.

Years ago I was working for this one tech company who terminated a guy in his late 50s who'd been there over 30 years. I ran into him crying in the bathroom -- he asked me at his age, what was he going to do?

Two wrongs don't make a right -- but making people unfireable (tenure) doesn't seem fair either.

Hope Professor Charney finds another gig but I don't know if it's the outrage he presents it as here.

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
You think that's a good description?

"Something is partially explained by a combination of numbers"?

That says nothing semantic of value. Better to exaggerate the causal relationship and give a sense of meaning than offer meaningless generics like that, because at least the general reader intuits a sense of the universe of the relationship. The above implies nothing.

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Lol. I was giving a basic intro for the 99% of readers who don't care about "kernel density" or controlling for output variables -- the fact that you conflate such an attempt with a "quantitative analysis" (which it was not) coupled with your unwillingness or inability to give a plain English description just proves my point.
ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
"less wrong" -- as if what's important is a gradient of "wrongness" and just helping the average person understand stuff without technical jargon.
ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Kernel density, bootstrap, using prior distribution, increment the derivative...all this stuff is so far above and beyond the ordinary person.

You and a couple of others have provided plenty of context for the serious data scientist who wants to understand the exact nature of the relationship between these two variables, but 99% of readers do not understand much less want to read about "kernel density".

Again, my challenge remains open: instead of complaining about inaccuracy, try to render the relationship in plain English.

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
I'm sorry, I'm not following your description.

Saying there is a quantitative strength to a relationship is, to a regular person, meaningless. Am I .56 in love with my wife?

Can I fit in a straight line to her?

These are not good descriptions. Of course HN is full of data scientists who wildly object to oversimplifying statistical relationships -- luckily you are here to give the detailed mathematical context. But these are not simplified descriptions for a general audience.

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
To you this is the major responsibility, but not to everyone.

I'm getting this response to my statement, from you and many other data scientists, who can't accept oversimplifying math, but all of whom have failed to produce a general description in plain English.

In some ways it's like the test-- everyone hates it but no one has a better alternative. You've complained maybe 7 or 8 times in this thread about how scientifically inaccurate my general summary is but have not produced a description that a regular person could understand in 5 words or less, with no technical jargon.

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
So funny how all the data scientists complain about incorrectness and yet fail to produce a plain English description...
ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
OK, but that only makes it more confusing. You say it tells us about 30% of the information we'd need to know...which makes it sound (to the lay person) like there's no connection because 70% of the information is elsewhere!

I appreciate your commitment to academic rigor but sometimes oversimplifying things, even at the cost of mathematical accuracy, is enough for a general audience who aren't going to compute variance of output variables.

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Uh...this is exactly what I mean. Your description is 100% scientifically accurate but probably way beyond the average reader.

Again, if you can simplify this in a way more accurate than I have, great, be my guest-- I look forward to reading it.

R^2, coefficient of determination, output variable variance, etc etc -- most readers aren't going to go that deep in the math. For those who do, like you, the links to the actual research is provided.

But so far all I see are data scientists complaining about how my description is not 100% statistically accurate without providing any alternative explanation that doesn't devolve into variance of output variables.

Again, be my guest to show me I'm wrong, but what you wrote above is not something that would be easy to understand for the general audience, IMHO.

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
And your completely scientifically accurate but easy for the lay reader to understand description in a few simple words is...?
ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Explaining half the variation, and the other half?

The point was to draw a connection for the general audience, not present the most scientifically accurate description of a relationship between two variables -- that's what the links to the research are for.

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
Again, I'm summarizing for a general audience. If you have a better way to describe it that doesn't devolve into polynomials and linear relationships between variables on a graphs it's more helpful to do so than just say, "You're totally incorrect!"
ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
I'm summarizing for a general audience. I could say, r is " the strength of the linear relationship between two variables on a graph" but I'm not sure that helps the average person understand the connection.

If you have a better description, it's more helpful to chime in with that instead of "You're wrong!"

ordinaryperson··on Increasingly Competitive College Admissions: Much More Than You Wanted to Know
> The accuracy of any of the selection methods we use in education is very poor. It just is.

The SAT when combined with the high school GPA (HSGPA) has an adjusted correlation correlation coefficient of 0.56 with first-year GPA, meaning the combined measurement accurately predicts how a potential college applicant will perform in their first year of college 56% of the time. [1]

That's actually pretty good, what other proposed metrics can say their signals match outcomes with 56% validity? How much you liked their essay?

Lower SAT scores have about 63% retention rate for first-year students whereas high SAT scores have about a 95% retention rate [2]. That is, high schoolers with poor SATs drop out of college about 40% of the time in their first year.

Standardized tests have many problems -- obviously -- but no one has developed a less unfair system.

When colleges abandon standardized tests what else are they relying on? Random signals made up by admissions officers? That's worse than job interviewing.

I have no problem criticizing standardized testing, but I feel everyone who does should be obligated to propose a better alternative method with a higher validity rate than 56%.

[1] https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED563202.pdf

[2] https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED563471.pdf

ordinaryperson··on Jack Dorsey says it’s time to rethink the fundamental dynamics of Twitter
As I mention in another reply -- I'm not saying this filtering would result in the most interesting feed, but it's frustrating you can't filter your feed at all.

If some people want more interesting opinions, great. If others want more bland but less abuse, also great. Right now you can't filter for anything and most of tweet replies are a giant waste of time.

ordinaryperson··on Jack Dorsey says it’s time to rethink the fundamental dynamics of Twitter
Yes. You're right. But even that -- how innovative is that as a feature?

I guess what I mean is: what innovative features have they introduced?

ordinaryperson··on Jack Dorsey says it’s time to rethink the fundamental dynamics of Twitter
Your point about Twitter's scale is fair, but I personally don't think the situation is hopeless, as you seem to suggest.

If you have troll engagers in your feed, unfollow them. But right now I have no way of filtering replies...it's frustrating. No system is perfect but let's at least TRY to improve the status quo.

If Twitter is consistently beta-testing new features to improve the quality of the UX/tweet replies, I personally am not seeing it.

ordinaryperson··on Jack Dorsey says it’s time to rethink the fundamental dynamics of Twitter
Maybe. But does Twitter even experiment to see?

Take Maggie Haberman, NYT reporter. Her Twitter replies are always a cesspool...what if she could lock down her tweets so only a whitelisted group of users (say people she follows) could comment? You'd still (hopefully) get contrary opinions but none of the dreck that dominates her feed now.

I don't know if that's the answer. But I don't see Twitter even trying, just Dorsey waxing philosophical about it.

ordinaryperson··on Jack Dorsey says it’s time to rethink the fundamental dynamics of Twitter
It's not a good heuristic for unique opinions -- sure (see: LinkedIn, the most horrifyingly boring social network feed). But it is if you want to filter out hate speech, which a lot of people do.

But my point is not real photos/names as the be-all, end-all. How about many heuristics, and let users filter accordingly? All this data available and none of it is used to improve the user experience, at least as far as I can tell.

ordinaryperson··on Jack Dorsey says it’s time to rethink the fundamental dynamics of Twitter
I don't understand why Twitter hasn't implemented some kind of reputation gradient that would allow users to filter by levels.

Yes, I realize they are tricky to implement and subject to abuse but imagine you got points for using your real name, real photo, demerits for insults etc, then users could filter out hordes of trolls and gutter nonsense and instead focus on the meaningful conversations that do actually occur there -- the verified checkmark is a proto-version of this.

Instead they rely solely on blacklisting, which is a never-ending game of whack-a-mole. Even HN has a more sophisticated system, where users can be shadow banned or have their comments appear lower than normal.

Not sure how useful this macro-scale philosophizing by Dorsey on Twitter itself is for delivering new, useful features to users. Serious question: has Twitter released any new, major features in the last 2-3 years?

ordinaryperson··on Google Fiber to pay nearly $4M to Louisville in exit deal
My large regional cable provider recently tripled the cost of modem rental to $15/month so I bought my own.

Opened the next bill but instead of seeing a $15 drop it was the same. Thought it was an error but no, they just unilaterally raised prices on a bunch of other services.

What can I do? There's no other option for me.

I get there are Byzantine local and state regulations that make last-mile internet unprofitable or a low-margin, commodity business, which is presumably why Ruth Porat and other bean counters at Google killed this effort. But improving America's internet is a social good that Google could invest its massive profits into; instead leadership would prefer to build repression-enabling tools to compete in China.

ordinaryperson··on JSON as configuration files: please don’t (2016)
The comments of these config files are part of what make them unreadable, these are not two unrelated issues.

Yes, searching Apache config is pretty much the only reasonable way of finding what you need. But have we really gotten to the point where we passively accept gargantuan, unreadable config files because it's possible to search for the exact pattern you need?

What if there's a problem in your config and you need to find the issue? Prepare to set aside a few hours of your time to read every block.

ordinaryperson··on JSON as configuration files: please don’t (2016)
Agreed that workaround are hideous, but no, it's not immediately obvious to me we need configuration data (which should be self-explanatory) glossed with comments.

Username? Got it. Password? OK. Hostname? Sure. Why do these things need comments?

If there's subtleties to the config, put that in the README. Or give better names to variables.

Functions are not always self-explanatory and get complicated fast, so comments in programming make a lot of sense and are helpful. A config file in theory should just be a series of assignment variables-- it's not clear to me why these require detailed explanations.

← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →