HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

otter-rock

88 karma · joined June 4, 2022

submissionscomments
otter-rock··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high?
So nuclear engineers just aren't allowed to do their jobs, and the safety requirements were never good enough to begin with.
otter-rock··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high?
You said that engineers don't engineer things, you called the techniques I mentioned an appeal to authority because I also said who's practicing those techniques, and you keep repeating yourself about everything instead of interacting with what I've written. And now you're whining about a personal attack I didn't make. You took it personally because you're presenting your own opinions as facts.
otter-rock··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high?
That's not what it's called.

Imagine you write software for rabbit-mq. But then you get a requirements change to use zero-mq for whatever reason. Is that deviance? Have you normalized it? No, and no.

Deviance is when you're dropping messages in production when you shouldn't. Normalizing is when you ignore it because "it's usually fine".

You're probably thinking that my analogy doesn't work because changing software libraries is different than accepting an out of spec part. But why? If it's out of spec, it's a different part. You can make a spec around that part and design to it all the same. Just because it wasn't your first choice doesn't mean it's dangerous.

otter-rock··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high?
Ok, you obviously have zero interest in an actual discussion, lest it confront your completely fabricated "facts". So for anyone else who's genuinely interested in more than just pontificating their own bs, the "special teams" this person mocked, rather than asked about, can be learned about here:

https://www.nrc.gov/about-nrc/regulatory/risk-informed.html

otter-rock··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high?
I see your concerns, and I think you're probably just unaware that they're addressed better than you know, but in a different way than you'd expect.

When they accept an expensive out-of-spec part, it's because they can safely redesign the less expensive parts. The only thing that hurts is their long-term profitability because it'll be less efficient than they hoped.

Big, expensive parts are always treated as one-of-a-kind articles with unique requirements. It's how bridges and roads get built, for example.

With nuclear, they have special teams that do nothing but manage every type of risk you could ever think of for every piece of nuclear material in the country. It's very advanced, and many industries are trying to use those techniques themselves now.

Nobody is normalizing or bending anything. Every potential problem is thoroughly addressed on an individual basis. There is no deviance from the safety requirements. Nuclear is decades ahead of every other field in terms of risk management.

otter-rock··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high?
It's a requirements change. Those happen all the time in everything. Why would that be completely forbidden or impossible here? Like you said, it might really suck. But the NRC does not allow trading off safety the way you suggest.
otter-rock··on Why are nuclear power construction costs so high?
Out-of-spec doesn't mean it can't work. It just means you have to redo the design using what's effectively a different part than you originally planned on.
otter-rock··on Ask HN: What are some mentally healthy apps to have?
Audubon and Merlin Bird ID.
otter-rock··on LTSpice Tutorial
I also like the interface because it's fast to use the hotkey-mouse combo.

Try putting a ".meas" directive on the schematic and then right-click it. There might be more UI than you think, but it's still not comprehensive.

The best way to make it feel intuitive imo is to try any spice without the GUI.

otter-rock··on The Race to Zero Defects in Auto ICs
The categories mentioned in the quoted comments - semiconductor, defense, and car companies. Also others too, like industrial and certain consumer appliances and electronics. Search job listings for electronics failure analysis to get an idea. Their job is to find the failure mechanism so the design team knows what to change.
otter-rock··on LTSpice Tutorial
I think it's sort of like how Linux feels unconventional if you're coming from Windows or Mac. It's technically not, but that's a useless fact because it is for you.

Anyone could make an alternate GUI for any spice, but I've never seen it. Unless you count running spice from a PCB tool like kicad, where it's an afterthought.

The hotkeys are at least configurable, btw. And there's an official cheat sheet for the defaults.

https://www.analog.com/en/technical-articles/ltspice-keyboar...

otter-rock··on LTSpice Tutorial
Is this about the GUI? It's a thin wrapper over the command line program. Use the keyboard shortcuts.

I don't see a contender on the horizon.

otter-rock··on LTSpice Tutorial
FesZ is one of the best electronics YouTubers. Most of his videos walk you through a topic from theory, to simulation, to build and test. Everything he does is cheap enough that you can follow along yourself for a few bucks, assuming you have some basic equipment.
otter-rock··on U.S. death rates show how politics are affecting public health
Not every agricultural operation is diversified like that. I don't have a great source, but this one is kind of ok if you flip back and forth between the maps. They have a better map that only works on desktop, and they have the raw data too.

https://www.nass.usda.gov/Publications/AgCensus/2017/Online_...

otter-rock··on U.S. death rates show how politics are affecting public health
The author specifically said that the solution is to find a less partisan approach. Who are you arguing with?
otter-rock··on The Race to Zero Defects in Auto ICs
> What really drives quality up is a big, hardass customer.

What drives up quality is cost of defects to the manufacturer. Cost battlegrounds change over time. Currently, some of the big ones are in electronic parts elimination and reliability.

> It's rare to see a transistor opened up today to see what went wrong.

Literally everyone cuts open their electronics nowadays. You don't see it because there's no longer any need to complain about it.

otter-rock··on Eliminating Toil
That's like claiming that the government services that still run on cobol should have been manual office jobs instead.
otter-rock··on Water Pump Theory
That's a very common occurrence outside of software.

I know a guy who is famous within his field for certain important discoveries. Later, he "discovered" something else, only to find out that it had been published decades earlier by people in an adjacent subject field, and that parts of industry had been using it for a long time. Years later, there are still no new resources about it.

If you know, you know. If you don't, you don't.

otter-rock··on Water Pump Theory
Fundamentals of fluid mechanics by Munson et al is also good.
otter-rock··on Ask HN: Do you use a physical calculator in your day job, and why?
I sometimes use a calculator at work when sketching and estimating an idea, and when checking my detailed work. It's an extra layer of defense against a mistake, but I never rely on it.
otter-rock··on EU deal on single mobile charging port likely June 7 in setback for Apple
Hopefully, they won't pick a wireless power standard too soon. We're still in the phase where proprietary solutions are fixing real deficiencies, and not just making arbitrarily different shapes to sell more stuff.
otter-rock··on U.S. Midwest in danger of rotating power blackouts this summer
That's a strawman argument.

Grid ties have finite capacity. They are not magic, infinite energy pipes.

Interstate AC grid ties subject the grids to federal regulations, which are designed to reduce the risk for residential customers much more than Texas regulations. They are not magic, instantaneous solutions to avoid all possible problems.

← PreviousPage 2 of 2