HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

owisd

567 karma · joined July 18, 2021

submissionscomments
owisd··on Emissions are no longer following the worst case scenario
Other countries are implementing carbon taxes on their imports from countries that don’t tax carbon so companies will end up paying it indirectly on import taxes if their own government doesn’t levy it.
owisd··on Reddit comments and submissions collected by Pushshift
I meant it more in the sense that (in this case) the RNC weren't proposing that the solution for this is for google to do zero filtering. They're still accepting that spam filtering is important, they just want the rules changed in their favour.
owisd··on Reddit comments and submissions collected by Pushshift
Nobody complains about spam getting removed yet you could make the same argument against that.
owisd··on Singh proposes corporate tax hike tied to CEO-worker pay gap
It’s a myth that this happens to any significant degree, your business / home / family / friends can’t all move with you as easily, so more than enough just suck it up and that counteracts the negative effects of the few that do leave.
owisd··on Mercedes EVs can go faster for $60 a month
For optional features it’s rent seeking if they’re charging much higher margins for the optional extras than for the base product.
owisd··on Up next: a lawsuit threatening your YouTube watch queue
No one is forcing you to smoke either, but there’d be armies of marketing teams with huge budgets encouraging you and your kids try if it were unregulated. I can recommend Fifth Risk by Michael Lewis if you want the long answer.
owisd··on Up next: a lawsuit threatening your YouTube watch queue
In principle I'm fine with all of that. I suspect there's not much mainstream appeal for a YouTube that only recommends ISIS videos, so you're not pushing ISIS videos to someone who wasn't already looking for them. I suspect such a site would fall foul of law enforcement on other grounds (such a rule change wouldn't be allowing anything that wasn't allowed before). I don't see why the regulator would need to decide on the same limit for pull-based search results (I've told the site what I'm looking for) rather than push-based recommendations (the site is pushing something else alongside what I was looking for).
owisd··on Up next: a lawsuit threatening your YouTube watch queue
Draw the line on number of parameters needed to produce the ordering. An A-Z or chronological ordering is based off 1 parameter whereas a recommendation algorithm uses dozens. A HN-style algorithm needs maybe 2-3 parameters. The regulator can make a value judgement that up to a certain number of parameters is just hosting a directory of third party content, whereas above that you’re promoting it and have to accept some liability for the content.
owisd··on European DSA Recipients of Services Report
It's a balancing act between the negative freedom to be allowed to manufacture and sell a locked down device VS the positive freedom to install whatever software you want on the devices that you buy. I know libertarians skew very much towards the negative end, but they don't get to gatekeep the word freedom.
owisd··on TikTok’s algorithm keeps pushing suicide to vulnerable kids
It's clearly doing some categorisation to curate individual recommendations rather than simply showing the same trending videos to everyone.
owisd··on TikTok’s algorithm keeps pushing suicide to vulnerable kids
Why are they pushing suicide videos to find out which kids are interested in them in the first place?
owisd··on Why some researchers think I’m wrong about social media and mental illness
If the converse were true it wouldn't explain the rise in depression.
owisd··on UK sets up fake booter sites to muddy DDoS market
Probably deliberate, for most a warning and a stern phone call will probably be enough to convince them not to try it again so if preventing crime rather than getting convictions is your goal then it's done its job.

It wouldn't be entrapment unless the NCA was proactively coercing people into placing orders. (you can't have a contract for something illegal so there'd be no right of action)

owisd··on The chat control proposal does not belong in democratic societies
Everything this site claims seems like an exaggeration when you actually follow the references through to the original proposal. Before a service needs to do anything at all the proposal would require an order from a judge where the government would need to present evidence in advance that they're likely to find CSAM and service providers only need to report back the specific material requested in the order. I'm not sure it's workable in this form either but hardly sounds like scope for mass surveillance.
owisd··on Home Prices Fell in February for First Time in 11 Years
Traders in interest rate swaps
owisd··on People had to be convinced of the usefulness of electricity
This argument only makes sense if you're only subsidising consumption, but infrastructure increases the productive capacity of the economy as a whole, so the government gets a return on its subsidy in increased taxes.
owisd··on The decline of net neutrality activism
Then the regulator will take them to court and case law will disambiguate the boundaries. Counterintuitively it’s the very prescriptive laws that allow companies to more easily come up with loopholes because legislators can’t possibly conceive of every scenario in advance, whereas the vague laws allow the courts to decide each new situation case by case as it arises.
owisd··on Google Search Is Dying (2022)
I disagree that whatever ranking system google uses will just be gamed to the same extent. If google downgraded the rank of pages with lots of ads and trackers it would substantially reduce the incentive to game the system, the reason it won’t is because most of those pages are running Adsense so there’s every incentive for google to keep the status quo.
owisd··on GOTOphobia considered harmful in C
Usually as a simple menu system, see e.g. https://github.com/sokrateshayraniyim/Your-Own-Library/blob/...
owisd··on GOTOphobia considered harmful in C
> On the other hand, today we have the very opposite situation: programmers not using goto when it's appropriate and abusing other constructs, what ironically makes code only less readable.

One I see all the time from beginners is creating a finite state machine using one method per state and jumping between states by calling the next state’s method from within the current state’s method. Essentially just emulating goto with the added disadvantage that you’re pushing each new state onto the stack until it overflows, so refactoring it using goto would constitute an improvement.

The fact that beginners reinvent this pattern over and over demonstrates it’s easier for people unfamiliar with programming to reason about a program that uses goto, which would explain why it was so ubiquitous in the early days of computing and given its shallower learning curve its usefulness as a teaching aid as a first step before structured programming is being overlooked.

owisd··on The US Supreme Court doesn’t understand the internet
They could rule against personalised recommendations (YouTube) vs while protecting recommendations where everyone sees the same thing (HN). In HN’s case I’m not sure it would matter much either way. HN is pretty heavily moderated already. If stories went into a moderation queue before hitting the main page rather than being retroactively moderated I’m not sure many of us would notice a difference.
owisd··on Cruel optimism and lazy pessimism
I don't think millennials all suddenly decided apropos nothing to avoid trades and take on useless degrees, they were encouraged to do so by their parents and teachers, and even then doing a useless degree is probably the rational choice since grad schemes have all replaced the equivalent schemes for high school leavers that existed 20+ years ago with no practical difference other than arbitrarily requiring a degree. Their "useless" degree might leave them with the same options their parents had with only a high school education, but it's still better than the options they have without one.

I heard this quote by John Maynard Keynes writing in 1919 about life before the First World War that reminded me of anyone claiming how lucky the current generation is to have smartphones provide modern marvels like Amazon next day delivery-

> The inhabitant of London could order by telephone, sipping his morning tea in bed, the various products of the whole earth, in such quantity as he might see fit, and reasonably expect their early delivery upon his doorstep;

We might have supercomputers in our pockets, but people just use them to do a budget version of things everyone has been doing for 100 years because they can't afford the real thing anymore.

owisd··on Examples of floating point problems
My 'favourite' is that the quadratic formula -b±sqrt(b²-4ac)/2a falls apart when you solve for the positive solution using floating point for cases where ε=b²/4ac is small, the workaround being to use the binomial expansion -b/2a*(0.5ε-0.125ε²+O(ε³))
owisd··on What does copyright say about generative models?
A good rule of thumb is if the derivative work is drawing sales away from the original work. Nobody is buying Captain America - The Winter Soldier to calculate the SHA256 so the movie studio sustains no losses from it being shared, so it shouldn’t count as copyright infringement.
owisd··on Europe makes shipping vessels pay for carbon emissions
The UK replaced the EU-ETS with an identical scheme : https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/participating-in-...
owisd··on Europe makes shipping vessels pay for carbon emissions
This is part of the EU-ETS which is being rolled out to all sectors so you can’t avoid it by switching to a different mode of transport.
owisd··on UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content
If we accept there are better places for debating then it doesn’t matter what‘s on the list.
owisd··on UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content
I think the common carrier argument might work if the major platforms just showed you posts from the accounts you follow in reverse chronological order, but when they’re algorithmically promoting and recommending specific posts it’s more akin to readers’ letters in a newspaper, which doesn’t have any common carrier rule, they’re not obliged to print your letter and can be held accountable for the contents of letters they do print.
owisd··on UK ditches ban on 'legal but harmful' online content
You can accept Twitter’s not the best place for debating either of these things without taking a judgment on whether they are true or false.
owisd··on The New Smoking (2021)
I would also put TV execs exploiting vulnerable people for ratings in the “real” column.
← PreviousPage 7 of 9Next →