HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

parksy

1,026 karma · joined January 12, 2014

submissionscomments
parksy··on Launch HN: Arengu (YC S21) – Frictionless Signup Flows
Hey, so this feedback is a bit leftfield but might be useful. On my home network I run pihole using some popular blocklists, and sdk.arengu.com is blocked in two of them, one of them since about 2 years ago. As a result the sign in example on the homepage didn't load initially. It looks like the required forms.js doesn't load.

Of course this is an edge case, your company can't reasonably be expected to cater for how people on the internet decide to filter content on their personal networks, and the majority of people won't run their own DNS servers & take the same slash and burn approach to whitelisting as I do, so I understand if it's seen as a non-issue or rare edge-case.

I'm guessing the SDK URL got flagged on the list because the form builder has been used by some websites for various marketing related purposes triggering a blacklist maintainer to blanket ban the URL (I've had to whitelist common things like cdnjs for similar reasons).

That's fine for marketing forms / flows, but I'm thinking since a website or application's login is more of a primary / critical feature it would make me think twice about using the service if I were designing an app aimed toward tech & privacy savvy developers.

As a workaround, does your service still work if developers decide to host the needed assets on their infrastructure or proxy them under their own DNS? Could be a way around it.

Anyway the feature looks interesting, login flows are far from trivial once you get into the area of social login, OTP, device authentication, 2FA etc. I'm hammering out the architecture of a SaaS service at the moment so I can appreciate the niche you're trying to hit, good luck with the launch and hopefully the above feedback is useful.

parksy··on Launch HN: Turion Space (YC S21) – Space debris removal and satellite servicing
My grandad always used to say "where there's muck there's brass" and I always imagined at some point that would include cleaning up space debris, whether to recycle the materials or simply clear space for others.

I actually love the idea of being able to hire someone to shift an orbital object into various orbits. It opens up the possibility of launching a proof of concept satellite or telescope, and not needing to worry about fitting it out with heavy fuel and thrusters. Just pay someone else to deal with that.

With a transport & servicing network in place, that opens the field for a range of centralised operations as well - refuelling depots, recycling services, production lines, it doesn't make sense for all of these to have their own dedicated transport networks.

Good luck with your enterprise, as space activities become more abundant, roles become increasingly specialised, and having a service dedicated to wrangling heavy objects about the place seems like a logical next step.

parksy··on “Safari's buggy” is valid criticism, “Safari's behind Chrome in features” is not
As a developer who started noodling on 8 bit BASIC, the power of a web browser that is essentially a universal, network-capable application engine is beyond amazing.

As a user, the constant misuse of dark patterns and the glut of careless unoptimized and insecure code and coders is nightmare fuel. Consider I grew up coding, trying to explain modern websites and web applications my folks is simply painful because quite often it just doesn't make sense. A lot of UX never actually asked a user how they want it to work, or disregarded their input.

The best websites for me are still those which adhere to pre web 2.0 design patterns. I find them easier to navigate and use, ie old reddit vs new - the new design doesn't bring anything useful other than nagware to register and install the app - reading a thread and click outside the main area by mistake, it navigates you back in history and you wait 10 seconds for all the ajax to finish popping into place. My old online banking interface was a simple list of my accounts and balances with links to common functions. The "new" app-inspired interface hides everything under animated menus and ugly graphs I don't need to want, while constant monte-carlo simulations mean basic features always move; my wife and I often have completely different UX, it's just another annoying half-baked web app with ajax popping in and out all over the place.

There's good stuff and well design applications of course. Shadertoy is amazing. For music there's fully-fledged DAW's in the browser - fantastic! Collaborative document editing in real time, brilliant!

But I think I am down with the concept of a different engine or mode for "web surfing" vs "web application execution" - it's a completely arbitrary distinction I know, but as a user I've got a completely different set of wants and needs when I'm just surfing, vs when I need an "application."

parksy··on The Insecurity Industry
That's one extreme extrapolation. How about, if this happens, it will be the end of commercial IP and the closed-web. Only open source with its inherent transparency and broad, distributed contributors (who would you sue? everybody at once?) and constant, real-time updates and improvements without lock-in or planned obsolescence would thrive when improved regulation gives avenues for redress and improves consumer awareness of security, as consumers flee the commercial silos in droves.
parksy··on Starlink review, four months in
One thing that caught me as interesting about the article was the obstruction map and what could be achieved with that kind of data if it was gathered and correlated with millions of other users. I am no expert but it seems that traditional observation from space has always been limited by the resolution from up on high. Flip the problem and have ground-based observers in densely populated areas track shadows in a rotating grid of point sources in the sky, and you can build a 3d map outwards instead, the only problem being how to increase the density, consistency, and spread of the ground-based sensor array.
parksy··on Time to assume that health research is fraudulent until proven otherwise?
I think this is one of the hurdles human civilisation has to iterate over en masse and long-term. Game theory is distorted by a mixture of power dynamics and the abstract nature of "society" - i.e. determining risk v reward (professional, personal, financial, etc) comes down to the individual person or organisation, whereas "society" as a concept doesn't get a say in each transaction as it occurs, so a lot of discussion gets side-tracked there. Without a gestalt consciousness such instances of suboptimal outcomes will continue to occur, and since gestalt consciousness is technologically a remote prospect, present-day social hierarchies are at best a gross approximation of the ideal "average path" or "surfing on the bell curve of understanding", balancing individual freedom and satisfaction against fear of repercussion and ridicule with accuracy and efficiency (at a social scale).

I do think that modern technology can revamp antiquated systems of peer review and appeals to authority with more robust and deterministic / objective measures of quality - an evolving consensus repository of the sum of human knowledge where each pull request is a debate, each experiment a commit to a branch that may become a new foundation or a footnote. Yet we still see fit to define knowledge as property, ownership as power, power as success. Fear of the impression of weakness, or the threat of starvation and poverty seems to override all other priorities and for the most part, we toe the line.

It is what it is I guess.

parksy··on Corona Game: A simulation of how Covid-19 spreads
I was thinking that the average age of death would have that effect but I wasn't sure what it was called, so I appreciate the pointer to QALYs. Your point is well taken that the total economic cost can't be based on an 'average' life given the typical demographics impacted by the pandemic.
parksy··on Corona Game: A simulation of how Covid-19 spreads
If the two metrics used are loss of life vs cost of pandemic, the cost of a life needs to be included in the final score I think.

In Australia, it appears some early models predicted between 50k to 150k lives lost assuming no response. A statistical life is valued at over $4m, meaning a cost of $200bn to $600bn. Also, with 60% of the population infected, that would mean over 12 million people infected - we still don't have a good idea what the long-term issues will be - but one study in Australia found ~5% of people experiencing "long covid" symptoms, which would mean at least 600,000 people with long-term complications - which in our hypothetical Harkonnen society we'd likely just shove them into a hole somewhere and forget about them, otherwise we'd have to deal with their social welfare (yuck!) and strain on the health system.

No doubt the cost, responses, short and long term impacts, etc, will be something economists and sociologists will debate for decades to come.

https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/thousands-of-predict...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_of_life#Australia

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-24/long-covid-nsw-resear...

Edit: On thinking about it, I think the value of life is based on insurance / compensation purposes, perhaps the value of a life in terms of total GDP contribution would be different? Anyway, a subject more for the actuaries and economists I think. Interesting to consider nonetheless, which I think may be the overall point of this game.

parksy··on The James Webb Space Telescope has passed the final mission analysis review
I fully agree, my first gut reaction every time I read an update about the JWST is fear that something will go wrong. I hope they take all the time needed to get it right.

I do also wonder if interactions with air / moisture / dust will degrade the components faster than they would wear out in space, the longer it's here on Earth? I'm guessing this is all accounted for too, just crazy to think of all the variables at play in the success of a project like this.

parksy··on Runway – Create impossible video
It looks like normal <video> tags that attempt to load webm, then mp4, then falls back on a still image. All assets are loaded from their own webserver too (also my PiHole didn't block anything.)

Perhaps you have autoplay blocked? They are set to autoplay by the looks of things.

parksy··on How to Love Animals in a Human-Shaped World
As a kid we didn't have a good run with pets so it's just easier to say "no" to owning animals and move on with a clear conscience.

Having said that, I do find myself always playing devil's advocate with myself: "But how can your conscience be clear when millions of abandoned pets are being put to sleep in animal shelters? So it's everyone else's job to deal with that is it? You would deny your children the joy of owning a cute little doggo woggo?" and to that nascent neurofractal I say, get in line, the CBT will get to you eventually.

So I dunno, I don't want to come across as being down on people who've made a decision to own pets, it's possible to overthink things and underthink things. I know many pet owners and the vast majority are kind and caring. I think it comes with the territory. Some have been more domineering and lord over their creatures like a ruthless dictator and I think that says a lot about a person, but I digress...

I pretty much agree with everything you just said, and I pretty much kill every plant I touch as well. Brown thumb gang!

parksy··on How to Love Animals in a Human-Shaped World
Your second paragraph is basically why I will never own a pet.

I can't ethically feed my pet, therefore owning a pet is unethical.

I love dogs, clumsy waggy little fuckers, but I won't subject another being to my fuckery just because I can.

edit: And yes, I teeter-totter on the ol' "you should adopt an abandoned pet" vs "feeding it for the rest of its life means other animals will die" vs "but you eat meat too you sanctimonious fuck" every time I think about the subject. At the end of the day, easier just to say "no pets" and move on with life for me.

parksy··on How to Love Animals in a Human-Shaped World
Corollary - I did keto for just over a year while on a vegetarian diet with the main goal being weight loss. During that time I felt extremely energised and healthier. While not strictly vegan, my diet was basically the low-carb nuts, legumes, mushrooms, fruits, vegetables, eggs and cheeses. I did have to add a few supplements, otherwise I'd feel like utter shit, magnesium and electrolytes mainly had a significant effect on my mood. But otherwise it's the healthiest and most alert I've felt since I was a teenager.

People I mention this to assume the toughest challenge is variety but as I love to cook it wasn't too hard to make it interesting each day. The toughest challenge was convenience, you grab a coffee or a lunch with friends and there's very few places that cater for all. The second most challenging aspect was cooking meals for the family, as I am the main cook for my wife and kids who did not at all buy into a vegetarian diet let alone keto, but that again wasn't too bad since I could just cook a normal meal, scrape out the bits I can have and whip something up for me afterwards.

After about a year on that diet I ran a sub-1hr 12km charity race which isn't exactly a world record, but not bad for a 40-something always-recovering alcoholic with weight and mental health problems. I'd definitely recommend keto (with proper medical supervision) but... maybe not at the same time as trying to eat less meat.

parksy··on How to Love Animals in a Human-Shaped World
I haven't met a vegan who argues dogs should never eat meat. I have heard about it on nightly news from time to time, but I would think that's a very fringe, very uninformed niche of people who got the memo but didn't read it.

The vegan perspective is less "meat is bad" and closer to "compassion for a creature and its rights to exist freely within its own context". A killer whale should be able to nom as many seals as it wants, a dog can have some raw meat to chew on.

parksy··on Pee bottles, constant monitoring and ignoring stop signs: Driving for Amazon
20ish years ago I was driving ingredients to restaurants. The business owners had metrics that required drivers to break speed and traffic laws in order to hand off all of the ordered goods to the customers. They never specifically ever said to speed or break the law, but the amount of stuff they piled our vans and trucks with made it impossible to deliver in the timeframes they set.

I was grateful to get the job, as previously I was fired from a 24x7 McDonalds store - I had used my personal vehicle to transport boxes of product from the owner's other store to meet demand after a rostered shift, and being sleepy after doing a graveyard shift plus that, woke up to the owner calling me and saying "if you can't even bother to wake up for your job, don't bother coming in again."

Anyway so in the first two days of my induction, my trainer taught me about driving over median curbs, waving as if you made an accidental mistake down one way streets, doing u-turns into oncoming traffic to get to a street that took a few extra minutes to get to, demonstrating the most efficient way to park the vehicle in front of the target establishment.

So this is nothing new. Amazon can stick it if they've just managed to commercialise it better than all the small businesses, but yeah, this has been happening since warehouses, telephones, and automobiles existed together. Just "wave and pretend" like you made a mistake, or this is normal, or whatever. Some low-level shitkicker will get the fine for parking in a fire zone, or jumping a curb, or whatever to meet targets. Alternatively, they can quit or be fired if they don't like doing that. for me having the cheese cutting guy ask constantly if I was gay and if he could shave my haemorrhoids was the cherry on the cake.

My heart sincerely goes out to all drivers. It is a very unforgiving task for many.

parksy··on Fastly Outage
No issues reported for Perth Australia. Strange because reddit, zip pay, fastly itself, and probably a bunch of other sites are down.

Doesn't seem the status page is automatically updated or perhaps whatever event or polling is used is also broken.

parksy··on How the Commodore Amiga powered cable systems in the 90s
Tangentially but our local small-town hospital ran its TV system through a C64 system for decades. It was there until the hospital was bulldozed and replaced around 5 years ago. I don't know exactly how it worked but my dad was the engineer at the hospital and explained it was used to provide TV services to paying (private insurance) patients.

All I recall is that whenever a TV was switched on you'd see the C64 load "*" prompt for a few seconds before the picture kicked in. This got me wondering about the guy who set that up, and a bit impressed with how it kept running without issue for so long, since as far as dad could recall they didn't need to do any maintenance on it.

I'm just imagining a dusty C64 forgotten in a crawlspace somewhere with a big "Do not turn off" label on it. I wonder what happened with it, I wouldn't mind seeing the code and setup. (edit - I've sent him an email to see if he recalls any details as he was there from the late 80s onward...)

parksy··on The Limits to Blockchain Scalability
A couple of points, the first is criticising lack of real-world use-cases for nascent technology is like criticising the web in the mid 90's. It's like expecting the cart to lead the horse.

Having said that, there's plenty of projects big and small that have merit. Granted, a lot of published "case studies" are just marketing fluff to attract search traffic, that shouldn't be an indictment of the technology itself which shows a lot of potential, especially where complex transactions need to be brokered between parties with competing interests.

DHL & Accenture have investigated and prototyped uses in supply chain logistics for pharmaceuticals -

- https://supplychaindigital.com/technology-4/dhl-and-accentur...

- https://www.dhl.com/au-en/home/insights-and-innovation/insig...

- [PDF warning DHL case study] dhl.com/content/dam/dhl/global/core/documents/pdf/glo-core-blockchain-trend-report.pdf

Banks are serious about blockchain for reconciliation -

- https://australianfintech.com.au/cba-westpac-back-r3-blockch...

Use case for trading distributed power generation with power ledger smart contracts -

https://www.powerledger.io/clients/tata-power-ddl-india

You'll find most of these projects are in prototype phase or early adoption, and as I said there's loads of disinformation, but if you filter through the crud and look for serious projects with demonstrated applications or investments you should be able to see the potential.

Again if you recall the mid 90's, companies like Amazon were just an online book shop, or Google was just an idea in a statistician's thesis. Far more ideas bombed that were successful; there was a time when the internet hadn't decided what to do about advertising and settled on Google's model. There was a bubble that popped and lots of investors were left in the lurch. But eventually the ideas that worked survived and these companies are the largest in the world today and spawned entire new industries.

In light of this, my view is that it's a stretch to say "scam after scam, that's all blockchain is." at this point, although there are plenty of scams surrounding it, definitely don't write it off entirely just yet.

parksy··on Show HN: Apply for a job through SSH, $ ssh jobs.hackclub.com
I think the OP's service is pretty cool, it reminds me of ye olde BBS's. I am actually writing my personal resume as a command prompt based on old 80's PCs as well, albeit in HTML/JS, so I do dig the aesthetic.

Application-wise: The statement "In case you want to apply for a job without admitting who you are" is begging the question that the service is actually for job applications, something we have no trust in or knowledge of other than the title of a post on a public forum.

Identity-wise: You're also making the assumption that key = person. Keys can be set up to authenticate client applications and remote services with each other. People can have dozens of keys for various things they have installed via wizards or copy-pasting tutorials which they may not even be aware of. Key pairs are also shared by email and internal docs far more often than they should be with limited control over who they are distributed to.

Harm-wise: If I were an evildoer, I would have spent my career obtaining and organising databases full of all sorts of information; email addresses, hashed passwords, usernames / aliases, phone numbers, etc. I'd definitely have a special database set aside for key-pairs I've scraped from various plaintext sources that I haven't found a use for. The opportunity to target a subset of industry professionals (with presumably more privileged access to information than the average joe) to correlate even a small fraction of known public keys with specific IPs, email addresses, even hackernews aliases would be a huge value add to my "services". You could just slurp the data in, then even if you get no hits, maybe a year or two down the line it becomes relevant.

For anyone dealing with this kind of threat vector on the daily the stakes are pretty high and can include bankruptcy and professional ruin. Yeah we all visit random websites, but it's not every day people connect to an SSH server outside of their trust network. Do you really wanna be that guy whose key was used to leak a database full of medical data or something?

The audience of this website include people who work with PII and may not be familiar with the intricacies of the SSH command line utility, and the state of affairs in information security is pretty bleak in IT-backed organisations as we see every single day, so in this context I don't think it's cool to bash people being privacy conscious.

parksy··on Show HN: Apply for a job through SSH, $ ssh jobs.hackclub.com
In case you want to connect to a random ssh server without giving it your public ssh keys.
parksy··on Enigma: GPT-2 trained on 10K Nature Papers: Can you spot the difference?
Mainly at present I see it as a demonstration of progress in the capabilities of the models. A machine is writing coherent syntax and grammar in close to real-time, maintaining a semblance of context while it does so, without requiring excruciatingly complex and detailed semantic algorithms.

One use-case is as a creative writing assistant. Typical ways to beat writer's block are to do something else (read, walk, talk, dream). At some point, either consciously or subconsciously, the hope is that these activities will elicit inspiration in the form of an experience or idea that will connect with the central vision of the author's work, allowing the writing to continue. So too it could be with prompts generated from these models, just another way of prompting and filtering ideas from the sensory soup of reality.

(While the "dark" version of reality has bedroom "writers" pooping out entire forests of auto-generated pulp upon ever-jaded readers, being able to instantly mashup the entire literary works of mankind into small contextual prompts would be another tool in the belt for more measured and experienced authors.)

There are other more practical use-cases for these models. There's work being done on auto-generating working or near-working software components from human language descriptions. Personally I'd love to just write functional tests and let the "AI" keep at it until all the tests pass. So seeing the models improve over time is a sign that this may not be an impossible feat.

From a less utilitarian perspective, I'd love computer assistants to have a bit of "personality". "Hey Jeeves, tell me the story about the druid who tapdanced on the moon." and just let the word salad play out in the background. Yeah it's a toy, but it would jazz up the place a bit, add a bit of sass even.

I do think we're a ways off the first computer generated science paper being successfully peer reviewed and contributing something new to human understanding of nature, I'd have scoffed at the idea ten years ago but now I'm sure it's only a matter of time.

parksy··on Observable Plot
Thanks for the reply - even if it's not within the design scope your test code reads much cleaner than the code I've used in the past (where perhaps naively I've manually transformed and presented each dimension individually where you've done a single normalise operation). For sure every tool fits a particular paradigm and parcoords are incredibly niche, but plotting aside from the demo code you provided I can see some general purpose uses for the transformations as well and definitely a good addition to the tool-belt. Good stuff!
parksy··on Observable Plot
I went through the tutorials/demos and this seems very intuitive. I don't do a lot of visualisation, but when I do, I've found manually coaxing data and configuring visual parameters to please a library to be tedious as it's time spent doing busy work I'd rather spend analysing the results. So for me the major drawcard is being able to drop a simple table of results in and let the library handle the necessary inferences for the type of vis I'm after. If it works for the majority of my use-cases, that's a big timesaver for me.

One type of visualisation I sometimes (honestly rarely) use but is extremely useful for finding unintuitive relationships in higher dimensions of data are parallel coordinates charts (actually it's your d3 code I've been borrowing in the past - so thanks for that!) Is this something that can be achieved with Plot at this stage? I'm not sure if it would be a facet, a transform, or something else, like a cross between marks and links (if that's doable).

Anyway, definitely bookmarked - I'll be sure to spend more time using this next time I need to visualise some data, looks like it will handle a lot of the standard vis without the typical boilerplate, thanks for releasing this.

parksy··on An NFT That Saves Lives
Well put, and another aspect beyond currency is a move against centralised control of enterprise. Centralised legal systems governing contracts, centralised ownership and rewards, centralised risk, etc. Some people looked at how the world is run and thought they could make a more efficient and secure way of doing things with more freedom for anyone that can swing an IDE to create fairer reward systems.

At least one of the implications of systems like ethereum is that they enable autonomous contracts that are decentralised and at least in theory don't require any separate and typically centralised governing body to execute and enforce, which could in turn lead to a range of new models of business and human interaction.

It remains to be seen what will happen, the technology is still young (the Web took about a decade to start catching on in the mainstream as perhaps being something more than a flash in the pan) and lofty ideas are being thrown at the wall as the new concepts are explored in both good and bad ways.

Having seen the ups and downs of the online revolution I have a hunch at least some of it will stick, and whether this moment goes down as some great proletarian revolution or becomes just another tool in the billionaires belt seems up in the air to me, but at the very least it is disruptive and we may be seeing the birth of the next generation of crypto barons.

Or anything could happen, like by some unlikely turn of events we solve prime factorisation and the whole thing fizzles into history as a big oops moment, or jackbooted forces raid homes and data centres to destroy all crypto-related hardware and knowledge.

I feel the outcome will be somewhere between the two extremes of utopia and dystopia, it just seems to be how things turn out, but as you say at least people are trying things. Disrupting the status quo is how society moves forward, humanity never seems too comfortable sitting on its haunches (for better or worse).

parksy··on An Update on the UMN Affair
The situation has echoes of the scholars who a few years back submitted fake papers to journals, some of which passed peer review and were published. That was an attempt to backdoor the scientific method, really.

I don't condone guerrilla penetration testing whether its on the Linux kernel or a science journal, and I am sure that the ethical implications will be subject to much outrage and debate for some time to come, but when it occurs and is successful it is concerning because if a small team of scholars can do it, so can anyone else.

The inner workings of the Linux kernel maintenance has been kind of a black box for me for years, I just naively trust it works and my next update won't compromise my system, so it's concerning that this happened and will be following to see how this plays out.

parksy··on Show HN: I made a sandbox game to help with financial planning
Kinda fun idea and with a bit of polish could be great. If you enter a negative amount when you transfer between accounts it does weird things...
parksy··on Discord ends deal talks with Microsoft
> Discord is amazing to create communities, that’s what Microsoft wanted.

Microsoft can easily recreate the platform, they don't want the capability, they want the existing audience.

parksy··on Intel joins DARPA in search of encryption 'holy grail'
From my understanding, FHE can represent Boolean circuits, so you don't write an "FHE application"; you can send an encrypted input into an encrypted Boolean circuit and get an encrypted result.

Since FHE operations are Boolean circuits, we can consider basic stuff like "AND" or "NOT" - but all the inputs, outputs and the operation itself are encrypted, so the owner of the server won't even know if someone called an AND gate, a NOT gate, or something else.

Which means that if primitive Boolean operations are supported, you can chain them to create a general purpose, Turing complete computer.

However if you were a nefarious actor looking at the order and frequency at which various primitives were called, then you could be able to discern a call graph (or at least, a statistical "heatmap"), and you might figure something about the nature of the program, and therefore be able to glean some kind of understanding of the information passing through it, however abstract.

However since FHE can represent boolean circuits, we're not just limited to primitives. A futuristic compiler could create a single boolean circuit to represent a complex application - however for something like a blog or eCommerce store, that would result in inordinate amount of cyphertext to represent the code, and undoubtedly be very slow to run.

I think more likely is the compiler would optimise layers or stacks of black-boxes that are not simply boolean primitives. Your plaintext code (in the language of you choosing) would have every branch of the call stack from input, processing, and output analysed n-levels deep optimising for a balance of runtime and obfuscation.

In such a case, the nefarious actor would see a blob of cypher going into a blob of other cypher to generate a blob of cypher as input into the next blob of cypher. Maybe there are parallel cypher blobs, but their internals are completely hidden. An inside actor might have intimate knowledge of how long each blob takes to execute for various inputs, so assuming that knowledge is shared we're back at good old timing attacks - which would probably become irrelevant on the next compiler pass anyway.

Use-cases I can think of are any kind of transactional situation where various actors have competing interests, where it may be in one or more actor's best interests to game the system. Anything peer-to-peer is a good example.

Gaming seems trite, but in the early days, gaming was full of client side cheats. The current model for multiplayer gaming to avoid cheating is centralised - every client has to interface with a central server that then has to figure out which moves were legal in the game's rules - peer-to-peer is fraught with cheaters since they can analyse and change the code client-side. Realtime FHE would allow game developers to come back to peer-to-peer gaming, since it would be mathematically improbable that a peer is cheating.

Escrow is another peer-to-peer type activity, where it would be useful to have a trusted middleman. Maybe provenance for digital / physical goods (that's a bit of a stretch). But essentially, right now, a lot of development effort is expended to make sure individuals in a system can't gain an advantage on the client side - if we didn't have to trust a user's computer to do the right thing, then the client/server trust barrier collapses.

parksy··on Write site-specific extensions to replace sites' JavaScript code
I'm pretty sure you're joking, but the client's browser makes the request for a resource. If you're letting your browser request code you don't want to execute, that's on you.
parksy··on Trust: The Need for Public Understanding of How Science Works
> One of the questions should be: Why should we build a model for the world?

The decision not to build a model, is a model.

> Is that really possible/doable?

Models are just data-driven predictions based on understanding. The better the data, the better the understanding, the better the model.

If a model for the world is impossible, then either the data is impossible to gather or process, or the understanding is impossible to achieve.

Data is just facts based on observed events, so I refuse to believe that a model for the world is impossible based on ability to track data.

Understanding is the wildcard - humans are complex beings. But each tiny step forward increases global understanding. Years ago, autism was considered "cold mother syndrome". Now through decades of careful and detailed analysis it's understood as a neurological disorder. Depression and anxiety were thought to be issues of the soul, demonic possession, laziness, etc. Now there is an ever expanding array of diagnostic tools to help sufferers.

So I refuse to believe that understanding is impossible.

tl;dr: Yes, a model for the world is possible.

> And if the real answer is "no",

That's a big if.

> why should we apply that failed model to the real world

"failed model" what failed model?

Also recall doing nothing is also a model. Bring on the dark ages!

> affecting (potentially in a negative way) the lives of millions of people?

In my world view, doing nothing and praying to higher powers, or allowing chaotic despots to rampage the lands has already caused immeasurable premature death and suffering.

Why would anyone vouch for a return to the dark ages, just because progress feels like effort?

← PreviousPage 5 of 10Next →