HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

outsidetheparty

2,340 karma · joined December 2, 2014

submissionscomments
outsidetheparty··on Atom feed format was born 20 years ago
My strong impression at the time was that the primary impetus for establishing Atom was that Dave Winer was abrasive and opinionated, and some people just didn't like him very much.
outsidetheparty··on Changing Wikipedia's theme back to the old one with a browser extension
> Let me suggest another hypothesis: both designs are equivalent^ and you just hated the feeling of unfamiliarity twice

Nah. I've been talked out of the Reddit one, but this one I'll stand by; the old design SO still feels familiar, but the typography was crap.

outsidetheparty··on Changing Wikipedia's theme back to the old one with a browser extension
> This isn't because most people don't like the changes, it's because outrage and anger go viral

That is a very good point I hadn't considered at all! How many people are going to be motivated to go online and rant about how much they love the new ${foo}? They're mostly just going to quietly go use ${foo} some more.

outsidetheparty··on Changing Wikipedia's theme back to the old one with a browser extension
I wasn't trying to suggest that "not objectively worse" was the baseline, of course!

What I was trying to express was that in many cases, it seems that users interpret a new design as worse simply because it's different and unfamiliar, rather than based on its objective merits.

outsidetheparty··on Changing Wikipedia's theme back to the old one with a browser extension
Fair enough, based on this and sibling comments, Reddit was a poor example for me to have chosen.

I didn't start using that site until after the redesign, and am not a heavy user now -- possibly I was misinformed, but I had the impression that the "new" design was launched with a lot missing and took a while to get back to feature parity.

Personally for aesthetics and usability I greatly prefer the new design -- the old one looks unreadably cramped to me --but the one test I was able to run before they throttled me as a suspected bot showed the new design weighing about nine times as many kb as the old for a given page. That's objectively not good.

outsidetheparty··on Changing Wikipedia's theme back to the old one with a browser extension
I don't agree, on a couple of different axes.

If we take as given, for the sake of argument, that the new thing is objectively better than the old thing, never changing means never getting those benefits. Stagnate permanently, rather than pay the temporary price of adjusting to change?

Also, userbases are not static. New users would don't need to pay the "cost" of adjusting, because they have nothing to adjust from; and if the new thing is objectively better than the old design, then it will attract more new users than the inferior old thing.

(Note I am not trying to make the case that the new wikipedia design is objectively better or worse than the previous one; that's an argument nobody will win.)

outsidetheparty··on Changing Wikipedia's theme back to the old one with a browser extension
It feels like every redesign of every major website I've ever seen has been accompanied by an outcry from users who hate the changes -- Reddit, Facebook, Stack Overflow, now Wikipedia...

Sometimes this is because the new design is missing features or capabilities compared to the previous version (reddit for example [EDIT: I have been re-educated on this point; I should have chosen a different example here]), or because it introduced changes that are contrary to how the product used to work (such as when Facebook switched from a chronological feed to The Algorithm). But just as often it feels like users just dislike change. The new thing feels wrong because it's unfamiliar, not because it's objectively worse. The Stack Overflow redesign a couple years back drew so much outrage at the time! I hated it too! But now that we're all used to it, if you go back in the archives and look at the previous design... it was worse. The new design was better, it just took some getting used to.

Maybe it's just because I don't habitually run with my browser set full-screen, so I'm not seeing all the "wasted space" people are complaining about, but I gotta say the new design looks a lot better to me aesthetically, and I like having the sticky sidebar available as I'm reading, updating as I scroll to give context to where I am in the doc. (And I also like how it goes away when I reduce the window size, just as it should.)

Not that I'm saying you shouldn't like what you like. I don't envy what designers are up against, I guess is my point.

outsidetheparty··on Loneliness is a measure of self-understanding
I'm kind of already not on board with this based on definition 1; but even if we redefined the word "loneliness" to fit those terms, the remainder of the argument feels more like wordplay than insight, to be honest.
outsidetheparty··on Genders.wtf
The Fallen London one is just perfect. “Squids! And yet you waste our time asking me trifling and impertinent questions about mine?”

10/10 five stars cannot be improved upon

outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Is 2023 the year chat.company.com starts replacing www.company.com?
Good lord I hope not. For the same reason we have books instead of conveying all knowledge through Socratic dialogue.

Chat interfaces might be useful for some purposes, where the user largely already knows what they’re asking for, but they would be terrible for any kind of structured information.

Just because we’ve invented a shiny new tool doesn’t mean we need to use it for everything.

outsidetheparty··on For Want of a JOIN
I got a chuckle out of "With the exception of NPM modules, most tools are designed to solve problems, possibly the ones you have," but have to agree with some other commenters that a better title for this would have been "for want of a mature code review process"
outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: How might HN build a social network together?
"To shift the paradigm, one must offer a more fulfilling alternative. A rewarding experience would highlight the disadvantages inherent to the current paradigm."

Yep, that's what I'm talking about. What's the "more fulfilling alternative" in a social network that won't let you talk to people?

outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: How might HN build a social network together?
Well, sure, but this is "like product but minus the thing that makes product compelling.

If you want people to use a service, you have to give them a reason to use it -- "because it's good for you" isn't exactly going to fill your onboarding funnel, however true it might be.

outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: How might HN build a social network together?
You've just re-invented group texts.

The thing is: people don't want limited reach. Why would anyone sign up for a network that limits everything they say to be visible to less than a dozen people? What's the incentive? With numbers like that I could just go outside.

So many "Let's solve a problem about social networks" ideas turn out to be "let's remove or limit the reason people use social networks in the first place"! The last one I saw -- also posted here on HN -- wanted to replace LinkedIn with a network that only allowed you to connect with people via their email addresses. So..... it was email.

(Of course, to be fair I thought the same thing when Twitter was introduced. "Why would anyone want to limit themselves to 160 characters?" I thought. So hey, who knows, maybe your group text simulator really is the next big thing)

outsidetheparty··on The Honor System (2012)
For anyone curious how it played out: Teller won in a default judgement for copyright infringement; Bakardy "did not participate in pretrial procedures and refused to attend the trial in person".

The judgement included $15k in damages, $30k for costs, and $500k in attorney's fees. Teller had asked for $989,568 in attorney's fees, so it sounds like the only real winner here was the lawyer.

https://www.courthousenews.com/teller-gets-545000-in-magic-f...

outsidetheparty··on Narcissistic Collapse
Pretty sure I’ve got it narrowed down to two possibilities
outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Anyone try semaglutide / Wegovy for weight loss?
Why not just say what you have to say?
outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Anyone try semaglutide / Wegovy for weight loss?
Why the monetization and email harvesting techniques? Why not just say what you have to say?
outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: How can I report a financial fraud ring?
This bit looks like the hook of the scam:

"I provide a mentorship where I will (1-on-1) walk you through making at least $3,500 per week through routinely carding Amazon, start to finish in exchange for less than 1/10th of the profit you make long-term"

So best case scenario you front your $350 for your first week of 'mentorship', then never hear from them again. More likely they string you along for as much as they can until you start asking when the profit part happens.

(And the limited-time-offer "4 out of 25 slots remaining" is classic bait, gotta build that sense of urgency so the mark doesn't take too much time to think about it before committing.)

outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Is it better to be a consultant in a time of layoffs?
Also… pay should reflect the value you add, not be a measure of your household expenses. If companies can afford to pay HCOL rates it’s because the employee is generating enough value to be worth that salary. They’d generate the same value if they lived in the boonies, and the company doesn’t magically become unable to afford it.

Let’s not let the industry trick us all into major pay cuts, eh?

outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Is it better to be a consultant in a time of layoffs?
Which is why both of us deserve way more than that.

(But for what it's worth -- things may be different in your country but $100k for a house hasn't been a realistic possibility even in the most rural parts of the US for a very very very long time.)

outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Is it better to be a consultant in a time of layoffs?
The comment(s) you're responding to were mostly tongue in cheek, but for what it's worth the cost of living in HCOL areas doesn't justify a 3x salary difference. It's not all tumbleweeds and dollar stores outside the valley.
outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Is it better to be a consultant in a time of layoffs?
Bite your tongue. I'm one of those devs and would very much prefer the $300k tyvm ;)
outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Is it better to be a consultant in a time of layoffs?
I was an established freelancer when the bubble burst in 2000-2002. I'm too lazy to dig up my old records to get the timing, but recall that there was an initial lull in work offers, then a pretty sizable bump maybe three to six months later from companies that had realized they'd cut too deep but still had work that needed doing, then things leveled off again at pretty much the same level as before the crash (well before the crash was "over"). I had one recurring job that had used to come up twice a year that stopped coming up; other than that I wasn't much personally affected.

Later boom-and-bust cycles I barely noticed, things stayed pretty steady.

It's a very different industry than it was 20 years ago, though, so I'm not sure how much predictive value that anecdata has. This time around I expect companies to be more willing to experiment with the low-cost offshore options than they might have been last year; offshoring wasn't really a well-established option back then.

outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Have you noticed any side-effects from 100% work-from-home?
I have sort of the opposite experience of this compared to many people: I worked from home as a freelancer for a couple decades, then spent a year actually in an office job again until COVID forced us all back home again.

I’ll admit the first few months or so of being in the same physical space as my coworkers was pretty nice! There were snacks, there was freeform conversation, you’d overhear something at the next desk and join in. We went out to group lunches together and got to know one another, etc — all good stuff.

After a while the conversations at the next desk started feeling kind of distracting, the snacks weren’t as appealing as what I had at home, I’d gotten tired of spending $$ on the same lunch, it was a pain finding a conference room or a place to have a quiet phone call… it was almost a relief when COVID hit. (I mean except for the plague part. That sucked. Just the getting to work from home part was good.)

Couple years later I feel just as personally close to the people who got hired after WFH as I do with the people I worked with in person, we get the same amount of work done (if not more), and I’m neither more nor less lonely or isolated feeling than I was when I was surrounded by people all day.

I feel like I get the same structure and routine in my day from the job whether it’s in my house or theirs, and my house is a lot nicer.

outsidetheparty··on macOS Ventura is now available
I'm so confused by that photo. Are you supposed to just duct-tape your phone to the laptop?
outsidetheparty··on I got scammed over a job offer
It’s in case your marketing domain gets nailed for spamming, you don’t want your regular employees work email blacklisted.
outsidetheparty··on Ask HN: Why is company letterhead a valid form of auth in 2022?
I mean... we still use physical signatures, too. Old habits die hard.

But I suspect this has a lot more to do with proving that you are explicitly representing yourself to them as a member of the organization; not proving that you actually are part of the organization.

outsidetheparty··on Talking to your customers: a disruptive Agile framework
I think the point is more that _not_ talking is even more misleading.
outsidetheparty··on Why American cities are broke (2021) [video]
"Capitalism"

(in its modern, dependent-on-continuous-growth interpretation)

← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →