HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

pa7x1

933 karma · joined May 7, 2020

submissionscomments
pa7x1··on Coinbase Sues the SEC
Not even within the SEC they seem to agree with this view. As shown by the plenty dissent letters SEC Commissioner Hester Pierce has sent.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/digital-assets/2023/04/19/i-dis...

https://www.sec.gov/news/statement/peirce-statement-kraken-0...

https://www.sec.gov/news/statement/peirce-rendering-inovatio...

pa7x1··on Statement on EU-US Cooperation on Turning Public Opinion Against Encryption
Well, if you were to ask in this very same forum if the trade-offs of private and permissionless communication, as granted by cryptography, should apply to money. You would get a much different answer.

So either a large part of HN has already been co-opted by this public campaign, or is uneducated/obtuse, or is able to trace a very different set of weights for what you can do with your expression but not your money.

pa7x1··on Physicists discover that gravity can create light
Gravity couples with anything that carries energy (in more precise terms with the energy-momentum tensor). Photons carry energy. Therefore there is interaction between photons and gravity. In particular, you can write Feynman diagrams for the interaction between a quanta of gravity (a graviton) and a photon. Some of the simplest ones look like this:

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Tree-level-Feynman-diagr...

There you can see different ways in which a pair of gravitons can interact leading to a pair of photons. If you want to dig deeper in the math behind it: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/335917/how-do-i-...

Regarding Hawking radiation, it's not gravity itself that causes it. It's a consequence of the existence of an event horizon. In fact, you can have a similar effect in flat spacetime (i.e. no gravity), an accelerating observer will see an event horizon and it will feel itself immersed in a thermal bath of particles at certain temperature that has to do with its acceleration. This is called the Unruh effect. Further reading: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect

pa7x1··on Physicists discover that gravity can create light
Gravity cannot be exchanged by photons or any other spin 1 particle, for that matter. Spin 1 particles lead to repulsive forces for like charged particles.

This leaves you with spin 0 and spin 2 as the simplest alternatives. Spin 0 doesn't result in light bending and gives a wrong result for Mercury's perihelion precession. Spin 2 gives you General Relativity.

pa7x1··on ‘Alien calculus’ could save particle physics from infinities
It's related in the sense that the vanilla attempts to quantize gravity lead to infinities as described in the article. But the nature of these infinities is more troubling in the case of quantum gravity than those found in the rest of the theories that compose the Standard Model. Infinities appear very early in the series expansion of quantized gravity, at second order of the series expansion for the free theory. And the techniques developed by physicists to deal with them ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renormalization ) do not work at all.

It's possible that the mathematical techniques being developed here only work for renormalizable theories. In which case they wouldn't work at all for Quantum Gravity. This would likely signal that there is something else missing that is needed to build a quantum theory of gravity.

pa7x1··on Nim 2.0.0 RC2
This is a valid observation.

I suspect, in practice, almost everyone follows the sane approach of enforcing a code style in your codebase. I think what usually gets lost when this is brought up is that the point of this code style insensitivity is not to encourage you go to crazy and mix and match it in your projects. It's so external dependencies don't have to infect your codebase. So you can actually apply a consistent code style within your project.

pa7x1··on Nim 2.0.0 RC2
The only situation I can imagine this causing a problem in your codebase is if you intentionally want to mix camelCase and snake_case in your codebase and these 2 meaning different things. So if you don't enforce in your codebase a specific code style practice and you would like someFunction and some_function to coexist and mean different things, then yes. Nim's approach is problematic for you.

If you enforce a code style or, if you don't but you would convene that someFunction and some_function should mean the same thing in your codebase. Then nim's approach should be transparent to you.

pa7x1··on Major shake-up coming for Fermilab, the troubled U.S. particle physics center
I think, at a minimum, we should update our Bayesian priors based on past evidence.
pa7x1··on Major shake-up coming for Fermilab, the troubled U.S. particle physics center
Roger Penrose is a remarkable mathematician and has made profound contributions to mathematics and its application to General Relativity. But his opinions on Quantum Mechanics, (e.g., its relationship with conscience) are very fringe, when not outright quack-material. Nobody takes him seriously on this topic and he has made no recognizable contribution or proved anything that would grant any credibility to the idea.

Sabine Hossenfelder is a peculiar character. She raises some good points regarding the futility of a lot of the phenomenological models that are published, in my mind they are little more than busy-work to have something to publish and survive the publish or perish attrition that researchers must endue. And she is right that is not the way to do science. It's a form of overfitting and throwing things to the wall in the hope something sticks. But this is mostly due to publish or perish. Discovering something deep is very difficult and if you have to have several publications per year to renew your contract you have strong incentives to build a silly toy model with little chances of being right. But the problem lies in the incentives that have been set up in academia. Remove them and most of those silly publications will disappear. But then it's hard to establish a different set of incentives that ensure those that most deserve funding get it. Beyond that fair criticism it's hard to understand what she proposes as an alternative. She doesn't bring anything constructive to the table. Pack it up and de-fund physics until our technical means allows us to probe the Planck scale?

There is certainly an argument to be made on how much funding different sciences should receive given their potential contribution to society. And I see a lot of low hanging fruits in other sciences that would grant most funding going there. But theoretical physicists cost pennies to our society; they are few, poorly paid, and require little more than pen and paper. At the same time, theoretical physicists have contributed to this date immensely valuable contributions that make our developed world possible. It's my perhaps biased opinion that they have had the most outsized impact into our progress. It's sensible capital allocation to keep some funding in the chance they keep changing our lives for the better as profoundly as they have done in the past.

There is this apocryphal quote that summarizes it quite well, it is said that William Gladston (british minister of finance) asked Michael Faraday what was the usefulness of this electromagnetic field he was researching. To which Faraday purportedly answered, "I don't know, sir, but one day you may be able to tax it". Even if this particular exchange didn't happen, it contains a very valuable truth, when you are researching the frontiers of science the practical application is not always obvious but that shouldn't deter us from doing it.

pa7x1··on Major shake-up coming for Fermilab, the troubled U.S. particle physics center
This is a complete misunderstanding of the state of physics. The problem is not theoretical physics, if anything, the problem lies in our technological/engineering prowess that has not been able to follow our advances in physics.

The Standard Model has some issues but it's, in principle, a valid effective description of all the fundamental forces minus gravity. The issue is that quantum effects of gravity are negligible until the Planck scale, we have no technological means to get even close to those levels. That is, physicists have been able to provide an understanding of the universe that for all we know for certain might be valid up to the Planck scale, which is where we know for sure new physics must appear. And because our technological ability is lagging much farther behind they must probe that new physics blindly, without any experimental evidence. This is an incredibly difficult thing to do.

Imagine that the ancient greeks managed to discover Quantum Mechanics. They lay down the correct Schrodinger equation, and understand the superposition principle, Heisenberg uncertainty principle, etc. They know it can potentially explain the atom but lacking sufficient engineering prowess they cannot really test the theory and verify its validity. This is the situation physics is in, we have mathematically consistent theories of quantum gravity but we cannot know if it's the correct description of the universe because experimental evidence is inaccessible and might be inaccessible for centuries to come.

pa7x1··on We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules for Americans
Current SEC's position seems to be mostly political posturing by Gary Gensler, and not necessarily based on technical or regulatory merits. There is strong dissent within the SEC with its most recent actions. Most notably by Hester Peirce, one of the 5 SEC commissioners. Something smells afoul at the top of the SEC.

You can watch a very interesting recent interview with her here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvsJM0regpw

Or read some of her recent dissents: https://www.sec.gov/news/statement/peirce-statement-kraken-0...

pa7x1··on We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules for Americans
Yes, but the statement you make above is in general for staking. Not staking as offered by Coinbase. My comment above clarifies that the specific details of how the staking is implemented matter, at least with respect to Security's law.

My non-lawyer interpretation is that, indeed, centralized staking offerings like Coinbase seem to fit the Howey test criteria and are at risk of being deemed a security offering. But not all staking is.

pa7x1··on We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules for Americans
There is nothing to rebut. Your argument has nothing to do with Security's laws or the legal jurisprudence around it. It can be substituted by "if it starts with B like Bitcoin, it's not a Security" which contains exactly the same amount of argumentative power.

It takes significantly more time to construct a rebuttal than to produce a gish gallop of senseless arguments like the one above. So I will simply refer you to this link: https://isethereumasecurity.com/

pa7x1··on We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules for Americans
Confidently wrong. Par for the course in HN.
pa7x1··on We asked the SEC for reasonable crypto rules for Americans
I think you forgot a prong in the Howey test. "With the expectation of profit from the effort of others."

There are various forms of staking, if it requires running your own validator the expectation of profit is derived from your own effort. Therefore not a security.

pa7x1··on Coinbase Launches Base
This was already my simplified version. What would you like me to expand on?
pa7x1··on Coinbase Launches Base
For those wondering what this is about.

Base is an optimistic rollup built on top of Ethereum. An optimistic rollup batches and compresses transactions and general computation. In an analogous manner that .zip or .tar.gz batch and compress files. The rollup executes transactions or general computation (Ethereum is a general purpose blockchain with a Turing complete programming language, so it can execute anything you code), computes a cryptographic proof of its correct execution and posting that to Ethereum. Which then verifies its correct execution.

Why do this?

Because blockchains don't scale. By don't scale I mean that there is a very explicit trade-off between vertical scalability (beefier nodes) vs. decentralization (barriers for anyone to participate in the consensus) and horizontal scalability (parallelization) vs. security (cost of attack). So Ethereum's approach to solving scalability is to accept head-on this limitation and instead of compromising on decentralization or security find ways around it.

With rollups you place the costly execution outside the blockchain and let the blockchain act as verifier and settlement layer of cryptographic proofs of computation. The blockchain verifies proofs, which are much cheaper, while the actual execution is done outside where you can scale vertically and horizontally.

With this approach Ethereum has settled over 600 bitcoin-equivalent transactions per second in the last hour (this is the actual figure, I just checked https://ethtps.info/ ). Remember when 1.5 years ago it was 15? Well... Now it's over 600. And plans to keep scaling until it reaches 1M-10M transactions per second by 2030.

So what?

Well, Coinbase is an exchange. A centralized exchange, for that matter. When you execute a transaction on Coinbase (or any other centralized exchange... NYSE, Nasdaq, Deutsche Bourse...) what knowledge do you have that the transaction was executed? That the stock the UI says you own is actually there. How do you know shorted stocks are actually lent and exist? This fixes it. You can see the code and be sure that it's executed correctly.

When CBDCs happen, and they are going to happen. The same kind of statements could be made for your money.

pa7x1··on Crypto exchange Kraken to shut staking service, pay $30M fine in SEC settlement
This is not completely correct. Ethereum's return to validators has 3 sources:

- new issuance

- transaction fees

- MEV

The average yield over the last month (annualized) is over 5%. Source: https://beaconcha.in/pools

Ethereum´s current issuance is 0.55% (654K ETH per year on a circulating supply of 120M, source: https://ultrasound.money/). This is split between the validators which are now around 13.7% of the network (source: https://beaconcha.in/). Resulting in a yield from newly minted ETH of 4%.

The other 25% of the yield comes transaction fees and MEV.

On top of that the ETH consumption through the burn more than compensates the newly minted ETH. As the network is net deflationary (source: https://ultrasound.money/). You can think of a company that pays employees partly with stock options but has also a buyback program. If the buyback program that comes from its ability to generate profit more than compensates the newly issued stock, the employees pay in stock is not self-dilutive.

What I'm basically getting at is that, if the network is not seeing net issuance (i.e. roughly flat or even negative), then the newly minted ETH is real yield. By the simple fact that nominal yield - monetary inflation is positive.

pa7x1··on Crypto exchange Kraken to shut staking service, pay $30M fine in SEC settlement
https://ultrasound.money/

Since the merge Ethereum has had net negative issuance. Ethereum's yield is not coming from dilution. The network is profitable, the profit is distributed to token holders and validators, plain and simple.

pa7x1··on ASML Q4 2022 financial results
The lasers are made by Trumpf in Germany.
pa7x1··on The Schwarzschild Defence
It's not every direction that points into the singularity inside the event horizon. It's time itself that points to the singularity, hence why it's inevitable to fall into the singularity in a Schwarzschild BH.
pa7x1··on “My PGP key is compromised, and at least many of my bitcoins stolen”
Ether is a productive asset, you can get cash-flows through staking.

You can also get access to debt and pay it. Aave, MakerDAO, Alchemyx...

pa7x1··on What will happen in 2023
The fee revenues come from its users, they pay when they use an application built on Ethereum to settle the transaction. Most of the applications, specially the most successful ones, the ones that spend the most ETH, are financial in nature at the moment. I suspect this is likely always going to be the case, as blockspace is a scarce resource only the most added value applications can compete for it. Non-financial applications will exist in the multiple L2s that are being built on top, these involve various cryptographic proofs to settle batches of transactions onto the L1. So financial applications and L2 proof verifiers will likely dominate the use of Ethereum in the future.
pa7x1··on What will happen in 2023
Ethereum's current valuation can be explained fully by its current use. With this I mean, if you take current demand for blockspace (i.e. demand to settle a transaction on Ethereum) in USD and issuance of ETH you get current prices. So Ethereum is not trading at any premium, nor any assumption of future growth cooked in. Ethereum is valued at the price that its current use justifies.

Here is the very quick back of the envelope calculation:

Current daily fee revenues: 2M USD (slightly above but let's round it)

Current daily ETH issued through staking: 1800 ETH (again, rounded)

2M USD / 1800 ETH = 1100 USD/ETH

In fact, if you plug-in 3 month moving average of blockspace demand and issuance you get the current 1200 USD it's trading at.

HN needs to start waking up to the fact that ETH is a productive asset, there are cash-flows behind it and those accrue to token-holders.

pa7x1··on Why Solana was decimated by Bankman-Fried’s downfall
There is also Vyper and Fe. But they are both much less mature, probably not recommended for production.
pa7x1··on Evolution of the Ethereum proof-of-stake consensus protocol
https://twitter.com/ethereumonarm/status/1432251814402002948...

This is just an example, there is plenty other hobbyists doing so.

And here detailed instructions for you to try at home: https://docs.rocketpool.net/guides/node/local/prepare-pi.htm...

pa7x1··on Evolution of the Ethereum proof-of-stake consensus protocol
https://www.theblock.co/post/104263/an-ofac-compliant-bitcoi...

A Bitcoin block is produced every 10 minutes. An Ethereum block every 12 seconds. It would take 98% of validators censoring transactions on Ethereum for a normal transaction to be included faster on Bitcoin than a censored transaction is included in Ethereum. In practice, there are miners censoring transactions on Bitcoin too, so the number is higher even.

This only shows that this is baseless FUD. Most importantly, Proposer-builder separation will take care of this problem completely on Ethereum.

pa7x1··on Evolution of the Ethereum proof-of-stake consensus protocol
Over Ethereum there are completely automated exchanges (think Nasdaq), lending, escrow, stablecoins, zero-knowledge proof verifiers, games, payments...

Blockchains are designed to meet the most extreme requirements of availability, censorship-resistance and cost of attack. They achieve them by exploring the extremes of replication of the solution space of distributed systems. For example, Ethereum runs on a Raspberry Pi, and every node runs the exact same things. Therefore how fast it goes is limited to the slowest node you want to make able to run the blockchain.

But, what you are dismissing as simple batch processing are the application of very novel techniques (novel as in math was invented in the last 5 years to make them possible) that allow to externalize most of the heavy computation outside the blockchain and delegate to the blockchain the verification of a proof. Therefore allowing to inherit the security properties of the blockchain but achieving much higher scalability.

Ethereum settles nowadays 200 bitcoin equivalent transactions per second. And is targeting to scale to 1-10M transactions per second by 2030.

pa7x1··on Evolution of the Ethereum proof-of-stake consensus protocol
Ethereum runs the EVM, which is a Turing complete execution environment. It can run things of arbitrary complexity.

> Congrats, you've reinvented batch processing.

This is an extreme over-simplification of zero knowledge proofs. You would do well in digging deeper what is being achieved instead of dismissing it without any understanding.

pa7x1··on Evolution of the Ethereum proof-of-stake consensus protocol
https://withdrawalsdevnet1.ethpandaops.io/

Testnets already happening. Q1 2023 on the table.

← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →