HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

parker_mountain

1,376 karma · joined September 14, 2022

submissionscomments
parker_mountain··on It’s painful how hellbent Mark Zuckerberg is on convincing us that VR is a thing
Do you really think you could use a tool that is, by its own admission, expressly designed for collaborative experiences without giving up your implicit identity?

The answer, by the way, is no. Facebook has had highly-accurate "shadow profiles" for people who do not use their service for over a decade.

Having a basic interaction graph, geo-location data, and being in the income band able to afford a $1500 headset begins to narrow down people a lot faster than you think. Not to mention the headset is technically capable of gathering skin tone (easily mapped by the hand recognition), IP address, height, and even performing facial recognition.

Using a fake username achieves nothing. Unless you use it for sideloaded, offline, single player games and nothing else - at which point, the pro headset doesn't really make sense.

parker_mountain··on That snapper might be 80 years old
I find this to be a false dichotomy of a statement: "either we eat fish or we don't". Unfortunately, supply and demand are clashing here - overfishing is a real and tangible problem!

The most likely path forward, and third option, is farmed fish and other seafood. One such company making excellent in-roads is TransparentSea, a pretty cool shrimp farming operation.

Too bad I think shrimp are disgusting, lol. Farmed tilapia it is for me!

parker_mountain··on Missing the Point of VR
It's extremely clear that VR will, for the next decade at least, be anything as a semi-niche entertainment format. AR will be the future, and VR will only take off when AR is ubiquitous and the AR hardware can be used to deliver VR content/experiences.

I think the premise of current consumer VR investments and experiences (Meta, ahem), are wasted money - the future will be something like a miniaturized magicleap/hololens.

Unlike the 90s, I think a lot of the required hardware precursors for success exist. The remaining "hard" precursors are display tech and interaction methods/input. When that's solved, then we will have at least the required baseline for building decent AR/VR experiences.

parker_mountain··on Best Dumb TVs
There is functionally no difference.
parker_mountain··on Best Dumb TVs
I'm not even sure where OP is getting those numbers, because a google search instantly found it for under $400
parker_mountain··on Is the FSF Fighting the Previous War?
> This is a FUD take

We already live in this future. Apple has 25% of the phone market worldwide.

parker_mountain··on Is the FSF Fighting the Previous War?
> the GPL is nearly everywhere except firmware and phones

GPLv2 is still a tenable license. GPLv2 also has huge flaws around libre intentions, and it is reasonably easy for a company to sidestep the intent of a copyleft license.

GPLv3, which was created to prevent companies from side-stepping the intent of FOSS, is a huge limiting factor to any project - companies simply cannot risk the implications of using it. And thus, projects using it rarely see commercial commits back - a huge source of contribution for any popular library.

As for firmware and phones, well, those are increasingly the majority of devices in existence. And servers are increasingly forgoing shipping userspaces, as they move to a more hardened and lightweight role.

The GPL is only in places where it is defanged (v2). Its use is steadily declining. The amount of use-cases for it is steadily declining. This has been the general trend of the industry and computers.

They are not on the winning side of libre/copyleft, and have not been for over a decade now. It is tragic.

parker_mountain··on Is the FSF Fighting the Previous War?
I have a lot of thoughts on this and not a lot of time to write them up. The things that really stand out to me are:

- a lot of FSF projects are based around the premise of a multi user *nix system. This is an outdated model of usage. Systems are generally single-user or no-user (and instead part of a herd of application hosts). Human login rarely happens except to debug, and that debugging rarely occurs on the host.

- the FSF has not done a good job of bringing new people in. They do not make a compelling case for their importance. I think this ties into the above - they don't have any compelling work to demonstrate for modern consumer freedom in one of the most important spaces - phones. This also ties into RMS - regardless of how you feel about the man, his presence in the FSF still continues to generate controversy that makes recruiting more difficult.

- The FSF is supposed to address issues about freedom, privacy, etc, but they have completely missed the modern age of application usage models. Web apps, centralized auth, locked down phone OSes, etc. They have very little presence, and a lot of licensing mindshare has gone to non-copyleft FOSS (apache, mit, etc)

- Richard Stallman famously corrects people who say Linux, by saying "GNU/Linux". This would be fine, except the vast majority of consumer electronics using Linux no longer ship with the GNU userspace. This should have been a huge red flag to the FSF that their efforts were being sidestepped entirely.

The FSF does not appear to have a clear vision of the future, or concrete goals, and has lost significant amounts of influence through inaction. I do not know what the way forward looks like for them.

Ultimately, I think the FSF "won" the mindset war, but has lost the overall battle.

parker_mountain··on After cutting radar, Tesla now dropping ultrasonic sensors from its EVs
In the event of a blinded vision system, such as sun glare, the vision system should be able to recognize its reduced capacity. That involves warning the driver and relying more heavily on radar/sensor fusion.
parker_mountain··on After cutting radar, Tesla now dropping ultrasonic sensors from its EVs
I have a 2020 BMW, with the same features. I have never had an issue in over 30,000 miles of driving. My previous generation BMW, also similarly equipped, did not have these issues. It did trigger the rear collision alert a handful of times, although all that does is tighten the seatbells and beep (i think).

So, these features can work reliably, and I don't think using a poor implementation is useful in this conversation.

The reality is that tesla has removed sensors from their playbook, which can only decrease the information the car has to work with.

parker_mountain··on TikTok Parent ByteDance Sees Losses Swell in Push for Growth
> know nothing about the workings of the legal system in China

Hello, I'm an appsec engineer working on product privacy for a large multinational company. I have a pretty accurate, battle tested, mental model about data privacy w/r/t international verticals. I have worked with our China vertical and also worked on key escrow separation models. You might even be able to figure out which company, based on the above.

It's interesting to see you make these claims about me when you know nothing about me.

parker_mountain··on TikTok Parent ByteDance Sees Losses Swell in Push for Growth
Well, I don't agree with OP, but the Chinese government is way more involved with its companies than the US is. Here, ostensibly, there's a court and legal process - versus China, where the government has all data by default.

So, any Chinese tech company is de facto going to have all of its data accessible by the Chinese government, by default.

parker_mountain··on HHS purchases $290M worth of drugs for nuclear emergencies
>"We don't see any practical evidence today in the U.S. intelligence community that he's moving closer to actual use, that there's an imminent threat of using tactical nuclear weapons," CIA director William Burns told CBS News Monday.

is different than

"that is not a train used by the nuclear organization, they are not moving weapons, etc "

He specifically does not address the claim. Which to me, is a red flag of lying by omission.

Personally, I never took the initial story super seriously, and view articles like this suspiciously.

parker_mountain··on HHS purchases $290M worth of drugs for nuclear emergencies
I suppose I made a mistake in getting political, but there's a difference between atrophying something, and sweeping the whole thing into the trash.
parker_mountain··on HHS purchases $290M worth of drugs for nuclear emergencies
Prominent news organizations, such as CBS and Newsweek, have reported on the nuclear train (albeit, referring to it as "not independently verified").

If you're going to claim that it was debunked by the Director of the CIA, you're going to need to provide a link, please - ideally to a credible news organization or the CIA itself. I did a quick google and it came up with nothing, so it's very possible I'm not searching in the right way.

parker_mountain··on HHS purchases $290M worth of drugs for nuclear emergencies
> If COVID taught us anything, when an actual crisis hits.

To be fair, nuclear crisis is not at all like COVID. It's one of those things that you can kinda see coming on the horizon. It's increasingly unlikely that, aside from a small scale nuclear attack, nuclear war will spring up without tons of advanced warning; for example, in the forms of degenerating relations between nuclear powers, and saber-rattling. Spending money on up-keep for these drugs isn't the best use of funds, and should only be done during periods of high tension.

And yes, as a society, our preparation for a COVID-like event was weak (in the US, in no small part due to Trump's efforts to reverse Obama-era preparations).

parker_mountain··on Girls in Yoga Pants Explain the Higher Education Apocalypse
> there should be fewer people going to university

Strong disagree. This is a rational response to seeing what higher education in the US has become, but it doesn't have to be that way.

What we need is a tertiary education model that seeks to refine critical thinking, awareness of the world, and a funnel into degrees with practical job outcomes - for those that seek them.

Other countries have this model, particularly in Europe, where college isn't a requirement for employment, but a benefit none-the-less.

parker_mountain··on RISC-V Laptop now available
This laptop is certainly not a daily driver, and certainly not something you'd buy if you're concerned about lifespan, durability, or support. It's a mobile demonstration that the burgeoning community of risc-v developers can bring along with them to conferences and boardroom tables. It's (relatively) expensive and is functionally a reference board with a battery and screen attached.

The price, OEM, and support story is a non-issue for the intended market.

parker_mountain··on Why JWTs Suck as Session Tokens (2017)
> sign out/session invalidation

I wrote it up in another comment, but basically: if you're using JWTs, and you have lots of services calling each other in a request (as you might with microservices), it's entirely appropriate to have a session check ("remote introspection") when you access sensitive information, such as PII.

And, maybe, at the edge layer as well.

parker_mountain··on Why JWTs Suck as Session Tokens (2017)
> Do not persist or store access tokens anywhere but in-memory.

Using short lived ATs is one defense against this happening, such as if an attacker compromises one of your services and starts scraping tokens off of it.

Ideally, the services should also have some sort of checks (such as service accounts), to ensure that only approved services can talk to each other.

parker_mountain··on Why JWTs Suck as Session Tokens (2017)
> if you would have only cookie with user id then anyone would be able to pretend to be anyone by manually setting the cookie with some user's uid.

That's what session id (as mentioned in the article) is for.

parker_mountain··on Why JWTs Suck as Session Tokens (2017)
Some concepts to think about:

local introspection: validating the validity and lifespan of a jwt by checking it cryptographically. does not need to make a network call, thus very fast and a great way to perform a low stakes operation.

remote introspection: validating the integrity and lifespan of a jwt by checking with the server that signed it and/or the server that issued the session. this should happen at least once per call flow, ideally as few times as possible but also every time sensitive information is accessed

if you have a heavy call graph, you can do local introspection on everything in the middle. and then, when you go to retrieve pii, do remote introspection.

if your token is appropriately short-lived (15 minutes), this means that an attacker can only yield information within that window with token scraping. that means that an attacker can only access data for as long as they have a foothold. i hope you have strong reporting and immutable architecture :)

> If you’re building a simple website like the ones described above, then your best bet is to stick with boring, simple, and secure server side sessions. Instead of storing a user ID inside of a JWT, then storing a JWT inside of a cookie: just store the user ID directly inside of the cookie and be done with it.

so basically, if your application is doing its own authn/authz (most monolithic applications), you don't need jwts.

parker_mountain··on Mozilla drags Microsoft, Google, Apple for obliterating browser choice
> the smart decision to invest effort into the only solution that makes sense longterm

I don't think it was smart at all. Building an OS is such a monumental challenge, and an embedded OS requires hardware support that an org the size of Mozilla was never going to be able to undertake. Anyone who had worked with embedded around the time of BTG immediately wrote it off, and it took a separate company taking tons of money (and relationships) from Google to even get anywhere.

> Android is effectively Google anyway

At least a super stripped down version of android would have had plug in compatibility with BSPs - which is Android's "hidden" strength.

parker_mountain··on Starlink now over 1M user terminals manufactured
mon français nest pas bon. 700,000? je suis surpris! je veux un livre d'anglais, merci.
parker_mountain··on The hypersane are among us, if only we are prepared to look (2020)
"Wonko the Sane" could afford a sizable coastal property on the California coast.
parker_mountain··on Hacked and Banned from Facebook
While there's a lot of people who work in information security here,

> Hacker News is a social news website focusing on computer science and entrepreneurship. It is run by the investment fund and startup incubator Y Combinator. In general, content that can be submitted is defined as "anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity."

So, we're not the kind of hackers you think we are. Mostly.

I'm sorry to hear what happened to you. Unfortunately, these companies often don't offer any sort of support despite acting as offering a place to host our memories. Facebook is a free service - not paid - and thus you should expect nothing from them. It's tragic, but that's the reality.

Moving forward, please enable MFA on all of your accounts. MFA stands for "multi factor authentication". Presumably, you have a Google and/or Apple account. Here are instructions for both

https://myaccount.google.com/signinoptions/two-step-verifica...

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204915

parker_mountain··on Mcmaster.com is the best e-commerce site I've ever used
It's a lot less common than you think, especially by email. In my spare time, I work on motorcycles, and I often have to source specific parts or - in rare cases - reach out to a local machine shop. I've given up on email, a phone call is often the only way to get a response.

When you work in the tech industry, you get accustomed to everything being done by text, but the rest of the world isn't so convinced :)

parker_mountain··on Mozilla drags Microsoft, Google, Apple for obliterating browser choice
This is Mozilla's own fault, in a lot of ways. They could have been building their own Electron clone (and creating tooling around porting existing sites to it), but instead they built Firefox Reality. Mozilla could have built the best Android web browser, with tight integration to the OS, but instead they built their own phone OS.
parker_mountain··on Mcmaster.com is the best e-commerce site I've ever used
Great website. Great company. Can't find what you're looking for? Website failing you?

Don't worry, just click the email link at the top of the page and they WILL get back to you - even over a 20 cent part.

parker_mountain··on Starlink now over 1M user terminals manufactured
OP assumed 100%. I just think that if you're starting above 50%, you're already way off.

The real number is actually way lower, probably.

← PreviousPage 9 of 11Next →