HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

papersmith

553 karma · joined February 22, 2007

submissionscomments
papersmith··on Files Vanished, Young Chinese Lose the Future
China's freedom seems to come in cycles, but the general trend seems optimistic.

In the 50s after the revolution, to justify the new regime on ideological grounds, Mao sanctioned freedom of speech against the state. But after a few years when the party failed to deliver some of its promises, criticism began to pile up, and the party responded with a massive crackdown of the witch-hunting and labour camp variety. This lasted through the cultural revolution of the 60s and 70s, and was enforced by the cult-of-personality campaign initiated by Mao's wife.

After Mao died and his rival Deng took over, there was quite a bit of freedom during the 80s in reaction to the economic reform and the end of cultural revolution, where pro-democracy activism accumulated that eventually led to the Tiananmen Square protest. The government again responded with a crackdown.

After the crackdown, government became more paranoid in the 90s, "patriotic education" were ramped up in public schools, though it paled in comparison to the Mao era (no more witch-hunting, correction camp, public humiliation, etc.).

Then in the 00s the internet became popular for the middle class, and cell phone for the peasants, but the government hasn't loosened its grip, so rather than ideologically-backed student activism, grassroot vigilantism were organized by regular folks against anything from corrupt local officials to animal cruelty cases. These usually come in the form of protests numbered upward of tens of thousands. To let off the steam in a controlled manner, the state sanctioned these protests (not the case before) as long as they are focused on the "local" bureaucrats (provincial and lower). In the mean time, the press are gradually given more freedom to cover these topics, as long as they are "localized" as well.

Overall, eventhough the state is using ever more sophisticated methods to maintain control, it's usually in response to greater pressure from the citizens, and the state seems to be losing ground.

papersmith··on Files Vanished, Young Chinese Lose the Future
That's another part of the reason. :) If the hole is too big you won't be able to bucket out the water fast enough.
papersmith··on Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer
I probably should've written a disclaimer as to indicate my opinion. :)

To be more specific, perhaps I should've emphasized that "modern" Asian cultures have questionable tastes, which is in direct contrast to traditional Asian sensibilities. I feel that modern Asian cultures are too busy imitating what's trendy in the west. It doesn't help the fact that instability of the past century made people lose faith in their indigineous cultures, while the western culture has evolved quite a bit since to adapt to changes of the world, thus leaving a big gap to catch up.

I'd venture that the vast portion of the old Asian cultures are appreciated now-a-days merely for their exotic aspects, even by Asian people themselves. Whatever is preserved for practical reasons don't always fit in a coherent manner, there are plenty of rough edges to work out.

I guess a bad analogy would be that Asian culture is like Unix, Apple is Europe, Windows is USA, China is BSD, and Japan is Ubuntu. The kernel is the philosophy, command line is the traditional culture, GUI is the pop culture, and the internet is globalization. Windows eventually took over and became more accessible over time with its killer GUI apps. For the time being, Unix lacks the ecosystem to build killer GUI apps, so they created Wine to run Windows apps. There are also plenty of native Unix GUI apps that sprang up, but most are created in response to their existing commercial counterparts, and many of their GUIs are imitations. FreeBSD has been around for a while, went through several regime changes, and is still kinda authoritarian with its userland programs. Ubuntu is later to the game, has the most success in adapting to modern GUI needs, but there's still some distance to go to catch up to Apple and perhaps Windows. Even though Unix is weak in GUI stuff, it's strong as servers, especially since the internet became popular.

Sorry about the silly analogy, perhaps I need to take a nap. :)

papersmith··on Files Vanished, Young Chinese Lose the Future
PRC's government is known to be relatively insensitive to external pressure, but is scared shitless of its own people. China doesn't rely on foreign aids, and contrary to popular beliefs, value from export accounts for a very small percentage of its GDP. This is part of the reason China is relatively unaffected by the current downturn.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=1052429...

If there's to be any changes, it has to be from within. That's why the government is so paranoid about protests and is spending loads on censorship. Recently it has been going after public interest lawyers, but these guys are much tougher to crack than angry peasants.

http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displayStory.cfm?story_i...

papersmith··on Mac Versus PC Debate Has Never Been Clearer
Being Asian myself, I concur that we tend to have questionable tastes. It probably has something to do with the cultures going through an identity crisis.

This is most pronounced in car designs. Japanese and Korean cars designs generally look like they are "trying too hard", especially in the recent years in their high-end models. Maybe they are going for the funky-factor of the ricers, I don't know. British, Italian, and French cars usually look the least desperate. German and American cars are somewhere in the middle. Just my opinion.

papersmith··on China and "our standard of living"
This is only true if the bar is rising at a pace regardless of increase in participants.

In reality, increases in trade raises the bar faster for everyone, often so much that it offsets the drop from the increased competition.

So say both country A and country B are increasing at 10 moon units per year. Country B trades as a net exporter with country A, and takes 1 moon unit per year from country A. However, the increase in economic activity boosts 2 moon units per year for everyone. Now country A is increasing at 11 moon units per year, and country B is increasing at 13 units per year.

papersmith··on Chinese engineer commits suicide after losing a 4th generation iPhone prototype
I think it has something to do with the Confucian formalities. This is true of Taiwan and Singapore as well. Though ironically enough mainland China is probably the least Confucian of the bunch as a result of Communism.

I've read a lot about mainland Chinese office workers quitting Japanese, Korean, Taiwanese, and Singaporean companies because of the "attitudes" and the office culture their superiors impose on them.

Foxconn is a Taiwanese company, so I'd expect some extra formalities involved in the offices. Interestingly enough, since the mainland companies are eager to emulate foreign corporate cultures, a good portions of them are adopting the formalities from its Asian neighbors. Though to balance things out many companies are also going for the more casual tones of western firms. It'd be interesting to see how it'll work out.

Assembly line workers are a different story. They are pretty much all treated like crap, since they are considered a lower social class because of their rural births and the lack of legal permits (and thus forfeiting many rights) to live in the cities. This is the major source of social unrest in China, it's mostly unreported in the west, and it's a much greater threat to the government than all the ethnic conflicts you hear in the media.

papersmith··on Valve: Let Fans Fund Games Development
It probably works better for niche projects where the participants are well-informed and can agree on most of the decisions, rather than watered-down mass market projects that try to please everyone.

Same reason democracy works better in small countries with highly educated population.

papersmith··on How to Do What You Love (2006)
"The problem with that is, like much Eastern spiritual thought, it doesn't scale. Sure, we could all be Zen practitioners, but we'd have no fast computers, cool phones, or footprints on the Moon to show for it."

I think what Buddhism preaches is more along the lines of functional minimalism rather that forgoing material production altogether. The idea is to develop a clear mind that can better distinguish between the means and the ends in everyday decision-making.

papersmith··on Meditation: Why Bother?
You have mentioned some important commonalities, but what do you think make psychotherapy and meditation stand apart from religions? Would you list a few of the major differences?
papersmith··on China's Google Maps (zoom out for best effect)
That's part of their business model. They also put virtual billboards on prime "real estates".
papersmith··on Ask Entrepreneurs: Productivity tips for a chronic procrastinator?
This worked pretty well for me:

http://www.43folders.com/2005/09/08/kick-procrastinations-as...

papersmith··on [dead]
Hmm, I wonder if aquasocks could do the trick (they're fairly inexpensive), though durability comes to mind.
papersmith··on Tesla Model S Unveiled
More pics:

http://www.autobloggreen.com/photos/tesla-model-s-live-revea...

papersmith··on Erlang Shen
FYI, Tien Shinhan in Dragonball is based on him.
papersmith··on Something I've noticed about the rich and powerful
Maybe he was referring to a bed warmer (wink wink).
papersmith··on Why America Will Remain the Superpower
That was certainly the case with China.
papersmith··on Do you know any programmers who exhibit these personality traits?
Cool, thanks :)
papersmith··on Do you know any programmers who exhibit these personality traits?
Could you post your URL here? I'd be really interested to subscribe.
papersmith··on What Makes Finnish Kids So Smart?
Sounds like education in East Asia as well, except classical musical instrument lessons being the only extracurricular activities, which are almost as demanding as schoolworks.
papersmith··on A New Fashion Catches On in Paris - Cheap Bicycle Rentals
The fact that the government's keeping a cap on gas prices doesn't help either. On the other hand, since my trip there in 2000, electric mopeds/scooters were already immensely popular there, way before I started see them here in North America.
papersmith··on Why are geeks often atheist?
Keep in mind that certainty is just a model constructed by our mind based on a limited sampling frame, so we can make practical decisions in a timely manner. Thus "absolutely sure", "leap of faith", or "atheism" are just practical labels for dealing with events of high probability in a nondeterministic universe. These are just limitations of our languages.
papersmith··on The Flawed Theory Behind Unit Testing
Nice article, but provocative title.

Essentially it comes down to that TDD works mainly because it forces you to think about the implementation more clearly before you begin coding, while the various benefits of automation come as a bonus.

papersmith··on Response to "Maglev and the naiivety of the Rails community" from Patrick Collison
That's awesome. I'll definitely give it a try then.
papersmith··on Response to "Maglev and the naiivety of the Rails community" from Patrick Collison
I find the transparent persistence and caching much more interesting. I wonder if you can transparently persist closures and continuations. If so you can do some really neat things.
papersmith··on How to Read a Book
I think it was first written in the 40s, then revised in the 60s.
papersmith··on PG: Disconnecting Distraction
I think a good compromise would be a table of sitting-height, but without a chair.
papersmith··on Tell YC: Answers from John McCarthy
In firefox, you can turn off page styles in "view". Same for opera. Not sure about safari.
papersmith··on The end is near: Henry Blodget's index of companies that don't make products and don't have revenues
And craigslist? Has he been living under a rock?
papersmith··on What music do you listen to while programming?
Chamber music works great for me. I especially like Mozart's sonatas.
← PreviousPage 4 of 8Next →